Fri 23 Feb 2007
canadian gothic
Posted by bon under issue stuff, Uncategorized
[8] Comments
my father has an ice-skating rink on the pond by his house this winter.
there is a Rockwell kind of veneer over this photo for me…this photo of my family on skates, taking by my dad on a sunny Sunday afternoon. a good afternoon. the ice was thick, and my skates clopped against it with that wintry schink-schink sound that’s almost like knives being sharpened, but happier. there were friendly family dogs on the banks of the pond, cavorting. we all took turns pulling Oscar in his little red sled. the photo may not show it, but there was much laughing. and whinging about sore feet.
we were like a full-page spread right out of a Canadian homemakers’ magazine, for gods’ sake.
and yet…there is no need break out the hot chocolate and gag on it, friends. the Rockwell bit is just a veneer, and part of me feels brittle and cheap even presenting the photo and its outdoorsy, clannish kitsch as a reflection of my life. i keep looking at it, liking it, trying to figure out what to make of it…trying to find a place for it, and relate to it on a level deeper than that of a friendly photo shoot. because this was no recreation of a childhood memory, for me, lived out in colour again for O’s sake. this was my childhood fantasy.
Oscar turned ten months old the other day. by the time i’d reached that venerable age, my father had left. not only left my mother and i, but left the province…and gone as far as he reasonably could while still staying technically in Canada. he took a nineteen-year old who happened to share my first name and who had previously been my babysitter along with him, which i suppose – this fine, insular island being what it is – made living closer somewhat inconvenient. they married when the divorce came through. they spent the next three decades in the Northwest Territories, coming home only in the summers. then, ten years after i’d grown up and moved away, they came back.
my father never saw me on skates until i was twenty-seven years old.
and all this winter, as i’ve been watching Oscar grow and (gypsy threats aside) bloom into a clever, watchful, laughing little personality, a small, wounded voice inside of me has been sitting in a corner, asking “how could he leave me that far behind, when i was small like this?” i see Oscar light up like a pageant contestant whenever Dave comes home from work, and, bewildered at how anyone could walk away from such blatant worship, that same little voice squeaks “what was wrong with me?”
i know better, of course. i’ve actually tried to stamp on the little voice, quite firmly, but only succeeded in making me feel sorry for it…ermmm….myself. and i resent that. i’m blown away by this vulnerability, this uncertainty. i’ve been told since i was small that the divorce was in no way a reflection on me, and i genuinely believe it. i’ve met both my parents. i’ve understood for twenty-odd years that the two of them, however civil, were no more meant to live together than they were to fly. i thought i’d worked through most of my baggage a long time ago.
then i had my own child, and lo, the floodgates of sadness came crashing open, apparently. because all the things that i am so fucking thrilled to share with Oscar, like his first Christmas, and his first steps, and his first time on skates (okay, i project) are things that i did without my father. i don’t believe in staying together for the kids. but really…three thousand miles away, eleven months of the year?
i know, petty problems. i don’t like feeling angry and wounded and childish. i don’t like the fact that i feel hurt…and in my hurt i feel embarrassed, too, like the statute of limitations has passed for airing of this particular load of laundry. but i don’t like the way that i feel small whenever i consider Oscar’s smallness, either. i feel protective of the child that i was. it’s true that when a child’s parents divorce before she can remember, there’s no specific image of family unity to grieve…those images all simply become veneered Rockwell paintings, part of a pop culture with no particularly relation to her own identity. but finding myself in the picture, now, with my own child, and particularly with my father behind the lens…ouch. that stings, and confuses.
i like my father, a lot. i love him, as well, and nurtured a little-girl crush on him from afar for years. but as an adult, i like him, wryly, and with a special eagerness i have no words for and no way of expressing to him except in the way i still become self-conscious around him, like a hopeful schoolkid. we don’t see each other much…distance is a habit i at least don’t seem to know how to break, any more, even when we’re close geographically.
but here we are, all in the picture on a Sunday afternoon. dark things lurk beneath this ice.




February 23rd, 2007 at 3:36 am
Our children have no idea how much we learn about ourselves from them, just because they exist.
Your honesty is refreshing Bon and lets me see beneath my own ice surface.
Thanks, Cyn
February 23rd, 2007 at 7:29 am
love the pic! how utterly heartwarming. it is nice to know that at least someone out there has a decent family life. you all make a lovely family. :)
February 23rd, 2007 at 11:55 am
ahhh… i don’t know how this comment is going to work out… don’t know if it’s going to be from the friend who remembers you well, or from the shrink i’ve been educated to be…
i love the photo. i love the fact that when O is older you will show him this – his first time “on skates”. all three of you are lucky to have this memory. your father is the one who missed out! you grew up without a father, but that, in itself, has contributed to the woman you are now. and i reckon you might just have turned out ok!!
and, think of the relationship you are able to have with your father now. which you may not have been able to have with him had he stayed and developed resentment for a life he wasn’t ready for.
you look at your child and wonder how anyone could leave such a new an incredible creation – a creation that is yours. and you wonder how your father could have done just that… left his amazing new creation. but your father is not you. and he had his own things to deal with, and his own way of dealing with them. things would have been a whole lot different had he stayed… but would they be better??
the simple fact that your father is behind the camera in this photo, i think, is really something. you’ve forgiven him. you may not feel like you’ve forgiven, but somewhere, i think you have. you want to let him into your life. you want him to be a part of O’s life.
that, in itself, is amazing!! you’ve overcome bon. i honestly believe that everything happens for a reason. i know that it’s so frikkin cliched… and i actually really hate saying it for just that reason, but the simple truth is, i believe it. i don’t know why your dad left. but think of who you’ve become – perhaps not because of it, but certainly in spite of it. and think of the life you’re giving O – again, perhaps not because of it, bet deinately in spite of it.
he is one lucky little boy. and you are one incredible and brave woman. you may well always hold some level of resentment for your dad. but i think you’re doing pretty bloody well. again.
you’ve been through alot bon, and once again, though you may not feel like it, it sounds like you’ve conquered. i can’t imagine anyone reading your blog and not feeling so incredibly inspired, and strengthened by it. by you. if only we all could be so selfless…
ps, i love your hat – fabulous!!
February 23rd, 2007 at 1:07 pm
thanks, Cath, and all…i appreciate the kind words. though Tiffany, i had to laugh at your description of a ‘decent’ family life…oddly, enough, i suppose, mine is. in its own way, it is.
and Cath, yeh, i’ve forgiven, long ago, and i actually don’t wish that my father had stayed. just stayed a little closer. moved back a little sooner. made life choices that were in some way related to me. it’s the being incidental that cuts…and always has, but now that i’m a parent i find it harder to excuse without in some way turning in on myself…hence the small voice that pipes up. the hurt is fresh again.
my father and my stepmother are good people…i’m quite fond of both of them. and i loved the afternoon on the pond. but sometimes, emotionally, wow it’s weird that we all live here now when my entire childhood i would have given my teeth for a day like that. it’s not that it’s too little , too late…it’s more like being taken to Disneyland at 35, almost sadder than never going.
February 23rd, 2007 at 3:42 pm
This post is very raw. Your feelings about being left as a child are very valid. Like you, I never really knew my father. It really doesn’t bother me much until I see Porgie and John playing together. He can make her laugh these big belly laughs. In those moments, I feel cheated.
Instead of having wonderful memories of daddy, I have tearful memories of my mother struggling to support us.
By the way, I love your writing style. Very engaging.
February 25th, 2007 at 12:32 am
Hey Bon;
I really identified with a lot on that post, not to mention that I thouroughly enjoyed the afternoon with my kids and my beautiful nephew, I do have a most wonderful crush on that boy….
My father (or other genetic donor if you would) lived a 10 minute drive away from me, and you and your father are much closer than he and I are, or really ever have been, and yes when he actually bothers with me I get that same nervous school girl twittering feeling that you so aptly described.
I was fortunate though that my mother decided to marry my “dad” who has been more than a father to me since I was 11 years old
February 26th, 2007 at 5:48 pm
It’s odd, huh? How having your own child makes you rethink everything that ever happened to you at the hands of your own parents – the good and the bad.
This is a very powerful piece of writing…thanks for your honesty.
February 27th, 2007 at 1:54 am
Wow. It’s erie to read your thoughts on your dad leaving because it so closely resembles the mixed bag of emotions I’ve always held for my own father. The comment you left me on my “Letters from Bob” post the other day were so true. I’m glad you felt the ability to go ahead and post your thoughts on your own site. Since you have a relationship with your father, you obviously had a lot more to lose than I did. Unfortunately, my father made enough bad choices that he became an unstable person and I decided enough was enough. Forget me, but my son deserved a better role model for a grandfather. Part of me I admit was scared he’d break my sons heart down the road…
I can remember thinking the exact same thoughts as you did – how can someone turn their back and leave a precious life they created? It’s almost unfathomable to me. But it happens.
If nothing else, I hope sharing this helps maybe get some of it out in the open. At least he will know how you feel. Whether he responds, may be a different story. I hope you’ll keep us posted as to how your relationship continues!
By the way – you’re baby IS SOOOO DARN CUTE!