Fri 12 Jun 2009
i would take the Northwest Passage
Posted by bon under pondering stuff
[29] Comments
a long time ago now, i went North. to teach.
i’d crossed the Arctic Circle once before, as a kid; the summer i was ten years old, i spent six weeks with my father in a landscape that looked like the moon to me – the sand and lichen and hardy little flowers of the tundra, dotted with patches of snow even in July. we caught fish. i had my first dark chocolate at the Hudson’s Bay Store. at 2 am in the midnight sun, i went outside – me who’d never been up past nine – with the other kids around town. i started grade six, because school starts in August up there. i was the only white kid in my class. there was a girl who was pregnant. the teacher was decapitated in a three-wheeler ATV accident a few weeks after i went home, back south, to my mother and a world i understood.
that six weeks was both the freest and loneliest i’d ever been.
thirteen years later i caught a plane the size of a sardine can and flew again up past the tree line, to a hamlet in the middle of the Northwest Passage.
i had a teaching license myself, this time around, and stayed away from ATVs. i taught the very first grade ten classes ever available in the community. the end of the residential schools, the long history of students being forced to travel far from home to be given what the dominant culture considered an education. nowhere near the end of their colonial legacy, of course. but i didn’t know that.
i thought education was an uncontested good.
one of my students was older than i was. at least 50% of them were parents, or pregnant. i taught To Kill a Mockingbird, brimful with naivete. i taught Midsummer Night’s Dream reinterpreted as Inuit legend. i taught a Canadian history curriculum that my students did not even exist in; a curriculum that rendered them absent, invisible, less than footnotes.
i did not understand why i was so angry.
something in me loved the North. the light, where the world tilts on its axis, flooded me whole.
the rest of me felt alien, Alice down the rabbit hole. it was culture shock. most human beings find it uncomfortable to be Other, to be constantly read as representatives of a foreign group rather than as an individual. i was not only white, teaching students who assumed i’d lived a Beverly Hills 90210 existence back at home, but a white teacher, part of a long history of imposed “education” implicitly aimed at colonizing the Inuit mind into a proper externally-determined subject.
i stayed two years. by the second year, i was no longer angry. but i was still uncomfortable. the job had made it impossible for me to ever see education as a neutral, straightforward process again.
it’s now twelve years since i left the North. some of the students i taught are dead now, lost to suicide and cancer and overall the lowest life expectancies in North America. many are grandparents. Nunavut has come to the Inuit, and brought with it not necessarily the self-determination hoped for, but a neo-colonial layer of bureaucracy that threatens – say a lot of Inuit voices – to stifle everything they aimed for.
and i have the chance to be involved with work there, again. research, ironically, on how the education system of which this research would be a part is perhaps incompatible with the traditional knowledge structures and ways of knowing of the people it has ostensibly tried to “help” for generations. research that would explore how the research construct itself privileges, once again, the belief systems of the dominant culture and contributes to making the Inuit “Other” even in their own eyes.
part of me chomps at the bit. theory is what i love, where my mind takes flight. and yet the prospect of this research makes me feel free and lonely like i did at ten, running wild in the midnight sun at two in the morning, wondering if i have any place in this at all, wondering if i can de-centre myself enough to ever really understand.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
i know the content of this post is pretty esoteric. but what i’m getting at is, i’m afraid of agreeing to stick my nose where i’m not sure it has any business being.
and at the same time i’m excited.
and i’m wondering, would YOU leap in?




June 12th, 2009 at 11:29 am
I think your greatest advantage in something like this is your awareness that YOU are other. You may not be capable of completely understanding but you might be able to help build a bridge toward a better understanding, although, I am not sure if a complete understanding will ever be possible.
(And I used understanding 3 times in one sentence. Aren’t I impressive?)
June 12th, 2009 at 11:32 am
I spent 3 months of the second grade as the only white child in a “school” in Alabama. I was other. My first conference papers in college were about cultural diversity. I was horrified to actually have native participants in the audience. It was no longer just theory, but people awaiting application. If you have the privilege of being invited into another world, or even the support as you’re pushed in, consider not only how it would affect you and the culture, but what you can learn and bring back to us, the ignorant.
June 12th, 2009 at 11:34 am
Oh Bon, what a wonderful opportunity….Incredible, really.
I can however see the reticence on your part and would probably feel the same… I guess the only constructive thing I would offer is that in order to break abusive cycles, one has to first seek to understand them. I believe our colonialist approaches to native communities smack, at the very least, of imperialism….and many many worse things.
It takes not only qualified but also mindful researchers to be able to examine how research constructs themselves impact the Inuit lifestyle, teaching paradigm and way of life….It seems, at least from an objective outsider view over here…that you are so PERFECTLY suited to examine this and that you will also examine it respectfully, objectively and, most importantly, subjectively…because you’ve had a chance to live along side of a group of people that not many researchers ever get to really touch.
LEAP
June 12th, 2009 at 11:37 am
THIS sounds like the kind of thing that I think life is all about.
If you are excited, unsure, and afraid, all at the same time – this is the best type of personal learning experience anyone could possibly have – GO FOR IT!
June 12th, 2009 at 12:04 pm
Maybe your childhood experiences were preparation for this very path. Count a 4th vote for GOING FOR IT!
June 12th, 2009 at 12:39 pm
Yeesh, and here it is a rainy Friday and I just wanted a chocolate bar, or something.
Yes, go for it. Let your past experiences guide you. Better you than some faceless bureaucrat who’s never spent time in the North, I’d say.
June 12th, 2009 at 12:40 pm
Wow! How exciting and terrifying all at once. Leap, my friend. You are so perfectly suited to this work, even in the very fact of your discomfort and ambivalence. Give it hell.
June 12th, 2009 at 1:15 pm
Bonnie… as you know, only those that have been there can know what it’s like. I completely understand your hesitancy and the underlying questioning your post above. My best friend in Naujaut was the same age as me (34 at the time) and he constantly lamented that he was not yet a Grandfather. I hadn’t had my first kid yet. Suicides, accidents, and yes, those god-awful cancers… great beauty but balanced by great pain… I will say this, if you do decide to do it, you’re probably the best one for the job. The North is a place where you act with your heart first. Your post shows that you already know that lesson well.
June 12th, 2009 at 2:15 pm
I just wonder how many people go in without the anger and the understanding of the wrongness. I’d rather have you, thoughtful and thinking than anyone else. As an anthropology grad, I remember being told that our whiteness can get us places the people we want to help can’t go, we were exhorted to use it to their benefit.
I say go for it.
June 12th, 2009 at 3:28 pm
wow, bon. so i’ve been following all your recent posts that talk in various ways about you reengaging with work – work environments, ambitions, personalities, dreams. it just seems amazing and wonderful that this opportunity has come to you at this time.
i didn’t find your post esoteric at all. i understand your question. once we begin seeing through a certain lens, it’s difficult NOT to see how “helping” often becomes an imposition. but this would be a job where you get to use that lens all the time to try to do some good – whatever that might be.
i think if it were me i would try to base my decision on whether or not this opportunity fulfills me, excites me, intuitively feels right, feels like a response to a need or question of mine. i’m sure i don’t know if it would be right for the inuit. i would only be able to say if it were right for me.
June 12th, 2009 at 5:06 pm
Yup – Leap. Help. Learn.
June 12th, 2009 at 8:17 pm
to be clear, this is just a chance to write grants and do the textual grounding for this research, which would be first-person Inuit interrogation of education…but i’d be one of the key people framing it, hence the discomfort, the wondering.
it’s not actually the job i interviewed for, it’s another p/t gig i’m already doing. thanks very much for reflecting it all back to me.
i think it’s my own excitement that makes me wary…it’s been a long time since i had the chance to dive into this level of academic work and so part of me doesn’t trust the rest of my filters b/c i’m jonesing to play with the texts.
i just wrote that. on a Friday night. hopeless nerd.
June 12th, 2009 at 9:18 pm
I once lived alongside a reserve in northern ontario-my mother had been fascinated with native cultures, so I had been aware, but until I hit the reserve we ended up beside, I really didn’t get it.
It was different, and changing that, ME changing my perceptions, their perceptions, it was nearly impossible. Not to mention changing years of…I don’t have enough adjectives.
I wasn’t there long, but it changed how I viewed “others”, what otherness meant, how it held inside a person and either ate them alive or blossomed. Ultimately, it was sad, because life had been structured in a way they could nearly never escape from, and somehow, it WAS my fault.
That’s my way of saying jump with both feet. THe chance to make change, to fix such a terrible wrong rendered, to truly let that culture breathe….what’s there to say no to?
June 12th, 2009 at 10:09 pm
Yeah, I think I would leap in.
June 12th, 2009 at 10:58 pm
Do it. Do it. Doit. doitdoitdoitdoitdoit.
Er, what I mention to say is, you should follow your heart of course.
(But oh, my.)
June 12th, 2009 at 11:45 pm
Would I leap in? I’m more of one to carefully dip a toe in and then think about it for a long time. Should you leap in? I think it would be a great opportunity. The sensitivity you bring to the task and your awareness of the biases bult in to the system strike me as invaluable.
June 13th, 2009 at 12:36 am
Hmm – I’d think about it, because it takes a lot to get me to move, but I think you’re going to. And I hope it goes well for you
June 13th, 2009 at 12:47 am
When I was working on my masters, my anger was directed at my classmates and professors who felt that 12 hours in a place was sufficient to make recommendations about the future development of the community. I actually shouted at the class and stormed out wanting to try to make them understand that, for some members of that community, the recommendations would be considered a map to the future not the whims of some graduate students.
From this experience came my thesis which explored urban bias in rural planning in Canada. I think you have made the first steps by understanding your previous experiences. Quite a lot of research has been done about urban bias in healthcare and education in developing countries, maybe that can be a source for you.
In short, GO FOR IT!
June 13th, 2009 at 12:57 am
I’d probably leap. I do a lot of things that I’m kind of uncomfortable with, due to similar reasons, but I do them anyways, because I just can’t not. I rationalize it with the belief that being uncomfortable and aware makes it ok.
June 13th, 2009 at 1:09 am
Just watching, wishing you the best.
June 13th, 2009 at 7:59 am
Go.
June 13th, 2009 at 1:39 pm
If I had your experience, knowledge and complete awareness of not knowing everything, then, yes, jump I would. If for no other reason than concern that another – without that awareness – would completely and truly stuff it up, with nary a care.
June 13th, 2009 at 4:30 pm
Nope, I’m much too timid…but you? I can see you satisfied by jumping in.
My dad worked on the North Slope for my entire childhood. 3 weeks on, 3 weeks off. There’s a beach named for me up there, but I doubt it gets used much. LOL. That is wholly unrelated to this post, but everything way up north reminds me of him.
June 13th, 2009 at 6:06 pm
yes, yes, YES!
(apologies to James Joyce.)
June 13th, 2009 at 9:46 pm
Nothing esoteric here. I get it. I so get it. And I would argue with myself over it but in the end, I would leap, because if not me then someone else and I would at least have the faith that I would care.
Holy hell, you’ve a wonderful past. Let it be as wonderful a future.
June 13th, 2009 at 11:59 pm
Yes, I would. Life in hindsight is something else, isn’t it? Your life now if fully of experience, a loving partner, and two awesome kiddos, not to mention everything else. At the end of the day, you have that all to come home to. You are lucky. But with the insight you gained while living and teaching there, you could provide some awesome insight into the info they seem to need. Seriously, that would be so cool.
. I love this story about your past.
June 15th, 2009 at 2:58 am
I’m glad you clarified this wasn’t the job you called ‘limited in scope’. But still I will disclose my hesitance to leap.
A lot has happened in research and communities in the last 5 years, the last 10. And, it is hard to go ‘back there’. I rode on the vapour trails of bright and giving BC anthropologists low back in the dark ages of ’02. When looking to do that again this year… I walked. I couldn’t go home again.
A lot has changed. Needs to change. Is changing and I don’t have the brain for it anymore. Can’t do the cartwheels. But if anyone would and could.. sounds like you.
Good luck.
June 15th, 2009 at 11:14 am
there is going to be someone white sticking in a nose. best for it to be you because you will understand that you have no business…
June 20th, 2009 at 5:16 am
Hmm. I have lurked for a year but must respond to this question, it’s a good one.. I have been in a similar situation, an outsider, doing ‘community based research’, with Aboriginal participants.
I think my attempt at honest reflexive inquiry, part of learning how to decolonize myself, has had a positive impact.. on myself and a few I can count as colleagues. But do be careful, taking a boatload of white guilt up there with you sets you up to be abused. (by saying that I by no means intend to downplay our culpability or responsibility as a nation..) Frantz Fanon said that the dream of the oppressed is to become the oppressor. Those in deep pain are looking for a willing subject for their rage.
My experience was, some people recognized my effort to learn and find a bridge of understanding, and would look me in the eyes and trust my intentions. Others saw my inquiries as a threat to their position and attacked me with astonishing force. They understandably protected whatever capital they had gathered. It took me a long time to understand that most participants in any power system are interested in keeping it fixed. No matter if they appear to an outsider to be in a less powerful position. They have learned how to work within and benefit from the structure that exists, and don’t want to jeopardize that.
This kind of research can be a minefield — and the biggest challenge is to not perpetuate the cycle by returning pain for pain.
Still, I wouldn’t trade this knowledge gained by fire, about myself and the so-called ‘other’, for anything.
Have you seen Dale Turner’s This is Not a Peace Pipe? He argues that Aboriginal and non-Ab researchers need to collaborate in order to create just relationships. It’s worth a try, I think, despite the risks.