Fri 9 May 2008
heeerre’s Bonnie!
Posted by bon under pondering stuff
i think i know now why i blog.
the company’s good and the outlet is needed, and appreciated, sure. but they’re not the primary reason. turns out blogging is the only thing keeping me from having to face the stark fact that i am actually, secretly, an incoherent twit. yep. oh, the shame. i blog to keep up my self-esteem, folks, to maintain the facade that i’ve actually mastered some command of my mind, heart, and the English language. snort.
basically, i am congenitally incapable of expressing myself concisely and thoughtfully in any form other than writing. seriously. i’m gregarious and all, and i can chatter away and be a pretty good conversational reflector of what the other party is saying, but ask me to actually form an unprepared idea in words, out loud, in real time, to an audience…and i hem and haw and turn into that painful, stereotypical grade 9 chemistry teacher who rambled on and on in ever-pitiful and incomprehensible circles until the students were all asleep or trying to burn their ears off with Bunsen burners.
and after six weeks on bedrest, sitting in my house all day writing work emails and making small talk with, um, my cat, i’m getting worse. the raging head cold isn’t helping, either.
last week, i got to take an afternoon off of babysitting my couch and trucked off to the local CBC station to record a Mother’s Day-focused conversation with some other Maritime mummies. i was psyched. an outing! a conversation! a chance to talk about parenthood in what i hoped would be a multi-faceted way! then i put the headset on and sat in front of the mic…and died a thousand small deaths. my brain began flitting about aimlessly, unable to organize itself without letters and lines of text to confine it. each question - and these were not shocking questions, folks - left me stunned, unprepared, searching desperately for a train of thought to land on. apparently trains are running sparse in these parts.
when the interviewer asked if we’d always wanted to be parents, i answered yes, and said honestly that i remembered being twenty-nine and newly single and suddenly wondering if motherhood would ever happen for me and realizing that some part of me would never fully come to fruition if it did not. dandy. then, following the base rules of logic and conversation, that pesky interviewer followed up with, “oh? and what would that part of you be?”
uh…um…errr…my knee? nope, nope, that’s not right. focus, Bonnie, focus.
i sputtered and floundered and rambled on for a few minutes, saying basically nothing, blathering on about how important it seemed to get to shape a life from the start, thus probably coming off like a controlling nutjob and offending countless adoptive parents of older children in the process. even as the words rolled out, all tripe and cliché, i knew they were the wrong ones…ones that didn’t really get close to the feeling i was trying to express…but i couldn’t collect my thoughts, couldn’t line them up and sort them and make them shiny and incisive and pretty, not for the life of me.
all the while in the back of my head a blog post eloquently composed itself, but only for the benefit of my keyboardless fingertips. my tongue was left to fend for itself, and i was left wishing i could rip it out.
it happened again today. a visitor dropped by and in the process of feeding me lunch, bless her, asked me a real question, a genuine, complex, recount how you feel about all this kind of question, and i was so delighted to have someone to actually talk to that i launched into a disconnected diatribe worthy of the Jerry Springer show. my guest smiled politely throughout, but again, i had this weird sensation of failing, profoundly, to get across what i was actually trying to communicate. and i faintly wished she could have called in her question an hour or two before, y’know…just to give me a chance to process, to get my thoughts down.
i could have a whole sheaf of papers taped to my chest! why do i love parenthood? see page 23! how do the dynamics of my extended family impact me? that’s a whole chapter, pages 40 through 57! how am i handling all this bedrest? what?! can’t you tell i’m doing splendidly?!?! see the frozen terror in my eyes at the prospect of human contact?!?! maybe that one is actually kinda taped to my chest…or face…figuratively speaking and all.
so here’s what i want to know…is this incoherence - at least the part of it that isn’t solely housebound battiness - just me? is this a phenomenon common among bloggers? could it be part of the reason so many of us are drawn to writing, this pleasantly editable, controllable space for presentation of our most intimate thoughts, but dressed up in their best lingerie? does blogging make it harder and harder to actually adjust to the ephemeral messiness of real-life conversation? am i just slowly beginning to lose all semblance of social skills the longer i spend perched on my couch in isolation, fighting off cabin fever?
note to self: do NOT watch The Shining while on bedrest. and lock all the axes in the shed. i have my nice blog, and don’t need any other ways of expressing myself, thank you very much. ![]()













May 9th, 2008 at 5:14 pm
And now you know why I’m both excited and terrified about next weekend. My capacity for saying boneheaded, ill-considered things - especially when wine is involved - is nearly limitless. So many times I’ve wished for my mouth to have a delete key.
May 9th, 2008 at 5:59 pm
I am immensely relieved to read this post, dear Bon. Because me? I’m a complete dork when it comes to thinking on my feet.
When I worked in high-tech marketing co-workers always invited me to brainstorming meetings because that Janet, she’s so creative with the writing and all! I would sit there, mute, sweating profusel. I would then return to my desk, brainstorm on my own for 10 minutes and email my ideas to the facilitator so I wouldn’t appear completely inept.
Yours in dork-icity,
J.
May 9th, 2008 at 8:05 pm
Oh yes. That is me. I’m so coherent with the aid of my trusty backspace key, unfortunately speaking aloud does not offer the same type of editing.
May 9th, 2008 at 8:08 pm
Definitely not just you. I have a good friend who comes over a few times a year. She always tries to have intelligent, grown-up conversation with me. Sometimes it works, and sometime it doesn’t. The last time she was here, we talked about a particular ideological issue, and I was so bumble-tongued that instead of saying the informed, useful things I would have done in writing, I fell back on shameless, rambling, unfair caricatures of people on the opposite side of the issue from me. Apparently, even when I can’t make sense, I can be petty and mean. By the time she left, I was so embarrassed.
May 9th, 2008 at 8:16 pm
Okay, first of all, this is complete bullshit. I have had many a loooong, through-the-night talk with you about ‘real’ things like life and how it affects you, philosophy, education etc. You expressed yourself very well, despite the copious amounts of red wine which were normally involved in the conversation.
Secondly, I think there are countless people out there who would freeze in front of a microphone, unless they’ve had public speaking lessons (which I have, and they help a lot, but only if i have what I need to say written down in dot point).
Thirdly, if you would email me your damn phone number then I could call you and you could practice!
May 9th, 2008 at 8:30 pm
ah Georgia, you’re quite right…i have vague memories of being quite loquacious with wine involved. i think the tragic lack of wine over three+ years of pregnancy and nursing has atrophied my brains, though.
May 9th, 2008 at 8:30 pm
I saw Veronica’s comment that started “definitely not just you…” and I misread it as “definitely just not you…” and thought HAH! someone else on here has met Bon and knows THE TRUTH!
But then… no. But next up was Georgia who clearly has an inside track. Because though you may make up your mind as you speak (as everyone does), you have one tack-sharp mind.
I’ll be listening on Sunday with my cuppa tea - you’ll be great.
May 9th, 2008 at 8:48 pm
Yes, you are eloquent one on one. I can attest to it. And for the record that follow-up question was unanswerable. Truly.
It is true, however, that blogging does strip a gal of all social skills. I used to be an eloquent conversationalist. Now I am a mumbling, fumbling misanthrope. It’s sad, really, and I don’t know if there’s any hope left for me.
May 9th, 2008 at 9:30 pm
Does this mean that next weekend we’ll all be sitting around saying “So…who’s good for the cup this year?”
I find the only interesting conversations I have ARE online, so when faced with a real and honest question with depth and meaning, I’m confused. I’m not the sharpest crayon in the box, but if the smartest question you hear all day is “OMFG! Did you see what happened on Survivor!” you lose some of the ability to converse in a relatively coherent and intelligent manner.
Or perhaps it’s just me. I can’t wait to meet you, and others on one hand to have “real conversation” and on the other hand, I’m desperately afraid you’ll all be one big mic…
May 9th, 2008 at 9:45 pm
Totally with you on this…..and I thought I was the only one! I’m a complete dork in social situations, and then stay awake afterwards in bed, thinking of all the things I should’ve said differently but didn’t because I am completely unable to think on my feet. Sigh.
May 9th, 2008 at 10:33 pm
Delete key is my friend, as is the ability to take my time crafting an argument.
But as I was suspicious of this here self-characterization, I am glad to see those who have met you call bullshit.
Perhaps one day I will get to find out for myself. I promise to bring wine.
May 9th, 2008 at 11:51 pm
Yes, just last weekend I left a blogger meet-up wanting to go back and revise things I said and worrying that I’d totally bored the pants off them or offended them and they left all, who IS that insensitive dolt who keeps putting her foot in her mouth?!? I can’t imagine how much worse it would have been if I’d had a mic to deal with!
May 10th, 2008 at 12:32 am
Yep. That’s me. Much better in writing, in person not quite so much…
However, the caveat is if I am actually “teaching.” I am a former school teacher, and now am frequently asked to lead sessions for Women’s Spiritual groups and when I am in teacher mode, I am quite eloquent. It’s casual conversation in which I sound like a dork.
May 10th, 2008 at 12:35 am
Don’t feel bad. I think we all fall into that talking just to talk mode without actually saying anything. Feel free to blame it on pregnancy hormones or cabin fever. You are an incredible writer though so at least you have that.
May 10th, 2008 at 12:58 am
I freakin love you.
May 10th, 2008 at 5:18 am
Check! My husband jokes that my mouth doesn’t work right, but it’s not a joke entirely or AT ALL. My brain connects directly to my fingers, and they say everything I can’t otherwise verbalize. Now whether blogging diminishes my other social abilities, I don’t really know, but it is hugely satisfying to have at least one way to make my thoughts known!
May 10th, 2008 at 12:27 pm
haaahahaa I can’t write or speak coherently, come visit me when I’ve been abducted by aliens and then returned with telepathy. I think it’s my only hope.
I blame it all on cabin fever. Cats aren’t good communicators.
(some of it may be that having a conversation runs the risk of speaking a truth that would otherwise remain hidden, or as I call it foot and mouth disease.)
May 10th, 2008 at 3:25 pm
you crack me up. i can personally blame my current fumbling on pregnancy brain and talking to cats, but i don’t know what my excuse is otherwise.
hey you made it through 6 weeks…that is a lifetime! keep on laying around and entertaining us with your beautiful words.
May 10th, 2008 at 4:37 pm
I am a big spazzy dork and have trouble making coherent sentences in person, let alone having anything insightful or intelligent to say. Thank God for writing.
May 10th, 2008 at 6:12 pm
Bon,
Where and when are you on radio tomorrow? I am assuming CBC, but what time?
And what you’re saying about incoherent? Been there.
However, someone last week described me as “articulate.” I was shocked.
Maybe we don’t need the backspace-delete keys as often as we think. As writers, perhaps we are always seeking the perfect turn of phrase?
Our own editors, we are.
Without the luxury of time and second drafts.
Look forward to “meeting you on the radio” as Michael Enright says.
May 10th, 2008 at 7:30 pm
Laurie…
it’s Maritime Magazine, CBC, at 8:30 am…i have this fantasy of me enjoying my breakfast in bed and hot coffee with craploads of milk foam whilst listening. the reality will probably be more like me straining to hear the show and keep hot beverages out of reach of small, wet child trying to perch himself on my lap and eat all my breakfast after waking me up at quarter to crocus.
still, sounds kinda nice.
and you are totally right about it being the editor in me that hates the sound of what i say aloud, the struggle for it…a constant esprit d’escalier. hence the reason it’s somewhat alleviated by wine…then i can’t remember what i was wanting to say!
May 10th, 2008 at 10:11 pm
At least you can think of something good to say on your blog. I can’t seem to communicate efficiently in real life or on the internet.
May 10th, 2008 at 10:52 pm
I’m terrible, just utterly terrible, at small talk. I also find it near impossible to talk about my feelings. Now, get me behind a mike and ask me to discuss something techno-geeky and I’m an ace.
May 10th, 2008 at 11:09 pm
I think it’s really difficult to answer true questions from one’s heart. I can do the glib PR-type answers really easily - lots of practice - but something that touches my real feelings and emotions is hard to bring across without a lot of asides, parentheses, and clarifications.
You’re made it through six weeks of bedrest already. You are a champ!
May 11th, 2008 at 1:46 am
Internet Burkha
That’s what I call it.
The shape within I can express, ironically.
More to come…
May 11th, 2008 at 1:47 am
… and I forgot. Good spot earlier this week on the difference between the communicative powers of VOICE and LANGUAGE.
That’s way your saying. Yes?
May 11th, 2008 at 1:47 am
That’s what your saying, I mean… she types sleepily.
sheesh.
May 11th, 2008 at 1:51 pm
You are fabulously eloquent on ‘paper.’ I would jump at the chance to let you babble incoherently at me in person (although, I’m not quite sure I believe it).
May 11th, 2008 at 2:59 pm
First, I laughed like crazy. then I paused, and thought, is this a joke? Maybe she is insinuating something about *me* AND *my writing* AND *how I speak IRL*, heck! But, phew, no! You were talking about Bonnie.
Nope, i think you are eloquent. You just have unrealistic expectations. Gifted people are always like that.
Six weeks on bedrest already?! Only you can make it seem so easy, you cool girl.
May 11th, 2008 at 3:02 pm
this condition actually carries over into my interpersonal communication. whenever my heart is heavy or i’m extremely emotionally involved in something, i have to write it to express it. i can’t talk about it. much to my man’s chagrin, this leads to emails to him regarding things i’m upset about rather than actual conversations. the verbal interaction takes place after i’ve written out what i need to say. if i rely solely on ‘talking it out’ i’m pretty much guaranteed to be unhappy with how i’ve explained something or forget to make a point which means i have to bring old conversations up until i feel i’ve gotten it right. at least when i write it, i can rewrite and revise. on a positive note, this keeps us from arguing. although, we have argued about my inability to express myself to him at appropriate times. i’m learning that sending an email to his blackberry right after he leaves for work is not always the best idea…even if it makes me feel better.
oh, and happy mother’s day to one of my favorite bloggers…
May 11th, 2008 at 4:18 pm
You are not a twit.
I think I blog because this is the only place where people semi listen to me!
Happy Mother’s Day!
May 11th, 2008 at 5:38 pm
Bon,
I listened to the radio and liked what I heard.
No blather, no incoherence.
Gems of wisdom scattered amidst a chat about all things mom-wise.
Perhaps it was the questions in the interview that caused you to feel a little off-kilter.
“What do your kids call their private parts?” then a hairpin turn to “let’s talk about Finn.”
Even I have a bit of whiplash.
The Shining? I think I might be feeling more like James Caan in “Misery” were I you. Any sledgehammers to lock in the shed?
May 11th, 2008 at 7:50 pm
know that feeling so well! Have also done a radio thing where I felt like I was gargling marbles and sprouting shite yet was able to write down exactly how i felt. sometimes i wonder if the writing takes over from the talking, some muscles get exercised, others atrophy etc. ne’er mind, it’s often only you who knows when you’re blathering…
and Happy Mothers Day.
May 11th, 2008 at 10:57 pm
no. really. she is a twit.
May 11th, 2008 at 10:58 pm
I’m still laughing at the idea of students burning their ears off with bunsen burners.
Funny, I think blogging has made me MORE coherent……
May 12th, 2008 at 12:53 am
takes one to know one, dave.
(smirk)
May 12th, 2008 at 9:36 am
thank you, Kate.
though yes, he & i ARE rather well-suited.
May 12th, 2008 at 10:50 am
Yeah, it happened to me on bed rest too. Both with pregnancy and with the chemo. I found that fighting through it every day by putting words on screen helped me immensely. But even now I have difficulty sometimes moving beyond the blog.
Sigh.