Mon 31 Mar 2008
in praise of universal health care
Posted by bon under issue stuff
i figure, if you tally up the days i’ve spent in hospital due to complications of pregnancy and the ultrasounds and procedures i’ve had done due to complications of pregnancy and the NICU time and attention and machinery my offspring have hogged due to their early arrivals - which in turn were due to complications of pregnancy - you’d come to two logical conclusions: one, pregnancy is not my calling and i need a new hobby, and two, in a country that provides universal health care, i’m a frigging drain on the system and a threat to freedom everywhere.
or at least, the latter is the conclusion i begin to come to every time i wade into the soup that appears to be the American electoral conversation regarding health care. and then i get down on my faithless knees and thank the good lord - in tongues and Esperanto and whatever bad French i can summon up from the nation’s shaky thirty-plus-year experiment in bilingualism - that i live where i do, and that some semblance of universal health care survives in Canada.
not that there aren’t problems with our system. there are. waits for family doctors and “elective” surgeries, even long waits for life-saving diagnostic measures like mammograms and MRIs, particularly in some centres. my local emergency room parking lot fills up some nights and people wait, listless and in pain, for hours on end. sometimes. other nights i’ve been seen in ten minutes. but when you’re the one waiting, it still sucks.
however, no one is turned away, deflected to another hospital further away in a crisis situation because they cannot pay. everybody who walks in is seen. there are no co-pays to tally, no lists of what is and isn’t covered, no dehumanizing rejections or anxious re-applications. you present your provincial health card - even if you’re visiting from another province - and you take your place in the line, and once you’re seen you walk out…so long as your age or medical condition don’t preclude walking. there is no exchange of cash. if you came by ambulance or left with a prescription, there will be a bill down the road, from the province or your pharmacy, but that’s about it. if you need physio, you get referred, and while the wait for hospital physio can be long, it’s free. Oscar’s asthma clinic appointments? free. my hearing test last year when Dave was sure i was going deaf and not just, erm, not listening? free. the referral last year about a possible cyst in one breast? free, and fast. i was seen by the specialist in less than a week. all was well. and none of these were even complications of pregnancy.
when it’s come to my attempts to procreate, the Canadian taxpayers have been generous. i guesstimate - though the billing numbers can admittedly be specious depending on how governments or corporations choose to subsidize or inflate the costs of running and staffing hospitals - that most adult, taxpaying citizens of my fair nation have likely spent at least 1.2 cents each on me and my universal health care over the last three years of this baby-attempting circus. if this pregnancy leads to further hospital bedrest and, far more costly, NICU time for wee Hughloise, those costs could rise to upwards of 1.5 cents each. Canadians, i thank you personally. seriously. i am your tax dollars at work, me and Oscar and the stitched-in one and the dreams that ended in an urn upstairs and a D&C in November. i don’t know how to tell you it was worth it, in financial terms…but i can tell you even after all the heartache, i would do it all again. does that count for something? is it worth a penny and a bit’s lifetime investment? i dunno. to me the two don’t exactly make for a natural equation, because i am not accustomed to valuing human life and grief and joy in pure dollars. and that’s why i’m grateful for universal health care, above all else. because it doesn’t force me to contort myself until i begin to see that equation as natural.
if universal health care didn’t exist, Dave and i would still be nearly $100,000 in debt, with no real hope of digging our way out no matter how many fancy Masters’ degrees we conjure up on our home printer. Finn was born fourteen weeks early, only three months after we moved back home from Korea. we were substitute teaching, working our butts off to get a mortgage, and taking short-term contracts where we could. we had jobs, but no insurance. in Canada, this meant we ended up on the hook for $750 of a thirteen thousand dollar airlift, which outraged naive moi…and i just missed out on qualifying for the fifteen weeks of maternity leave pay i would otherwise have gotten from the government in spite of the baby’s death, because i hadn’t worked quite enough hours. so we spent that summer broke and grieving and i had to hustle for a new job before i was really up for it and it was hard. but…but. i did not spend that summer contemplating a bottomless, hopeless, helpless pit of debt in hospital bills, the weight of them crushing. i did not have to ask myself if that eleven hours was worth the cost of the desperate machines, the specialists, the medication, the wires, the tubes. i only had to ask myself if i had the courage to try again.
and so i sit, agog, watching the vitriol spew from pundits and bloggers and BabyCenter board posters every time the subject comes up, and i shake my head, because i just don’t get it. freedom? um….has the word ‘free’ in it, folks! seriously, if you want to talk freedom and health care in the same sentence, talk about freedom to. freedom to see a doctor when you’re sick without worrying whether you can afford it. freedom to focus on healing after injury or loss, freedom to try again after the death of a child without worrying that it will financially cripple you. freedom to see specialists for your child without your husband having to take a pay cut to qualify for insurance because hers was cut off and she has a pre-existing condition.
i guess i’m just slow coming to terms with how scary this whole concept of socialized medicine can be for a lot of people. i grew up in a country where most citizens take pride in our universal health care system, much as we love to bitch about it out of the other side of our mouths - heck, we still acclaimed our long-dead Medicare founder Tommy Douglas as the Greatest Canadian ever a couple of years ago in a national contest, and not because he’s Kiefer Sutherland’s grandfather. but i suppose, in the end, where a people’s collective sense of belonging and pride is located is a subtle, touchy thing…and it is in this one place that i see huge and real differences between the self-identified average American and the self-identified average Canadian.
so just let me say that i’m grateful to the True North, strong and free, while i sit here nursing the fishing line they hitched into my cervix last week, on twelve hours notice, gratis. i am eating right, and working hard, and doing my best with your 1.2 cents, folks. and if you ever need my 2 cents, well…help yourself.













March 31st, 2008 at 11:10 pm
(I’m first??) Do not get me started, or I won’t leave room for anyone else to post. As self-employed Americans, the husband and I are pretty much egregiously hosed by the insurance companies, and pay outrageous premiums, get no preventative care, the preconditions are mindboggling . . . and yet, in a catastrophe, they saved us. I’m guessing Maddy’s short six day stay on earth cost in the neighborhood of $300K. We paid probably $3 of it. I’m afraid to pick up the phone and ask if they’d even consider covering another pregnancy, or if they’d consider another child a precondition.
April 1st, 2008 at 12:51 am
Amen. True North strong and FREE.
April 1st, 2008 at 6:03 am
We moved from Canada to Scotland and an almost-identical medical system. I don’t think we’d have made this move without free health care, it’s enough of a deal for us that we’d never consider moving to the states (and we have jobs where moves are frequent and expected).
You’re perfectly right, freedom should equal free-from-financial-worry about those health issues we can’t control. (We’ve been cheap on the healthcare front so far, lucky us, but I’m more than happy to pay into the general pot for those without our luck).
April 1st, 2008 at 8:29 am
Yep, free health care AND year-long partly funded mat leave…
and I’d be happy to contribute even more to you, though I’m hoping not to have to.
April 1st, 2008 at 8:46 am
It IS marvelous to think about how wonderful universal health care is. When I was so sick a few years ago, we actually talked about how that would likely have been a bankrupting experience in the States.
April 1st, 2008 at 8:51 am
(pumping fist in the air)
Yes! Right on, Bon. Truly, I do think that the closest thing we Canucks have to a national identity (besides bitching about the weather, of course) is our pride in national health care.
I’m assuming you’ve seen “Sicko”. Regardless of how you feel about Michael Moore’s politics, there was one moment in particular that I thought was really nice. He’s puttering around in a golf cart with a retired fella from southern Ontario, and the gentleman basically says “when your neighbours are sick or in trouble, you take care of them. That’s what our system is for.”
Right on. And I’d gladly contribute five times as much for you and your fishing line and little Hughloise.
April 1st, 2008 at 9:13 am
Hooray to that! I couldn’t imagine contemplating the health of my child in dollars and cents. Honey, the dog got hit by a car…sorry we can’t afford the $2000 to save her. Honey, the kids are hurt, sorry we can’t afford…Yeah, that’s just not right.
April 1st, 2008 at 9:20 am
Another day where I wish I were Canadian….
April 1st, 2008 at 9:42 am
I work for an American company, and will hear sometimes “Why don’t you move down south?”
Not without my healthcare.
My mother dying from cancer was a slow ordeal, with frequent hospital stays, tests, treatments. The drugs alone would have bankrupted us. We would have been grieving, and absolutely poor.
No one should have to live like that.
As much as I feel everyone should pay their own way-that libertarianlike attitude does not extend to health care or education. How it’s offensive or “wrong” to care for other people, to ensure care and coverage…I just don’t get it. And yet, everyone wants to defend the right to bear arms….
Our systems is far from perfect. But I don’t worry as much as I do when I travel in the states. I cannot imagine living there as well.
And I’ll take my tax refund in timbits for all the tax money of mine you’ve used. Kthanxbai.
April 1st, 2008 at 10:17 am
Sadly, sadly, sadly for many of my fellow Americans freedom = freedom from, freedom from tyranny, by which many seem to mean freedom from obligations to have their money help others. I know it is more complicated than that, but I’ve boiled it all the way down a few times now & it keeps looking back at me, ugly in the bottom of the pot- just plain selfishness b/c those claiming freedom from, already have freedom to.
April 1st, 2008 at 10:27 am
amen.
Erik and I used to wonder how much Frances’s eight-day stay in the NICU would have cost us, down south, and how we would have paid for it. And my diabetes. And the kidney infections I used to get as a kid. It’s expensive enough, just for the drugs (and yes, I do have to pay for hte drugs for diabetes–our universal health care system is not actually all that universal. But that’s no reason to make it less so).
So I figure the 1.5 cents I paid you are more than balanced out by the at least 3.0 cents you’ve contributed to me over the year. When I see you in May, I’ll bring you a cookie and we’ll be even.
April 1st, 2008 at 10:43 am
A health crisis in our family put us nearly in an amount of debt it scares me to type, and that was WITH INSURANCE.
We moved from “socialist” MA to “pull up your own damn boots by yourself” TX.
We got out of that debt. But oh it set us back. We even sold our house and downsized everything.
I don’t like to talk about that. It feels shameful. But I wonder if I ought to be the only one feeling shame.
FTR, in *most* of the US (with a few notable exceptions you only need one hand for)? Getting pregnant and staying pregnant is your own personal problem; not one for insurance.
Bon, this post.
*on my feet applauding* Bravo!
April 1st, 2008 at 10:52 am
I can see where you are coming from. I have a friend who went to the emergency room here in the Southern U.S. due to what they believe was a ruptured cyst. She hasn’t finished getting all the bills for the ambulance ride, the MRIs, and the E.R. visit yet. The bills she has gotten so far total up to over $9,000 for the 8 hours she was there and she has no insurance. When I had Bear I did 6 days in the hospital and he did 16. With my insurance we paid approximately $1,700.00 out of pocket in co-pays. Lets not even mention what we pay monthly for our premiums.
April 1st, 2008 at 11:32 am
Yes, Bon. Well put, well said. If only more of us got our voices out there? It seems that a lot of Americans really think we have a terrible system here and that our doctors collect food stamps and that we are al prescribed cod liver oil and a tylenol for cancer and that it’s backwards and over-priced, etc. etc. But whenever I hear anything insurance-related from our American friends, it seems wayyyyy worse than anything I’d have to face here.
I’d pay at least another penny to keep you well. At least.
April 1st, 2008 at 12:21 pm
I’ve been pretty healthy my entire life and my husband has pretty much never needed the health-care system. We HAPPILY give our 1.5 to you, our 3 to Andrea and our whatever to whoever else needs it. And, why, would you look at that! I have just enough left over to buy a little gift for Huhloise when s/he arrives.
My niece had a bone-marrow transplant that necessitated almost a full year in hospital. I want to thank you all for helping her from the bottom of my freedom-loving, socialist heart and I humbly ask you all to watch over me when I eventually enter my dotage.
Oh, one more thing: I ranted the other day about a missed diagnosis on my thyroid. Mistakes happen no matter what system you’re in. My grandfather died of a curable condition when Tommy Douglas was still a Baptist preacher. My dad died of a curable disease at the height of the socialized-everything Trudeau era. And now, my tiny little gripe about my thyroid. Shit happens all the time.
April 1st, 2008 at 12:30 pm
My state’s pretty good on the healthcare front, including mandated coverage for infertility treatment (though not everyone who can’t have a baby meets their definition of infertile). But it really is too bad that single payer seems completely politically infeasible.
April 1st, 2008 at 12:58 pm
Kiefer Sutherland is related to Tommy Douglas?! I had no idea.
Great post. I have done my share of bitching about the healthcare system, but when we spirited my youngest to the hospital last January with a raging UTI she was admitted immediately. In general, when you’re really sick, you get the care you need without thinking about the cost.
Also, without Universal Healthcare I would be out at work right now because we would need the benefits.
April 1st, 2008 at 12:59 pm
Though our system is terribly lacking, it’s FAR better then what it could be. I am extremely grateful for what we do have.
Excellent, excellent post Bon!
April 1st, 2008 at 1:08 pm
Bon, exactly! and while everyone continues to debate and punditize, millions go deeper into debt over what should be a basic human right. it’s utterly shameful.
April 1st, 2008 at 1:32 pm
Amen, Bon. AMEN.
You and I are thinking along the same lines today.
April 1st, 2008 at 2:06 pm
clapping my hands over here … i can’t even imagine having to deal with the emotional recovery of losing my boys after weeks in nicu on top of the financial recovery of that … i remember the first thing we did in the months that followed was to go out and buy a house because we so badly needed to move forward. if i had medical bills to pay, that never would have happened. our healthcare system may have its flaws but it is indeed praiseworthy on more levels than not because universal healthcare is and should be a basic human right.
April 1st, 2008 at 2:21 pm
I am jealous of your health care system. We spent thousands of dollars on both Porgie’s and Izzy’s births - and both were routine pregnancies, with uncomplicated births. I was actually just charged $700 because the doctor performing my c-section with Izzy had a surgical assistant. According to my insurance company, a c-section does not require a surgical assistant. It is so frustrating and exhausting to argue with the insurance companies.
April 1st, 2008 at 3:14 pm
I, too, would pay 100 times that wee amount to ensure you this dream, Bon. You are a good ‘neighbor’ to have up there in the True North. I hope to visit your parts one day. Hugs to you -
April 1st, 2008 at 6:03 pm
I’m standing up and cheering, Bon.
The problem in the U.S. is that the “haves” don’t want the “have nots” to affect them at all. But they already do. They’re just living in denial, or GWB’s airless bubble.
I’ve been off reading all blogs for a good long time now, despite the ocassional posting over at my site. I didn’t know you were preggers again. CONGRATS! And I didn’t know about the cerclage. (Stay in there, baby bun. You need to bake longer!) I’m so happy for you, babe.
April 1st, 2008 at 8:12 pm
Came here by way of Julie’s.
I so agree that a Universal Health System is something to be loud and proud of. As an Australian, it has been our right since the early seventies to have access to free health care.
Of course, times, they are a changing, and our last government had a brainwave to try to move to private health across the board.
Like that is such and excellent idea…
April 1st, 2008 at 10:03 pm
I cannot even begin to calculate what I’ve cost Ontario taxpayers in the last year. I’ve always had to tell my husband not to complain about our taxes and since last year he hasn’t said a word. We have a phenomenal system and I cannot understand the fear some Americans have of universal health care.
When I finished university I got a great job in Michigan. I backed out when I was sent the HMO information including a list of which doctors - by name - I could see. When I called to turn down the offer my would have been supervisor called me a socialist.
She was right.
April 1st, 2008 at 10:23 pm
Rock on.
People think It Won’t Happen to Them because they are X, Y, or Z. And when it does, it’s too late because they have become the voiceless, those they previously suspected of having done something to deserve that.
Yeah, human psychology is wonderful. Even more wonderful are the soulless assess willing to exploit said psychology to divide and alienate, and line their pockets. Ok, rant done.
Hooray for fishing line.
April 2nd, 2008 at 4:50 am
Thoughtful post. I’m due to call our insurance company tomorrow to make sure that the hospital where I’m going to deliver is already set up to take my coverage when we arrive. And fill out whatever other forms need to be done. And make more photocopies of the insurance card so that they can be handed out left and right when I go for more appointments.
I don’t take this good coverage for granted though. We pay a lot for it, but we’re grateful to be able to afford it, unlike so many others in the US.
April 2nd, 2008 at 9:18 am
as a yank, i am very very jealous.
April 2nd, 2008 at 10:18 am
I ache with teh jealousies.
John and I are uninsured. It totally effing sucks.
April 2nd, 2008 at 12:36 pm
I come from the UK - where the National Health Service provides ‘free’ medical care for all.
But it’s crap. And it’s not free. We pay enormous taxes to cover it.
April 2nd, 2008 at 2:20 pm
Thank you for writing this post. I am by nature conservative. I believe people should be required to try to help themselves before they look to the government to solve their problems. But even I see that the health care system we have here is a disaster.
Insurance companies denying coverage at will because they must to stay afloat.
Responsible people who made responsible life choices unable to pay medical bills or get coverage.
Our middle child who cost us $15,000 because our insurance didn’t have maternity coverage.
Kyla.
We hear so much here about the horrors of the Canadian and Brittish public healthcare systems, I am so glad you shared your perspective.
April 2nd, 2008 at 3:07 pm
i’m crapping big bricks waiting to see how much of my $20K cerclage (just the hospital bill; the performing doc and anesthesiologist are separate) my insurance company will sock me with…if i read the fine print correctly i’ll get to pay 30% of it.
we need a sugar daddy.
April 3rd, 2008 at 11:05 pm
We’re rugged individualists down here, don’t you know.
April 4th, 2008 at 11:02 am
Thanks for this post. I know that with universal health care some things would change, and not always for the better, but it seems to me that the good of everyone getting health care outweighs the bad. i think it’s only the rich with good insurance who feel otherwise here, but unfortunately they are loud and well lobbied.
April 4th, 2008 at 12:24 pm
*Applauds*
I agree with you Bon, and honey, a few years back, I cost the system a mint of two, then I paid a bunch of taxes for a few years, and cost them nothing, this year and the last few months of 2007, I cost the system don’t.ask.how.much.
And that’s okay. I will gladly pay for all your healthcare through my taxes, and you can help pay all of mine, and really, isn’t that what friends and neighbours and fellow citizens are for?
And yes, I rant about diagnosis stuff but so what? Doctors don’t always diagnose stuff over in the US properly either. But never, ever, ever have I had to worry about money or bills or who was going to pay. And that little piece of stress made all the difference I think.
On another note, I saw a comment you left on another blog about prenatal diagnosis stuff? If there is anything you need–anything at all, just email. Take care.