Tue 3 Feb 2009
groundhog day, again
Posted by bon under coping stuff, relationship stuff
[34] Comments
there appears to have been a rip in the space-time continuum because both my children are currently sleeping. in the daytime. in their beds.
lest you think i exaggerate the rarity of this blessed event let me explain that the younger one is just learning to nap like a civilized infant whilst the elder one is – cue wails from the maternal peanut gallery – in the processing of outgrowing his tenure as a civilized infant and instead barreling whole hog towards being either a Big Child or a pirate, depending on the day, and neither Big Children nor pirates nap particularly well, unfortunately. i suspect it’s all the swaggering and roaring, in either case, but at the moment both my offspring are dozing and i am lying here on my side on the couch sans the company of short people and thinking that the gray light flooding in the window makes it feel rather like the beginnings of bedrest last year and wondering if i’m any different now than i was then.
i wonder this because i have this pesky attachment to the idea of myself as a dynamic, improving being. it’s the old modernist myth of progress boiled down to the individual level, where i get all twitterpated each time i become conscious of some personal failing as personal rather than the only reasonable and normal response to a given situation – oh, huh, not everybody goes into paroxysms of fury at drivers who fail to signal? – because, my stars! the emancipation! the agency! i can shed this flawed skin and emerge from my chrysalis new and delightful and better! now with more cowbell!
sometimes the change is real. i can learn. i now reserve all my turn-signal righteousness for my poor, beleaguered mother, who – as she is also capable of learning, if not of turning on her blinker before she engages the car in a turn – now simply refuses to drive me anywhere. win win, jolly good, pip pip.
but mostly i suspect that the idea that we are ever-improving beings is shite. it’s a dangerous siren song, and one so ubiquitous that as a culture and a species we repeatedly steer blindly towards the paths of our own demise. we choose short-term gains in spite of long-term damage and in almost all areas carry on as if nothing rotten is ever really going to happen to us. we’re engaged in progress! we’ll be fine! i know all the seventy-three reasons why high fructose corn syrup is bad for my glucose-intolerant self and my goal of looking less than four months pregnant again someday and my commitment to avoiding the agro-industrial complex where possible, but i saunter by that pack of Nibs in the store and damn! they are just so shiny and purty i swear they hop into my cart of their own accord. every time i go grocery shopping, it’s like groundhog day in the candy aisle.
some self-sabotaging habits are easier to make fun of than others.
from the time i was four, i wanted a little girl of my own. i had Finn and lost him and broken/brokenhearted realized i wouldn’t have traded him for a thousand girls. then Oscar, and i adjusted my expectations and the joys of a baby boy became the rhythm of my days and i understood, for the first time, that my preference had been a prejudice passed down and picked up, and i was shamed. then a miscarriage, and i began to bargain with precisely the sort of god i don’t believe in for just one more baby and damn the vagina i’d be more than blessed with another sweet boy and i meant it, i really did. except that underneath there was still a wistful part of me that ached – and seethed with a dirty, private jealousy – each time someone i knew who’d wanted a girl just…had one…seemingly magically, first try, no complications, as if plucked from the sky. i figured that this embarrassing allergy to other people’s good news was me being ungracious about not getting what i’d set my mind on all those years ago. and i’d wallow a bit and then kick myself and give thanks for my wee pirate-in-training and within a day or two the ugly green head of my jealousy and self-pity would bury itself again and i could get back to going about my life.
then i found out Josephine would be, indeed, Josephine. and i was amazed, because wanting her had come to seem like wanting the sky. and i said, self, take note. sometimes it comes easy. remember. you did not need to adjust your expectations. so get over yourself. a persecution complex ain’t pretty.
last spring i lay on this couch and wondered if maybe i’d be a better human once my heart’s desire of this healthy baby girl got safely here and the quavering over whether it would ever happen for me ended, once and for all.
i can report that the answer is…um, alas, nope.
one of my most beloved old friends is having her first baby. she’s 38. she’s always wanted a girl, and said on the phone last week that she was sure it was a girl, that she hadn’t really given any thought to it being anything else. turns out she was justified.
this baby will be loved and delighted in, by me almost as much as by her parents. she & Josephine will be close in age, and i know that my friend will be a beautiful mama, a good mother. but my first, visceral reaction? the same old jealousy, green and slimy and bilious. i cringed at the pique and said nah. really? but before i could even get the rejection formed it had delivered its soliloquy of woundedness and petty pity. why so easy for her? she didn’t even know she was pregnant until she was almost three months…she did all the things i never did, and bang, she gets her heart’s desire, nonetheless perfect and healthy.
oh, ugly. why not her, after all? i don’t know better people than her. and we all have our lucky breaks and our broken places and this friend of mine deserves all the joy in the world and i’d give it to her if i could so what in hell is this curmudgeonliness? i lack for nothing. there is no zero sum economy. life is too short to compare. adjusting one’s expectations can be good for growth. and yet there it is, the jealousy, naked and quivering. it helps nothing; i do not want it. but like groundhog day, it pops up. and i need to unlearn it, somehow.
she will not know, my friend, not from the face of genuine celebration i turn to her. it is not her burden. i don’t want it to be mine. but change is not so simple as skipping the Nibs aisle.
oh frail human. the same mistakes over and over, the same songs and refrains of willful blindness and short-term self-interest and stupid jealousy that sometimes i get so full to boiling i just want to spit.
today is the day after groundhog day, and i wanted to wake up different.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
i hesitate to publish this. jealousy is like the final frontier of friendship taboos…especially the messy stuff, the real stuff that runs way deeper than the cultural cache of yo bitch! your kids are sleeping?!? hate hate hate that counts as sisterhood these days. and i know – both out here and among real-life friends who struggle with IF or have lost babies or unlike me did not get one of the gender they’d set their heart on – that i risk revealing myself as an ungrateful moron when a sweet pirate and a baby girl sleep upstairs.
i sat with friends a few weeks ago, all of us mamas a few times over, and a pregnant one (not to be confused with pregnant friend above) recounted the drama of telling her infertile SIL about her news, after SIL had responded to another family pregnancy announcement by crying all day. the pregnant one found this frustrating, hurtful. i found it heartbreaking.
both are true, i think, depending on where you’re standing. i believe we most of us have our heartbreaks, and also that we’re responsible to those we love to try to fix our shit, try to be as good as we can be. i despair at how often it feels like we’re just groundhogs running on hamster wheels, stumbling over the same old thought patterns and habits and emotional minefields, blind and unable to flip the calendar over to a fresh page.
is it just me? do you have responses – emotional and otherwise – that you’d like to leave behind? how do you do it?




February 3rd, 2009 at 3:28 pm
oh honey…why do you think I’m in therapy? My entire life is unconcious reaction.
February 3rd, 2009 at 3:46 pm
Oh boy.
Oh boy.
You couldn’t have known this but I am reading this post on the one year anniversary of my first miscarriage. Last night I was low. So very low and I blamed the reno chaos and my fractured, internet-addicted psyche, and my needy child and a gazillion other things. And then I stumbled upon the annual letter that my husband writes to my daughter for her birthday. In it he refers to one of Miss M’s favourite elephants, purchased as he put it “during difficult emotional times for your Mommy.”
That’s when it hit me that 1) I was really sad b/c I knew, just knew, at a physical level that the miscarriage anniversary was waiting to eat me whole AND 2) that my husband who wanted that babe as much if not more than I did is a good man who has the capacity to simply let go. He did not make the story about him even though he could have and should have. Somehow, in this past year the miscarriages have become ALL ABOUT ME while the desire for more children has been his quiet want stifled by my greater fears. That’s not to say I am having and epiphany and we will now try for more kids. I am 43. I know that I am done. What I still need to learn, though, is how to take myself out of the centre of the drama and to concede that the drama is indeed over.
Upstairs in my bathroom right now, tucked away in a little cosmetics drawer is a positive pregnancy test from the second go-round that is still showing both pink lines. Can I, 9 months later find the strength to throw it out and simply move on? I don’t know. Maybe I too am unable to change.
A way too personal comment and a tangential one too BUT that’s how this post hit me.
February 3rd, 2009 at 3:48 pm
Oh, jealousy! I know thee well. I would like to leave it behind; be wholeheartedly happy for others without the “but” chaser. Alas.
You know what other reaction I would like to take for a ride in the country and abandon for good? The defensive place I immediately go to whenever my husband has a legitimate beef with something I have done. Sometimes I’m emotionally retarded.
February 3rd, 2009 at 3:53 pm
When we desire or obsess about something over a period of time, we build neural paths to rival the East LA Interchange.
About nine years ago I fell crazy in love with a co-worker. It took a LONG time and a serious conscious effort to stop thinking…
A few nights ago, I had a dream about being with him that brought me such joy, and the knowledge that it’s all still locked in there in my head.
February 3rd, 2009 at 4:27 pm
It’s the jealousy that I too have struggled with…its not an emotion I even recognized in myself initially, I was not a jealous person before losing Ezra. But it pops up in the most unexpected ways and places. You make such a good point about the two sides of the jealousy. Last weekend an old friend informed me that she is pregnant…and as I flatly told her that I am ‘happy for her, just sad for me’ I couldn’t help but imagine how difficult it must be for her that I cannot join in celebrating her motherhood-to-be in the way she certainly celebrated mine (before it was so cruelly wrenched away). And as I came home to sob my heart out, I wonder if she too was hurt by my cool response. But I’m not far enough out from losing Ezra to do anything about it…there’s nothing I can do change the new sad me.
February 3rd, 2009 at 4:34 pm
It’s not just you. All of us feel certain emotions that we’d rather not face head on. I guess that’s part of the human experience. I just try to find some positive aspect to what I’m feeling, so the entire experience is not so negative. It’s impossible to find the positive right away, and it might be days later, but I try to ask myself why I felt that twinge of jealousy or rage or whatever emotion might be eating me on the inside. Sometimes, it doesn’t even matter “why”, but I just feel better to acknowledge the emotion I felt and that I have a right to what I’m feeling. I practice Nichirin Buddhism and the chanting is my opportunity to reflect on my less-than-desirable emotions. Thank you for your writing; it’s extraordinary how it makes me feel so much.
February 3rd, 2009 at 4:37 pm
Thank you for posting this, because it’s not just you. I don’t hate or dislike the babies I see when I go out into the world, and some I truly celebrate, but in spite of myself, I find myself thinking, why is her baby here and mine isn’t? And worse, why couldn’t it have happened to that baby instead? Ugly, ugly jealousy – hateful, irrational, angry.
I wish I could disown it, cut it out of myself, erase it. But for now I just have to recognize it, keep it to myself, and hope I become better someday.
February 3rd, 2009 at 4:44 pm
Oh yes, there is a me — no, there are mes — that are so loathsome that I cringe when one of them turns up. Like the one that gets jealous and hurt and pouty when a daughter tells her father something I don’t know. I try not to associate with this woman, but somehow she keeps turning up.
This hit such a chord! You are perceptive and articulate and … and wow!
What do I do about it? Besides shoving the horrible woman back under water for the umpteenth time? I hope to laugh at myself.
And to never, never, never let on it happens.
February 3rd, 2009 at 4:55 pm
Mary…there’s the rub. i think i just let the cat out of the bag.
De, you blew my mind. neural pathways. hmmm. that may actually be an image i can turn into a strategy to try to create different highways so the kneejerk reactions change. thank you.
Ezra’s Mommy…i don’t think i was a jealous person before, either. but i’ve been living with this part of me for awhile now, and it’s crept out into various areas of my life and i think i’m ready to try to staunch it now. and i don’t think the world would be a bad place if we all got a little better at hearing “happy for you, sad for me”…and didn’t feel guilt but empathy when we were on the positive side of that.
Mad, i’ve always found that my psyche retains anniversaries…part of bearing witness or something. and i want to rephrase what i tweeted…i don’t think jealousy is all-about-me-syndrome with resentment, exactly, but with more why-not-me focus. the resentment isn’t the point…the other person isn’t the point. ahem. xo.
February 3rd, 2009 at 5:08 pm
I know a year seems like a long time, but in reality, it’s not. I think it might all be too fresh to expect to be able to transform just yet. I still get those same knee jerk reactions when I think someone (anyone) has had it easier than me, but that’s because pregnancy and birthing has been hard. It’s scarred me a little bit and I think it’s always getting better but I’m not sure when it will go away. Maybe that’s too much to hope for. Maybe we just have to hope it continues to lessen in time.
February 3rd, 2009 at 5:50 pm
Well, I have similar reactions to real estate happiness because I live in vancouver. It started when we livedin a small apartment and couldn’t afford a bigger rental. But it remains even though we got into a fabulous waterfront 2br co-op!
I am the much older fertile friend and I have said things like “happy for me and still sad for you” to a very close friend. After several m/c asnd a very sick premature baby we can celebrate together now but it still isn’t fair that I came by my 2 boys so easily…
February 3rd, 2009 at 6:20 pm
Do I have responses that I’d like to leave behind?
HELL YES.
And there are times when I make myself sick – literally – going over them in my head. Playing them out and replaying them again.
February 3rd, 2009 at 6:36 pm
Re: superhighways for thoughts… This has made sense to me for a wile now regarding sitching habits. Hard to switch off onto the unfamiliar country road. it’s a bumpy ride but a much better view & outlook.
February 3rd, 2009 at 8:00 pm
jealousy is indeed a curse, and it is raging inside of me right now. before my loss? i was probably mildly envious of some people and some situations, but it wasn’t out of control. i’m female, we all are a bit! post loss, i’m seething with jealousy. for the nine months i carried hope, i thought she was a boy. that’s ok, i got used to the idea and thought having a boy first would be just lovely. i always wanted a girl though, as i wanted that fantastic mother-daughter thing i’ve got going on with my own mama. and i only ever had a girl name picked out, we could never decide on a boy name. and bam. she dies at 40 weeks 5 days. and i got my girl, but she’s gone. my biggest fear now is not just never having any more children, but never getting me a girl to keep. i couldn’t even give my daughter the name i had picked out. i simply didn’t want to bury it.
and back to the jealousy, about six of my friends have had girls since hope died. and one just recently, used “my name”. yeah, i’m pretty much out of control jealous right now!
February 3rd, 2009 at 9:08 pm
I think you wouldn’t be human if you didn’t have the dark and ugly emotions as well as the sunshine and unicorns ones.
February 3rd, 2009 at 11:35 pm
ha! I just wrote today about my green green envy for those who are happy. who appear content and easy.
I have no answers. But i will tell you of a close friend I have who suffered many many losses. Baby losses. And how can she help but feel pique as you call it, when one of our own but glances at a fertility clinic and the deed is done? How indeed. It is not fair.
life. The universe as I have said many a time is a cruel mistress.
February 3rd, 2009 at 11:35 pm
I feel jealous of mothers with babies who actually sleep. Why is it so easy for them? I am jealous of mothers who work from home when the kiddos are asleep. Where are all these awesome jobs and why can’t I find one? I am jealous of people with money. Why are we always struggling to get by?
I think I am FULL of jealousy.
February 4th, 2009 at 12:09 am
I think some traits are more changeable than others. Fear changes – you can grow past fear. Shyness, insecurity … those things can be mended, under the right circumstances. That path out of other dark corners is harder to find.
February 4th, 2009 at 12:15 am
“embarrassing allergy to other people’s good news…” Why hello, Bon’s green-eyed monster. Meet mine.
I’ve also got the self-loathing response, too, in those bad-mother moments. Too much snapping and not enough patience, too much bloody TV, too much f*cking aching for time to myself… and then this response kicks in and says ‘you weren’t enough of a mother to deserve these two, let alone Liam’ or ‘how would you ever have coped with three? you aren’t good enough with two’ and I believe it, and that is my blackest of black.
Somehow on those days I feel as though Liam is with me, but not in the way I wish. I feel him as an extra witness, another set of eyes who sees who I really am, and I can’t stand the sensation of failing him, or of shame. Your baby dies (or some other tragedy strikes) and you fail to remain grateful and profound.. it’s some kind of an insult to the dead and the suffering, people who would envy our functional lungs and roofs and muscles and voices and large appliances.
I want permission to be flawed, free from the burden of enlightenment. But would I want to be oblivious again, or without the knowing of him? No.
Another incredible post, Bon. You make my brain itch. And a nice itch. Not the pain-and-discomfort itch. Mostly. (smile)
xo
February 4th, 2009 at 2:10 am
pirates nap if you let them drink enough grog all day.
February 4th, 2009 at 9:14 am
Jealousy is a curse, it certainly is. One I struggle with is a family member about my age…who things just seem to be so much easier for than me, than our little family. Always an easier, better paying job, a bigger house, a newer car. I’m sure they have their struggles too, but from my point of view, it seems like some of us are always struggling, and some get all the breaks. And that makes me resentful, no matter how I try to pretend it doesn’t.
February 4th, 2009 at 11:00 am
Yes, I am jealous. All the time. Of every woman friend I have. Yes you, and Mad, and Kate, and Jada. You all have something I wish I had, or some talent I don’t possess, or a poise I don’t feel. And it stunts me, makes me into a hermit, makes me feel small and wounded and about nine years old.
If I knew how to leave it behind, believe me, I would tell you the secret.
You are braver than I am, to come out with this. So there you go, now I can envy you for that, too.
February 4th, 2009 at 12:41 pm
Is there life without envy??
February 4th, 2009 at 12:59 pm
Jealousy. I see it in myself, and it makes me oh so sad. But you HAVE the baby girl, and she is sweet and wonderful and Josephine, and I am so, so happy for you and Oscar and daddy….
I am learning to let go. To not be jealous, and to enjoy and be grateful But if it comes back, remember, you’re only human….
February 4th, 2009 at 2:26 pm
I just spent two years getting over my irrational and yet painful envy of the “third child.” It finally happened. And now I am free to envy people who aren’t allergic to their puppies, who have a career, and whose children always have combed hair. (as opposed to being grateful for my puppy {achoo!} thankful that I don’t have to work, and kissing the ground that my healthy, bright kids walk on.)
February 4th, 2009 at 5:23 pm
I lived, ate, and breathed jealousy for many many years, and it never went away when I shoved it down. Only when I admitted to myself, and perhaps to someone else.
I’ve been envious of so many things over the years that it’s hard to remember all of them. You just have to get it out, like in this post.
It will become less sharp over the years, less cutting. It takes time.
As for napping ending, have you thought about making him have quiet book time then? Like you have to be quiet in your room for this two hours and then you can play pirate? It was my only plan.
February 4th, 2009 at 6:11 pm
Now with more cowbell! Hee hee!
I believe people can improve and that yelling at traffic offenders or being jealous of friends aren’t really obstacles that are too big.
It’s not fair for people to ignore the law, even seemingly minor traffic laws. And the maternal instinct is extremely powerful. Why do some women have such a hard time getting or staying pregnant while others, like my friend who just announced her third child is on the way, can joke about how fertile they are? It’s not fair.
Since you asked, I have been conditioned from childhood not to think that I am pretty. I was always compared to my cousin, the natural beauty. She was the pretty one, and I was supposedly the smart one. (I wonder if she doubts her intelligence the way I’ve come to doubt the level of my appearance.) It doesn’t seem to matter that my cousin is nowadays way too thin and wrinkled-looking from years of smoking — she will always be the pretty one. And I might always look at an attractive person and wonder why that couldn’t have been me. Because, once again, it isn’t fair.
Maybe it’s that unfairness of it all that’s at the bottom of everything?
February 5th, 2009 at 2:14 am
I feel like I don’t have anything useful to offer but I do want to say I love you for saying “now with more cowbell.”
February 5th, 2009 at 5:45 pm
The green-eyed monster lives within us all. Don’t know why, but it’s there. I envy your ability to express it so well.
February 6th, 2009 at 1:12 am
been trying to figure out how to respond to this. maybe just thank you for your honesty.
February 6th, 2009 at 11:57 am
Don’t we all?
I remember when all of this KayTar drama started, I was part of an online birth club board…there was one little boy with Down Syndrome and he started walking. Walking before my KayTar. MY KayTar, that should have been “normal”. I actually wrote a post about it, here. This is the first time I’ve even thought of it in ages and as I reread it, I was struck by my poor tender heart that still bled so easily when pricked. I’m sad for that girl, crying over calling her little girl “special needs” for the first time. I can’t remember a time when saying it hurt me so, but it did.
At times, I still have gut reactions that I’m less than proud of, though I know it is my cross to bear and I keep it to myself just long enough to acknowledge it and let it go.
February 7th, 2009 at 12:35 am
Bon, I think that your response to the friend having the girl is a knee-jerk reaction, it’s been ingrained after all you’ve had to go through…
…And I hear you, loud and clear. I don’t think it’s something that ever goes away, you just learn to smother it a bit better, or avoid the easily avoidable so that jealousy doesn’t rear it’s head and the hurt doesn’t cut through you.
February 14th, 2009 at 2:21 am
You know, I’ve never told anyone this. Seventeen years ago, after my miscarriage, I was in a mall and saw a lady go by with triplets in a stroller. I cried all the way through the mall about how unfair it was – that I couldn’t even have one and she got THREE! But I can laugh about it now.
February 16th, 2009 at 5:04 pm
i see those ‘ugly’ bits and raise them some cowbell.
oh yeah. i hear you. lately i am so tired of myself; exhausted by the bitterness that lies dormant until it suddenly ROARS AWAKE LIKE A STARVING SEALION and eats the parts of my brain that moderate thoughts like ‘she doesn’t deserve to be pregnant’ and ‘how am i supposed to be happy for these two morons who got pregnant on the first try, they don’t know struggle’. but then, eventually, it quietens: ‘why is it never me?’
why indeed. the universe and i are still trying to figure it out. i think that by admitting them and perhaps even by putting them out there…we are flawed and genuine. such liberty might become liberating?
maybe.