Wed 3 Jun 2009
when i grow up redux – on potential
Posted by bon under issue stuff, milestone stuff
[33] Comments
my mother tells me i walked at nine months old.
she has been telling me that for as long as i can remember. she’s also prone to mentioning that i spoke in clear sentences by two, and stayed dry through the nights shortly after.
oh, i was a starbaby, clearly. and my mother’s pride in the accomplishments of my infant self has been a reliable camp stove for the cockles of my heart for, um, ever.
sure, i’ve done other things in my life. i have a good eight or nine years of post-secondary education under my belt, been around the world a few times, have written a few things i’m proud of. but ask my mother, and you’ll get the distinct impression i peaked in 1973.
it took me a good 35 years to figure out the sad truth about my child prodigy status.
being the first among my little friendlets to walk never actually made a better walker than they were. i spoke early, yes, and admittedly i haven’t stopped…but once you hit grade three or so, being a monolingual, publicly verbal creature ceases to be so impressive. and i seldom wet myself, true, but so far as i’m aware, neither do many other thirty-somethings. (well, except for those unfortunate post-partum bladder indiscretions…HUSH. for years i was continent, people. totally, reliably continent.)
my mother has spent my entire life exuding beatific pride in perfectly normal milestones that almost all typically-developing children meet somewhere within a twelve-month period. i was no freakin’ Mozart, composing symphonies in Pampers, for crying out loud. i walked early. i stopped pissing myself a few months before some of my friends.
i spoke in sentences probably a full year before my son did. but now that he’s reached what the charts call age-appropriate fluency…whaddaya know? he says stuff just as smart as the kid who started talking a year earlier.
my handy-dandy parental primers, mostly used as helpful doorstops since the early days of Oscar’s infancy, all have the same message: the delicate self-esteem of a child has its first roots in the reflections cast back to said child by his or her caregivers. you are good, you are special, we communicate to the little folk, and THIS is why.
i made them doorstops because they all communicated to ME one troubling message: my self-esteem is rooted in the very same old sacred cows that i’ve been railing against since i turned thirteen. dammit.
my mother, bless her good and earnest heart, wasn’t trying to set me up for a middle-age of nagging insecurity. she is, to her core, a believer in Authority. she appeals to it, honours it, makes an occasional shrine of it. and left alone young, with an infant to raise, she turned to Authority to bolster and validate her efforts. enter Dr. Spock, with his normative charts.
if i walked early, she must be doing a good job. spoke early, and without that pesky island accent? she was offering rich language development resources in the home environment. toilet trained before two? clearly, despite the pinched disapproval of single parenting amongst the Good Families of the city in that time, she must be morally upright enough to earn some stamp of approval and seal of quality, else i’d have been soiling myself all over town until well past three.
you see where all this goes wrong, right? i grew up with the idea that doing things early was not only a marker of my great, if vague, potential…but that it was a good in itself. i was good because Authority declared me good. and prompt. that is all. thanks for playing.
my mother’s Dr. Spock book – i read the damn thing myself in adolescence whilst plowing indiscriminately through her bookshelf – stopped at age three. and so did any discussion of my skill set, my qualities as an individual.
the school system eventually took up where Dr. Spock had left off, as Validating Authority for my mother’s efforts to raise an acceptable (and preferably slightly above average) child. the school system was generally kind to me, because i had been raised with literacies it appreciated. and when the school system was done with me and had convocated my Honours-achieving hind end out its doors – early, yet again, as i graduated high school at 17 and had completed two separate bachelor’s degrees at 22 – i assume my mother believed some other benign system of authority, some Dr. Spock of the professional world, closed to her but in her mind a meritocracy clearly waiting to welcome me with open arms, would step in to take me up on my promise, my potential.
for a brief period, she even stopped talking about my potty training achievements and instead offered up my degrees as social appetizers at every occasion, even having them framed at her own expense and hung in her apartment.
but i did not arrive. i worked hard, but had no idea how to leverage the skills i had into opportunity. i didn’t even understand the concept.
when i finished school, i knew i’d walked early and toilet-trained early, but other than that my personal canvas of self-description was filled only with my own adolescent graffiti. ”i like to imagine myself as David Bowie’s personal concubine” is not a self-description one could go far with in the depressed Canadian economy of the early-90’s recession. and so i floated, town-to-town, up and down the dial, always working, trying every path. and i came to find myself in my late-ish thirties, writing about tutus and wondering what i want to do with the rest of my life.
and my mother, who loves me and whose ambitions for me only ever extended so far as me being acceptable to Authority – a line i’ve been falling on and off of like a wagon since junior high – has gradually settled into an apparently contented relationship with my achievements, wherein her acquaintances relate stories of their adult childrens’ law practices and government pensions and sojourns with Doctors without Borders, and mom chirps “Bonnie’s always been gifted with words. Do you know she could speak in full sentences by the time she was twenty-two months? Of course, she walked at nine months…she was always bright…and she was dry through the night by the time she turned two. Children these days seem to be in diapers right until kindergarten…have you noticed…?”
…and then all the maters cluck in unison, and magically, any discussion of my current skill set disappears entirely from view.
which i’m starting to see the benefit in.
if my mother wants to bask in the glow of my prodigious tippy-toeing across a carpet during the Trudeau heyday (or Nixon’s China visit, for you south-of-the-border readers)…well, that’s her prerogative. it keeps my potential open. and i’m beginning to think maybe there’s potential in being a late-bloomer, after all.
so as Josephine closes in on nine months happily flat on her puffy diapered ass, i say dandy. pass the cookies. take your time, kiddo.
what was your sense of your own potential, growing up? where did it come from? and do you think you’ve fulfilled it, in any way?




June 3rd, 2009 at 3:25 pm
For me, it was really high school and early college. I aced the SATs, got an almost perfect score. I was in the top ten in college, and the only one in the top ten with a job. Teachers talked frequently of my potential, in acting, in singing.
I traveled when young, like you (a year in Australia, a year in England.) I acted professionally, for little money. I taught sustainability to children, for even less. Now I have hundreds of thousands of dollars in student loans from my (and my husband’s) bachelors and masters degrees, and the only way to pay it back is – well, it’s not through professional acting. I’m about to turn 31, and starting law school in the fall, driven there by bills that squawk to be paid and a potential that screams to be “realized,” whatever that means. And questioning, always questioning, how I became that woman in her thirties who still mumbles her SAT score to herself as a judge of her worth.
This caught me on a bad day.
June 3rd, 2009 at 3:35 pm
I was under the impression I might be a chess prodigy until I figured out at about 9 that maybe my dad was letting me win to ‘poitively reinforce’ learning how to play. Still bugs me, that.
June 3rd, 2009 at 3:48 pm
My parents have never had a nice thing to say about me as a baby or small child (and precious little after that), so I’m just a wee bit envious. But just a bit.
And then I got stuck in the gifted program. Mixed blessing. The education was great, certainly better than if I’d stayed in the advanced. But do you have any idea how many of my former classmates are coasting through their lives, waiting for the world to deliver their super-special extra-fabulous Career to them on a silver platter on account of their excess gray matter? Too many. An early blessing of that sort (especially when it’s couched in language of innate abilities), I think, can teach a kid not to work. And that’s bad. It took me a long, long, long time to figure out that even if I was smart I was still going to have to work my ass off if I wanted to be a writer.
And I think fulfilling one’s potential is a moving target, always. How do you know whether or not you’ll fulfill your potential until the game’s done, anyway? Your values change, your priorities change, so of course your goals change too.
Did you ever read Gladwell’s article on late bloomers? http://www.gladwell.com/2008/2008_10_20_a_latebloomers.html
June 3rd, 2009 at 4:24 pm
My *potential* was always outstanding – if I had just worked a little harder. I was good, but not great. B’s were fine, except I *could* have gotten A’s (since I did all those other times) if I’d worked a little harder – or at least so I was told. So I tried to work harder, and I stressed, and I didn’t enjoy life as much as I could have.
I did eventually go to grad school – paid for by my fortune 500 company employment. And you know what? I worked my butt off because I wanted to. I got a 4.0, Dean’s honors, the whole shebang. And it felt great! Because I DID IT! I worked the system and I won!
But now I’m a mom and a waitress (with a 4.0 MBA from a reputable school!), so I’m not sure there was a point to it all, except it STILL makes ME feel good to know that I COULD do it. And I will always have that as a point of pride.
I’ve been struggling with the conveyor belt of expectations for years. Good grades meant good college meant good job. Except it didn’t, because you CAN have it all, but not all at the same time. I distinctly remember the moment in college when I realized that the high power law career was NOT going to jive with the stay-at-home mom gig and I was going to have to choose.
So many choices, life paths, unexpected twists and turns. So little time. So muddy the future. And, I hope, so much potential ahead of me. I will NOT fall into the trap of feeling like where I am now will define forever who I am or who I can be.
June 3rd, 2009 at 10:30 pm
All I wanted to be, growing up, was a writer and a good mother. I’ve done that last one (I think) and I feel comfortable that I can do the first one. I think.
Seriously, though? Since I was… oh… 11 or so, people have been telling me that I was a good writer. So there was this sense going into my 20s that I would RIGHT OFF THE BAT be a published author with novels under my belt and when that did not happen I really felt that I’d let everyone down. This sense of having missed some magical sweet spot – or having missed, at least, the opportunity to be the enfant terrible of Canadian literature haunted me for ages.
And then I got over it.
June 3rd, 2009 at 10:34 pm
I could walk at nine months. My husband couldn’t walk until 18 months. Now, I can barely walk and am dependent on orthotics; my husband can run a 3 hour marathon in his 40s. Feh.
This comparison is my life writ small. I think I peaked in my 20s and it was a minor peak at that. I look at MadDad and he just keeps getting better–in his thinking, his craft, his everything. Why? I dunno but it’s been coming along since long before we became breeders.
I think I’ve become content with my mediocrity. I wish I were better in my career and I wish I could still will my brain into complex thought patterns but I can live with who I am and how I get by in the world.
It would also be nice to have a small slice of ambition too but I’ll settle for generic happiness instead.
June 4th, 2009 at 12:13 am
you know, it’s funny. I don’t remember much before I was 16. But I remember very clearly, my dad saying “I don’t worry about you, you’ll always make ends meet”.
Not, you’ll soar or succeed or be happy. You’ll always survive. Weird, right?
June 4th, 2009 at 12:29 am
Some eerie parallels with my life there, and I don’t think that for all my trumpeted “language skills” – which in any case seem to have abandoned me now – I could have expressed them a fraction as well as you do.
I’m new here, I think I will be sticking around.
June 4th, 2009 at 1:08 am
you made a WKRP reference. I say you’ve lived up to that potential.
June 4th, 2009 at 1:27 am
yes, I think we both have lived up to our potential–because internal potential is more important than external. I would rather be a kind, generous, well educated busboy (or sahm) than a pain in the arse to all around me with my very own widget factory and a thousand employees.
June 4th, 2009 at 1:32 am
(It’s those times when I am a pain in the arse to all around me while sitting at home not contributing to the world economy that make me go d’oh!)
June 4th, 2009 at 2:28 am
Your post goes hand in hand with the post I put up today. Although yours is more literate and less dramatic. And yours includes a nod to WKRP. Awesome.
Now if you will excuse me. I’ve got to do my kegels.
June 4th, 2009 at 7:50 am
I was considered gifted from a very early age. I had extra classes starting in grade primary because they didn’t want me getting bored with the regular material. School administrators tried to skip me a grade more than once (mom always resisted, bless her).
All through elementary school, and into junior high, I was held apart from my peers and made to feel different. As a result I was teased and bullied to an excessive degree; in junior high it got worse. It wasn’t until high school that I started feeling at least partly comfortable with being a “smart kid”.
I can never shake the nagging feeling that I should have done more… more schooling, in particular. I think my early branding as super-bright blighted my potential, because I am so completely terrified of failing or being caught out in a mistake that I often don’t take risks – so I miss out on opportunities.
Sorry for the essay, you hit a nerve (again. Stop doing that).
June 4th, 2009 at 10:29 am
Ah, good to know I’m not the only one spoiled with potential.
My strongest memory of this is when I was getting really, really desperate to figure out what to study at university. I asked my Dad (who was also my employer) what he thought I would be good at, and what I should probably avoid.
His response was that I really had the capacity to do anything, anything at all (and why). I’m sure he meant that to be reassuring and inspiring and door-opening for me, but I just felt so overwhelmed. Especially because just about everything appealed to me, too. *sigh* Now? I’m on my freaking fifth university qualification. A little guidance early on would have saved a whole lot of time.
When I think of that conversation I wonder what equivalent ‘helpful’ thing I’m going to do for/to my kids that totally backfires.
June 4th, 2009 at 10:38 am
You ask my husband, (any husband really) since he has a ring side seat on the mother/daughter relationship, and you’ll get a slightly different story. But, a few years back I had to stop trying to be everything I thought my mother wanted me to be. Because of course I really had no idea what that was and whatever it was I couldn’t do it.
Begin the second revolution between daughter and mother. (the first occured at 15 and lasted 3 horrible bloody years) This one was short lived and quite civilized. We told each other off, cursed, drank wine, learned a few things and moved on. I learned my mother wants nothing of me or for me but happiness. How to find it is the trick apparently, to which even she doesn’t have the answer. But that doesn’t stop her from the “you know what you should do…” comments.
My parents had expectations of me, but they weren’t what I thought they were. I was raised with the belief I could do anything. That’s what I was told. I wasn’t prepared to work like a dog for all of what I sought but, I guess that’s life.
I am happy with me. Where I am. My potential is still being filled. But I still crave to be truely exceptional at something now and then. To mine out that hidden talent that remains so elusive, and leave the world gasping.
June 4th, 2009 at 10:59 am
I’m the classic first-born in an alcoholic family, over-achiever, neurotic as the day is long. What I could do or be was not celebrated by my mother, just expected because she was so busy making sure her husband and son were sober enough not to end up in a cop car. She praised, quiet, pretty, so I became this loud chick who refuses to wear lipstick or comb her hair. I know that there are some women who see motherhood as stopping them from acheiving their potential in some ways. I get it. But, for me it is the opposite. Motherhood was the first time in my life when I could sincerely reflect without needing to know it from any outside source, and say that I’m so damn good at this. It brings me a certain peace that no other acheivement I’ve ever reached has given me. Who would have known that the hairy-arm pitted college feminist that I was would turn out to be Martha Stewartish, but with way cooler hair.
June 4th, 2009 at 1:48 pm
I always had the sense that I could do whatever the hell I wanted-my parents had firmly stored in my the message that my future was entirely up to what I want. There were expectations from my parents in terms of performance-I was expected to perform to MY potential, such as it was.
Aside from being told I was reading at 2, I don’t know much else about milestones. It didn’t make me anything but a voracious reader, even now, but that was par for the course in our house. After everything fragmented, staying mostly together and not being too drunk/stoned in public was a goal.
Always knew I’d go to university. GOt there. Hated it. I had the impression that it would be this fabulous place people went to LEARN. I was so wrong it’s not even funny.
I’ve really just floated since then…sometimes that’s nice, sometimes it’s really bloody lonely.
June 4th, 2009 at 2:38 pm
Geez, Bonnie, it’s like you’re in my head. I did all the same stuff at the same times and my mom is still holding it all up as my crowning achievement. Well, except for the college degrees. We’re still stuck on spontaneous self-potty-training in my case.
Plus I haven’t even managed to produce my own kids, I just take care of other people’s…
June 4th, 2009 at 3:33 pm
I was always told, by parents and teachers, that I could do anything I wanted. At one point in college my art prof wanted me to major in art, my philosophy prof thought I should take up philosophy, and my math prof (bwahahaha) thought I should major in math.
After too much grad school, I’ve settled on and landed a degree that led to a job. I like my job, but it’s only a job so far. Somehow I thought I’d have more of a vocation, a calling, a surety about what I could give back to the world. So many of the (impractical) things I love to do have been so seriously back-burnered that I wonder if I’ll ever pick them up again. I wonder if I’ll still be any good at them if I do.
If you haven’t read it, this article from the New Yorker is encouraging: Late Bloomers
June 4th, 2009 at 7:58 pm
to Andrea & Erica…thanks for the Gladwell link. i am currently on page 4 of 6 and am wrapping the piece around myself like a comforting blankie, not even wanting to finish.
i WANT to be like Gladwell, dashing off smart commentary on the world, of course. but i am stewing in my perfectionism. learning. yeh, that’s the ticket.
June 4th, 2009 at 8:14 pm
oh dear. i got to page six. it appears that i am going to be one of them late-blooming geniuses, i’ll need a patron.
we are now open for applications. inquire within.
June 5th, 2009 at 4:23 am
These last two posts of yours have really touched me and I want to write reams in response, except I think I’m so tired my head might hit the keyboard. So I’ll just thank you instead. Thanks.
June 5th, 2009 at 10:14 am
I’ve always felt smart and capable…and been lazy. I was in the gifted program in elementary, which has always confirmed that I was intelligent, at least in terms of school, but it also told me that learning came easily to me and I didn’t have to work at it. I coasted through school mostly with A’s, some B’s (which I was always grounded for, except in math), but I never worked for any of it. Now that I’ve decided to become a doctor, I’m having to retrain myself. Yes, I’m intelligent, but so are the other people I’m competing against for a slot in medical school, so I better step it up. There’s no more coasting. Though, my early experiences do make me think I have the ability to pull this off, if I work at it.
June 5th, 2009 at 1:14 pm
Or a day job. These days, I think they do basically the same thing.
June 5th, 2009 at 2:08 pm
Yep. Told I was a genius very early on. It’s been the bane of my existence ever since. I’ve got nothing to show for it, nothing at all.
(And, it shouldn’t need to be noted, I am no genius.)
June 5th, 2009 at 7:43 pm
never REALLY believed in myself. Pretty much still there.
True story, on my 39th birthday just a few days ago, while my sister handed me a lovely present, I pooped myself. Oh yes I did.
Don’t you feel better?
June 5th, 2009 at 8:21 pm
dear woman in a window,
do i feel better? not really. more just terribly afraid of 39, now.
June 6th, 2009 at 12:01 am
Oh, man. I’m a big bundle of unrealized potential. I always feel like I could do amazing things if only I could…um…stick to something, perhaps? I was always really good at school. Pretty much in every subject. Which means that…I’m really good at being in school. Which is probably why I’ve spent so much time in school.
Crap. I just realized that I have all but 6 years of my 20 years of adult life as a student. And I took some classes during those 6 “non student” years.
June 7th, 2009 at 12:32 am
It sounds as though I am not the only one who feels “you have so much potential” isn’t really a compliment…
June 7th, 2009 at 4:45 am
Just have to say to Thordora that I had exactly the same experience with University, thought it would be a place to learn and was bitterly disapointed. 2nd time round I’m enjoying it, and, studying law, feeling like I’m beyond my potential sometimes. Always still comparining myself to my ever-so-articulate and knowledgeable younger sister. Try to tell myself that I’m just as smart as her, but if that’s the case how come Dad never wants to have intellectual debates with me instead of her?
June 7th, 2009 at 3:23 pm
I think all old people claim that their children walked and talked and potty trained early. According to my granmother, all of the children were walking by nine months (she has 5 children). They were also all potty trained by age 2. AMAZING!
June 10th, 2009 at 3:01 pm
My parents were always outwardly proud of me, my grades, my musical abilities, my general sense of humour and personality. But I never had the sense that but the world was my oyster! I could do anything! In fact, I was always very insecure about my abilities. Case in point: I loved writing, secretly yearned to be a writer, but thought my grasp of grammar was too weak to be a professional writer.
So I guess I’m really hitting my stride now, because I feel like I can do anything I set my mind to. Life experiences and, to a large extent, becoming a mother have buoyed my confidence up. Sadly, these same forces have seriously dragged my continence down.
June 12th, 2009 at 7:21 pm
I was always told that I could do anything if I would just “apply myself.” Finally, finishing my college years late, I realized that might not be entirely true. But all my life, I’ve had this underlying sense that I’ve wasted all that gorgeous potential I had.