Mon 20 Oct 2008
to the brim
Posted by bon under pondering stuff, stuff to buy
[28] Comments
my house is drowning.
or rather, i feel like my house is drowning…to the outside observer, it more likely looks a little cluttered, overstuffed. and dusty, definitely dusty. but i can live with the dustbunnies…we reached a detente years ago, where they keep to their corners and i keep to mine. it’s the clutter, the sense of being crowded in on by stuff, stuff everywhere, that makes me batshit crazy, turns my voice shrill and my eyes all deer in headlights. i have more tolerance for dental drilling than i do for clutter, especially clutter of the sort where there’s really nowhere left to put any frigging thing and you can no longer keep track of what half of it is for or where it would go.
i blame the children.
Josephine, it appears, was born with six suitcases worth of stuff to her name. i swear i didn’t buy it, much…it just materialized with celebrations and kindnesses, donations and gifts and hand-me-downs and my occasional breakdown in the face of wee smocked dresses on sale. Oscar, too, owns more clothes than i do, and seems to sing toys from the sky like birds.
or bird droppings. scattershot, they adorn our den helter-skelter, while i flap about the house trodding on Thomas the Tank Engine and squawking “confusion and delay!” in my best – if unintentional – Sir Topham Hatt imitation. Thomas at least has spent a solid year enthralling my offspring…the charms of others have not been so enduring. i didn’t realize how quickly kids outgrow their toys…that the Little People farm will not do him until he’s twelve, no matter whether i spent fifty bucks on it or not. in any case, old toys are banished to the shed to lie in wait for Posey or for loan to little cousins, and new ones arrive to take their place. the task of trying to squeeze them back into the house when Poe is ready looms like a date with my own personal idea of hell.
yesterday my half-sister, bless her, brought her rainforest swing for Josephine. it’s a gorgeous swing, almost new. the baby loves it. and it has a footprint the size of a small zeppelin…i’ve slept in rooms smaller than the floorspace that swing eats up. i’ve been hyperventilating since it arrived, trying to figure out which wall to knock out in order to make room for the bloody thing. i want it, don’t get me wrong. but i don’t want to give up the room for it. and when your house is twelve hundred square feet, room is not in infinite supply…thus clutter happens.
so much has come so easy. fifty years ago, families of four and five and six children were regularly raised in houses precisely this size, likely with fewer lamentations and a lot less clutter. my mother, who has not hesitated to inform me more than a few times that she got me through to toilet training with only a dozen thin old diapers and a wringer washer, stares in thinly veiled horror at the largesse of toys and outfits that her grandchildren possess. i shrug lamely and swear i didn’t buy it all, and she and i both recognize how lucky i am to be freed from the worry and want that haunted her all through my childhood.
but it’s too much, people. it is a joy and privilege to be able to give my kids some nice things…creature comforts, imaginative toys, cute clothes. i am in no way above the materialism of my world and my time…this age of indulgence that’s crept over all of us – or at least all of us who can lay our hands on credit – has left me thinking little of dropping dollars on things that please me. and things for my children please me. but when we live more simply than most people we know and i still have nightmares wherein colonizing, primary-coloured plastic toys eat me alive whilst playing tinny nursery rhyme tunes, there’s a problem somewhere. and maybe it’s not just that i’m disturbed.
recession scares me, sure. the shitkicking my savings have taken over the past month or so leaves a little tang of fear in my mouth so sour that my brain prefers not to consider the subject at all. but, at the same time, the Scots pioneer deep down in my soul feels freed by the prospect of reckoning, of forced frugality, of a retreat from a culture of such excess that my not-quite-six-week-old owns more stuff than whole families not so far from here whom fortune has not treated so generously. parenting as a consumer pastime is not what i want to be. i need less, folks, less than what i have.
we may all have to make do on less, and i don’t want to paint that as falsely rosy. for some, there is genuinely no wiggle room. but for many of us, less is a very relative term at this juncture…our less still more than any generation before us ever considered having, and much of it unnecessary. i hope our culture can use this downturn to do a little needed paring of our bloat, our clutter. i do not want my children to mistake all this for entitlement, or for happiness. and – for the sake of my sanity – i do not want to step on another godforsaken toy train.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
are you drowning? in stuff, or fear of what a downturn will mean?




October 21st, 2008 at 1:14 am
Ah yes – I come from a long line of pack-rats. My parents don’t live in a house anymore – they sold theirs 13 years ago for a 44 foot travel trailer and life on the road. But even in that small space, my mom can pack-rat with the best of them. Every horizontal surface has stuff piled high and every cupboard is a jack-in-the-box waiting to spew stuff on your feet, ankles, or head.
I consider myself a recovering pack-rat. It’s like alcoholism – I will never be “recovered” but always battling the stuff and clutter. I fight it by routinely donating as much as possible to anyone who’ll take it. Amvets and Goodwill are saving graces and the annual church rummage sale is nirvana (for de-cluttering, NOT shopping).
Financially, I have no fear. We have always lived within our means – or expanded our means to accommodate our desired lifestyle (thus my 3 part-time jobs). My family were savers of everything, including money and I’m NOT trying to recover from that. Honestly, I think this is the time to scrape up change from the couch cushions and get in on the stock market, because it will recover eventually as it always has.
October 21st, 2008 at 2:07 am
i hear ya, girly…we too are drowning in stuff- why is it so hard to say no to hand me downs? let alone the new things i pick up here and there for the both of them…don’t get me started on smocked items (swoon)…
i will say i would give an appendage or two for our swing (same footprint as yours, ours has the fish)- damn thing saved my sanity with the pnut, and the bean seems to enjoy it almost as much…wee thing is sleeping away in it right now, and letting me have hands for a change!!n goddamn i love that bloody thing. worth every stubbed toe on it’s ridiculous feet!
glad to see you all so well- so much joy from these little wonders! xo.
October 21st, 2008 at 3:47 am
fighting the deluge is a pass time of mine.
October 21st, 2008 at 9:24 am
I am looking for some idea and stumble upon your posting :) decide to wish you Thanks. Eugene
October 21st, 2008 at 9:43 am
I fight the good fight and purge almost weekly. I am NOT a packrat. The husband is. Urgo, a problem.
It’s a bit better now that we have no babies. How something so SMALL can have so much CRAP I’ll never know.
We live pretty simply, so i don’t worry much about recession. I can’t do anything about it, so come what may. I’ve lived on perogies and Mr. Noodle before. :)
And those swings are awesome. But huge, yes. :)
October 21st, 2008 at 10:18 am
Both. I’m a ruthless pruner and I can and do throw things out or give them away because I too hate clutter, but it always comes back in just as fast as I get rid of it. And I’m very scared of the economic downturn. It’s different when you don’t have anyone to help you out.
October 21st, 2008 at 10:20 am
yes, yes, we have too much stuff, and although we, too, don’t have a lot of extra money and most of our stuff was handed down or whatever, it is, regardless, too much stuff, and I hope that a recession does help ALL OF US to pare down and make do with less stuff
October 21st, 2008 at 10:59 am
Love this. My “economic downturn” blog post was a whiny whine about all the things I can’t have. I much prefer your perspective.
Our 900 s.f. house lends itself to constant pruning. It’s the best, and the worst, thing about living in it.
October 21st, 2008 at 1:04 pm
What Thodora said.
When our kids were toddlers, my husband built a bin on wheels, big enought to take the bulk of the small toys. Every night before stories the kids toddled after me and we pushed the toy bin all over the house (850 sq ft)and put every toy IN it. Big stuff like FP toy farm had to be folded up and placed under change table. If the box got overfull, I pruned stuff out and got rid of it. Otherwise neat freak husband could not stand living in the place. Good discipline for kidlets, also a fun game (find toy, throw toy, etc), tidy ground floor by bedtime.
But you know what? Worse than plastic toys are the teenagers’ size 14 shoes left in the entryway when they all come to your house to have band practice. (And that’s before the noise starts).
At least the multiple outfits you have now are tiny and will fit in the closet.
October 21st, 2008 at 1:22 pm
I am clutter personified. I am incapable of picking up anything. We have a huge house and there is never a clear path from one room to the next to walk on. I wish I found purging easier. I wish I knew how all the god forsaken junk found its way into my house. It never seems like much when you acquire it: a puzzle here, some paint there and KA-BLAM! you suddenly are held hostage by stuff.
October 21st, 2008 at 1:46 pm
The toy clutter is intense around here too. I swear, I only bought about 5% of the stuff, but 9 + years of birthdays and other celebrations has filled my house to the brim. We mostly keep it in the basement playroom where it’s out of sight. Otherwise, it would slowly drive me insane. Luckily we get telemarketing calls (daily, it seems), from organizations that want this stuff. So every few months I purge away and leave it on my front steps for the good folks at Canadian Diabetes and Ont. Federation for Cerebral Palsy. They are the only telemarketing calls I welcome.
October 21st, 2008 at 2:59 pm
“Confusion and delay!” I love it. That is exactly, exactly our house. I can’t take it anymore, and one sad, lone person (i.e. me) can’t possibly clean it all. There is just no room. We have two birthdays and Christmas coming up and I am starting to hyperventilate about where to put things. (We desperately want our three sets of grandparents to buy Zoo or Science Centre membership, or contribut to the RESPs, but they will have none of it and keep buying truck upon car upon truck.)
Send help.
October 21st, 2008 at 6:20 pm
My mother was a huge packrat so I really try not to hoard things – but I married a hoarder, so it’s kind of hard.
I am drowning in one thing though – LAUNDRY.
October 21st, 2008 at 7:02 pm
First, a resounding “amen” from my corner; I echo each and every point, including the preference for dental drilling to clutter.
Second, Bon, and I know I’ve said this before, but your writing is just so good. Are you submitting somewhere? Because this post needs to be an article, published nationally, for all to read.
October 21st, 2008 at 7:40 pm
I too detest clutter, and lately the peace treaty with the dust bunnies has ended.
With Christmas looming and grand parents asking for wish lists, I just can’t help it, my lips become clamped shut. Don’t buy them anything, they don’t need anything.
But, of course they will have presents, too many. Grandmother rolls in with toys to make Santa look like Scrooge. It’s churns my stomach, but I should be grateful I know. I just hate having so many toys, none are apreciated or used properly.
I would rather one thoughtful, creative toy, then a dozen knocked from the shelves of Walmart because some company decided they’re cool.
October 21st, 2008 at 8:02 pm
Ummmm, I’m thinking I have little or no credibility with you on this topic. I would argue we have made some progress. We are trying to be more selective about what comes through the door. We have been trying to select items which encourage active play / learning. Isaac has actually been helping teach me we can live with far less and be quite happy by insisting on wearing only a select number of his clothing items (insists on spider man pyjamas every night… i have given in and just throw them in the wash every few days…simplifies things.
C
October 21st, 2008 at 8:09 pm
When we visit my mom’s house, Anna plays with toys that are over thirty years old that my mom lovingly kept in the basement for visiting small-ones through the years. On my sister’s birthday, she got to watch her one-year-old play with the castle my sister received on her first birthday. None of this answers your question. But my mom is not clutter-tolerant. Stephen and I definitely, definitely are. And our house is even smaller than yours . . .
October 21st, 2008 at 9:07 pm
despite my need for complete organization
i suck at keeping my house clutter free. the only thing i keep clean is the dining room table.
why, yes i AM a freak!
and now that my kids are older and the swings, cribs, etc. are gone it is SO much better. but there is still a lot of crap, so we are working on having them pick things out to donate before the christmas deluge comes.
October 22nd, 2008 at 12:52 am
I fight a weekly battle with a woman to whom love MEANS consumerism. She has to buy things for my children or I am denying them their chance at a happy childhood. Bollocks. I had much less than they do now and was happy. Sure I wanted penny loafers in grade 7 when all the other girls had them, but did it kill me NOT to have them? No. Was it character-building? You betcha. This Entitlementitis that has everyone in its grips these days scares me much more than any recession, perceived or otherwise, could. These kids show up at university expecting someone to hand them a degree and a nice job. They are disrespectful, thoughtless and inconsiderate. Now I’m not saying that kids that are showered with gobs of stuff can’t be good, but there is some correlation between never being told ‘no’ and expecting the world on a platter. I’m all for decluttering. If my kids want to play, there’s a perfectly good forest five minutes from here that will keep them going until 12, easy.
October 22nd, 2008 at 1:52 am
Your own personal idea of hell … “nightmares wherein colonizing, primary-coloured plastic toys eat me alive whilst playing tinny nursery rhyme tunes” … stepping on toy trains … oh, I relate. Even though our house is a bit larger than yours, we still have the clutter problem. I blame my husband, who has the pile gene and hates throwing things away (he keeps 10-year-old catalogs!), and my son, for being so cute and attracting so many toys to himself. Why do so many children’s toys have to have so many pieces to keep track of? And what would be the lifesaver to keep our house from drowning? :)
October 22nd, 2008 at 3:27 am
We’re hopelessly buried in toys and baby gear too. The living room has essentially become a big playroom, since we have no furniture there yet (hey, we only moved here . . . um, 10 months ago) and it’s yet another pile of puzzles and stuffed animals.
I’ve been giving away as much as I can to Goodwill, but this last visit to my parent’s house has made me rethink. I see old things that they’ve saved for so many years make a reappearance. A reupholstered chair. Carefully stashed away toys from my childhood, now brought out for my boys. My old footstool is set in front of the bathroom sink so that Q-ster can reach the faucet. I guess it’s a matter of choosing wisely what to keep.
October 22nd, 2008 at 7:36 am
Yes, drowning in stuff. And man do trains hurt when you stand on them.
October 22nd, 2008 at 6:37 pm
“the Scots pioneer deep down in my soul feels freed by the prospect of reckoning, of forced frugality” — I feel exactly the same way. When we discussed this, and I mentioned that maybe it’d be good for everyone to learn the concept of making do with what we have (I was raised pretty frugally) and to not get what we want by simply getting credit, my husband reminded me that I have things because of credit too. Yep, I know. BUT….I rather wish I didn’t. I’d like to see the mindset change. I am frustrated that we had to “bail out” an economy (what a joke) so that we could free up credit…WHY? So people can continue to buy what they can’t afford with no repercussions? Astonishing mentality.
October 23rd, 2008 at 3:43 pm
I’m not really worried about my own family, but I get knots in my stomach thinking about what the coming downturn is likely to mean for some other families.
October 23rd, 2008 at 4:19 pm
Obviously so many of us are struggling with the same things. We live with our four children (ages 15mo-8) in 1200sf. The original owners of our house raised five children in it who still speak fondly of their childhood. Our barely three feet of counter space in the kitchen I manage to keep cleared enough to prepare meals for us. But our dining roon table is a source of constant dynamic clutter…homework, music theory, my laptop, scrapbooks and various crafts on the go. Can’t seem to keep it cleared for the life of me. You can imagine the distress I felt when our youngest child arrived and brought with her as much stuff as the others. Well meaning and lovely gifts but stuff none the less. It’s better now that she’s past her first birthday…and will be for you too!
October 26th, 2008 at 3:51 pm
We’ve a healthy dose of Scots frugality too (funny enough most of our Scottish neighbours don’t – sometimes I think the culture has been better preserved outside of the country) so the recession isn’t worrying us.
We’re in a small 2.5 bedroom house that we’re exploding out of. It’s not just the toys, it’s also the adult stuff we feel is necessary like a fitted kitchen, camping gear, a computer and desk… sometimes it’s easy to pare back the kids’ stuff than my own.
October 28th, 2008 at 11:36 pm
I totally hear what you’re saying. I’ve just emerged from a total house cleanout, whereby my house looks once again like a sane person lives here. Toys neatly put away, closets organized, winter clothes front and center. Until, you know, the boys wake up.
It does get better once the little ones aren’t so little, of course….
By the way, do you know Stimey? She started a secondary blog called The Junk Pyramid in which she gets rid of 6 things a day that she (and her 3 boys) have outgrown. It’s pretty great.