Thu 5 Jun 2008
over the sea to Skye
Posted by bon under pondering stuff
my mother and i went to a funeral this morning. for a family friend, a big, warm bear of a man whose daughters i was close to when we were children, a man who then left that family and started another and whom i hadn’t seen in nearly twenty years when i wandered into his antique store in December of 2005.
it was just before Christmas, but i was the only one in the shop. i recognized him and introduced myself, asked how he was, innocuously. and i watched him, suddenly, without warning, crumble in front of me. it was his first day back at work. his wife, his second wife, had died just weeks before, on the operating table where they’d expected to save her life. instead she was gone. oh. how was i? oh. we were seven or so months out from losing Finn, and i’d gotten used to saying, “fine,” to putting on the mask, but i didn’t then, didn’t need to…couldn’t. it would have shamed us both, somehow. so i told him, and he listened, and we stood there amongst the dusty wooden rockers and the phonographs with tears on both our faces and it was the most honest random conversation i think i’ve ever had in my life. with a man i barely knew and yet had known for as long as i can remember. it was the only real conversation we ever had. i was grateful for it, then and now.
and they piped him out today, Donnie who always wore his kilt for occasions, the Skye Boat Song and roses for everyone to take home with them because Donnie loved to give flowers.
we couldn’t go to the cemetery because they don’t provide wheelchairs or chaise lounges for the bedresting, so my mother brought me home. and told me, on the drive, that she doesn’t expect to see me in heaven after she goes.
this came out deadpan, a total non-sequitur. i laughed a little nervously, uncertain if a lecture on my moral failings was about to follow. it did not…which was a relief of an almost palpable nature…rather, my mother wanted to inform me of her own theological predilections so that i could instruct whomever takes command of her funeral when the time comes that mention of “hanging around up there, waiting for you all” is not to happen. my little black heart could not have swelled bigger. my mother and i have our differences of faith - she has one, i do not, a rather significant difference - but it appears in this we are almost…alike. the afterlife is mysterious to both of us, veiled. and i find bizarre comfort in this unusual synchronicity. i told her if it turns out we’re wrong and heaven really is all gowns and harps and reunifications, i’ll understand it if i get there and she’s sulking in the corner, refusing to talk to me just because she doesn’t want to admit having made a mistake. she retorted that if heaven really turns out all that conventional, she doesn’t expect i’ll be showing up at all. and we both laughed.
she also told me she’d like a piper for her funeral, like Donnie had. i nodded at this, tears suddenly in my eyes. we live in a part of the world where nearly half the population is still pure-blood highland Scots, two hundred years removed from clan and the auld country but fiercely attached to what remnants remain of that dour legacy of clearances and imperial machinations. i would like to take her to Scotland, someday…but i don’t think she actually wants to see the real place. the Scotland in her mind is hers, her own. if we went , she’d risk feeling less connected to the reality than she does here, at a remove, where its romance and sentiment are keystones of her birthright, her identity, the community to which she belongs. none more Scots than the Scots abroad, och aye. so she will have a piper, i promised. i asked for one myself, just in case.
speed bonnie boat, like a bird on a wing
onward the sailors cry
carrying the lad who’s born to be king
over the sea to Skye
i didn’t tell her that the other songs on my secret personal funeral list are “Ripple” by the Grateful Dead and Sinatra’s “My Way”…and that really, if we have to have a funeral, why not make it all-music, an all-night hootenannie, with plenty of liquor?
i’d like to keep her around for awhile if i can, not kill her off with horror.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
have you ever thought about your own funeral…what you’d want said, or read? played? any suggestions for my ever-revolving list of (secular) life-affirming classics? though i do have a soft spot for old staunch hymns, i must admit…but i doubt Dave would allow them any play, if he outlived me. ![]()













June 5th, 2008 at 2:47 pm
Randomly suicidal me thinks about it all the time. It’s retarded.
Samson by Regina Spektor is on my list. So pretty, so fragile. Andromeda Suite by The Legendary Pink Dots….
I’ve already informed Mogo I want to be burned simply, and thrown into the wind to become part of everyone around me, my atoms mingling with the ether and the dirt and the birds. People think I’m kidding about that-I’m not. I don’t want to rot-I want to fly.
Not believing in heaven is an interesting thing-it leaves me excited to know what comes after…when I might go….or where I might not. And I’d dearly love a piper of my own…
June 5th, 2008 at 2:51 pm
I have never put much thought into my funeral. But an all night party sounds fun!
June 5th, 2008 at 3:05 pm
i used to think of my funeral with the anticipatory attention to detail one usually invests in a wedding. i even had a written version saved “just in case.” i got rid of it, finally. mostly because, as i mature (which is taking a hell of a lot longer than i thought it would) my ideas change.
i used to want ben harper’s version of the verve’s ‘drugs don’t work’ played. it’s so beautiful, if a little sad. then i wanted ‘hallelujah’ but that’s so cliche, isn’t it? plus i kept going back and forth between leonard cohen and jeff buckley. then i realized i could put together a playlist. with a slideshow. with an open bar. and appetizers.
yeah…that’s when i realized that this wasn’t really a party i would get to enjoy. and i stopped.
mostly because i didn’t want to die and be watching my funeral from somewhere (above, below, perched on a wall, naked in the corner because NO ONE CAN SEE ME) and disappointed that the event didn’t go as planned. the lighting all wrong, the food not as delicious as hoped, the speeches droll.
clearly, there’s something wrong with me.
June 5th, 2008 at 3:07 pm
Geez. This was a pretty post. My uncle Lawrence had a piper at his funeral and I just about disgraced myself crying.
I had a funeral playlist and then I nearly died and it stopped being fun, you know?
June 5th, 2008 at 4:02 pm
even though i am an atheist, i love love love the mozart “ave verum corpus” and want that sung at my funeral.
i rather think that funerals should be celebratory and alcohol-fueled - so yes to the pipers, and yes to the hootenanny, and yes to the all night affair.
June 5th, 2008 at 4:14 pm
This question made me smile oddly enough. Amazing Grace by Flogging Molly, without a doubt, amongst a few others.
June 5th, 2008 at 4:24 pm
I am all for unconventional funerals. When my granfather died my senior year of high school we cremated him and dumped his ashes out on the family farm while riding in the back of the farm truck (at his request). We played Merle Haggard at his memorial service. I think there is something poetic about celebrating your funeral the same way you lived your life.
June 5th, 2008 at 4:26 pm
So many songs, my funeral would be all music if I had my choice.
And I do like the idea of an old-fashioned wake. Lay me out in the parlour and let the whiskey flow free; put me in the compost bin, after, for all I care. What’s me will be long gone; hopefully rending the veil between what’s now and what’s next.
Fields of Gold - Eva Cassidy
Death is not the End - Bob Dylan
Let It Be - The Beatles
Hurt - Johnny Cash
Be Thou My Vision - Van Morrison
June 5th, 2008 at 5:02 pm
Having recently buried my grandfather I’ve thought about this.
1) Big parties must be had. One reoccuring trend when a friend/relative dies is that I see friends I haven’t seen in years. What fun. Don’t cry on my account, drink er up.
2) I told Mart to cremate me and scatter me where he thinks of me most. Likely in a pasture under the feet of my horse.
3) My love will come with me to the afterlife, and be waiting. If I’m wrong, then I’ll never know, so I guess there is no harm.
3) Guitar indoors, and singing, belt it out! Pipes outside, I am a Wallace after all.
June 5th, 2008 at 5:14 pm
My family is from New Orleans, Jazz funeral it is, thankyouverymuch
June 5th, 2008 at 5:24 pm
Wait a minute. I’m the one with the little black heart.
June 5th, 2008 at 5:24 pm
You know, I actually haven’t put any real thought into what I’d like for my funeral. I think some Al Purdy would definitely be in order, probably “Necropsy of Love,” because it’s my favourite of all time…
June 5th, 2008 at 5:25 pm
If the boys are old enough not to be freaked out by the lyrics, I want You’ll Have Time by William Shatner (yes, you read that right):
Live life
Live life like you’re gonna die
Because you’re gonna
I hate to be the bearer of bad news
But you’re gonna die
Maybe not today or even next year
But before you know it you’ll be saying
“Is this all there was?
What was all the fuss?
Why did I bother?”
Regardless I want the whole shebang to end with Four Strong Winds.
Then my husband is having me cremated and taking my ashes to scatter in Mexico because (once following a bad vacation), I said, “Over my dead body will I ever go back” and he took it literally.
June 5th, 2008 at 6:59 pm
“an all-night hootenannie, with plenty of liquor.” Sounds good!
June 5th, 2008 at 8:03 pm
Not a topic I’d given much thought, but dancing music, for certain.
June 5th, 2008 at 10:54 pm
Some months after the death of my daughter I realized that I had used all “my” funeral songs for her service. I feel it is somehow horrifyingly fitting. Now when I hear them at played church I feel a piercing sorrow rather than the morbid fantasies I used to have.
June 6th, 2008 at 12:44 am
Oddly, not the funeral. Not the part I really think about. Strange for a control freak, no?
June 6th, 2008 at 8:46 am
I’ve told Josh I want a bouncy moonwalk at my funeral. I’m half joking…but come on, a moonwalk? That’s a spirit lifter, for sure. Especially if there’s an open bar…which I think is non-negotiable. Drunk people in a bouncy house…that’s the send off for me.
June 6th, 2008 at 10:57 am
I honestly haven’t given my own funeral much thought. It’s mostly denial, methinks.
My husband, who was raised very Catholic, but has succumbed to my ‘Meh’ version of religion, has all-night hootenannie aspirations. At one point he told me he didn’t want a traditional funeral, but rather, he wanted me to lay out his deceased body on the big work table in his wood shop and we could have a big party all around him. I told him I would absolutely do that for him, provided we replaced his corpse lying on the table with an urn of his ashes. I suspect having his actual body there would be a deterrent to his whole party theme, you know?
June 6th, 2008 at 10:58 am
I don’t want a funeral. I want a party. With a live swing band. And then to be cremated.
My nanny only had two wishes for her funeral - a closed casket, and “Amazing Grace”. A beautiful song, right? But three years later and I can’t even hum the first couple of bars without breaking down. I would hate to take a song I loved and have it forever be associated with sad memory for the ones I leave behind.
June 6th, 2008 at 12:43 pm
Sorry to make note of minor point in what was a deep and beautiful post–”My Way” is a fairly conventional Funeral song these days.
Daniel keeps a copy of it at his office.
My favorite out of the norm funeral song was “Goodnight Irene.”
I’m hoping with you that you and your mom have many long years ahead. But If for some reason I make it to your funeral, I might bring a long a copy of “I’ll Fly Away” just in case.
June 6th, 2008 at 8:56 pm
My brother and nephew are pipe majors. Seriously. You know, just in case you ever need to put out a tender for whatever reason. This is yet another reason why all my family gatherings are LOUD.
At my mother’s funeral I read e e cummings:
if there are any heavens
my mother will (all by herself) have one.
it will not be a pansy heaven
nor a fragile heaven of lilies-of-the-valley
but it will be a heaven of blackred roses
I read the entire poem but this is all I can remember by heart 8 years later.
June 6th, 2008 at 10:26 pm
Lovely post. And that song is one of our favorites, one we sing to The Poo all the time.
When my dad died, planning his funeral was so hard. He was sick for so long but he never told us what he wanted. We chose hymns and verses and flowers, blindly. I hope we did what he wanted, but we’ll never know.
So when I get closer, or even now, I should think about that. Thank you for reminding me to do that.
I know one thing for sure. I want them to play “Blackbird” by The Beatltes. Definitely.
June 7th, 2008 at 1:27 am
i really have not thought much about it, other than I want to be creamated and scattered, so that no one has to care for my grave, or go to a cemetary to think of me. I am rather partial to the very long hymn “for all the saints,” which my mother insists we sing ALL TWELVE verses of at her funeral, or none at all (and frankly, I agree with her, as it tells a beautiful story). Funerals are for the mourners, not for the dead, so I say whoever is left behind can do whatever they want. but an all night hootenannie sounds perfect
June 7th, 2008 at 9:18 am
My own funeral I don’t think about much, but i like the way our family does funerals. As little sermoning as possible and a great big family get together wake at someone’s house (with a lot of alcohol of course). Recently we’ve had a couple too many, and got to re-know our second cousins. We all decided at the second funeral in as many weeks that we had to stop meeting like that, and so I organised a reunion of sorts. It was great.
June 8th, 2008 at 9:05 am
This is interesting, because I used to think about this all the time. To the point where I had to bite my tongue when making out my living will/last will not to include specifics about music and readings and food (I think the lawyer was tired enough with my edits). And now? After having to think through a child’s memorial — where I couldn’t for the life of me think of anything remotely appropriate so we didn’t do anything? I can think of nothing that matters less. Cremate me, throw me to the wind somewhere with a view or a sunset or a soccer match, and go have a drink.
June 10th, 2008 at 12:32 pm
Bon,
I don’t want tears and mournful songs at my funeral. I want parents and children to gather, to take my children in their arms, and to hug them closely when I can’t anymore. They can sing if they like, but I really just hope that friends and family will focus on life, and a future that will encompass my children even when I am no longer here to set up playdates and parties. I don’t mind if everyone forgets me, but I could not bear it if they forgot my children.
June 10th, 2008 at 7:57 pm
Fiddlers green by the Hip
June 11th, 2008 at 5:03 pm
oddly enough I have thought often about what will come after my death, and have made sure my family knows. now that I have S I keep meaning to write things down, but somehow time slips away and I try not to think about me having to leave him.
August 2nd, 2008 at 12:50 am
Very late, but I’m quite behind in my reading. I couldn’t let this one slip by without a comment because I have a song I’ve wanted at my funeral since the first time I heard it (elementary school) 30-some years ago: Laura Nyro’s “When I Die” — Blood, Sweat and Tears version. I had her “Wedding Bell Blues” as one of our wedding songs. That was when I realized that these 2 childhood faves were by the same person and started to learn about her.
Other than that 1 song they can do what they want. I would prefer to be buried, because I enjoy cemeteries, but space-wise it seems so selfish not to be cremated.