Thu 31 Jan 2008
the fox who cried wolf
Posted by bon under issue stuff
in the old folk tale Chicken Little, an acorn falls on the head of a naive and gullible chicken, who jumps to the conclusion that the sky is falling. in a tizzy, she runs about the town shouting about imminent disaster, and whips the populace into mass hysteria…which an unscrupulous fox uses to manipulate the chicken and her fellow citizens to his own benefit. in other words, he eats them.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
it has come to my attention that i am a colossal, erm, fake.
i started the month - and the fresh new year - full of good, fine intentions. everything was coming up green. we were going to become more healthy hereabouts at the crib, and more earth-friendly, too. we were going to make a difference in our own lives and the world’s by eating less meat and more local foods, buying nothing that we didn’t actually, genuinely need (say, um, a helmet for Oscar’s premier venture on bob skates), using up what lurks in our freezer, and walking and generally exercising more. plus i was going to start a clothing exchange for kids’ stuff, or at least in my own mind, i was…i don’t think that plan ever made it to the public stage. but i was going to harness the power of teh internets, see, and bring people together and, you know, divide loaves and fishes and generally create a rainbow connection that would result in global harmony, a halt to climate change, and thinner thighs.
we are now approaching the end of month one of this fine venture. the community-building and clothing-exchanging end of the plan never even got verbalized properly. the exercycle saw a few minutes’ work but is now gathering dust once more. we flew to England and back, burning loads of jet fuel for half-empty planes both ways, and ate nothing but poor dead cows and lambs encased in pastry the entire time we were there. our deep freeze did get divested of some of its long-term inhabitants (yesterday’s near-province-wide power outage almost got them all out, and for good) and we have managed to eat the majority of the vegetables we bought this month, but i’ve also personally consumed about three boxes of leftover Christmas chocolates. Dave’s started leaving all the lights on again. yeh yeh. it ain’t easy being green.
and sometimes, with these kicks of better living i go on sporadically, i start to feel like the boy who cried wolf…shouting out “getting healthy! going greener!” and then, um, sitting down on my squishy butt and opening another bag of individually plastic-wrapped candies made out of pesticides and corn syrup. and worse, i begin to suspect that my green guilt and half-hearted efforts are the cornerstone of something even darker: that every time i fail to put my money where my mouth is i not only condone the illogic of rampant consumerism and blind, short-term societal self-satisfaction, but feed it and benefit from it like the fox in Chicken Little. every time i give in, i add to the chorus of cynical disbelief. every time i give up, i weigh in on the side of how hard it is to really be green, to live an earth-friendly life in this day and age. so i not only get to then enjoy the fruits of my unsustainable lifestyle whilst feeling virtuous for having made such a noble effort, but i lend my virtual voice to the general idea that this is all just to big and too hard for any of us to make a difference about, and that trying is just running around like Henny Penny, squawking foolishly.
but i do not believe that. and i do not want to give up. and so, with each new month, i will start again…Sisyphus pushing uphill, perhaps…but every so often, i may gain ground. and dear readers, you will keep me honest, whether you care about my personal Chicken Little saga or not. just because you’re there. and because i would hate for you to think i was a manipulative fake, even more than i hate to, erm, admit it to myself occasionally.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
one of the reasons i think i’m attracted to flights of fancy about my cyclically impending personal green revolutions is that i spent a great deal of my childhood in a family deeply governed by the Protestant work ethic and the scarcity mentality of the Great Depression. in my home, saving mattered. money was hard to save because it was hard to come by, but food and resources were carefully planned and accounted for, time was well used, and the act of making something “go a little further” was inculcated in me as an inherent pleasure more delightful than sunshine. we were frugal in a way that would have made every stereotypical Scottish ancestor in our clan lineage just bust with pride. saving was not just economic, it was moral. and waste was a source of shame that luckily, given our financial limitations, my mother and i simply did not have to stagger under in the way that others more burdened by excess did.
it does not take a psychologist to see how, in my banal middle-class adulthood, a part of me thrills to the idea of tightening my bootstraps and taking on the fine (ie. moral) challenge of reducing waste on all fronts, both commercial and environmental. i’m deeply attracted to the romance of scarcity, you see. when i was a kid i used to put myself to sleep imagining that i was trapped on a boat for a year and had to creatively, cheaply, and nutritiously stock the pantry with just the right number of tin cans. i like to imagine if any lard-ass North American can survive the projected apocalypses of oil crashing and seas rising…well, it’s gotta be me, right? i could make a case of beans last a year and Like It, at least in my own addled mind.
but a few things happened over the past week or so to point out to me what a crock of shit that little childhood hangover is. first, we spent three days last week in York, England. beautiful, historical, totally flooded York. i’ve never been witness to a flood before, not in person. and it struck me, standing on a stone bridge abutted by an 800-ish year old tower, well aware from my earlier trip through the Yorkminster crypts that the street level of the town has actually risen by at least six feet over the last millenium or two, that the fact that the water was completely covering the park benches on the riverbank really couldn’t be a good sign. and i noted that i don’t know how to swim. especially in sewage.
my survivalist daydreams were further disrupted yesterday when 90% of my province lost power for a couple of hours in the wake of an ice storm. i was at work. it was 12:0-something-or-other and i was really getting hungry and preparing to head to the campus cafeteria for pizza when the lights went out. by the time i dug my way out from the sudden blackout in the windowless, airless hole that is my office, it became clear that the cafeterias had, erm, shut. so i thought gamely, hell, i’ll drive to the sandwich shop! they have cold food! (note, i did not consider walking. but it was icy, so i excuse myself). Dave & i met up, got in the car, and drove to where the campus exits onto one of Charlottetown’s main arteries, which is still only a two-lane stree…normally pretty scantily populated by traffic at lunchtime. but yesterday, the whole city was on the move. lines of traffic snaked both ways as far as the eye could see, half the population piled into cars, aimlessly and lunchlessly steering towards where they hoped food might be. but nearly everything had closed and locked its doors, cold food or not…because all the cash registers are electronic.
it was like an eerie vision of a future i hope never comes. never before have i had hammered home to me how clearly dependent we all are on the constructions and fictions that make up this society…all of us like soft helpless sheep, driving in our little tin cans, using gas, money in our pockets…totally unable to feed ourselves as we steer towards the empty promise of open doors and possible hamburgers, unattainable.
i went home and ate rice chips and cheese, and watered my plants, and realized how odd it really is to be growing things in my home that i cannot eat. because those plastic cards in my wallet? untasty.













February 1st, 2008 at 3:43 am
Welcome back. I’ve been worried about you these past two days, not knowing if you were one of the unlucky ones without power for 48+ hours.
As for the post. Yes and yes again.
February 1st, 2008 at 3:48 am
I never thought of it as “the romance of scarcity,” but yes, I have much guilt about all the wating I do. And spend 1.50 USD on a 20 ounce bottle of diet pepsi at the convenience store when a 2 liter cost less at the grocery? I have the hands of the devil!
I enjoy sci fi writing, and have read many the post apocalyptic story. I have determined that I will not last a week shoudl I need to rely on my skills to live after an EMP stops all the computers. No doubt about it.
February 1st, 2008 at 5:05 am
I have to de-lurk myself after reading this post… brilliant and hilarious! You’ve captured perfectly the feeling of being beholden to our privileges at the same time we want to use them to do good. I laugh and cringe about this all the time, too. But I was always told it was a uniquely Dutch (read: thrifty) Protestant Work Ethic… ahh, the moral integrity of our ancestors. Cheers to you, and thanks so much for your writing.
February 1st, 2008 at 8:48 am
We’ve got it much easier over here across the pond, with the only shortages of organic stuff coming when the stores run out because so many people are turning green and farms can’t convert fast enough. Organic baby potatoes in bio-degradable corn based bags yummmmmmm…..We’ve got the best intentions for some gardening in the yard this year, taking the massive (dead) compost pile from corpse to copse and generally carbon-offsetting life, but otherwise are trying to embrace the Change One Thing approach - makes success demonstrably more likely and feels do-able. Last weeks was actually putting ALL the recycling out (accomplished). This weeks is no pre-packed sandwiches not in 100% recyclable packages (not so successful).
Excellent ’scare you and make it all seem more necessary; sci fi: The Sheep Look Up.
Glad you got home alright, Hugs from us.
e
February 1st, 2008 at 10:23 am
I must say, I am unashamedly not green. I split my rubbish because the council provides two seperate bins and damn it the recycling one is twice the size of the normal one. I take short showers because if I don’t there is a high likelihood the kids will kill each other. I have lights on in whatever room I’m in and the two adjacent ones and I don’t feel at all guilty ’cause I’m blind and I hate being in the dark. As far as I’m concerned Bon, you’re doin’ alright!
February 1st, 2008 at 12:11 pm
I think huge family makeovers are very difficult. I try to change one thing at a time, because I do not have the strength to go ALL GREEN all at once.
You are very, very right that we are quite dependant upon a global economy. BUt, until people in Ontario can grow vegetables in January, it may have to stay that way.
February 1st, 2008 at 12:12 pm
We lost power for a day this week, which was REALLY delightful. WE’re buying a generator now and stockpiling canned food - stuff that only a generation ago would have seemed like survialist silliness. Welcome to the end, I guess.
February 1st, 2008 at 12:25 pm
The one thing that always bugged me about apocalyptic sci-fi was the lack of sick people or those with chronic illnesses. Because you know that little plastic box I have strapped ot my stomach that keeps me alive? It only works with batteries. I would be screwed.
If the modern industrial economy goes down, I’m going down with it.
That said, because I’m so dependent on it, I happen to think that this soft-sheep lifestyle thing is pretty great. There’s nothing wrong with dependence and interdependence and all that, so long as we’re not oblivious to the problems we’re creating and actually do something about them.
February 1st, 2008 at 12:57 pm
Welcome back! I too wondered if you were among the dark, cold, hungry, probably smelly people on the island without power.
We too are trying in small ways to be greener. No plastic garbage bags, organic food whenever possible, only owing one car instead of two, moving closer to town so we would have a shorter commute and burn less fuel, buying new efficient appliances when we did move, and recycling like mad fiends. I am all too conscious of my failings (yes, I use pull-ups, people) but I think if everyone made small incremental changes it would be far more effective than a few die-hards growing all their own food, raising chickens, and eschewing all meat products.
It is alarming though how fast our civilization breaks down when the power goes out, isn’t it?
February 1st, 2008 at 1:39 pm
We’ve been trying too, but perhaps without the resolution, which makes the exercise less fraught with guilt? Exchanged car for hybrid, bought a quarter grass-fed cow that was raised nearby (whole thing neatly cut and packaged in my freezer), changing out lightbuls where we can. But parts are difficult; our city doesn’t recycle much, so we’re left scrambling to find out who WILL take those plastic containers that fruit come in. I drive — albeit my hybrid — too much. My sins are coffee and wine, neither grown locally, both of which take up an immense amount of fuel to get to me. I think we do what we can, when we can, and hope it becomes woven into our lives at some point. And hope others are doing what they can, too. As the above said, hilarious and beautiful post.
February 1st, 2008 at 2:48 pm
This was too funny, Bon. I wondered how you were making out when I heard about the power outage on the CBC.
We try too. We don’t need to drive anywhere here (we could take transit), but we drive cause it’s faster. And we have a gas guzzling, turbo wagon…instead of a hybrid…which I wanted, but D wouldn’t go for.
Most other things, we are pretty good with and we do have good recycling and composting programs. We try to buy locally as much as possible…good organic beef, farmer’s market, bread baked around the corner etc…
February 1st, 2008 at 4:16 pm
I also live in a constant state of guilt. I try my best but keep thinking “I could be doing more”. But I dont’. Ugh.
Very eye-opening, that power outage!
February 1st, 2008 at 6:20 pm
I was also worried, until the news said C-Town was ok.
I try and make tiny changes as I go, little steps instead of big ones. For me, questions purchases before I make them IS a big step. Growing up not poor, but with no extras 99% of the time makes me WANT the extras. It’s a struggle.
I want to try winter gardening soon-it scares me to think that someday, we’ll HAVE to do it, and we won’t know how. (There’s an entire series of fantast that this is a central part of)
February 1st, 2008 at 7:47 pm
What an interesting—and image-laden!—post.
It gives feet to flights of fancy and weight to weightlessness and meaning to chaos when we do these things.
February 1st, 2008 at 8:18 pm
oh god, Bon. i so know what you are saying. we are getting ready to put our money where our mouths are later this year and my voice will move into action and i am scared shitless.
February 1st, 2008 at 8:43 pm
Those are some scary thoughts. Wow.
February 1st, 2008 at 8:56 pm
Sci Fi apocalypse? A real oldie — ‘The Death of Grass’. This so inspired my father that he wanted me to have the daughters take lessons in archery, hand to hand combat, and survival foraging.
Letting The Side Down? Nah — every try is a help. Everything you teach the kids is a help. Everything is a compromise — for instance, we heat with wood, but we gather the wood using fossil fuel and we emit nasty stuff in the wood smoke.
This is such a good, thought provoking post. Love it. Thanks!
February 1st, 2008 at 9:51 pm
I too used to and still do see the romance in scarcity. I think of it like marriage. From the outside looking in it looks idyllic and romantic, from the inside looking out every day is survival and work. That why I enjoy watching Jericho so much. It feeds into that daydream of what it would be like if modern society was brought to its knees. If you haven’t watched it I highly recommend renting the 1st season on Netflix. The second season premieres here in the next week or so I believe unless the writers strike screwed that up. I guess the writers strike is our modern version of a faminine. What will we watch? How do we entertain ourselves? The humanity.
February 1st, 2008 at 9:55 pm
Bon, you are not a fake. You tried to take on in one month what most people aspire to over a whole year. You are already leaps and bounds ahead of the game as compared to some of us (raising my hand) who still eat cheetos mindlessly and never stops to think how riddiculous it is to pay $1.00 for the little plastic toxic bag of junk, and only thinks- mmmmm. yummy.
You’ll get there. Baby steps!
February 2nd, 2008 at 3:14 am
nay, not fake, whimsical!
February 2nd, 2008 at 1:20 pm
At least you have, or had, the intent. In my house, dh has recently discovered the joys of Costco so it is unabashed consumerism all the way. 10 tubes of toothpaste at a time? What a great idea! Repeatedly he tells me: “They have huge cans of infant formula there!” He can’t seem to get it in his head that pretty much the last thing you need when trying to breastfeed twins is, uh, huge cans of infant formula in the house…
Still, we are trying to eat less meat, so that is *something*. Even though you can get huge slabs of meat at Costco too…
February 4th, 2008 at 2:57 pm
My sister in law, who lives in the country close-ish to here, remarked to me that most people don’t have enough food in the house to last them a week. Thanks to her huge summertime garden and stockpiling, preserving ways, her family of six has enough food in the house to get them through at least a month.
I know whose house I’m heading to when the apocalypse comes. I will bring the two jars of peach jam leftover from my summertime preserving, to get my family of five in the door.
February 5th, 2008 at 5:48 pm
Yes to everything. I had that I’m a giver-upper, a can’t do it -er. That we don’t have a lot of food around, or the means to care for ourselves. Boo.
Let’s keep trying, though, shall we?
February 8th, 2008 at 7:26 pm
I had Robinson Crusoe daydreams throughout my childhood. I’d also sit in my bedroom and make nuclear fallout shelters out of legos. I’d walk alongside my mother through a grocery store and imagine what it would be like to be trapped by catastrophe and have to live off of aisle 4 for a year. I’d read nuclear apocalypse books and take survival notes. I was a child of the 80’s.