Mon 14 Jan 2008
requiem
Posted by bon under coping stuff
[32] Comments
i’m always surprised, startled even, by the occasional intersection of my own small part of the planet with The Big World, with fame or notoriety or the evening news. i remember struggling, as a kid, to truly grasp the idea that people far, far away read Anne of Green Gables and actually took it seriously, thought of it as a good book. not because i didn’t – at that age the only judgement i had for Anne was sycophantic, heart-singing adoration – but because it’s set on little old PEI, the mundane backwater setting for my own, erm, slightly less poignantly uplifting story. i knew i thought the world of Anne and her impish, earnest shenanigans. i just couldn’t believe anybody else – out there, you know, in the real world – had actually heard of her.
i’ve been in a bit of the same state of shock this past couple of days, as every time i turn on the radio CBC news tells me again, on national broadcasts, about the tragedy in Bathurst, New Brunswick this past weekend. those of you outside Canadian borders may not have heard…late Friday night, on the way back home from a basketball game, a van of high school basketball players and their coach and family hit some ice on the highway and slid straight into the path of an oncoming tractor trailer. seven of the players are dead. so is the coach’s wife, who was a teacher at the school. the coach, who was driving, survived, along with his daughter and two players, so far as i can make out. they were nearly home, minutes from the exit that would have seen them safely off the highway.
it is a terrible story, and of pretty epic proportions, though i’m still shocked to see it at the top of Newsworld every hour. this is a part of the country that tends to get rather minimal news coverage outside of our own insular regional broadcasting, and doesn’t factor much in the national picture other Canadians seem to carry in their heads. when i lived in Vancouver, briefly, at twenty-two, desperately homesick, i took up daytime smoking mostly to have reason to congregate outside with the other smokers at the market where i worked, and at least twice heard people say they were from “out east” only to have my pitiful crows of “oh my god, really!?! i’m from PEI!” met with raised eyebrows and the blase comeback, “i’m from Guelph.”
Guelph is two hours from Toronto. in the middle of the country. but people seem to forget we’re out here.
i first heard about the accident early Saturday morning, before the details had even come in about where it had occurred, only that a van of high school athletes had crashed on the way back from some game and there had been multiple deaths. and i was struck, teacher as i once was, with what a shock wave this would send over the school, whatever school it might be. i had visions of adolescent grief and mourning that made me cringe against the rawness, the open wound of it all. one of the schools i work with here on the Island just went through its own heartbreaking accident a week ago, with one student killed and others hurt, still in recovery, and i know that entire community is still struggling to assimilate the reality. having the fabric of things torn open by death is a weird kind of shock at any age, but in adolescence there’s a particular vulnerability and confusion and instinct for the grandiose that makes it especially cruel. high school is bad enough without death.
i am not an adolescent anymore, at least on my better days. i’ve been up close to death and having the fabric of things torn open a few times now, and though the shock always takes me out at the knees, i like to think i’ve gotten beyond my base, juvenile instinct for making more of it than i have right to…and particularly for connecting myself, maudlin-like, to sorrow that is not my own.
yet the sorrow of the Bathurst High School boys’ basketball team has been living in my house the past few days. tears well in my eyes whenever i hear yet another story about it, and along with the disbelief that this has really made the national news and that the Prime Minister may attend the funerals on Wednesday, is something else there…something very personal, though ephemeral. i am not grieving those boys exactly, or the teacher who died, much as i have seen their names and faces now and looked, hard. i am in grief over proximity. i am grieving, for once, having been passed over…the exultant, fearful sorrow of those who, if destruction comes close, expect that something will smite them over the head, and are left shaken when it doesn’t. i am grieving the twenty-years-hence that will never happen for those boys.
because Dave went to Bathurst High School. he graduated as Male Athlete of the Year. he spent his high school years in those vans, on those roads, with that same poor surviving soul for a coach. there’s a Bathurst Phantoms rugby tshirt, almost a rag, still in our bureau. he still has his red and black hockey jacket, though it lives down at his parents’ cottage, a castoff brought out only on cold summer nights. the glory of the high school athlete was something he didn’t find hard to leave behind, i don’t think, and yet it is a part of him i barely know, hardly recognize, because i was so not an athlete and so not an athlete’s kind of girl that it isn’t a topic of conversation that, erm, comes up often.
but he wrote a post yesterday, trying to clear out some of the weight, to bear witness. Dave’s older brother, Stephen, died suddenly at 22 the week after Dave started high school at BHS. Dave wasn’t quite 15. he’d just made the hockey team, been given Stephen’s old number. he never got to tell him. and it was in those team vans, crowded, with tunes playing, pinging everywhere across the province late at night no matter the road conditions, that Dave found his way through the loss of his brother, found his feet despite that gaping hole. i think the vans were a kind of sanctuary for him, in those high school years that are hard enough in the first place.
and i think in my tears each time i hear about the Bathurst Phantoms are guilt and thanks, in the shock of proximity, that he made it through safe and largely unharmed, to me, this man now so far removed from the boy he was.
and my tears are sorrow, too, for those boys who will never get to find their way past high school to the maybe someones who might have loved them, chosen them, raised children with them, and looked at their old treasures in the closet and said, “oh yeh? did you use to play basketball?”
i am shocked, you see, that you might have heard of them, these boys from the little town of Bathurst, population 16,000ish. because to me they are all just Daves, in other incarnations.




January 15th, 2008 at 3:57 am
This was a beautiful post…and so very, very true. But the very end of your post? The very end of your post was phenomenal.
January 15th, 2008 at 4:11 am
Oh bon, I wanted to write about this and then couldn’t. I am such a loss for what happened in this place where I live. When I hear of that coach and the weight he must bear, his life surely destroyed by one small patch of ice, I burst into tears and must leave the room. When I think of those parents waiting outside the school for the van that never came…
Thank you for writing this and for writing about Dave. I’m off to read his post now.
January 15th, 2008 at 4:18 am
oh bon. what a tragedy. what a horrible loss. and the mirror, sometimes mirrors are too close, too painful, too full of what ifs and yet still even that unable to detract you from this moment in time.
January 15th, 2008 at 5:03 am
I am speechless for Bathurst, but was so grateful to read your words, and Dave’s…
January 15th, 2008 at 11:53 am
That’s a terribly sad story, even more so if it hits so close to you heart. Thanks for sharing this.
January 15th, 2008 at 11:57 am
I’ve been tearing up at this as well. When I lived in Northern Ontario, we’d drive for hours to games, and I always worried.
The man driving that van, the pain, the families…I went to high school in a town that small-I know the pain it causes when one young person dies, that many, unimaginable.
January 15th, 2008 at 12:56 pm
I tried to comment yesterday but it wouldn’t post, so here goes again. Just to say thank you. I’ve been waiting for someone to do this, and I’m glad it was you.
January 15th, 2008 at 1:01 pm
We prayed for their families in church on Sunday. It’s unbearable to even think about.
January 15th, 2008 at 1:29 pm
My post today was something completely inconsequential and light because I just couldn’t begin to encompass the sadness and shock I feel every time the news comes on.
I too am glad it was you who addressed this. For all of us.
January 15th, 2008 at 2:25 pm
This leaves me speechless. Thank you for your eloquence.
January 15th, 2008 at 2:27 pm
A bus load of college atheletes on their way to Florida plunged off a bridge and down onto the highway here last year. I think of the parents endlessly. It’s horrifying to imagine.
xo,
J
January 15th, 2008 at 2:54 pm
I hadn’t heard about this…and I am so sad to think about them…what a beautiful tribute.
January 15th, 2008 at 2:55 pm
I cannot imagine.
It is a beautiful Requiem, Bon.
January 15th, 2008 at 3:05 pm
Yes, I heard of the accident down here in Texas. It breaks my heart. I think the hardest part was knowing how close they were to home and their families were there waiting for them.
January 15th, 2008 at 3:41 pm
The Bathurst Phantoms? Of all the details in your post, that was the one that made me catch my breath. It’s the kind of painfully obtrusive coincidence that makes you believe that life is nothing more than a badly written novel with an unhappy ending.
January 15th, 2008 at 3:41 pm
I hadn’t heard. I hadn’t had the TV on in days. I am crying. Not I have tears in my eyes crying. I am sobbing and catching my breath, and wiping my eyes and my snot with my fists because I can’t find the tissues. The sorrow, the horror. I have no words. But I know you hear what it is I would say if I could muster a complete sentence.
I am going to go read Dave now.
January 15th, 2008 at 4:27 pm
How tragic. How heartbreaking. I shudder and choke a little to think of families waiting for triumphant young children with a big future ahead of them and instead getting the news nobody ever wants. I can’t seem to manage these stories, emotionally. I forced my husband to not mention the 4 children a dad threw off a bridge who all drowned. Can’t. do. it.
January 15th, 2008 at 4:50 pm
News of the crash has been a near-constant in our media here, where I live, so many hours away. The whole post is beautiful, but the last paragraph caught in my throat.
I’m glad you found the words to express the sorrow we’re all feeling for the inconceivable loss. I’m off to read Dave’s post, now.
January 15th, 2008 at 4:53 pm
I hadn’t heard about this tragedy (I haven’t watched the news or looked at a newspaper in weeks). So sad. I can’t even imagine the grief that those 7 families must be feeling. And the coach – his grief must be immense.
January 15th, 2008 at 5:33 pm
Its the way things are snuffed. So quickly. It’s that that always gets me.
Poor Dave. His brother. Watching my two girls, I cannot imagine how they would feel without the other.
January 15th, 2008 at 7:07 pm
My husband lost his younger brother in 1996, suddenly as well. It’s a wound that remains jagged and raw.
I did read about this accident, this horrid horrid accident, and felt it as a mother waiting for her child, going about with the presumption of everything being just fine, and the reality of course being too much to comprehend and survive.
And that poor coach, not even the slightest bit at fault, having to live with the death of his wife and those students.
January 15th, 2008 at 7:15 pm
Oh Bon, I am just so sorry – your story is utterly hearfelt. I see your connection to it, writhing. What an awful loss. It is entirely unfair, such an experience. (Hugs) to all you people ‘up north’ experiencing this in the news right now.
January 15th, 2008 at 8:13 pm
Actually, it seems you have quite a lot of personal connection to this tragedy and thus, your grief, is very real. It is terribly sad, and horrible, and all of those words that are used to describe the unthinkable.
Lives cut short…. it never gets any easier to bear that reality.
January 16th, 2008 at 1:14 am
As an athlete of yesteryear, as a writer, as a mother my heart is battered from reading this.
Your words are haunting and fitting and achingly perfect.
My thoughts are with all of you, so many miles away.
January 16th, 2008 at 2:35 am
Oh it’s all just so awful. Awful.
January 16th, 2008 at 7:36 am
It’s on the front page of every paper where we are, and on every newscast. I’ve been thinking and thinking about it. I just don’t know what to say.
January 16th, 2008 at 6:31 pm
beautiful and melancholy and so perfectly capturing the sadness of death at such a young age
January 16th, 2008 at 7:38 pm
My heart just aches for all those families.
Truly aches.
January 16th, 2008 at 7:59 pm
Very touching.
As you said, those people who were killed could have been Dave. It’s too bad that sometimes it seems it takes a tragedy to remind us that we are all in this life together.
January 16th, 2008 at 11:24 pm
Oh. What a horrible, horrible tragedy. Just heartbreaking.
January 17th, 2008 at 1:30 am
I’ve been under a rock down here apparently, and had not heard. When I hear of such tragedies I now of course think of the mothers and the loss of their “daves”, but your poignant thoughts on the young men are very moving indeed. Your connection is very real, thank you for a beautiful post. Oh, and please hug Dave for me.
January 17th, 2008 at 3:15 am
Oh Bon. This just knocked the wind right out of me. I don’t know what to say, but I’m sorry for those boys and the families and community who lost them.
You wrote this beautifully, by the way. Just beautiful.