Tue 17 Nov 2009
the fire escape
Posted by bon under mama-baby stuff, pondering stuff, school stuff
[32] Comments
they were shorter than i remembered.
coming home to a three-year-old and a one-year-old is a like entering a fun-house mirror. in your mind, these tiny creatures who whip your sorry ass out of bed at ungodly hours and spend half their waking moments trying to boss you into oblivion just seem…taller, somehow. they are large in spirit.
until you burst through the gate at the airport and the impossibly tiny boy who is your big kid hurtles in your arms laughing and you realize his little body is barely heavier than a suitcase.
and then, home finally, you come through the door and tiny legs run thump thump thump to meet you and your body sweeps up its baby like a missing piece and there are tears in your eyes.
you don’t know whether it’s going to be good to get home until you get there.
it was. and i was relieved to find it so.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
seventeen years ago, i sat on a back fire escape in Montreal on an October night, weeping into a boyfriend’s arms. we were scheduled to leave the next morning, head back to the tiny college town that had been our stage and our womb for 3+ years. Magic Johnson had just announced he had AIDS. the boyfriend’s father had just announced he had diabetes.
neither were the source of my misery, only the flavours that separate that trip from the others in the cloudy, grotty puddle of memory.
i just didn’t want to go back.
i don’t think it was the seedy charm of the big city, or even the pressures of the daily grind as a senior honours bulimic with a manic-depressive roommate and no clue of what to do with myself after college.
it was me. i just didn’t want to go back to the confusion of being me at nearly 21. a Thanksgiving weekend in somebody else’s parents’ apartment was a vast relief. i ate pumpkin pie made with Splenda and said thank you and washed up the dishes and everything was nice and externalized and tidy and i felt validated and safe.
the kid i was that fall hadn’t felt particularly safe in a long time. and the year that was about to follow would knock everything out at the knees – my first real breakup, my first betrayal, a reckoning, the scattering of my circle to the wind post-graduation. and in the midst of it all, my grandmother’s house, the one she’d been born in, the one that’d been my only constant home in a childhood of apartments, sold and lost as the slow decay began. i didn’t know any of that out on that fire escape, watching the city, but i think maybe i sensed it, smelled the shift on the air. or maybe i simply knew i didn’t have a clue how to handle the inevitable closures that accompany one’s last year of anything.
i was scared shitless. i grew up risk averse and yet reckless, a combination not so uncommon among those who have little to lose in status and material goods. i had no long-term planning skills, no sense of agency to choose next steps or any belief that the choices i made would actually impact anything much. i felt like i was supposed to be figuring something out, but i couldn’t, for the life of me, sort out what it was.
i remember thinking, if we could just stay here, skip all the next steps, the part i don’t know how to do. get to the next chapter, whatever that is.
i found myself thinking the exact same thing last week. different fall evening in Montreal. no fire escape, no tears this time. and the illusions of safety centered around leaving the city rather than staying. homecoming as escape from having to get to the next chapter somehow.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
i spent our five days in Montreal last week wondering if we could live there, if i could drag a whole family of four to the city and have us stay afloat, financially and emotionally.
while we were there, i met with a woman who analyses writing and discourse and rhetoric for a living. she’s kind, funny, disarming. open. and she stated flat-out that she’s willing to work with me on my long-neglected Ph.D, be a mentor and supervisor for my dissertation. i’d need to commit to two years in the city.
they have little Portuguese pastries there, and a Czech bar. they also have rents three times our mortgage. there are museums, places other than MacDonald’s to take kids to play on a rainy Saturday. there are waiting lists a mile long for childcare, and apparently you have to know where you’re going to be living to even get on them. there would be no Nannie there…my mom gets traveller’s cheques just to leave PEI. which is an occasion reported on the local news.
i meet tomorrow with a representative from the fledgling Ph.D program here. two faculty members here, whom i respect and am deeply fond of and whom i’ve worked with for a few years now have also said yes, they’d take me on. if the program will accept me, because they’re only taking four students next year. four is a teensy little number. a number so small it hurts the ego to attempt it, because Everyone Will Know. (that and the blogging about it. that always helps with the privacy).
not much funding for first year in either program, so far as i can tell. my mouth gets dry as cotton when i look at the proposals, the grant applications.
it’s heady and daunting both, an eight-ball of self-doubt and projected glory. part of me tells myself it makes sense, either way – that investing in my education, after my childbearing hiatus, is the kind of long-term planning i’m still struggling to master. part of me wants to flatten myself to the ground like a hedgehog and stay stock-still until i can just wake up in the next chapter.
i need to do something about that instinct.
but i have these little kids. they were born in the aftermath of upheaval and sorrow like i hope never to know again. and since they came along, grounding me, making me happy to come home even from the glamour of a hotel room with cable, change scares the shit out of me even more than before.
halp. what would Jesus do? what would you do? i know people move to big cities all the time, even without much capital and with kids. but lord above, this all has me nervous, people. even staying. just the risk of putting it out there, applying, courting the possible no. and the possible yes.
talk me down off the fire escape after all these years, friends. tell me how to think about it all in a way that doesn’t hurt my head quite so much?




November 17th, 2009 at 11:25 pm
your family — you, dave, and the kids — can be a family anywhere. your kids are still young enough to be flexible about moving. and you and dave sure seem like city types to me.
i say go for it.
November 17th, 2009 at 11:29 pm
do it before the kids will care, before BFFs and soccer teams and school….
it is ok to be scared. but don’t go until i can come visit you on PEI! ;-p
November 17th, 2009 at 11:30 pm
I think you should first meet with the representatives and learn a little more, then come back to us. Is this something that can only be done in Montreal?
November 17th, 2009 at 11:35 pm
Hm. Do what feels right, whole-picture wise. Is finishing the PhD scary enough that you don’t need the extra terror of a family move, and away from support structures already in place? Or is the city a draw for more than a visit?
You’re smart, hon. And you’re mature and motivated and what with the Internets and all, in the end, it may not really matter where you do the PhD–it may be what you do the PhD, the conferences you go to, the contacts you make for yourself, the quality and promotion of your own intellectual labour.
I’m a homebody myself, -ish, so whatever influence that has over me, take with a grain of salt. But it seems to me your life has been spent on the run, and headlong, and transient. Maybe staying put might be the thing. Maybe.
November 18th, 2009 at 12:05 am
My life is such a clusterfuck right now I can barely tell myself what to do. But I have a hunch that what your heart is telling you? THAT is the right option.
I sometimes think we become a little TOO cautious with our child attached selves, and forget that living, and experience mean something to.
But then I remember I’ve lost both job and marriage this year, and know I’m in no position to offer any guidance.
Boy, that was real helpful huh? :P
November 18th, 2009 at 12:23 am
This may be of no help to you whatsoever, but my unscientific yet highly reliable method for deciding these sorts of things often ends up being something like:
- work out ALL the pros & cons (usually in my head, but when I actually bother to write it down on paper it does help)
- vacillate for a while, especially based on who I’m talking to and what pitch they have, while noting inner tugs to see if I’m partially reluctant or agreeing relatively easily
- finally (due to inner tugs) realise what the most significant pros & cons are & then work on how I can address cons
- get someone else, perhaps a coin, to make the decision for me, which then makes me realise if I’m TRULY okay with that decision or REALLY want the other option
- make final decision
- run with it
Whatever you choose you will miss out on certain things, but you will also be fine.
November 18th, 2009 at 1:04 am
Why do you want the Ph.D? Is it something that feels incomplete, and you will feel great personal satisfaction in achieving the goal? Or does it enable you to get the job of your dreams? Either of those (and many others) are good reasons, and perhaps examining the “why” behind the goal will help you balance whether the trade-offs are worth it.
November 18th, 2009 at 1:35 am
i think you already know in your heart what feels right…i would trust that, bon. trust yourself.
for me, it would be personally better if i had much more family support while these littles are so small (away from here). *but professionally* the program i am in here is far superior to the one that would be in the smaller town where the family is (so consider strongly the writing process and who your readers will be- for your topic- does it matter where you write for?) and we’ve found a wonderful sitter and i love that my kids are being raised in the same city i was- they know diversity as normal, not something to be taught. and we plan on moving back someday, maybe.
and you know what? you can always change your plan if it doesn’t work out. from someone who is languishing away at her dissertation in a big city with two little ones and is financing the whole damn thing on her own dime, i tell you, girl, nothing is permanent. you can try anything and if it works that is great and if it doesn’t it was a part of the journey to the next place.
this isn’t helpful at all and i’m sorry. best to you tomorrow!
November 18th, 2009 at 8:10 am
I’m a homebody, like Mimi, so take that into account. If I could do the PhD in my own place, with the family supports and the childcare and the not-uprooting, I would. I have a friend who admits that every three or four years she starts getting the urge to change cities, change houses, change jobs, because that’s what she’s always done… except that this time around she has a not-quite-two year old and there is no reason to move or change other than the habit of wanderlust.
GAWD I hate offering assvice, even when it’s asked for – I sound presumptous, even to myself. Just try this: imagine that you have already applied for the PEI program, and been accepted. Do you feel relieved, or disappointed? That will be your answer, right there. The rest is details.
Good luck. And hey, congratulations on deciding to go for it, wherever you end up. That’s a major decision, and I’m proud of you.
November 18th, 2009 at 9:47 am
I’ll go ahead and tell you what we just did, and how we feel about it, and you can see if that helps.
A few months ago we were living in North Carolina, parents of a toddler. The husband was finishing his PhD, job searching fruitlessly in this crap economy. I was in a job that I had to either leave or sue (won’t digress on that, just know that it was a horrid situation. I never actually contemplated suicide, but if I was still there now . . . I think I might have.) I applied to law schools, almost on a whim. I Got into one in New Orleans, a city to which we have no connections. A city 9 hours from either of our parents.
We went. In the worst economy imaginable, when my husband still can’t find a job, I left a (horrid, but paying) job so we could both be grad students, living in a much more expensive place. We sold everything – house, cars. We borrowed a little. We are happy. It is working out. My sister in law calls it (still) a leap of faith, but it was one we had to make. I am very, very glad we did it. I’m exhausted, and we’re poor, and we may each start bagging groceries or something for a little extra money. But we were in an untenable situation, and we leapt into a similarly untenable situation that is ten times better because it is full of hope.
Also, I love city life. I ride my bike everywhere. I don’t miss the suburban house we owned. Our city apartment (actually bigger than the house!) is great.
Maybe that helps, maybe not. How unhappy are you now? For us, it was worth the risk.
November 18th, 2009 at 11:08 am
We must keep trying, no? Just keep swallowing the fear until that time you realize you are on the other side.
November 18th, 2009 at 11:34 am
Another blogger once wrote me a comment when I was similarly analyizing myself into the ground. She said not to make a decision from a place of fear, only love. We all fear the unknown, the uncertain. But if you remove all the fear (of failing, of financial issues, etc.) from the equation, the answer becomes obvious. Well it did for me anyway. Hopefully it does for you. Then there’s always what my mom would say – things work out the way they are supposed to.
November 18th, 2009 at 12:57 pm
I’m going to be totally reductive about this: so, the options you’re considering are (a) do a PhD in The Big City or (b) do a PhD Where You Are Now.
In some ways, I don’t think the place matters all that much (easy for me to say). But what are the post-PhD options? Will you be able to get a job doing something you like? Will you have to move to get a job? I ask because I know many (not all, but far too many) people who went into PhD programs expecting something very different from what actually happened once the program was finished.
November 18th, 2009 at 1:44 pm
We did the opposite move–from city where we had a some family, to small town where we have no one. We haven’t regretted it, but the no family thing is haaaaard when you have very small kids.
But that’s just us. Your mileage may vary, you know? Good luck, because I know it’s hard, and I know there’s no way anyone can decide for you. I hate making big decisions. Hate.
November 18th, 2009 at 2:29 pm
I have the same feelings whenever I visit Vancouver. I see other young families there and I think “There – those people do it. How? I don’t know. But they have a house, and a car, and they don’t look any more divined than we are.”
And then the same hesitations, except with that much more distance. I have to keep reminding myself that it wouldn’t be the same as it was when we lived there before – we aren’t 25 anymore. We have kids now. Our lives would be much the same – hanging out at home and in the backyard, if we were lucky enough to have one – except we’d be struggling to make ends meet. It’s not like if we could manage a move to BC, we’d be skiing four times a week.
BUT. I’ve also been on Commercial Drive and seen young moms having coffee together at Little Nest, babies in mai teis, just enjoying being there.
I don’t think I’m helping. I’m just as haunted as you are. And I don’t know how you decide. That’s not even counting the career angst – I’m just talking about place.
Something’s going to occur that’s going to tip your scales. A conversation with a mentor, a conversation with your mother, the way the sun hits your back deck on an unseasonably warm November day. Who knows. But something will set your course. Just watch for it. xo
November 18th, 2009 at 3:22 pm
Well, you know my vote would be to split the difference and come to my town so that you could get an education away from your home institution but still be close to family. I realize that is not an option you are considering and that I am simply offering you my own pipe dream.
So my real advice? If you are getting a PhD, you need to think about life after a PhD. Will institutions be more likely to hire you if you come out of an established program than a fledgling program? No offense to UPEI, but the answer is “yes.” Will you be better equipped to return to the Maritimes if you leave them first? The answer once again is “yes”–given the way academic hiring decisions get made. Are you doing the PhD in order to get an academic job? If so, your better bet is Montreal. You may live hand to mouth for a while, but you will survive there and ultimately thrive. The kids are young enough to take it all in stride.
That’s the advice the practical me has to give.
That said, the me who is sad about living far from family would likely answer differently.
November 18th, 2009 at 4:07 pm
can you move to a suburb – to mitigate the CITY and its costs?
November 18th, 2009 at 9:46 pm
the city part of me, the one that lapped up new york and strolled around san francisco last week, that part sees the enchantment, the opportunity, the vibrancy that a city offers. black tights and high boots for a play date? why the hell not?
the other part, my settled into my hometown part, it sees our backyard, lush and green, the hills that spread behind our home free (for now) of people. the grandparents always ready and able to assume and dote on the kids and thinks, hell no!
our dream is an island off BC, sheep and a huge garden, possibly a winery, oh so many things that would not be the dry and dust that is here. it is a lovely dream but would likely come with a host of challenges. and it would have to happen by way of financial miracle. that is why we buy lottery tickets, you know.
helping much? probably not. but it sounds like the return to work is refreshing deeper desires, desires to stretch and learn and think. those things can happen anywhere. it might be just that they have to happen. we will have to watch and see.
and thanks for sweet comment, that boy slays me too.
November 19th, 2009 at 10:53 am
I think that it’s easy to take lightly how it will feel to move far away from family. Other places have their allure, but family has roots and once you move far away from them, it might be more wrenching than you might think.
And cities are REALLY expensive.
But I KNOW how you are feeling. Boy howdy, do I ever.
November 19th, 2009 at 11:57 am
Bon,
Why do you want the Ph.D.? Do you want to get an academic job on the tenure-track? Or is this more about personal fulfillment? If you are looking to reach a particular career goal with this Ph.D., you need to think very carefully about the job market, how best to achieve that career goal, and how much of a gamble you’re willing to take. Because as someone who has a Ph.D. in the semi-hard sciences (molecular cell biology) let me tell you that the academic job market is absolute crap for us science Ph.Ds, and there are a ton of bitter, disillusioned post-docs here who despair of ever being stably employed in the field for which we’ve spent 6, 7, 8, 9, or more years training.
Okay, I don’t want to bring you or anyone else here down. I just want you to be very clear-eyed and hard-edged in your thinking here. Talk to lots of people–not just the professors, but the recent alumni of these programs, the current grad students, and others in the field. Although I know you’ve been teaching a long time and are probably familiar with all these people =)
And about following dreams… I walked away from my field a few years ago and thought I’d never be back. If I look clearly at the odds, the economy, and the funding climate in my field, going back to academic research in my field is one of the stupidest things I could do (as my husband won’t quite come out and say). But you know what? I’m going back after all next year. I’ve had to make pragmatic compromises, and I also have to accept the high probability of failure. I AM giving my dreams one more shot–and I don’t want to tell ANYONE to give up their dreams–but you have to be very clear-eyed about it and the consequences.
Good luck. You’re an amazing writer and thinker, Bon.
November 19th, 2009 at 12:08 pm
Oh, I feel you here, as I watch my intended PhD defense date and graduation slip away into other semester. It is hard and stressful and you’re always DIFFERENT in that academic place when you’re studying with children. In the States at least it’s like straddling two worlds. Professors don’t know what to do with you — it doesn’t feel right to treat you with the careless disrespect of your typical “student.” And you have to do a billion more than any of those carefree tots… whiling away their weekends and complaining of workloads.
Advice? Well, maybe not so much. Only that the two things that have made every difference for me were a supportive spouse and the flexibility in everyone around me.
I wish you luck and inspiration on the choice. You are a gem to either program, any program, that gets you.
November 19th, 2009 at 3:43 pm
No real advice to give, but staying on the fire escape is a decision, too, and probably just as risky as anything else. I’m wishing you luck and courage and peace in your decision-making.
November 20th, 2009 at 2:26 am
I don’t have any advice. I can tell you my method of making life-changing decisions, though. What I do is, I figure out who I am most jealous of. Really! To put it more positively, I figure out whose life I’d most like to borrow for awhile — or what elements I’d like to borrow.
I wish you luck!
November 20th, 2009 at 4:24 am
Whoo. That’s a doozy. I often think of the comment of elderly people – that they regretted what they didn’t do; not so much the things they did. No family housing or university daycare??
November 20th, 2009 at 5:16 pm
My husband, two kids, aged almost 3 years and almost 9 months and I live in Vancouver. Both sets of families live on PEI. It’s a mixed blessing, being so far away. Mind you, both he and I have not lived on PEI with any longevity since 1989/90, so it’s a bit different. Pros: we’re far away from family politics; there’s no (good or bad) meddling from parents who use good old-fashioned 1970s Dr. Spock theories on children, and finally to be totally and utterly selfish, we do not have to succomb to guilt about having to attend compulsory Sunday dinners, as well as convincing certain family members at said dinners why we don’t believe in Christening our children. Cons of living far away for us: won’t know extended family as well as they would if they lived on PEI-actually that could be a pro in some instances. Oh, and no free babysitting-big con.
As trite as it sounds…follow your heart. Keep in mind,if you are really wanting to make the move, now’s the time to do it, before the kids get entrenched in school.
November 20th, 2009 at 8:55 pm
I’m in the “why phd?” camp. Does it make the job you really want to do possible? What is the job you really want to do? Where would you have to be to do that job once you got it? Would that job pay enough to keep living in the city?
The dreamy me says “Cool do it” to all of your options, but seems like now’s the time for a Rory Gilmore Pro/Con list. : )
Good luck!
(And Jesus would probably say go to the place with the most people where they don’t know you, throw yourself into your work, save them all or die trying. Then come back and do it again. ; P )
November 20th, 2009 at 9:26 pm
thanks, guys, for all the real advice, your stories of where you are and how that’s working and wins and losses, both sides. with every one i go, yes! oh wait! shit! there’s that…
the meeting with UPEI went really well, was really positive. and i just got back from the absolutely fabulous annual international potluck run by our International Students society. it was our little university at its best: students from all over leading a wicked evening of food and entertainment, some with their whole families there, lots of local students in the mix, our president and his partner enjoying the evening and dancing. reminded me that i don’t actually always have to travel for a little taste of the world.
that said, even though it’ll involve investing in two relatively different proposals, i think i’ll apply to both. i don’t want to close the door on either yet. and i have a few friends of friends in Montreal with little kids whom i need to touch base with, find out if the childcare situation really IS possible. that would make a huge difference.
why the Ph.D? partly b/c if i stay here, i’ll always be profoundly limited without it in terms of most of the things i want to do, and those for which i wouldn’t need it are very hard to come by (see my federal job shot last spring). partly b/c academia has always kinda felt like the place i’d end up, the natural place for me with my love of theory. i’ve worked in universities for 11 years now, doing other people’s grants, teaching sessionally. just feels like, hell, why not play on the A team?
i’m not giving up any great security to leap into this, either. i feel the need for a plan and this is the one i’m most likely to control… :)
November 20th, 2009 at 11:54 pm
we did the leap of faith. all the way across the country with nothing but love and the seat of our pants. No real $$, no jobs, no family. I do not look back, but for my mother. My daughter, born out here far from my dearest friends, my mother, my network, grew up with only visits from her beloved (& so good for her, for eachother) Grannie & then Grannie was gone. That is my only regret. Is it fair to share it with you? Certainly it would be better if we were having a long conversation. A glass of wine. Tea on the porch.
You are only talking about a finite time, and a manageable distance.
The onest truth is, I do not think you should listen to any one of us. But to your heart. It will guide you, it will. Kate is quite right about that. Gather the information, listen for the click. If it never comes, do the one that makes you feel happiest. Don’t think too much more than you feel.
Bon courage!! You’ll be just fine either way. You can write this: “and your body sweeps up its baby like a missing piece” –
have talent and smarts galore. And love.
Which is everything.
November 21st, 2009 at 12:40 am
Love your writing and have been following since I had a babe.
I went to McGill for undergrad. You will love it in Montreal and so will the kiddies!
November 21st, 2009 at 1:36 pm
I am so impressed that you even have a plan and know that you want something after these little life changers, the where feels like the easy part, except that I know full well it’s not.
November 24th, 2009 at 9:14 am
I’m glad you are consisting both options. The city is possible with kids and jobs etc. Obviously you get less of the big outdoors but you get other stuff. Do bypass suburbia though worst of all worlds.
November 24th, 2009 at 9:32 am
I’d be the last to offer any sort of well thought advice, I am just reminded of the quote:
“Opportunity may knock only once, but temptation leans on the doorbell.”
I guess you have to decide which is which.
Best to you, over the miles.