Tue 7 Apr 2009
two hearts
Posted by bon under issue stuff, mama-baby stuff
[30] Comments
there’s this little girl i want to meet someday. her name is Lily. she was four weeks old yesterday.
her parents live here, in this smallest of capital cities. i don’t know them…though in the newpaper clippings they look vaguely familiar, as if perhaps i’ve brushed by them in a grocery store aisle or a coffee shop over the years. i may happen on them again someday, later, our daughters in the same gymnastics or driver’s ed class. i may. i hope i do.
they are not here right now. they’re in Toronto, with their daughter, at Canada’s foremost hospital for sick children. Lillian O’Connor is four weeks old. she is waiting for a heart transplant. without one – and soon – she will not survive.
there’s another little girl in the same hospital who i’ll never meet. her name is Kaylee. she was two months old yesterday. she has a rare and fatal brain malformation…there’s nothing doctors can do to save her.
Kaylee’s parents want to donate Kaylee’s heart to Lily, if there is compatibility and the ethical protocol can be met…and if Lily does turn out to be highest on the recipient list when Kaylee is declared dead. the story is an emotional Paaschendale…mud and tragedy enough to drown in.
21 years after the first successful infant heart transplant, infant organ donation is still a very messy issue.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
i’ve been waking up with Kaylee and Lily’s parents on my mind the past few days. i’ve been waking up a lot, admittedly, with a teething baby whose bronchiolitis has her jacked up on ventolin and sleeping in torturously small 45 minute increments the past 36 hours or so. crawling out of bed at 2:30 am, and 3:30, and 4…i consciously force my brain to remind itself, i’m glad she’s here. i’m glad she’s relatively healthy. this too shall pass...and it can hurry the f*ck up and not let the door hit it on the…grumble grunt…zzzzz. the reminders keep me from cursing quite so flagrantly.
four years ago i would have eaten glass for the luxury of waking to soothe my baby.
i think Lily and Kaylee are both first babies, as Finn was. i peer into the picture of their parents’ faces, these four new parents, on my computer screen and wonder. any time a death sentence is pronounced upon your child, the world crashes in on itself. when it is your firstborn, and parenthood is a new world you’ve turned your life inside out to embrace, the crash is perhaps particularly bewildering, because you become that contradiction our society has no words for…a parent who has no child.
i wonder what will happen to them, to Kaylee’s parents, to Lily’s. about waiting by the bedside of your daughter, waiting for news of a transplant heart, every cell trained on wishing and praying and willing the universe to provide; about the helplessness and heartbreak of knowing mercy can come only in the form of another family’s hell. i wonder about Kaylee’s mother waking in the middle of the night a month from now, and whether some small part of her will rail that it was not her girl who could be spared. i wonder how their sorrow will mark them. her mother is only twenty…i heard her voice on the radio this morning, and it made me cry. i hope her strength is long, enduring. i hope nobody is fool or cruel enough to say to her, “you’re young. you can have another baby.”
i wonder at the grace shown us, strange backhanded grace, that we were never given hope after Finn’s first lung collapse at an hour old. i knew his death came because nothing more could be done for him…not because the cure didn’t come in time, not because there were no donors to save him.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
nobody talked to us about organ donation when Finn died. he only weighed a kilogram, hefty for a 26 weeker, but – as vital organs mostly need to be transplanted among people within similar weight ranges – probably too small for any recipient baby to have undergone the transplant procedure. his corneas? probably too underdeveloped. and the oxygen loss he suffered when his lungs failed him at birth – that probably made him a poor donor too.
or so i tell myself. in truth, the possibility of donation didn’t cross my mind during the hours we had with him. and it was never mentioned, probably for all the reasons above.
if it had been, in that strange underwater blur of clanging ventilators and harsh lights and fear and beauty that was the lifetime lived in the blink of an eye beside that little incubator on which i wrote his name and all my fierce, defiant hope on a piece of masking tape, i might have resented it. it takes time to process the shock of having had a baby at all, let alone a baby whose prognosis is suddenly more dire than ever imagined…and time is precious when you don’t have much of it and thinking about after when he was still here was something my mind flatly refused to do, full stop, except to cram in as much of the sight and the smell and the feel of him, tiny fingers squeezing my own, as i could while i could. because i did understand, right from the moment that first doctor clapped hope shut all over my eager face, that time would be too short and time with him was all that counted.
and yet, in the same breath, i would’ve said yes, had it been an option. because some part of him, then, would have had more time. even if that part was not for me to touch, to know. the hardest point of coming home with just a blitzkreig of memories and an urn was that my child – in the eyes of the world – disappeared. i could do nothing to help him. but to help another child live through him? that difference would’ve been staggering, i think, on the long road to my own peace.
organ donation among infants is relatively rare, and controversial. even when a child’s physiology is incompatible with life, as in the case of ancephaly or the brain anomaly Kaylee suffers from, the requirements for declaration of death are often not met until healthy organs have deteriorated past the point of transplant.
the rules exist to protect the living from having organs harvested, obviously. and yet the system works particularly poorly with infants because definitions of death – brain death vs. cardiac death – are inconsistent and because the organs are so small and easily damaged.
as it stands at latest reporting, Kaylee’s parents plan to take their little girl off life support today. they plan to make her heart available – so doctors will stand by, waiting for her heart to stop beating, and for the full five minutes to pass before she can legally be declared dead. and Lily’s parents? they have to decide whether to accept the heart, to risk having their daughter prepped for surgery and readied to receive the heart, without knowing whether or not after the five minutes required by law have past Kaylee’s heart will still be viable.
gah.
and i sit here in Lily’s hometown, what should be Lily’s hometown someday, my heart in my mouth.
these two families have found each other in Toronto over the past week or so, and in each other found the possibility that their daughter’s stories may merge, two hearts into one life.
Update: the story only gets more fraught…last night, Kaylee’s parents said goodbye and their daughter was brought into surgery to attempt donation (though it apparently isn’t clear whether Lillian was, in fact, the designated recipient), but Kaylee stayed awake when life support was removed. as her condition means her organs only fail when she’s asleep, the surgery was obviously called off. it doesn’t mean her prognosis, unfortunately, is any rosier, and her family is vowing to try again for donation if circumstances make that possible. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20090408.BABY08/TPStory/TPNational/Ontario/




April 7th, 2009 at 2:38 pm
chills. and the overwhelming gratefulness that both my babies are here with me.
April 7th, 2009 at 2:42 pm
oh my god, Bon. what a story… it left me totally winded and in tears. I love your words and you heart.
And hope little Posey feels better soon and deep sleep is restored to your household. xo
April 7th, 2009 at 3:11 pm
Oh. It is too sad, and too hopeful all at once. I don’t know whether to cry at fate, or be renewed in my estimation of human generosity. Beautiful post, bon.
April 7th, 2009 at 3:12 pm
oh, oh, oh.
i wish it didn’t have to be so hard so much of the time.
April 7th, 2009 at 3:18 pm
It’s almost unbearable, breathtaking to be absorbed in such a story, when there’s nothing you can do. Imagine being one of the decision-makers. Just imagine having to make daily decisions about whether others live or die, playing God. So much suffering. I was 8 months pregnant when I lost my baby girl. She was 6 pounds 4 ounces, bigger than many full-term babies, and nothing visibly wrong, when she was born, other than not being alive. I asked if there was anything we could donate, anything we could do some someone would benefit. They patted me and explained she was dead and no one could use her organs. They gave me the same looks as when I asked if taking Metamucil had killed my baby. Tsk tsk. They must be prepared for these questions, you know? How do you prepare to deal with death every day. I understand your pain and frustration and the fruitlessness. What if Lily isn’t first on the list and someone else gets the transplant? What is just? Do people with the ability to connect deserve life more than those who just wait in ignorance? These are the things that plague me too. I’m glad you have the courage to post your thoughts and inspire others.
April 7th, 2009 at 3:39 pm
That story is so damned heartbreaking.
April 7th, 2009 at 5:02 pm
I just have tears. I can’t imagine, but you told it so well that somewhere in there I almost could imagine and I think I broke just a little.
April 7th, 2009 at 5:39 pm
bon,
thank you for this post. i will be thinking of kaylee and lily today with love. infant organ transplant is not something i’ve even thought about until now. angel mae was far too young and small to have helped anyone. but if we go for pregnancy #2, i will be going in with my heart in my mouth and prepared for the worst. i will think of this next time, should the worst happen, and ask who could benefit. so thank you for this.
April 7th, 2009 at 7:06 pm
This is heart breaking. And as you know, I know this pain too. All too well. The firstborn. A little girl. Our parenthood. All gone in a flash. And like one of the above commenters, gone before she was born, even at 8 pounds and 40 weeks and 5 days, so nothing to “salvage” to help other little sick babies. This world we live in can be so cruel.
I will hold those two little babies, and their families in my heart.
April 7th, 2009 at 7:18 pm
My Grannie just had a corneal transplant. Her 2nd. At 93. And the issues are just as complex for those at the latter end of life as for those at the beginning – I wish it were clearer, the decisions around loss and the faces of family making those decisions. My grannie can see today, though, and it’s given her will to live. Being on the recieving end of grace, it’s hard to understand the loss, but I do love and respect and absolutely honour the giving. I wish them peace with these days, and the decisions the days bring.
April 7th, 2009 at 8:03 pm
My heart is in my throat. This is so hard, and the hope somehow makes it even more so, but I hope for Lily, for Lily’s family and for Kaylee’s.
April 7th, 2009 at 8:32 pm
I’ve been following this in the news, and I’m angry and sad and partly trying not to imagine ever having to make these types of decisions for my irritating and wonderful daughters, at any age.
Just…the strength and hope of Kaylee’s parents-seeing them on the news, and how much they want some part of their little girl to last and mean something…it’s crushing.
I hope we all get to meet Lily someday, here and now.
April 7th, 2009 at 8:53 pm
I have been following this story for the past month and a half and I cant seem to realize that a child has to lose his or her life in order to give another child life. I cried most of the evening and tried to figure this logics of life and death. Kaylees passing may save lilys life. Im praying that after the operation all goes well. I pray she recovers well and that sweet angel kaylee will watch over her and guide through recovery. This story that you have written was veryy touching and I hope that the only decision I need tomake as I wake up andlook at my 2 daughters is what will ANGELEIGH have for lunch and hope she has a good day at school. What should SAVANAH-ROSE weartoday cause its chilly outside.Kaylee sweet angel you have affected many lives and definetly mine and I will think of you as often as I could and will think of you as many times as I look into my childrens eyes. God bless your little soul. Look over your parents and guide them through love and life. Sweet Lily I hope one day I could meet you and hold you and tell you how you affected my life. I wish you a great life and I hope god watches over you for the rest of your life. LOve both sweet angels
April 7th, 2009 at 9:57 pm
I don’t even know what to say after that. I think you did the story justice in a poignant and beautiful way.
April 7th, 2009 at 11:44 pm
Wow. There is so much pain, and so little hope… sometimes it feels overwhelming.
April 7th, 2009 at 11:45 pm
Wow. There is so much pain, and so little hope… sometimes it feels overwhelming.
April 7th, 2009 at 11:50 pm
Like you, waiting. Hoping. Weeping.
April 7th, 2009 at 11:50 pm
shitshitshit
what else is there to say?
There should be something for birthing mothers to sign, before giving birth, when our heads are clear and our vision true, to donate or not to donate. Wouldn’t that be the time to decide?
April 7th, 2009 at 11:53 pm
Oh, damn. Damn. Damn. Father is not giving up, however.
April 8th, 2009 at 1:38 am
i have not lost like you, but witnessed recently the loss of a little one, a twin. it makes me breathless when i read her mama’s words and pray for their family. there is no road map to navigate any of it, the only think i find i can do is pray to my name-less god, not asking just hoping.
April 8th, 2009 at 1:41 am
Bon, you have me in tears tonight. I am just heart broken thinking about these two families and what they are going through. Thinking about your family and what you went through, and my own parents and how it must have torn them apart inside when my brother passed away. I need to go hug my little ones.
April 8th, 2009 at 8:08 am
Saw the update last night, when Kaylee’s parents took her off the ventilator and against all expectation and reason she breathed on her own for over half an hour.
This whole story brings me to a feeling too deep even for tears. And a feeling of horrible inadequacy that I can be so frustrated with my healthy, boisterous boys.
Thank you for your thoughts on this.
April 8th, 2009 at 12:09 pm
It is front-page news on every paper in this city today.
April 8th, 2009 at 12:19 pm
Oh my god, I can barely stand more stories of baby girls sick and dying. I have learned of two others this month as well…and they are all first children as well. The world is shattering for people all around us, every day. And what to make of it? I suppose to acknowledge and absorb the joy that is around us when we are priveleged enough to be near it.
You are wonderful to bring this story to light.
April 8th, 2009 at 1:38 pm
You give me a new lens, bon. You know that eh? I used to hate seeing stories like this on the news; human interest stories, I believe they are called. I hated them because I never knew what they offered us in the grand scheme of things other than that sensation of “the need to hold our own kids tight.” I was never much for lessons of the heart that came at the expense of others’ suffering. Stories such as this one always felt like nothing more than terrible journalistic voyeurism into the pain of others–people who then get spit out by the other end of the media machine.
You make me see differently because you (and Kate and Niobe and others) have voiced a fuller story than the media ever could. You have allowed the parents of Kaylee and Lillian to become significant–as people whose pain and loss is a story of life, not just a lesson voyeuristically offered up. You make me realize that by not knowing these stories, we silence them and the people at the heart of them.
I’m not sure I am expressing myself well at all.
April 9th, 2009 at 12:32 am
There is too much death and despair. I feel powerless and angry over it.
Every time I hear about tragedy, I try and find something that sets these people apart from me, my selfish way to protect myself from the truth…that we are all vulnerable to it, and there we are all the same when it comes to death.
I’m keeping these families in my thoughts and prayers.
April 9th, 2009 at 4:42 pm
i have been following Kaylee’s story in our local newspaper and am struck by the maturity of her young mother. to give in the face of such sorrow takes strength. thank you for this post.
April 9th, 2009 at 9:42 pm
So sad. Ugh. I hate that people have to go through horrible things like this. Breaks my heart.
April 10th, 2009 at 3:16 pm
Hi hon,
You are being ten times kinder than I am on this subject. I am filled with rage at the horrendous way the parents are being treated by hospital staff and doctors. They always are at the incredibly shitty hospital. The stories I could tell….
They have technical wonders there beyond belief, but no heart, no soul. Jason Wallace is an amazing human being with the decency and guts to speak up and tell the world what it is really like to be there. I can’t tell you how much I admire him.
That said, I wanted to donate Matthew’s organs and asked about it before he died, but no one would take them. He was still alive and we knew he was dying and they still said no, the bastards. They always do. Not because they don’t want organs, but because they still treat bereaved parents like children unable to make decisions.
So many parents I know would’ve liked to donate their child’s organs or tissues when they are dying but the doctors won’t ask.
There is so much more I could type here, but I won’t….just know, hon, that they could have used Finn’s heart tissues and stillborn babies tissues for heart valve replacement, etc. They could have done a lot, and maybe you and others could ask them to change their policy. I know for a fact that they do it in the US. Why not here?
Trust me, after I get done with Sick Kids….they sure as hell will be doing it from now on.
April 12th, 2009 at 2:09 am
oh. oof.
I’m an organ donar. I’m sure if Finn’s organs could have saved another baby’s life they would have asked you. and of course you would say yes. to not only have part of Finn live on, but so that some other child, some other parent, could have a happy ending.