Sun 15 Jun 2008
not another Hallmark card
Posted by bon under relationship stuff
[29] Comments
Father’s Day has always been my least favourite holiday on the Hallmark calendar. my father spent my childhood thousands of miles away, a voice on a phone, a series of semi-regular notes and letters in a cursive script round and beautiful. he was, always, my father. he was not a dad, though, never a daddy – neither rulesetter nor guide of my heart nor anything else the painfully gendered and whitewashed selection of Father’s Day cards at the gift shop have ever suggested he might have been, had he wanted to. i have called him by his first name since i could speak. every year for the past twenty-five or so, i have gone looking for a Father’s Day card for this man with whom civilities have always been observed with some pleasantness, and have struggled to scrounge up something that does not use the words “Dad” or “Daddy”, that does not refer to the great wisdom he imparted or patience he showed or money he doled out at my every whim, and yet that neither diminishes him to some couch potato stereotype ineptly blowing up a bbq, nor makes fart jokes. every year, i am baffled to discover that such a card does not exist, except occasionally when The Far Side saves my ass. this year, i had to resort to a card that ran along the lines of “i didn’t get you a bad tie, i just got you this card.” i was rather shamed. i love my father, for all…well, for all. i think he deserves a better card than that. but there was nothing else there that did not ring ridiculous, that did not cue the tumbleweeds to come blowing through the holes in the scenery, making them obvious, even cruel.
so i didn’t try to get Dave a card. if our local supplier doesn’t carry much for the post-divorce family, finding something touchingly appropriate for “my not-quite husband on one of those fake holidays we hate anyway and have loathed particularly since we spent our first versions thereof as parents without a living child and thus realized just how wretched and contrived and surreal the whole shebang is” seemed, well, unlikely. but i did let him sleep in, and made him an omelet and coffee. and i hope somewhere in there i said thank you to him, because Oscar is too young to say it yet, too young to know that life doesn’t always come this way, with a dad who is willing to love you up close and everyday and with patience and joy in your accomplishments, who is able to be present and steady, who is able to teach you to laugh at yourself and at him, too, and who will love you without reservation. but i am grateful on O’s behalf that he has this kind of dad, more grateful than i can say.

and as i watched the two of them play today, daddy and boy, i realized i never fully knew how much i was missing all those years, growing up for all cultural intents and purposes without a father. i am grateful for that too, because the twinge of comprehension does not cut nearly so deeply as it would have had i not come to the recognition here and now, as a part of something beautiful and strangely healing, this partnership and gift that parenting is, for us, when we are paying attention.





June 15th, 2008 at 11:44 pm
Beautiful, Bon. Your words here are better than any Father’s Day card could be.
xo CGF
June 16th, 2008 at 12:18 am
((Bon)) – Interestingly, but precisely, this is exactly why these Hallmark holidays bother me so. I always have felt for those who don’t have, be it a mother, a father, a lost child, or what not. It seems to me a day, sure whatever to celebrate your parent(s), but we should be doing that anyway, all the time. To parade the notion for weeks on end, to commercialize the perfect little family on TV, on billboards and store fronts, to shut down life otherwise when so, so many people in our world today actually have some kind of loss associated with these two days – it pains me. I lived your typical life, no loss to date, as of yet, but still…it’s always hurt me to know that others, out there, have to endure this day. Is that cynical? It sounds like I am an utterly cynical person on this notion; I am not. We do the cards and the wishing and all that, but…there is always some guilt associated with it for us, too – if we can not be with my husband’s family, we are with mine; vice versa, but one dad is alone on this holiday. And to be made to feel that way, for a holiday like this? That has always made me sad, too…ack…hugs to you, as O has the perfect Dad, it seems, and in this moment of your lives, that is what counts most for you – (not erasing, of course, the years you also had to endure it…)XO
June 16th, 2008 at 12:50 am
I always love the way you think. Thank you for sharing these personal thoughts about your father, and Oscar’s.
I have the same difficulty getting Mother’s Day or birthday cards for my mom. I can’t bring myslef to buy one that expresses something far from my own feelings. And my feelings are rarely set forth on cards.
June 16th, 2008 at 12:52 am
lucky stars, those stars. x
June 16th, 2008 at 12:57 am
I stormed out of the card store, this week, in protest.
This is a lovely, lovely piece, Bon.
June 16th, 2008 at 2:07 am
I always like to say that I spend Mother’s Day being a mother, and my husband spends Father’s Day being a father. A privilege and a gift that is not lost on either one of us. There is no fanfare, but it is a nice opportunity for the kids to remember to say thank you and to let Dad choose the restaurant for once.
I’m glad Oscar has that kind of Dad too. So very glad.
June 16th, 2008 at 2:08 am
Gorgeous. Father’s Day annoys me because it is so lamely obligatory. My own dad was hurt last year because I never mentioned it, and I was hurt because it seemed not to occur to him why.
June 16th, 2008 at 6:46 am
Um, was yesterday really Father’s Day? I don’t think I’ve ever done anything to celebrate it and this year was no exception.
June 16th, 2008 at 9:11 am
We had a barbecue and my kids gave their dad cards they made at school. And then The Boy threw up all over EVERYTHING and my husband cleaned everything up in the middle of the night. Happy Father’s Day, baby!
June 16th, 2008 at 10:48 am
I think I posted something similar last year, about the annoyingness of these cards. Paging Hallmark!
June 16th, 2008 at 11:16 am
Beautiful. You’ve got it exactly right. Such sweet photos.
June 16th, 2008 at 11:45 am
now I can see how much O looks like Dave.
Cards are always hard for me, too. It’s great that my children are old enough to make cards, so I had them make one for Grandpa, too. Still a bit of a cop out, and I did feel this year, possibly for the first time, that my dad did a good enough job, that he deserved a heartfelt thank you.
I felt a bit sorry for my husband because he spent about half the day in the bathroom with Lorenzo (I’ll be writing a book on how NOT to potty train, if I survive), but now that he’s at work and I am here, I think he had a “genuine” fathering moment and he lived to tell about it.
June 16th, 2008 at 12:01 pm
we have similar father-feelings and father-histories, i think.
June 16th, 2008 at 1:15 pm
I’ve been kind of shocked by the father’s day cards too; most of them are really offensive or patronizing or insulting to everyone concerned. I didn’t buy any this year …
June 16th, 2008 at 1:52 pm
“life doesn’t always come this way, with a dad who is willing to love you up close and everyday and with patience and joy in your accomplishments, who is able to be present and steady, who is able to teach you to laugh at yourself and at him, too, and who will love you without reservation.”
That is so true. I never thought all that much about what I missed by not having my dad around but now as a parent I don’t understand how any parent can be anything but what you wrote above.
June 16th, 2008 at 2:25 pm
I agree with De – they do look very similar. Oscar sure is a lucky boy.
My father’s day gift to my husband – not riding his ass too hard about his hangover. :)
I too hate most Hallmark cards.
June 16th, 2008 at 3:22 pm
MadDad ushered in Father’s Day by rinsing vomit chunks off the sheets at 3am and then putting them in the washer. Yup, Miss M has her first new day care malaise and MadDad deserved the humble gifts we offered.
As you know, I didn’t have reason to look on Father’s Day with anything but melancholy until quite recently. Seeing Miss M get excited about it all yesterday changed everything. It’s really great when the kids are young enough to be seduced by it and old enough to understand.
June 16th, 2008 at 3:27 pm
Oh, they have the same smile…
June 16th, 2008 at 4:22 pm
Simply lovely. And frankly? Probably one of the better father’s days and father’s day sentiments around, it looks like.
June 16th, 2008 at 5:43 pm
I don’t see the day as a Hallmark holiday. I always look for just the right card, and if I can’t find one, pick a blank one with a funny picture and write a little something for both Dad and Mart.
I know how much Mart weighed his choice of being Dad when he met me and Reiley, and I am so greatful and thankful he took the chance. So the special day is well deserved.
June 16th, 2008 at 9:58 pm
Happy Dad’s Day Dave. Strange that you guys have the same Mum’s Day as us but a different Dad’s Day.
June 16th, 2008 at 10:17 pm
Lovely pictures, and lovely thoughts. I have a different father-history than you – my dad has been nothing but an inspiration and a comfort to me – and yet…I still can never find a card that I think fits him. Like you say – too mushy or too insulting. I still often make one, or find a nice blank one. This year I found good ones for my own dad and my husband (Cora did make one at daycare – sponge-print dolphins)…can’t remember where I tucked them away. So, everyone got a rather plain notecard this year.
Our gift to daddy? The new cookbook Artisan Bread in Five Minutes a Day. A gift for everyone to enjoy! :)
June 17th, 2008 at 8:36 am
Your husband there, see how he opens up to you at the camera. (Ya, I used the word husband. Not married? Yes you are…)
June 17th, 2008 at 11:08 am
ah bon. what a glorious photo of your men, and a sense of peace in knowing that O will not know the same childhood as you did. I often wonder about those cards. I have several people in my life that I would love to acknowledge, but they don’t fit into any of the pigeonholes the card companies have created. sigh.
June 17th, 2008 at 3:38 pm
Gorgeous photos of your two guys.
I even had a difficult time finding a card for my dad who was a traditional sort of father. I don’t know why the folks who make greeting cards think there is no middle ground between mushy, mushy, mush and dad as a bumbling stereotype.
June 17th, 2008 at 5:21 pm
oh, i have the same problems getting my biodad a card, diff but similar problems for my fil, and completely different issues getting one for the man who raised me as his own but whom i’ve never called “dad”- so hard to find the one that says what you really feel.
so easy for me to find so many for pnutsdaddy, who is the most incredible father. he’s the reason why i love holidays that have been hijacked by corporations- i love having special days to call attention to him and only him, for all he does for her and me and all he is his for her and me- he deserves it, as does dave, as do all the amazing daddies out there.
but i certainly do hear you on the separate pain that loss brings to those days as well- they seem almost unimaginably cruel and heartless, as if you needed another reason to feel that pain again.
June 17th, 2008 at 9:56 pm
I couldn’t believe how hard it was to find the right Father’s Day cards for both the fathers in my life. Everything was cheesy, or gross, or contrived. In the end I resorted to blank cards for both my dad, and one for my husband, which I let the kids fill in.
beautiful post.
June 17th, 2008 at 11:43 pm
I totally dodge this bullet and do not give my father a father’s day card from me. The “grandkids” give them a card. Of course, I am still in the card aisle thinking, “Which is the most generic?” And buy that one. Problem solved….sorta Beautifully written post.
June 21st, 2008 at 12:05 pm
My card to my father this year said something about me wishing him low gas prices. I, too, am always looking for a card that doesn’t praise my father for being something he wasn’t. While I do appreciate the financial support he gave us, there doesn’t seem to be an appropriate card for that. And while I did send a card this year, I have stopped making the obligatory phone call, it being the only attempt we make at a conversation in the whole year. Thank you for giving voice to my feelings on a day when I would much rather be buying a card for “Daddy”. Except I don’t have one.