Sun 20 Apr 2008
songs of labour and other things i’m not supposed to say
Posted by bon under coping stuff, pregnancy stuff
two years ago this morning i woke up exactly 36 weeks pregnant, rolled awkwardly over, smiled at Dave as the sun poured in our bedroom window and the cat perched atop my enormous belly, purring, and said, “God, i hope i don’t go into labour today.”
he looked me cock-eyed. i was almost ten weeks more pregnant than i’d ever been before…and while we’d spent most of January, February, and March silently hoping each morning that the day would bring precisely nothing in the way of labour, never before had i actually spoken the words aloud.
but he knows me. “why today?” he inquired, with the exaggerated tolerance of one who does not expect that the answer will hold much relevance.
“it’s Hitler’s birthday.”
“yes….” and when i looked stricken, as if his lack of immediate and evident reaction was dooming our offspring to a life of wretched, hopeless flailing against an evil horoscope, he laughed. “ummm, yeh. but nobody knows that,” he said.
“well, i know it,” was my reply. and then the floodgates of neurosis burst. “…and Finn died on April 30th, and that’s the same day Hitler died, and i don’t want some weird kind of Hitler theme in my children’s dates!” i finished on a slightly hysterical note, and then sulked righteously, feeling silly but strangely content, entrenched in my petulance and my warm spot in the bed.
i’ve always remembered dates without effort. my fixation on them, though unintentional, was a strange, ever-present part of the way i coped with the grief and helplessness of the year between Finn’s birth and Oscar’s. the dates were a grim truth or consequences game of life and death, a measuring out of patience and endurance: on this day last year, or when i last did this, or it has been twenty weeks since he died and in another twenty weeks this baby might have a chance at viability. but that morning, serious as i was about the whole Hitler connection and also my sneaking suspicion that it meant i’d truly turned the corner into crazy, the conversation was…light. it assumed that a baby born that day - however unauspicious the date - would live. it was, for the first time in almost a year, the closest Dave & i came to joking about birth.
and so we kept going. “how do you know all sorts of other horrible people weren’t born on other dates that you have no idea about?” Dave countered. he rolled out of the bed and picked up the laptop. he likes obscure historical information. and before he went to work that morning, Wikipedia most kindly helped us identify not only a variety of pleasant, innocuous things which had happened on April 20ths of years past, but which famous folk had been born on each day of the following two weeks. i set my sights somewhere in May. and promptly went into labour about 8 pm that night.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Oscar was born at 1:47 am the following morning. he made it safely into April 21st, thus putting him in the fine birthday company of Queen Elizabeth II and Iggy Pop, whose sensibilities visibly compete in his cusp-of-Taurus soul. he passed through me like a thunderstorm. i went into labour at book club, eating trifle. for an hour or more i sat with my secret, a Cheshire cat silently timing the increasing, regular contractions. when i left, i don’t think anyone but me believed that i’d be having a baby that night. i made my way home at ten, found Dave webcasting live, smiled and waved, sniffed the tumbler on his desk to see who’d be driving to the hospital, and went upstairs to pack my bag. we took some last belly photos, laid down for a few minutes to watch the Lamaze tape a friend had sent months before, before another year of childbirth classes got cut short by my untimely admission to hospital for bedrest. i wrote in my journal in the quiet of our yellow kitchen, posted a quick post on the fledgling blog. and about twenty minutes too late, not long before midnight, we left for the hospital. by the time we arrived, five minutes later, i was in full-blown, five-centimetres-dilated and hard contractions every minute kind of labour. the second helping of trifle threatened a reappearance at every turn. and then, without warning, when the overwhelming pain would not allow me to bend in the middle and thus sit on the birthing ball i’d been so hopefully looking forward to “enjoying,” i went into a complete, disassociative panic attack. it was what i’ve since discovered is a classic post-traumatic-stress-reaction panic response, not uncommon in women who’ve had traumatic or ill-supported births or post-birth infant losses associated with their previous experience of labour. but no one had ever mentioned such a thing, and it had not occurred to me to anticipate it, look it up, prepare for such an eventuality. not until my labour ramped from zero to sixty in fifteen minutes and there was suddenly no respite from the brutal, muscular jaws of my uterus and my scarred cervix and i could not catch my breath, could not breathe at all and the fifty-one weeks in the interim were burned away as if with acid and i was animal and desperate and pleading and frightened, so frightened, and this time i knew exactly what the abyss looked like and i knew i was not strong enough for that.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
i went into labour twice with Finn. the first time, they stopped it with drugs and they airlifted me and put me on bedrest and high doses of antibiotics and more than two weeks later i began to believe all would be well when i woke up one morning in my hospital room with a strange twinge in my belly. they strapped on monitors and wheeled me down to Labour & Delivery faster than i could even rescue my long-distance phone card from my bedside table, so i had to call Dave’s sister, locally, and get her to track him down in Charlottetown where he was closing on our new house, our first home. he had just set foot inside the door, had not even signed for the keys, when he turned around and hightailed it back out the door for that loneliest, scariest four-hour race to the hospital. there was no single day where, even stuck in different provinces, we just got to celebrate being homeowners for the first time. just like there was no single day where we just got to celebrate being parents.
i did not believe, i don’t think, that the timing could really be that impossibly bad; that of the seventeen days i’d been in hospital to date it would, it could be that one, that one with the carefully scheduled dryer delivery and the phone and internet hook-ups and all the necessary paperwork that Dave had to be there for. i had accepted that the baby would be early, had thrilled to reach the 26 week mark the day before, representing a 75% chance of survival. i was feeling positive, prepared to deal with altered timelines, expectations. but not that morning. just not that morning. i spent the first hour or two of active labour in total denial, sure the meds would stop the increasing tide just as they had before. when it became evident that they would not, and i knew Dave was still hours away, i moved from denial to shock. then the pain overtook me.
when you labour that early they strap you to your back on a delivery table, because the baby must be monitored at all times. i had back labour. i had scar tissue on my cervix that was preventing dilation, even though my contractions came a minute apart for almost two hours straight. i had young nurses who were competent but inexperienced, unable to rise to meet me and hold my eyes through that fog of pain. when i broke with all my own preconceived notions and begged for an epidural, i discovered the main body of anesthesiologists for the hospital were on strike, and due to some c-sections that morning it would be close to two hours before i could expect one. it was exactly two hours. Dave arrived ten minutes later, and for a window all was calm. then the baby’s heartrate dipped badly, and suddenly it was rush and bustle and there were noises being made about a c-section and i said yes, yes please but the doctor, white-haired and cold and never met my eyes said no, no we’d have to do a vertical cut and it’s just not worth it for this baby at this point and i remember blinking, yet another shock because clearly my baby needed to come out and i didn’t give a shit about me thank you very much and i was honed in utterly on the 75% chance of survival, you see, because we’d already had a bad enough day so surely all would be well if we could just get the baby out. and an older nurse who had come in a moment before with the 3 pm shift change, curly-haired, she looked me in the eye for what felt like the first time all day and said meaningfully do you want a second opinion? and i said yes and then there was someone else there and he wanted to just check one more time manually and i felt nothing, numb, but he said the cervix is gone - the scar tissue had torn, finally - this baby is coming! now! and an alarm and two quick pushes and my eyes locked on Dave’s, beseeching, and in a rush of blood i saw one small, perfect ear as ten people in yellow gowns and masks rushed into the room and they whisked him away, our tiny son, the baby i had just birthed. it was 3:24 pm. he lived for eleven hours.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
so it was that i went into Oscar’s birth, exactly fifty-one weeks later, four weeks early, assuming that it couldn’t help but be better, that so long as i came out with a live baby on the other end all would be well. and yet the irony is that i walked out of Finn’s birth broken-hearted but feeling nonetheless amazed and proud of what my body had done, however insufficiently. i was awed by the fact that i had borne him, made him in the first place, from that perfect ear to his tiny toes, replicas of his father’s. in the hours before he died, i was so high from the sheer wonder of having given birth that had you handed me an ashtray instead of a baby to hold in those moments, i think i’d have cradled it tenderly, fallen in love. for months after he died, one of the only ways i could manage to treat myself with any care and respect whatsoever, to stave off the bleakness and the craving for destruction was to remind myself, “i am Finn’s mother.”
Oscar’s birth did not leave me with the same sense of anything, except ultimately, relief that he was safely out and then bewilderment and guilt that i could not summon the same high for a successful birth as i had for the doomed one. O’s delivery was quick and dirty and out of control, a clusterfuck of interventions i didn’t want and didn’t believe i needed, and it culminated not only in a third-degree episiotomy - done with scissors i still see in flashbacks - that i begged them not to do and that caused me raw pain for a year afterwards, but worse, in being rushed off to the OR only minutes after birth to have the stitches ripped open again because the placenta did not disengage. i had good nurses, good solid nurses, and Dave with me until the moment they took me away, but they could not reach me where i was, in the grip of visceral flashback. i was helpless, and then acted upon, quickly and without my consent, because all was happening so fast. i did not get to hold my baby for more than a minute. i did not get to nurse him, to do more than glance at his small self, to breathe. after the placenta was scraped out and the hemorrhage stopped, i was left alone in Recovery, shaking and utterly beaten by the panic and a sense of shamed, helpless violation and failure, and once again, shock, that i could have managed yet again to be so completely unprepared for what birth would bring. and sure, somehow, that when i emerged from that dark night of the soul, that this baby too would have disappeared forever, another tiny ghost ripped away.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
he did not, bless him. he was there, squalling and puffy, three hours later when i finally got to cradle him for a moment, hours again after that when the morning shift ultimately brought him back for me to try to nurse. and so i landed, finally, shakily, gratefully, in the place that comes after labour, in the land of the living and of moving forward, of babies and spit up and sleep deprivation and smiles and joy and bittersweet milestones.
but labour, to me, is like another country, that only those who have been there can begin to imagine or describe, and that never turns out quite the same in any two depictions. only now, a full two years after the night O was born, can i look back on that birth and say, with any conviction, all that matters is a healthy baby. it does, beyond all measure. and yet i hate the phrase, wince each time i hear it. because being torn and broken and alienated does matter, does impact how a person experiences new motherhood, no matter how truisms may shame or belittle her experience. birth can be a trauma and wound in and of itself that requires processing and grieving just as real and profound as that demanded by loss. birth for me has been a profound and great and terrible thing, a wild horse that brings me to my knees. every minute of it, both times, was worth it, to meet my babies, to watch my beautiful living boy try to blow out candles for his birthday. i will do it again, without hesitation. and yet i am terrified, utterly. i am afraid of more shock, more surprises. i am afraid of a reprise of the guilt of having my body fail one child and my endorphins fail to soar at the birth of the other, afraid of what possibly could go wrong that i haven’t even thought of yet. i am afraid of being that afraid again.
i wonder, sometimes, if it is like this for everyone, each in our own way. and i wonder, in some small, fool part of me, if hoping that the third time’s a charm will make everything easier when the time comes around again.
hopefully it will be months and months away from April.













April 20th, 2008 at 10:37 pm
I pray that the 3rd time will be a charm and so much more for you. You deserve a better delivery experience than the previous two. Although I had a terrible birth experience with Bear I hold out hope that the next one will be better although I am still terrified. It is a series of contradictions for me. Exhilaration and dread.
April 20th, 2008 at 10:44 pm
I wish I could be with you for your birth, to chase away the scissors and the panic, to give you a peaceful space to labour and birth.
I think we all hope that third time is very much a charm. I think of you often, especially on days like today, warm days where I’m outside in the sun, and I know you’re inside, staring out, thinking, pondering….your Oscar growing up around you.
This time will be fine. This time will be yours.
Happy Birthday Mama.
April 20th, 2008 at 10:44 pm
I hope, with all of my heart, that the third time is a charm. And happy birthday Oscar!
April 20th, 2008 at 10:56 pm
Birth really is the one thing a body can do that is so basic and primal and important and affecting. This was just riveting, beautifully written. Happy Birthday, too.
April 20th, 2008 at 11:14 pm
Wonderfully written. I feel like crying. And happy birthday to the lovely boy x
April 20th, 2008 at 11:16 pm
The third time will be different and amazing and wonderful in its own way … happy birthday darling Oscar!
April 20th, 2008 at 11:43 pm
Happy birthday to Oscar.
And may the third time be as far from the first as possible.
April 20th, 2008 at 11:43 pm
Months and months away.
Is there any chance of you getting to see somebody to talk about this, to prepare? Knowing it might happen again is helpful, but maybe a professional would be able to give you some tools you would be able to use to bring yourself back to the moment.
My labor, too, is quick, but because of the order they came in, and because of the environment I was in they were neither of them traumatic as such. I am sorry it wasn’t so for you.
April 20th, 2008 at 11:59 pm
Julia,
i met with a doula earlier this week, just to test the waters and find out what kind of resources are available where i am. she was lovely, and if i do end up delivering here in PEI (ie, if i make it past 32 weeks) then i may consider her services, just to have an advocate and support who is less connected to the baby and i than Dave is. but she has no background, really, with post-traumatic birth…and given my penchant for quick deliveries and retained placentas, was unable to say that she’d necessarily be able to make the event less interventionist. still might be worthwhile, but i do wish i had the resources of a larger centre available for this…because at the core of it, i’m just not sure i trust myself anymore to handle it. the fear is the problem. and the fear is what i’m so afraid of.
April 21st, 2008 at 12:27 am
There is no not-supposed-to-say, not here.
xo
April 21st, 2008 at 12:33 am
Well, Bon (as I collect myself after reading that amazing series - wow - thank you for sharing), for me, the 3rd time was the best one of mine. I wish the same for you, in more than a ‘cheers, clink glasses of wine together kind of way;’ rather, in a fierce, prayerful ‘I wanna-sock-that doctor-who said that to you during Finn’s birth-holy crap let me at em’ kind of way. I really believe in this for you, Bon. In my heart.
I don’t know you but for here, but I have faith (the kind that resonates through the universe, not just the church) that this one, this one will be much more peaceful, and all will be well. You keep horizontal, sister, but enjoy your boy, your Dave, and your days…XO
April 21st, 2008 at 12:59 am
Okay, doesn’t everyone know that April 20 is Hitler’s birthday? Hasn’t Dave seen 4:20 graffiti tagged on a building! It’s a marijuana subculture reference, that was once explained to me as being a toker insult to Hitler.
Thanks for sharing this. My first birth experience (well, second if you include the one that brought me to this planet, but let’s just ignore the fact that I came out of my mother’s woohoo because it makes me feel all squidgey) was not what I expected or needed and I was somewhat fearful when the second boy was due. I really believe that I needed to mourn that labour which went awry. Does that sound silly?
April 21st, 2008 at 1:20 am
me and O, Taurus’ both. i like that.
and the rest: it’s always on the menu here, Bon. always ok.
April 21st, 2008 at 8:39 am
Bon,
Thank you for saying that it does matter to be torn, broken and alienated. My first son was born in October by c-section and for most of the procedure I could feel everything. I was so traumatized and my baby was bruised and everu time I tried to talk about it all my mother and family would say was “but everyone’s okay now.”
April 21st, 2008 at 8:42 am
I was prepared for the post-traumatic response only because you told me about yours. Expecting it might help, but I think the doula idea is fabulous. I felt warmly connected enough to the doctors at my practice that it didn’t seem necessary, but I can certainly see the practicality of it.
I hope too, that your labour is months and months away from April, and I hope it’s finally the completely beautiful experience of which we all dream.
April 21st, 2008 at 10:09 am
I’m sorry you had to face that in that way. I’m shocked–you’d think that there woudl be enough women facing labour after loss that there would be some kind of counseling program in Ob offices or hospitals.
April 21st, 2008 at 10:41 am
Wow, That is a very powerful story.
I’m new here so I haven’t read much achival stuff.
April 21st, 2008 at 11:03 am
Labor is scary, there is no two ways about it and I am absolutely terrified of it. Even though it was not all horrible all I can do, preparing to go into this a second time, is remember those minutes (hours?) while transitioning when I just kept repeating in a blind panic: “make it stop. make it stop. make it stop.” I am spending far too much time trying to block that out.
But we do it again. We do it for Oscars, happy birthday little one.
PS Bon, I wish you would write a book, I just devour everything you ever put on the page.
April 21st, 2008 at 11:23 am
I didn’t mourn labour but I did mourn breastfeeding. I cannot imagine the psychological pain that birthing a child after losing a child would bring about. It all makes perfect sense to me when I read it here. Thank you for writing it.
I would like (you know, in that dream world of mine) to pull together a book for health-care professionals (mid-wives, obs, doulas and the like) that was nothing but a collection of blog posts on those trails women endure during pregnancy, labour and new motherhood–a book that might spread out the “a-ha” factor for those who’ve been assigned our care.
April 21st, 2008 at 12:00 pm
Oh Bon, I wish I could smooth back your hair and whisper the fears away, but I know it isn’t that easy. If only it were.
Happy birthday to your little O. If he had waited just a day, he and BubTar would be birthday buddies.
Like others have said, there is no not supposed to say here. That is why these spaces are so beautiful.
April 21st, 2008 at 2:25 pm
Happy birthday Oscar. And you know I hope for you a more peaceful birth. Now that I have been blessed with a truly good birth experience, I rage for all the women who have, for whatever reason, lost that right.
Always in awe of you, friend.
April 21st, 2008 at 2:28 pm
It won’t help to say that usually birthing gets easier each time around- because as you so eloquently described, there are no rules for any of this.
It was easier to deliver Pumpkin, but not without its drama. Not without its fear. But, it was easier. That was the fourth time for me. But I will definitely praying that the third time is your charm.
April 21st, 2008 at 4:30 pm
oh, sweet bon. you need to mourn the ‘what-could/should/might-have been’ as a part of your loss experience.
yesterday i dug out all the stuff i had written and recorded about the pnuts birth just to remind myself of what actually had happened, plus start gathering together what i might need with me when this one arrives. funny that about the birthing ball- my list for her included the item: “bring birth plan”- which of course goes straight out the window when you’re early and break your water but don’t dilate and are expected to have a teeny one and your bp skyrockets.
for this bean my plan is so much simpler than what i imagined birth would be like back then (and i won’t pretend that her birth was traumatic for me- surprising, unexpected, but all in all, lovely when i consider the alternatives). this is my plan now: “live birth. healthy near-as-possible-to-term boy. minimal to no complications for either of us.”
i pray it’s not to much to ask for you or me. hope oscar’s bday was wonderful.
April 21st, 2008 at 4:34 pm
Jeebus Bon, I’m simply gasping for air at the horror. I went into labor the first time with a “live baby, please!” attitude, and it wound up scary, and painful, but not remotely as bad as that. My second, which I worried about a bit more given the first, was a walk around the block. I don’t care about labor; I’m very removed, it’s very out of body for me. And yet. The athlete who I sometimes pretend I still am beckons to me not to go out this way, to go out on a win. And by win, I’m pretty sure she’s telling me the whole nine yards: nine months and labor. It’s amazing what we can go through, and so tragic when we finish with no reward but night terrors.
April 21st, 2008 at 4:48 pm
Happy Birthday O.
I wish you all nothing but the best.
You’ve earned it.
April 21st, 2008 at 6:28 pm
I am going to spend some time every day from now on hoping that the third time’s a charm.
The PTSD — I’ve never thought about it in relation to labor and delivery, but of course it could happen. (And as a former researcher into anxiety and mood disorders, I find the idea of it a compelling avenue for research.) Thanks for enlightening me — and potentially saving some other women from having to be thrown off-guard if it should happen to them.
April 21st, 2008 at 6:38 pm
i’m bottling up a hug to send to you. i pray that the third time will be different, better, with no regrets.
happy birthday to dear Oscar.
April 21st, 2008 at 8:14 pm
I’m happy to know you would do it again. I hope you stay fat bellied for many months to come. I hope you’re third is what you always thought it should be. I hope for you and yours.
Happy birthday to my fellow heart of an aries, strong will of a taurus Oscar.
April 21st, 2008 at 9:14 pm
listen, if only one thing mattered, all of us would agree that a healthy baby is that one thing. But we are human, complex, and many layered. Many things matter and that is as it should be. After all, Finn matters and Oscar matters - and all your experiences of birth matter tremendously. I wonder, as you are starting to get ready, if there are some things you can do to make it what you need it to be - not that birth can be controlled, heavens, no - but if there is something you are asking from this experience, I’d love to help you get it - it’s what I do for work and if I lived next door, I’d do it for you for nothing in exchange but the satisfaction of giving you something you need, like a cup of sugar or half-n-half on a Saturday morning. If I can help, even from far away, let me know.
April 21st, 2008 at 9:59 pm
Doh! You posted this last night and today is the 21st. Happy Birthday, Oscar!!!
Me, I suck with dates. Clearly.
April 22nd, 2008 at 2:38 am
Happy Birthday Oscar!
As for being scared of labour, I am now painfully aware of how you feel. I think, for the first time, I will be scared of pregnancy next time it comes around.
Miss you.
April 22nd, 2008 at 2:01 pm
Bon, this made me tear, and made my heart ache for you. It also makes me gnash my teeth for what some of us have to go through. I am sorry for all the trauma, and hold hope for this one. Really, to have been through those births and still want to do it again, you are one brave, phenomenal woman and I hope the Universe gets it that you deserve a good birth this time, many months away from April. Big hugs to you, and belated Happy Birthday to sugared-out Oscar.
April 22nd, 2008 at 3:14 pm
Your writing is amazing, Bon. So many, so different emotions in one post.
I hope very much that the third birth is months and months away, and that it will be, and bring, what you hope for.
April 22nd, 2008 at 7:34 pm
It’s good that you have a place to let this out. Even though you met with that one doula, I think it might be worthwhile to find out if there is any other kind of therapy or treatment you can get as you prepare. Maybe…?
I’ll keep you in my prayers, meager as they are.
April 22nd, 2008 at 8:56 pm
The doula is a great idea because she is there to hold your hand, look you in the eye, calm your fears,, help you to stay positive, even help you laugh.
As hard as birthing is, remember that it can be a good experience, and that it is , for many, and if , in the meantime, a professional therapist might be good to consult with, to see if now is a good time for some therapy, while you wait…. the power of the mind… keep hold of that. You can do this, as many women have done before - you are strong and loved.
April 22nd, 2008 at 10:00 pm
I do hope third time is the charm for you.
April 23rd, 2008 at 4:09 am
Requesting charmed 3rd time here and close-to-term as possible from the universe. I am glad you are looking into the Doula idea. Even if they just keep looking you in the eyes and saying “this is different”. My husband was completely flipped out. Sure we were both dying, hating to see me in pain and fear. And I had a full midwife, new midwife, a nurse and a student nurse in a major hospital. Next time I am getting a doula.
April 24th, 2008 at 5:09 am
*exhales* thank you.
everytime i kiss my three month old daughter, my chest hurts from the sheer beauty. i love her fierce, bold, full.
but i hated being pregnant. giving birth (along with the emergency c-section i could feel) was the single most traumatic experience i’ve ever been through. after the surgery, i felt no elation, no profound joy, not even anything as exciting as depression. i was dejected, disappointed, embarrassed. and my man was there as much as possible but i couldn’t, in my wildest dreams, expect him to understand.
thank you for sharing a story that makes me cry with recognition, empathy, relief.
and my daughter’s name is finn.
April 24th, 2008 at 12:54 pm
I don’t have words, Bon.
I just want to honor the beauty of the words you’ve put down here.
I’ll do it with my silence.
April 24th, 2008 at 8:43 pm
Thank you so much for sharing these intimate parts of yourself with us Bon.
I’m sorry that the clusterfuck and your panic made Oscar’s birth less than what you were hoping for.
I was telling a friend the other day how I hoped that I wouldn’t have to have a C with this baby, and she responded, “it’s not the end of the world”. No, it’s not, but it does matter. It is something that I will always have some regrets about, despite that everything turned out okay.
I hope that your next birth experience leaves you with no regrets or sadness. It sounds like you’re doing everything you can now to make that true.
April 25th, 2008 at 3:16 am
Most women would be petrified. You’ve already had your share of pain.
April 29th, 2008 at 1:13 pm
i just have to say something, although i don’t know what…maybe just that I read it.
I’m 23 weeks pregnant, and your post moved me to tears.