Tue 13 Mar 2007
meta-mommy, part deux
Posted by bon under pondering stuff
[8] Comments
yeh, i know. my fancy French numerals in these post titles aren’t exactly turning this into continental philosophy or anything. but, when i theme, folks…hell, i might as well theme grandly.

i woke up this morning to find that honours had been showered upon me…and no, for once it wasn’t just baby pee. even better. and rather serendipitous, actually…i’d just started blathering on about how i think – oh yes, such thinking going on here at the Crib this week – and then, in wacky tandem, Christy and Mrs. Chicken up and bestow Thinking Blogger awards on me! how perfectly lovely…and timely, which is unusual for me. i swear i did not offer either of them free babysitting, so i’m really quite puzzled about the kismet of it all. perhaps the planets have magically aligned in my favour and all that i say shall now become truth…oh heady fantasy. just in case, let’s pretend this post is about how i not only think, but sleep on a bed of hundred dollar bills, huh? ’til eight o clock every morning? whilst David Bowie waits at the foot of the bed to give me pedicures? and how jujubes have been found to be a health food?
alas, not quite. but i am deeply grateful for the honour…particularly coming from these two writers. Christy’s was one of the first blogs i discovered when i finally realized that there were multitudes of us out there, reflecting on what it means to raise little people and to change in the process. she relentlessly challenges her own assumptions and proves the limitlessness of love. her courage and honesty have humbled me, and given me the gumption in turn to unpack some of the more complex and cobwebby corners of my own experiences on this road. and when Christy’s not making me cry, Mrs. Chicken is. that, or causing me to spew coffee on my keyboard. she speaks freely of loss and disappointment and cheese products and working husbands and the sweetness of mothering, with a deep vein of thoughtfulness throughout. a morning without fresh chicken is like…well…worse than you’d think from the literal meaning of my words. ;)
so there. toot, goes my horn, and thanks to two great and generous bloggers, says moi. it’s amazing and rewarding to be reminded that people are out there reading…it really is.
but the fine gold (or silver, your choice) linky love props weren’t only being handed out in my direction. one of the other awards Christy bestowed went to Vicki at Speak Softly…for a post i’d likely never otherwise have found, just going to show that these marvellous head-swelling award memes actually do serve their nominally intended purpose of drawing new readers to fine posts. along with the head-swelling, which is fun too.
and Vicki, too, is wondering about what it means to blog and make community and shared meaning from the experience of parenting, but she’s pretty pissed about a potential publisher wrapping up the whole experiment in the cutesy – and therefore, inherently a little bit denigrating – package of “mommyblogging.” and so i had to think some more. damn lucky it’s my theme this week.
do i mind being called a “mommyblogger?”
as with anything, i suppose, my response is contextual. if some sneering suit is patting me on the head whilst using the word, particularly as code for “self-involved, over-privileged navel-gazing reindeer-sweater-bedecked surburban should-be soccer-mom who uses too many exclamation marks in the drivel she writes about the brats she barely takes care of…” (and i’m paraphrasing here, but i know that this view of the mommyblog exists) – then yeh. yeh, i mind. i’m not surburban, dude.
but seriously. the truth is that the notion that what many of us are doing out here is drivel is, itself, where the drivel lies. that old cesspool of contempt and derision and marginalizing condescension that so often accumulates around feminized work in our society isn’t, unfortunately, absent from the discourse surrounding the phenomenon of momblogs. or blogs by mothers. or blogs by writers who are also caregivers. as you wish. as Vicki points out, there’s no reason why all of us populating this corner of the blogosphere (while also populating the earth with our sweet offspring) can’t demand a little more dignity for what is, on both counts, pretty fine and significant work.
i know words matter. words cut and minimize and infantilize, if they are allowed to. but words also build amazing communities of thought and connection. and because so many of the women who write about their lives and their mothering write with such sharp wit and rich insight about the stereotypes that mommyhood brings with it, i want to have faith that we could, if we chose, reclaim the word “mommyblog” and make it something proud. we could wear it with the same patient, rise-above-it sense of irony with which we wear our children’s pee and spitup and mashed bananas every day. i think we could. i think we could take that snivelling little word and make it cool.
whether we want to, on the other hand, is a different conversation. how do you feel about it? what do you think about it?
finally….i also think – since this is still a blog about my boy & i, however the heck i style it – that i would like to announce that Oscar stood by himself today. for five. whole. seconds. it was beautiful, and scary.
and that’s all i can think for today.
8 Responses to “ meta-mommy, part deux ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from all the best things she said | cribchronicles.com
February 7th, 2012 at 10:12 pm[...] March, 2007. it has always been her perspective on the term “mommyblogger” that gave it dignity, for me: [...]




March 13th, 2007 at 2:53 pm
Dear bon,
Thank you so much for the honor of posting my post. I think the ire I expressed had exactly to do with the choice of words, and words used by women in particular, to, as you put it, marginalize the marginalization. And my ire also had to do with how easily we accepted the honor bestowed on us–look! academics!!! writing about mommies!!! let’s all jump on board!!!! with all our exclamation marks!–without seriously considering the way in which we were and are being portrayed. We ourselves have shown, as you so beautifully put it, through our words that words matter, the way we write and talk about our lives, our families, our partners and our children.
I would have loved for those editors to consider more seriously the words they were using. After all, they are editors, yes? And by putting together that collection, they are editors who will influence readers. I would have loved for them to have enjoined a real discussion about what we call ourselves and why. I don’t condemn a woman who wants to call herself a mommy blogger. I agree there can be power in those words, power we reclaim. The gift of feminism, at least the feminism upon which I was raised, came in the form of acceptance. But let’s not forget the struggle too, to be called what we are, which is women.
My final thought (and then I will get off my soap box) is this: I sent the editors a link to my post as my own submission to their collection. Granted, the content was antagonistic, but I have not heard back. So much for their willingness to question the words they are using, or their net effect on their so-called audience. Then again, maybe mommy bloggers aren’t the audience. In which case, more marginalization there, if you ask me….
Best,
Vicki
March 13th, 2007 at 4:43 pm
Vicki, i’m so glad you came on over.
you make a really great point that i overlooked in my initial read & commentary…which is the institutional (ie. academic & editorial) relationship to what we as “mommybloggers” do. we exist because the internet allows us to bypass the formal gatekeeping hurdles to publication – and by extension, to most forms of public voice – that once kept people marginalized in terms of knowledge creation and the benefits of having a powerful public voice. women at home with small children, outside the formal structures and networks of academia and professional publishing, have – i think – been one of the groups that’s gained the most just from this dramatic new access to voice.
but ironically, we’re still all hot and excited whenever someone from the “real” world of publishing or academia deigns to recognize our work…even if in a condescending, marginalizing, or limiting manner.
i know i’m speaking in generalizations here…but i do think it’s interesting. and i guess that’s where i come back to the whole “take back the mommyblogger title” thing…i think there’s a lot to be said for opportunities to publish academically, or to be paid for writing in more traditional publishing channels. obviously, money and credentials matter. but i think we need to think about what respect can mean or become within this free, open medium…so that we don’t begin to look down on ourselves or internalize the condescension.
March 13th, 2007 at 4:44 pm
You deserve this award. You make me think, too. I’m just saying.
March 13th, 2007 at 6:12 pm
This post just proves how right I was and how much you deserve this. You rock, babe.
March 13th, 2007 at 8:16 pm
Well done. Congratulations. Mrs. Chicken and company chose well.
Congrats on Oscar standing!!! Yea!!!
And loved, loved the line…I’m not suburban, dude.
Me either!! LOL!
March 14th, 2007 at 2:49 am
Got to go to class. Even though i just had one here. thanks for making me think. Again, Christy
March 15th, 2007 at 4:42 am
Standing! Hooray! The era of MOMMY, I WANT TO WALK! NOW! has begun!
How was that for exclamation points?
Personally, I love the term mommyblogger when applied correctly to those of us who write about our kids and delight in it (and who aren’t currently professional writers or claim other labels and reject the term). It implies and acknowledges the community inherent in child-raising, and it gives voice to the nameless thousands out there who have for centuries carried babies, held little hands, wiped noses, and helped children learn. The thousands — millions — tens of millions — who give their all to helping these little children learn to talk, read, cook, laugh, love, and find themselves in a big, scary world. The tens of millions who, in a world of “Dr” this and “Mr” that, are known primarily by one name — Mommy.
I am proud to be a Mommy, and proud to be a mommyblogger. That’s my choice, but right now it feels pretty wonderful.