Sat 6 Oct 2007
my last Duchess and other neuroses
Posted by bon under stuff stuff
[23] Comments
the incomparable Slouching Mom offered interview questions. like a fish to bait, i bit. i’m a person who’s always found minds attractive, and Slouchy’s mind – from what i can piece together from the online personae she unmasks for us – is fascinating, and intuitive, and friggin’ brilliant. i wanted to know what she’d ask, so bad that i actually promised to answer. if i can’t sit down and have coffee with Slouchy and her generous, curious brain…then this virtual exploration will have to do.
but she does have an open invite to visit PEI.
1. Offer your high-school self a piece of advice you wish she’d taken.
oh lord. just one?
i reel a little when i try to get a sense of who i was twenty years ago: a part of me feels like that girl was older, in her certainties, than i’ll ever be again, and another part of me feels slightly mortified that she ever existed in the first place. i was so earnest then, and so confused – a total sponge for input and information, yet so completely abstract, without a compass. all i knew was that i didn’t want to be like anyone i knew, that i didn’t want the adult lives i saw in front of me. looking back, i feel a narrative connection to where i was then, in my life…ie. how i got here from there…but no more. like Browning’s “My Last Duchess,” that young me is a painting on a wall, which i can dissect in detail, even with warmth and sympathy…but ultimately, i killed that girl, traded her in for the new model(s) i’ve become in the interim.
however, for the sake of pain avoided on the road to here, i would happily sit down with that younger me – that much younger me – and say two things. first, for god’s sake, little girl, no one is expecting you to have your entire life together by the time you hit eighteen. it’s okay to be unsure. it’s even okay to start again if you find yourself on a bad path. time isn’t really wasted, especially if you learn from it. stop being such a perfectionist – you’ll only disappoint yourself.
two, you’re not fat. it’s hormones, and not worth hating yourself over. pluck your eyebrows and get out of those awful unflattering ’80s clothes and stand tall: there’s beauty in there, and someday, someone will come along to reflect that back to you, thank jeebus. for now, it would be good if you could believe it yourself.
2. Describe the most vivid memory you have from your early childhood.
i always struggle to come up with answers to “most favourite” or “most vivid” or “most whatever” questions, as they make me feel vaguely deficient for reasons i’ve never quite explored. like i’m excluding too much from the package, perhaps. but i do clearish-ly remember the first day of kindergarten, wherein i launched myself into the classroom and proceeded to show the teacher how i could count. to one hundred. i have no firm recollection of whether or not she actually let me go all the way…i really, really hope not.
3. What would we be most surprised to learn about you?
that depends, erm, on what image you’ve constructed of me from reading between the lines of this blog.
i imagine you’d all be shocked, for instance, to learn that i’m a little neurotic.
oh no? you knew that. hmmm….
whiny? nope, that too.
tone deaf? ha. you can probably hear me humming from where you are, and it probably hurts your ears.
okay…how ’bout i have a paroxysmal fear of large dogs but send Oscar to a home with a bull dog in it, all day long every weekday. Bruiser is rather like a coffee table with a tail, really, but still…he has teeth. tell me what that tells you. please. ’cause i don’t know if it’s surprising, but i do know i don’t know what to make of it and could use the feedback.
4. Tell us what books are on your bedside table right now — the good, the bad, and the ugly.
by “bedside table,” do you mean strewn about the bed, under the pillows and stuffed down the side stuck up against the wall? good. we’re working on a collection that includes the most recent Harry Potter, which i believe Dave can now recite aloud, a Keegan history of World War II, Proust’s “Swann’s Way” (which i open at random, glory in about two pages of, and then promptly fall asleep. works like a charm. i have never finished the book and never hope to, but start it afresh every year), a biography of Mark Rothko, a Richard Scarry chewable book, and Nancy Friday’s “My Secret Garden.” sex fantasies of the seventies, oh yeh.
5. You were an only child. Oscar may end up without a younger sister or brother. Using your own experience as a frame of reference, what about being an only child do you not want for Oscar, and why?
ah…ah, great question. and carefully framed, which touched me. i don’t want O to grow up an only child in part simply because he was born a second son, and i feel bound, almost, to honour both him and his brother by having him grow up with a sibling. but i don’t know if that makes any sense or is just a vestige of grief, and therefore about me rather than O. but i wonder if he will have his own grief, someday, too…even just in the form of wonder and wistfulness, and i’d like him to have someone to share that with, someone to whom it belongs just as it belongs to him.
that sharing of memory and identity is really the key for me in wanting to raise two, even had Finn not been a part of our lives. it’s less about practicalities or even the supposed socialization benefits of siblings than about the weight of carrying an entire family legacy on one’s own shoulders.
there is, for me at least, an urgency to being an only child…and a loneliness, but i wasn’t lonely as a kid. it was in transitioning to adulthood that i realized i was leaving behind a whole world that had no existence outside of me, no narrative outside my own. there is no one but me who remembers my Nannie as a grandmother. no one but me who will remember the names of the dolls i loved, or recall the narrow hall of the apartment i lived in with my mom in elementary school through the eyes of a child.
i live in an odd and privileged limbo in the sibling department, as i do have half-siblings who live me near me now in our respective adulthoods, and while i don’t see them much i do like knowing they’re out there. there’s something comforting to me about them. and yet i know that so much of who i am and how i see myself is a near-direct result of having grown up as an only child, and i don’t think it’s a terrible thing, just not one i would choose for O if it turns out to be within my power.
we shall see.
****************************************************************************
and on that effervescent note…if you haven’t fallen asleep or slit your wrists with the palpable maudlin angst, and would like to know what questions MY mind would blather out if we were at virtual coffee, you may, erm, beg in the comments. even though i’m late to this and you’ve probably answered fifteen people’s questions already.
’cause i really will ask odd ones, i promise.
23 Responses to “ my last Duchess and other neuroses ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from Modeling » my last Duchess and other neuroses
October 8th, 2007 at 2:04 am[...] dad4justice wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptYou were an only child. Oscar may end up without a younger sister or brother. Using your own experience as a frame of reference, what about being an only child do you not want for Oscar, and why? ah…ah, great question. and carefully … [...]




October 6th, 2007 at 1:04 am
MQ will be an only child, barring any really odd changes in our status, and I wonder about it. Found your thoughts on that very interesting.
October 6th, 2007 at 1:09 am
I’d loveto see what questions you would have for me bonnie……
October 6th, 2007 at 1:40 am
I loved your response to the high school question. I have a love/hate feeling towards my former self.
October 6th, 2007 at 1:46 am
OK, I’m blushing here. Thank you for the kind words, but no, not brilliant.
Your answers were as interesting and thoughtful as I expected them to be.
And as for Oscar and the dog, do you think it could be as simple as wanting him to be free of a fear that’s burdened you?
I’d love to visit PEI. It’s not out of the question…
October 6th, 2007 at 2:08 am
What great answers — I always love when people answer questions…it is just so interesting to see what people have to say – especially about themselves!
October 6th, 2007 at 2:18 am
crap crap crap, bon! that answer about how you feel about ‘only child’-ness is exactly exactly what i think … only i don’t know if i’m prepared to go through colic and two years of no sleep and 50 pounds of weight gain again. but the business of carrying the burden of the family legacy? no one has ever really understood that when i’ve explained maybe-another-baby reasoning to them. gah.
if you’ve got questions for me (she asked humbly, aware that she started this comment by swearing repeatedly) i would be happy to answer them …
October 6th, 2007 at 2:20 am
Great answers–I loved your matter post so much I bookmarked it to my bookmark bar so I can reread it again and again. I would assure my 18 year old self that men can love smart girls, that I don’t have to choose between my mind and my heart. I was struck by what you said about leaving behind a narrative that had no existence outside of your own. I have felt that since my mom died in 2004, even though I have five younger brothers, none of whom seem to remember very much of their childhood. I started a family blog Remembering to develop more collective memories, but I am the only family member who contributes.
October 6th, 2007 at 2:26 am
The dog. I think your child is finding the path through your fear.
so many things to take from this post…
October 6th, 2007 at 2:35 am
I was framing a response to #3 (the dog part of it), when your answer to #5 made me suck in my breath.
I can’t figure out a way to put that breath-suck into words, so here’s what I was going to say about the dog thing:
I have a phobia of bees, and when there were lots of then buzzing around on the beach this summer I routinely RAN AWAY and left them to land on my children.
I have decided that this was a perfectly rational response. I’ve been told my whole life that the bees will not bother me if I don’t bother them, and my children have no intention of bothering the bees. I, on the other hand, run away because I have no choice.
October 6th, 2007 at 4:38 am
As always- I have read your words with utter fascination, amazement, and a touch of tears.
I did laugh out loud though at your request to your younger self to “pluck your eyebrows.” Yes, why did no one tell me about that all important beauty secret much, much sooner?!?
October 6th, 2007 at 5:33 am
how about one question? one giant simple perfect question. dish it, girl.
October 6th, 2007 at 1:35 pm
This was great. I so related to your advice to yourself, except I would tell me to avoid early 90s fashions (oversize pants? why the heck?) and to give up on all the no-frizz products and just accept the curly hair. And to wear my retainer!
About O and only children…I wasn’t one but I think lots about whether I will have more than one living child. It’s a horrible place to be.
I’ve seen this in other places, but yours is the only offer I’ve been tempted to accept. Ask me something please.
October 6th, 2007 at 2:47 pm
Since I suffer from a congenital inability to answer even the simplest questions, I’m even more dazzled by your answers than I otherwise would be. And, of course, I’m looking forward to reading the questions that you pose to someone else.
October 6th, 2007 at 6:31 pm
Oh my Goodness, Bon, as an only child myself, you entirely summed up my experience – how so eloquently put. I am moved. An regarding your thoughts on a sibling for Oscar (and Finn), I understand that too, from the same perspective. We are very much alike. (Hugs) Thanks for sharing – I love this stuff.
October 6th, 2007 at 7:44 pm
it’s okay to be unsure. it’s even okay to start again if you find yourself on a bad path. time isn’t really wasted, especially if you learn from it. stop being such a perfectionist – you’ll only disappoint yourself.
Advice that I wish I had been give as well at 18…
Great answers. I look forward to seeing what questions you come up with in future interviews of others.
October 6th, 2007 at 11:46 pm
Amazing answers, bon, particularly the one about only child-ness. I’ve often wondered about being an only child, because we pondered it so with Liam.
October 7th, 2007 at 1:27 am
Love your answers! Your bedside books put mine to shame!
I’d love to answer your questions, too! I’ve yet to do a meme!
October 7th, 2007 at 1:34 am
Fascinating, as usual. I was an only kid for eight years, and begged for it to end. I was thrilled when it did, and still am. This is why, I think, even before Monkey started asking for a sibling, it was not an option for me. It breaks my heart that she looks like an only kid now. It chases me.
I would love to answer some questions from you, if you would…
October 7th, 2007 at 5:30 am
Damn. You know what? I really like you.
October 7th, 2007 at 3:31 pm
I really enjoyed your answers.
My younger self could have used that same advice.
I also felt the same way about having my daughter be the ‘only’ child.
October 7th, 2007 at 11:04 pm
“it was in transitioning to adulthood that i realized i was leaving behind a whole world that had no existence outside of me, no narrative outside my own.” i think this describes how my dad felt as an only child.
and everything you write is so wonderful–even the memes!
October 9th, 2007 at 5:46 am
yep that high school one. I can relate.
thanks — I still need it.