Tue 20 May 2008
dignity
Posted by bon under issue stuff
[29] Comments
i may have, erm, mentioned that i went to see Leonard Cohen the other night. i may have mentioned i was going in a wheelchair. i may have made some flippant, agist cracks about how he’d probably find me more alluring that way, anyway. and how i was gonna get me a little Children’s Wish Foundation sign that read Leonard, I – insert husky significance here, and little cartoon hearts – have a wish, wink wink, nudge nudge, and hold it up high whilst waggling my eyebrows. pelvic rest (and our respective partners) be damned – it’s Leonard Cohen. in town. purrr.
he’s nearly seventy-four and yep, his hair is gray and he has a bit of a wattle and he stoops like he really does ache in the places he used to play…but oh, oh, i could overlook that for an evening. a jug of wine, a pack of smokes, and thou, Leonard. that VOICE. that poetry. that melancholic face under a gray fedora, earnest and compelling, arrogant and monkishly humble. in his words, beauty out of sorrows. in his songs, shameless celebration of the complexities of being human; the sacraments of wounding we inflict on each other and call love, religion, mythology. in my fantasy world, you could sit in front of Leonard Cohen and tell him anything – the deepest darkest, the pettiest, the saddest – and his old-world eyes would shine and say, i know. you are known. now crawl up on my lap and let me worship you. and then there would be nothing to hide from, anymore.
i had a friend in university, a male friend, who was convinced that Leonard Cohen was a dirty old misogynist pig. and i used to look at this friend and smile, and think, and that, dear Kevin, is why you are so utterly single. not because i’m into misogyny – i’m not. but Kevin missed the point. Leonard Cohen, with all his talk of women and sex and stereotypes, is the man who taught me the dignity of physicality, of sexuality; taught me that the cerebral and the poetic need the body, too. his writing is full of muses, sure, and muses do not make a full personhood to aspire to. but i wouldn’t have minded being one of his muses, nonetheless: his muses have power, are agents, make choices and are instruments of their own complicated destinies. he loves them, richly and without romance – and they are truly women, not ingenues or Barbies. his muses always have their own side to the story.
so it was with all this pent-up one-sided intimacy between me and Leonard that i rolled into the concert the other evening. Dave dropped my friend and i at the stage door, so he could park – my friend went about procuring the wheelchair the commissionaire had said would be available. it was. we went through the entertaining little production wherein i transitioned magically before said commissionaire’s eyes from hale, hearty chick to the actual person wanting the wheelchair, but he adjusted with remarkable grace. then we wheeled into the crowd.
and i swear not one person in that full house, all gathered about the lobby, mingling, electric with the ‘pinch me’ shock of an artist of Cohen’s stature and reclusivity performing here, made eye contact with me. in this town i grew up in, at a concert where i spotted forty casual acquaintances without even trying, not one saw me.
it’s no affront to be rendered invisible when you’ve chosen the chair as a way of bending bedrest rules…when at the end of the concert you can sing out, “Praise Leonard! Hallelujah! I’ve been healed!” and rise from your chair and walk, self-consciously but with no pain, no struggle, to the car that will return you to your couch and your temporary invalid status. it is amusing, even, a social experiment of sorts.
but it is a hell of a lesson, too.
i learned from Leonard Cohen years ago that the body cannot be left out of the equation, that dignity is in being seen and embraced for all you are, raced and gendered and sized and abled and damaged and sexual and cerebral and individual and role, all at once. everyone deserves that dignity.
but the number of times, always in pregnancy, when i’ve been out and about in a wheelchair and realized that only kids are meeting my eyes…i don’t think we’re getting that message, as a society.
just a note, folks…the woman in the wheelchair trying to scoot by without rolling over your feet? she may be ripe with designs on Leonard Cohen that would knock your socks off. she may not. she is often rendered so invisible as to be the anti-muse. but she, i can assure you, still has her own side to the story, and is worth a look, a moment. there is nothing to hide from…i swear.




May 20th, 2008 at 11:25 pm
ugh. are they overcompensating, so afraid to be rude by looking that they don’t look at all?
either way, it’s awful, and i’m sorry.
no one puts bonnie in a corner. not if i have anything to say about it.
May 21st, 2008 at 12:03 am
I like slouching mom’s Dirty Dancing nod. Too funny.
I agree, the women Leonard mythologies are very real. Gritty. With thoughts of their own and the scars of life and even (*gasp*) body hair! Real women. Not symbols of what men think women should be, which is so often the fodder for other less dignified less lasting musicians.
May 21st, 2008 at 12:26 am
OK, so first, I’ll fess up that I have no idea who this guy is.
But, does it make it better that I try to look most people in the eye and nod hello, unless they are carrying large, bloody axes?
May 21st, 2008 at 2:50 am
Most people seem to either avert their eyes from those with disability or stare. With 50 million Americans disabled in the U.S. you’d think people here could look at someone with a disability as they would any other person, but they don’t.
I felt a similar effect when I came back to work after the stillbirth. People either gawked or they avoided. Noone treated me like a fellow human.
May 21st, 2008 at 8:45 am
It’s interesting that antigone picked up on the same parallel as I did – slouching mom described it as those being so afraid to be rude that they overcompensate, thus rendering the wheelchair-traveller invisible.
I’ve always appreciated people who are ballsy enough to risk saying the wrong thing – those who care enough to try, regardless of their own discomfort. This post today – how you managed to weave sex and a near-octogenarian and groupies and poetry and the identity of people with disabilities – pure, undistilled bon. I love it, and I won’t forget it.
May 21st, 2008 at 8:45 am
Bon, I LOVE this post, though I’m sorry nobody looked at you. What you said about Cohen’s women, I think that’s part of what I was trying to say the other night.
I try to make eye contact with and smile at people who I suspect are both visible and invisible, but then I worry they think I’m only smiling at them because of their disability or whatever it is that makes them visible and invisible.
May 21st, 2008 at 8:48 am
That sucks that no one looked at you. A friend of ours in a wheelchair had bitchin’ flame designs painted on the sides, which cracked him up.
All of my early sexual experiences were set to Leonard Cohen, so I can’t quite listen to him now. But I know what you’re saying.
May 21st, 2008 at 9:28 am
Did you read Goldfish’s Blog Against Disablism carnival stuff this year? There’s always lots in there about the invisibility of disabilities and how that affects people.
I know what you mean. It sucks, too. I try to smile.
May 21st, 2008 at 9:45 am
just to be clear, it didn’t hurt me but rather opened my eyes. because i COULD get up and walk, and i knew it.
and yeh, the invisibility parallel to those suffering loss other people are uncomfortable with is potent, Antigone & Kate…funny, actually, during the concert when Leonard hit the lines “like a baby stillborn…i have torn everyone who reached out for me” and “for the mother in confusion, her cradle still unfilled” i realized that he may be the only artist i’m aware of who’s recognized this sorrow as a part of his work, honoured it in his catalogue of grief without painting a sentimental “song about a dead baby” tearjerker of a picture.
for me, a part of this is always wondering whether Finn, had he lived, might have been profoundly disabled due to his oxygen loss after birth…wondering how people would have approached him, seen him…and thus internalizing that invisibility from the perspective of a mother, recognizing that everyone is somebody’s child.
May 21st, 2008 at 10:46 am
I learned this when KayTar had her wee walker. It’s a bit of a tough lesson.
May 21st, 2008 at 11:03 am
God, woman, you knock my socks off. Not with your designs on him, but in the way that you write about it.
May 21st, 2008 at 12:06 pm
this pales in comparison to anything really, but was an eye opener for me: in ‘94 I suffered a horrific ankle sprain, did nerve damage, doc thought I would’ve been better off breaking it in two. And I was on crutches for months, but for the first two, was not to even rest on my bad foot while it healed. And I discovered: taking the bus was a nightmare, and no one helped me up/down; I worked in a basement office with no elevator; I could not carry books/trays anything really, and no one offered help; I apartment hunted, all were walk-ups, and not a single landlord offered sympathies until I told one it was a soccer injury (needless to say, we got that apartment). The following summer I was in DC and a woman right in front of me missed the curb and twisted her ankle hard. She went down in a heap, and people walked right over her — someone even kicked her pocketbook! I was the only person who stopped, elevated her foot, figured it was probably badly sprained and not broken, and gave her money for a taxi to the urgent care clinic since she obviously couldn’t get to a cash machine.
Since this time, I’ve been acutely aware of how little we do for the disabled to truly make things accessible, and to honestly observe them and greet them in our daily lives. I often wonder what would happen if everyone was obligated to spend a day on crutches or in a wheelchair, just to see how their lives would change.
Sorry for the rant. Glad you liked the concert. Back to feet up on the couch, you!
May 21st, 2008 at 1:56 pm
You blow me away, Bon. Every word you write, is just gem.
Totally ditto on your sentiment and what everyone had said, esp Kate’s. I used to feel it is rude to look at people in wheel chairs, but now I know it depends on my mindset and attitude!
Glad you had a blast, I heart Leonard Cohen. I wanted to name my baby Leonard.
May 21st, 2008 at 3:16 pm
The way you write is poetry. I think Leonard would approve.
It’s an interesting, if unintentional, social experiment you describe. I’m sitting here wondering if I do that, if I subconsciously avoid some people’s eyes. I fervently hope not. You have reminded me to be more aware of my own behaviour.
May 21st, 2008 at 3:51 pm
This is a real story. Thanks for sharing it. You’ve given me sound perspective today. I second Kate’s view on it, too. About people unfraid to say the wrong thing in this realm; it’s better to be recognized than ignored, even if the words aren’t quite right. Glad you enjoyed the music. I don’t know him either…
May 22nd, 2008 at 9:42 am
Bon, I love that you live in a place where you could do that experiment – pity about the result though. You see, I could go anywhere in a wheel chair and wouldn’t know whether ppl were avoiding my eyes ’cause of the chair or just ’cause. Big cities. Myself, I catch everyone’e eye then look away just before I smile ’cause they’ll probably think I’ strange or be really confused and wonder if they know me.
Btw, I had to google Leonard Cohen to discover he is ‘a Canadian poet, novelist and singer-songwriter’.
May 22nd, 2008 at 12:26 pm
I always feel strange as I don’t want to offend, and no one offers lessons on how to not act like a moron around wheelchairs.
So I suck it in and act like normal and somehow, it all turns out that way. Glad you saw your oldest lover. Sad the lesson shown.
May 22nd, 2008 at 12:29 pm
Wonderful, wonderful post. I love how you conscripted Leonard Cohen into your insight. Wow.
May 22nd, 2008 at 6:35 pm
As a coda – I’m pretty sure that the LC documentary film crew started filming you, Dave, me and my sis as soon as they spied the young-attractive-wheelchair-based-fan they assumed you were. So not only did your neighbours not make eye contact, some tv/film crew objectified you in an attempt to be “inclusive” for their doc. Bets on whether the voice-over includes specious reference to “how far LC fans will go/ how dedicated they are/what an experience to bring everyone?” Loved seeing you all, thanks for the doppler demo
May 22nd, 2008 at 6:42 pm
I’m envious you saw Cohen. And I’ve been guilty of the look-away myself, I must confess. Not because I don’t want to see, but always because my instinct is to NOT make the person feel comfortable, and so I look away.
May 22nd, 2008 at 10:39 pm
I often wish I were invisible. And I can’t stand for people to look me in the eye. There must be others — whether in wheelchairs or not — who feel exactly the same way.
(and, just by the way, I think Leonard Cohen must be a Canadian thing because neither I nor anyone else in the US that I’ve asked have ever heard of him)
May 22nd, 2008 at 11:14 pm
BTW, did you see the documentary on The National a couple of years ago about the real-life Suzanne. She’s in her 60s now, living in a trailer on a beach somewhere in California, crazy and lovable as the day is long. And, yes, real. Very real. Too real, in fact, for my love of the song to bear.
I have always wondered about the Edmonton prostitute named Marianne, though.
May 22nd, 2008 at 11:16 pm
Niobe, in a way a wheelchair might be your worst nightmare.
because even if you want to hide, being invisible while in public is distinctly different from just having people not notice you…it’s not the pleasant anonymity of a busy city street or anything. rather, people go out of their way not to notice you, trip over themselves trying not to notice you, rendering you far more conspicuous in a sense. it’s like being a rolling source of discomfort – and that’s evident, even if no one makes eye contact.
May 23rd, 2008 at 10:25 am
I was just thinking the other night about how much I love “Everybody Knows.” So much emotion packed into a few minutes.
Glad you got to experience that, and sorry the crowd was afraid to look a beautiful woman in the eyes.
May 23rd, 2008 at 4:46 pm
Bon: I just looked this dude up and realized that alas, I do like him. I had no idea he was the song-writer behind SO MANY classic songs I love. What are your favorite’s of Leonard’s? I will check them out on ITunes – Suzanne, by Judy Collins, I grew up to. Turns out he wrote it. Never knew that…(and boy, in his younger days, he was a hot one!)
May 23rd, 2008 at 11:04 pm
I always make a point of making eye contact with people in wheel chairs, especially since they are more apt than people not in wheelchairs to make eye contact with me, and to smile. I do this because I KNOW how brutal society is and can only imagine how alienating being in a wheelchair must be….
I really loved this post. There’s no ignoring a voice like yours. Thank you for this.
May 25th, 2008 at 4:25 am
I love this post.
May 28th, 2008 at 9:21 pm
One day whilr getting groceries I started chatting to the woman behind me in the line, who happened to be in a wheelchair. It wasn’t really chatting like I would with someone I knew well (because I didn’t)… just the “nice day, how ’bout the price of milk” kind of stuff. And when I was done paying and about to leave the woman thanked me for talking to her. She said people don’t usually do that. And I found that incredibly sad.
I’m sorry you had to experience that kind of invisibility. But I thank you for writing about it. It was very thought provoking.
June 10th, 2008 at 11:44 am
Yes, yes, yes. I hear you, and you are so very right on this. It only takes an hour in a wheelchair to be forever changed.