Sat 16 Jun 2007
come away, human child
Posted by bon under coping stuff
Come away, human child, to the water
and the wild
With a faery, hand in hand,
For the world’s more full of weeping than you can understand.
- William Butler Yeats, 1886
little Liam died yesterday morning.
Liam Stewart Inglis, six weeks old, son of Kate & Justin, brother to Evan, twin to Ben. he died in his mother’s arms, against her skin, over her heart, in a hospital he never got to leave. the same hospital where Finn died two years ago, in my arms, in a little blue blanket. small, frail bodies…gone, we hope, to be whole somewhere else.
i need to say something, and i’m not sure what. nobody ever knows what to say when a baby dies.
i once had words. in the moment, in the grace and visceral adrenalin and profound surrealness of having touched death, been party to that crossing over, the heart speaks. i committed some of those words to paper…a few to Dave. a few have leaked out here, long after the fact. but my words were mostly for Finn, most spoken to the air.
in Kate’s case, the heart is speaking with a terrible beauty the likes of which i’ve seldom read. the tribute she wrote for Liam yesterday - just after they let him go - is elegy, and celebration, and release. it sings and sorrows, and honours Liam. with her words, as ever, she’s done good by her boy. she has written him out of his life with the same fierce love and courage that has written him and Ben into so many people’s hearts these past six weeks.
the words i had two years ago still leave me with nothing to offer her. i cannot add to her song for Liam, not really. he was not mine.
but i still need to keep saying something. because nobody knows what to say when a baby dies, and that - in its own way - is one of the worst parts of losing a child. after the outpouring of sympathy and sorrow and kindness…silence. not just the absence of laughter and babbling, of the child him or herself, but the silence of others, the hole where that part of your life was. because nobody knows what to say. because nobody wants to hurt you. because we are all - even those of us who’ve walked the same awful road in our own way - terribly, terribly afraid of saying the wrong thing.
so most say nothing, or fall back on platitudes about angels that usually serve to make the speaker feel perhaps a little better about the order of the universe.
i didn’t know, when Finn died, that there was a whole, small, sad corner of the blogosphere out here written by mothers whose children have died. even if i’d known, i think i’d have slunk to that corner timidly, desperately seeking the communion of grief, of freedom from feeling like the freak show who had to clearly show she was not going crazy because her baby had died. but i would have done it in secret, looking over my shoulder, afraid - and i cannot believe this now, though i know it is true - that someone would see my sorrow and judge me for it. i was, outside my own journal and the tiny, private circle of Dave and myself, almost entirely tongue-tied about Finn for months after his birth and death. not because i didn’t want to talk about him…i did. desperately. i wanted nothing more than to say his name, to sate myself with it, to mark it on the world…before memory erased it all. rather i was afraid i’d start and not stop, not be able to shut up. i was afraid i’d cross the boundaries of normal conversation, that i’d come undone in the middle of one of those conversations and never be able to find my way back.
now, i kinda wish i had. people tried…a few dear friends who didn’t just stare at their shoes in respectful silence, trying not to say the wrong thing. a few even asked about Finn, directly. and i told them about him, and lit up inside…but then faltered. the conversation would founder, and i would fear that my friend was uncomfortable, and i would clam up, close myself off again. because there is not much to say, in the normal language of everyday, about a newborn, no matter how healthy or unremarkable. an eleven hour life does not make for much to say…nor even a six week one. not unless you ask that child’s mother about how she felt about him.
i’m not sure entirely where i’m going, here. i feel sad, and powerless. and touched, by the life of a little boy i never met, who ran his tiny fingers across his twin’s face and stunned his doctors. i wish i could sit with Kate, whom i’ve never met, and hold her hand and maybe drink a bottle down, and just listen. and find out all about more about Liam, how he felt in her arms, how exactly he slipped away…find out how he changed her, what his life meant. i wish she could the same for me, to be honest.
so…if you don’t know what to say when a baby dies, here’s my assvice, for what it’s worth. go tell Kate that you will remember Liam. that you will remember that he was here. that there will not be total silence, and then a hole, gaping. that three months from now, six…no one will make her feel she should be over it. that you will still ask her, two years from now, about him, about this journey of letting him go. that he will not slip from their lives, from the Inglis family picture that people carry in their minds. that he will not be the reason you all avert your eyes and look at her in hushed tones for the rest of her life.
now is the time for the great outpouring, yes. but she’s not going to forget. as time goes on, you don’t have to pretend you have, either.
i don’t know if that’s the right thing to say. but i think it might be a start. and hell, if i’m wrong, i’ve already told her she can tell me to eff off.
peace, little Liam. i’m glad you were here. i hold a little of you in my heart, with another wee boy you share far more with than i’d ever hoped.
39 Responses to “ come away, human child ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from Petroville » Blog Archive » A Perfect Post - June’07
July 2nd, 2007 at 9:01 am[...] winners: Suburban Turmoil awarded Niihaus Playgroups are No Place for Children awarded Crib Cronicles Oh, The Joys awarded Tired Mummy Childs Play x 2 & Don’t Take the Repeats & Chicken [...]













June 17th, 2007 at 2:04 am
This is beautiful. And this is why I love the blogging community.
I will not forget Liam. I will not forget reading and re-reading the beginning of Kate’s post, just hoping that I was mistaken - that he wasn’t gone. But then, how by the time I had finished it, she had passed on some of her peace right through her words, and I felt like it was okay to say goodbye too.
I will not forget Finn either. I have culled through your archives, trying to learn about him. Trying to find out about the little boy who is not with you. I wasn’t sure why this was important to me at first, but I think you explained it today.
It is important not to forget.
June 17th, 2007 at 2:18 am
It’s funny, Bon, I have thought of you every day that I have read Kate’s blog. I’ve thought “I wonder how it is for Bon to read this?” I have thought of you and hoped this was ok for you. This post was beautiful.
And thank you for the nudge. I am one that doesn’t want to offend as I have been the recipient of many good intentions that clanged in my ears…not for lack of love of the sender, but for the resistance I had to hearing it.
Amazing these threads and connections…
June 17th, 2007 at 2:23 am
Thank you for these beautiful words and helpful guidance.
June 17th, 2007 at 2:34 am
I, like little monkies, have thought of you while reading about kate’s ordeal these past several weeks and have wondered how it might make you feel.
Who could forget Liam? Kate showed him to us so clearly through her astounding words.
And — who could forget Finn? Because you have been able to immortalize Finn; your words have allowed us to know him and to remember him.
The Yeats is just right.
June 17th, 2007 at 2:37 am
I read her post earlier today. My heart broke and I’ve never even met the woman. That’s the power of words. Yours too. Your words in this post struck me. I’m still new to your blog and did not know about your son. I don’t think there’s a statute of limitations on condolences. I’m so sorry for your loss and amazed at your strength. Peace.
June 17th, 2007 at 2:41 am
Thank you for sharing this, for linking to Kate’s blog, and for giving your readers some idea of what to say.
June 17th, 2007 at 2:43 am
Fuck! This year is really on my shit list.
Thank you for describing why the silence stinks. I am fortunate enough to have close friends who never let me clam up and don’t think I should be over any damn thing any time at all. But I certainly know the feeling of not wanting to make someone else uncomfortable.
One day perhaps we can sit together and talk of our boys. I’d like that.
June 17th, 2007 at 3:01 am
This is so heart-wrenching–I am so so sad. Your words couldn’t be more true and what you have done for Finn is so important, as is what Kate has done for Liam.
June 17th, 2007 at 5:58 am
You speak so well and importantly. While we run in overlapping circles of discussion I think if memory serves I found your blog first as I looked for advice on the loss of a baby. I needed some help last year as a dear mama friend of mine lost one.
Thank you for that then. It is good advice (scourge tag assvice, tsk. tsk.) I used that post that first helped me when I wrote of Liam last night as well. I have been looking for your words Bon. thank you for speaking with such effort. I try to say it.. I said to Kate when I commented… A little boy that makes 500 mothers love their children more than they ever knew. A glorious person she was so generous to share.
Amazing.
June 17th, 2007 at 6:00 am
And I do love that passage. But I know it mostly from the lowbrow Waterboys source.
June 17th, 2007 at 2:07 pm
Thank you for telling us what to say.
Liam and Finn and all the other children…we’ll never forget.
June 17th, 2007 at 2:11 pm
I think that advice goes for everyone who has lost someone dear-don’t forget. Time doesn’t always heal it. You still want to talk about it, and I would think that would be increased with a small child. You want to talk about him to make him real?
I cannot get her words from my mind, the watch at the oceanside in the clothes he last lay upon. I’ve cried on and off for a boy I’ll never meet, for a mother, for brothers.
It’s heartbreaking.
June 17th, 2007 at 3:03 pm
After reading this, you’ll probably think I am a bitch, but I feel the need to share.
My sister-in-law had a stillbirth when she was 8 months pregnant. Of course, our entire family was shocked and so very sad for her. I remember feeling the need to avoid her, because I just didn’t know what to say or do. I was one of those assholes who would stare at my shoes.
For years, she would send Christmas cards from her, her husband, and her baby. I remember how I hated to be reminded of her baby’s death.
Thanks to you (and a few others), I now realize how selfish and horrible I was being. I was more worried about how I felt, instead of how she felt. I wish that I had listened to her. I wish that I had asked about little Joseph.
I feel awful about my behavior.
June 17th, 2007 at 3:44 pm
no Christy, not a bitch. not at all.
the fact that people stare at their shoes more often than not, and are terrified of saying the wrong thing, and burdened by being reminded of such sadness…it’s so common as to be a systemic problem, a societal issue. it’s not your fault…you were being normal. infant death is treated like a horrible taboo in our society, i suppose because now that it is less common than it once was it looms as one of our greatest collective fears. it is normal to be uncomfortable of what you fear, to not want to be reminded of the shadows of sadness that are part of everyday life.
part of what i was trying to say here is that our “normal” is a problem. that the burden of grief is enough without the silencing. now, not every grieving mother wants to talk. i’m not very good at it myself, in real life, because it’s such a strange and exposed conversation. but even a few words that let me know Finn is acknowledged matter…because then i am reminded that my internal world and the external one are not in total conflict, if that makes sense. the openness to another’s grief is what matters, i think. and as Thordora said above…it’s not just infant loss. all grief lasts a long time.
and…i doubt it’s too late to ask your sister-in-law about Joseph. whether or not she wants to talk, i doubt she’s forgotten him. and it may be nice for her to know that you haven’t either. Mrs. Chicky made a good point - there’s no statute of limitations on condolences.
June 17th, 2007 at 5:28 pm
i was so sad when i read this a few days ago, and i too, thought of you. and finn.
bon, i promise i will remember.
June 17th, 2007 at 6:49 pm
It doesn’t make sense, but hearing, even in passing and even second hand, that someone I didn’t know lost a baby I didn’t know about hurts so much more than thinking of my own lost twins. I can accept the fact that I have to suffer. I find it somehow harder to accept the fact that other people have to suffer.
June 17th, 2007 at 7:59 pm
thank you for saying something. kate, liam, ben, the whole family…those words permeate out there…and fill the holes with love.
peace.
m
June 17th, 2007 at 8:28 pm
Thank you for saying what I didn’t know how to articulate. I’ve experienced loss, but there are so many gradients of grief. This is one I can’t comprehend.
June 17th, 2007 at 9:14 pm
Bon,
I only know you from reading a bit here and there on your blog, prompted to click through from Kate’s comments section by some particularly beautiful and insightful comment. I’ve always been impressed by what I’ve read, never more than today.
What a beautiful tribute to Liam, to all the mama’s grieving losses that most cannot even bear to contemplate. I hold Liam close in my heart, and now I will hold your Finn there too.
Jeanette
June 17th, 2007 at 11:52 pm
Bon, I’ve finally clicked through after many of your touching posts on Kate’s blog. I’ve wondered about Finn. I’m going back now to meet him, to meet you. Your writing is beautiful. Thank you for sharing your feelings, so truthful and raw and meaningful, and for offering your helpful guidance to non-knowers of the loss pain.
Blessings and peace to you.
June 18th, 2007 at 12:03 am
I went over and visited Kate, and her post made my heart clench and my eyes sting. The loss is unimaginable. And i agree with you that we cannot forget. Ever. I think that miscarriage is a different experience, yet people often have the similar reactions. The casseroles and flowers and hugs come then. . .well, it is just so hard for anyone to know what is right, what words will hurt and what will comfort. But in the end, i think just letting the parent know that you remember is important.
I am so glad I found this beautiful place, I’ll visit again for sure.
June 18th, 2007 at 1:16 am
bon,
I never knew Kate, never read about Liam, never saw the heartbreak until last week . . . and then I read it all. The struggles, the tiny triumphs, the hours and hours in the ICU. I do not know how one heart can bear it all, and still be open to the love of husband, of sons, of . . . the future. I watched the story unfold knowing the ending . . . and it was . . . beyond words.
You, however, are never beyond words, and your words have helped me understand the pain and heartbreak of losing a child. . . understand just a little bit, as if observing from afar. I hope I never have to put that experience to practice here in my local life, but if I do, I will certainly be prepared by you.
In your words, Finn lives on. In Kate’s words, Liam has touched a thousand mothers. Thank you for sharing your story.
Count me as one more who will never forget your tiny Finn.
June 18th, 2007 at 3:26 am
Thank you for helping me know what to say to people going through this. I’m sorry you know anything about it, though.
June 18th, 2007 at 3:35 am
Thank you, Bon, for opening this window into your heart and Kate’s.
June 18th, 2007 at 4:40 am
Bon,
It’s so heartwarming to see this glorious circle of women, mothers, writers, and friends, coming together, penguining up, and bonding together in kindness and love.
This post was so helpful. I’m grateful for women like you, Kate, Jeanette, and many more, who are able to reach out and embrace each other so beautifully with your words.
Maybe your darling babies are together right now, sharing secrets and watching over you together.
I’m thinking of both of your angels tonight - they have made a difference to so many of us.
June 18th, 2007 at 1:49 pm
Bon,
As another mother who has lost a child, let me tell you how brave and wonderful you are for writing this. I had dinner with another friend who lost a 22 weeker and she said she “never” thought about it and I wondered if that was because she didn’t know how. There are no words but you have found them.
June 18th, 2007 at 2:40 pm
How could I forget, after those words, both Kate’s and yours?
June 18th, 2007 at 7:34 pm
Bon, your website is great, and this is a wonderful tribute to Little Liam. I found Kate’s blog a few weeks ago, just after her boys were born. I have followed their story daily and am one of the many who have fallen in love with her sweet babes. I am so sorry that you have lost a child as well; I am so deeply sorry. Your post is a tribute to all who grieve such a loss and understand this pain…
June 18th, 2007 at 9:24 pm
This so beautifully expresses to Kate what I have been feeling: a loss for words, but a corner of my heart grieving for her son, whom I never knew.
Thank you for this post, Bon.
June 19th, 2007 at 12:52 am
I’m late in commenting. When I read the first lines of your post this weekend, I knew I needed to come back and read this when I could give you my full attention.
I read about Liam for the first time maybe a week before he died. I had to read every word about the twins. When I saw that Liam had died, well, it’s horrible but in the midst of overwhelming sadness, I was so relieved not to be Kate. But I also can’t get her or Liam or Ben off of my mind. I wonder how she’ll feel on Ben’s first birthday. I wonder how Ben will feel on his 18th. Ah, that poor family. It’s a sadness I can’t even comprehend.
I have to admit that I’ve looked through your archives looking for crumbs about Finn too. I’ve seen your comments and wondered how Liam’s story was affecting you. So thank you for sharing. And I promise that I won’t forget.
June 19th, 2007 at 5:16 am
Through you I found Kate, just yesterday, I went back and read, then reread, my heart aching for her and her little boys, the three of them. I kept re reading those posts from their birth on, selfishly or selflessly I don’t know which, hoping for a different ending, more upset everytime when it wasn’t, wanting to comfort that Mama, whom I’ve never met in the fiercest way. It’s not just Liam that won’t be forgotten, it’s the entirety of them, Liam, Evan, Ben, Justin, Kate, one no less then the other. All of them remembered.
Beautiful Bon. And thank you.
June 19th, 2007 at 4:11 pm
I read Kates’ entry entitled tribute because of your connection. Your words and her words and the whole story - tears flowing, and appreciated the poetic souls that are able to somehow put a little of these immense, profound feelings into some words - though words are never enough, they do the job to communicate and I will never forget your boy or Liam - so that is a big something. The blogging world is amazing for that. My dusty journals are just that - dusty , for me- though - therapeutic and helpful at the time, I just don’t make the time now to”journal” - I never told anyone except my husband, Mother-in-law and sister and “doctors” about my miscarriage 6 years ago - I now have healthy, vibrant children, for whom I am eternally grateful, but I wonder if a part of me just shut down and shut up about my miscarriage for some unknown reason. This blog helps me to sort through this - and why I didn’t share more. I was awed at the number of responses to Kates’ tribute. I scrolled down and down and down and kept reading, and thinking - wow, where are all these wonderful women? - and wow, I’m glad they are here.
June 20th, 2007 at 3:12 am
You are so right, this is so true.
June 20th, 2007 at 10:41 pm
Today, at Kates’ blog - there are 500, count’em 500!! entries under “Tribute”- from all around the world, most likely - I want to believe that this energy is being harnessed - how powerful to witness this on the internet - and yet… we are still all faceless strangers (well, some of you might know each other in person) - so to that effect, it is foreign to me - but this written word develops a community who are able to convey their sharing and caring - so, a good thing- a great thing.
June 21st, 2007 at 3:57 am
Bon, you’re amazing. This was such an incredible gift for you to give Kate and those of us who can’t find the words when someone loses a child. I think you’re right - it’s our greatest collective fear and so we shy away from it - but hopefully more of us will be a little braver the next time we are (god forbid) confronted with that situation.
Thank you. Your story, your story of you and Dave and Finn and O, have moved me and I will always remember that.
July 2nd, 2007 at 1:40 pm
That was a beautiful post. My heart aches for your losses.
It is so important to remember
July 2nd, 2007 at 11:41 pm
So unbelievably beautiful.
July 3rd, 2007 at 6:59 pm
A wise mentor once told me that she never knew what to say at funerals until her husband died. Then she knew: there was nothing you could say. You can only be there. But being there is the most important thing you can do. You may only be here virtually, but you are doing what matters most: being there.