Sun 7 Feb 2010
snips and snails
Posted by bon under pondering stuff, relationship stuff
[25] Comments
here’s the truth of it, in all its ugliness: raising a boy is making me a better person. not a better parent, mind you. but a more rounded human being.
i didn’t know i needed reinvention. but turns out those beer ads from college were correct: what does not kill you makes you strong.
or at least, less of a bigot.
i blame SuperBowl XXVI for some of my former wayward and biased assumptions. in 1992, my birthday was the same weekend as the SuperBowl. i spent most of my supposed “party” perched on the corner of my boyfriend’s dumpster-dived couch choking on the acrid fumes of weed and spicy chicken wings for eight straight hours of joyous pregame- and game-centric celebration with a pack of 200 lb boys and ten 2-4s of beer. nobody – boyfriend included – said two words to me other than, “chips?”
what’s wrong with that, you ask? even in college, i didn’t like beer. or football. not even a little. and chips are nice and all, but they are not birthday cake.
somehow, i have been bitter about “manly” pursuits ever since.
on twitter last week, there was a brief flurry of discussion on moms of girls only vs. moms of boys only. it raised the question of whether boy moms and girl moms end up being different from each other, in spite of being otherwise similar in age, tastes, class, career, education, etc.
and the consensus seemed to be yeh, a little, overall.
and i can see it. or at least, i could see it in ME, had things gone a little differently.
(aside: those of us with children of both sexes were cruelly ostracized from this conversation. please note that we need enlightenment too, people! a little “are you a bi-mom?” quiz would help me know myself, please and thankyou. stage direction: end self-mockery of stereotype i am actually trying to explore.)
when i was a little girl, and lived in a mindscape constructed mostly of cast-off and stolen characters & scenarios from Victorian children’s literature, all hard-knock lives and depths of despair and pretty pinafores, the so-called world of boys seemed like a foreign land.
i tried, occasionally, to venture there. not so much in person: the boys i knew were relegated, in my egocentric universe, to occasional supporting roles of annoying little brother or know-it-all classmate. i did not know enough about dinosaurs or Star Wars to talk to them past first grade.
i thought of their world as a strange exotica populated by Spiderman cartoons, boring little metal cars that never went anywhere and Dukes of Hazzard pyjamas.
i created families in my doodle pads, large multi-generational family trees populated by imaginary people with extraordinary names. i killed off the parents ruthlessly, dull folk named George and Sandra and Ervin and Eunice, gave them dates of death and tidy tombstones. but their children, whom i frequently sent to orphanages dressed in middies and awkward lederhosen sewn from curtains a la Sound of Music? well, some of those children had to be boys. so i drew Jasons and Norberts and Antonys, and relegated them to the rat-infested basements of the asylums inhabited by their far more interesting sisters.
i didn’t really them see them, as a whole, as characters, worthy of empathy or inner lives. i mistook the stuff that didn’t interest me – the superheroes, the sports, the whole discourse of boyhood – as a sign that the entire gender were dismissable.
yeh, i liked a few of ‘em. but i treated boyfriends – particularly after that unfortunate SuperBowl birthday – as rare fossilized humans trapped in the amber of maleness, that most regrettable rock.
and i never imagined myself the mother of a boy. i wanted girls, absolutely. but beyond that, far more importantly, i thought that to be the mother of a boy was to be forever stuck at that SuperBowl party with nobody to say three words to and my nose permanently crinkled in bewildered distaste.
and that, i venture, is exactly how i’d feel today if i’d never had a boy.
mothers are, uh, female. meaning that that most of them were once female children. and a lot of the female children i knew back when i was myself a female child shared exactly the same opinion of boys that i did: ewww. admittedly, a lot of us later changed our tunes, at least regarding individual exceptions to the rule, but i suspect that for many the prejudice against male things and manly pursuits and so-called “boy stuff” remains. fair enough. i still don’t like football.
but i don’t get to perform my parenthood as a bastion against it, draw simple lines that exclude it and keep me and my offspring safely spared, relegated to our “girl things” and smugly superior in our remove. i don’t have to encourage my son to like it, but i do have to reign in my contempt, consider it, try to offer him literacies and considered views as he begins to negotiate the world of what boys are “supposed” to like.
i don’t know if it’ll ever do my kid any favours. but i think it may have actually made me a bigger person.
that, and the nachos i’ve just eaten writing this post through the SuperBowl.
25 Responses to “ snips and snails ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Trackback from cribchronicles (Bonnie Stewart)
February 7th, 2010 at 11:00 pm
‘kay now that THAT’s done, go read mah SuperBowl Bigot confession. and redemption. [link to post] -
Trackback from davecormier (dave cormier)
February 7th, 2010 at 11:08 pm
RT @cribchronicles: ‘kay now that THAT’s done, go read mah SuperBowl Bigot confession. and redemption. [link to post] -
Trackback from Rachel_Photo (Rachel Peters)
February 7th, 2010 at 11:32 pm
RT @cribchronicles: ‘kay now that THAT’s done, go read mah SuperBowl Bigot confession. and redemption. [link to post] …




February 7th, 2010 at 11:20 pm
I feel like I should comment b/c I started that tweetfest the other day. I think the reason I felt more comfortable with the moms at the boy’s birthday party than with the moms at the girl’s birthday party is that I am too, too accustomed to boys, what with having 3 brothers, a husband who is one of 4 boys and more nephews than I care to mention. My little domestic life these days often baffles me b/c it is so, uh, girlie. I happen to have a very girlie girl (hockey and other sports’ addictions aside) and I really can’t tell if I have fallen into feuling her or her me but the ponies and dolls and etc now threaten to become a mission in and of themselves. Being at that party, where M was the only girl and the other moms were so NOT mothers of girls, I breathed a sigh of what? Relief? Comfort? Familiarity? I dunno. But it was palpable.
February 7th, 2010 at 11:30 pm
Great Article. Your are an excellent writer
February 7th, 2010 at 11:40 pm
My two older brothers and father were very distant figures and I always considered my husband atypical – he’d always hang in the kitchen with the women while the men slumped on the couch in the living room – but in over a quarter of a century with the man, I can’t say I gained any insight into what makes him tick. But my son? He’s a redneck throwback with an interest in trucking and NASCAR that baffles. It’s not his interests that have taught me, it’s what co-exists within him that I never would have seen in a grown man – his goodness and sensitivity.
February 7th, 2010 at 11:56 pm
Oooh, I missed that twitter conversation. Wouldn’t it figure my first week back at work is when things get interesting.
I grew up as one of five sisters. I now have three little boys. I haven’t analyzed why I think so, but I do feel I am well suited to be a boy-mama. I’d love to have been witness to that conversation you mention – just to see what some of those differences were.
(I wrote through the Superbowl too…shhh!)
February 8th, 2010 at 6:50 am
The mothering aspect – I keep missing that that is your point. The biggest difference between my two kids is in how they deal with others: my daughter is high-strung and cunning; my son is straightforward. But they’re both painfully shy and clingy, so I don’t think play group and mother’s club would have been any easier if he’d come first.
February 8th, 2010 at 7:08 am
I only had sisters and only wanted girl children (which I got) but my best friend as a kid was a boy, and my youngest’s best friends were (pre-Switzerland) boys. And most of my post-parent friends have boy children. So. I’m confused?
February 8th, 2010 at 8:51 am
Nachos cross all gender barriers with their deliciousness.
The biggest thing I’ve had to adjust to with my boys is the physicality – whether it’s a tackle or a hug, everything is full contact, all the time. As a consequence, we’ve had more injuries than I’m strictly comfortable with, too.
Oh, and apparently the whole “farting is hilarious” thing? Comes attached to the Y-chromosome. Gack.
February 8th, 2010 at 9:59 am
I am a tomboy. I have 2 brothers. I have 2 boys. I’ve always liked boy stuff. Sports, bugs, climbing trees, throwing rocks. Anything you can do I can do better kind of thing, while growing up. I always viewed it as a bonus. I could have it both ways, like boy stuff and girl stuff, my brothers couldn’t do that. (without getting teased)
I like that for the most part, boys lack the drama of social crap that girls get wrapped up in. Because of that I think I’m better suited as a boy mom, since I would have no patience for it with a daughter.
February 8th, 2010 at 11:53 am
in the end, what i realize i missed until i HAD a boy was that being a “boy mom” isn’t necessarily being sentenced to a life in the purgatory of farts and nasty fighting toys. you have to negotiate some of that stuff – cultural expectations come with the territory – but i thought of it as being swallowed wholesale. and i thought i could NEVER live with that identity, never feel like myself within it.
truth is i don’t like princesses either. but i KNEW – because i AM female – that that didn’t have to be the be-all and end-all of girlhood. i genuinely had no clue about boyhood. and so i built walls around the possibility of boys as a result.
i think had i only had girls i would’ve been the sort of mother who made moms of boys FEEL that wall, without ever intending to be overtly discriminatory. but i fear my relief at not being one of them might have been palpable.
and that kinda shames me. so i am grateful for the accident of chromosomes that forced me to confront my own biases, is all. because i really didn’t know, until Finn and Oscar, that a person could love being the mother of a boy.
and i do.
February 8th, 2010 at 12:30 pm
damn. I think farts are awesome. Do I lose my girlclub membership and secret handshake?
(just messing Hannah)
I was terrified of boys, and got two amazing girls. BUT, if you were to list out Vivian’s interests on paper, and her behaviors, most people would likely assume she was a boy. She doesn’t do, or like, girl things. I find that now, she THINKS she needs to, like her sudden desire for a Barbie-but I don’t know if that’s genuine exploration or peer pressure.
Boys scared me, but now, I wish I had one, because I realized we are raising people, not boys or girls, men or women. Just people who hate peas.
February 8th, 2010 at 1:10 pm
Very good post. Having studied women’s studies, worked with women’s shelters as a volunteer and am see the world with a feminist lense all the time, I am so happy to have had a boy. He is still small (one year) but I feel he is making me so much more well rounded. Seeing the world from a white boy’s eyes in 2010 and beyond is going to be fascinating and I suspect it may shatter my preconceptions. Was very afraid of becoming a hockey mom and all that but cannot wait now. (Although of course I would have encouraged a girl to play hockey too!)
February 8th, 2010 at 1:48 pm
I had brothers, so boys were a known quantity. And they were SO known that it was GIRLS who were the mysterious unknown for me. I find my relationship with my son uncomplicated and easy and its my relationships with my daughter that are sort of murky and hardish.
February 8th, 2010 at 3:08 pm
Have experiences of being a girl make you afraid of raising a daughter? It did me. Thinking back to when I young, I don’t know how I would have handled me, as a parent.
I think I’m biased in the other direction.
February 8th, 2010 at 3:25 pm
I like what Hannah said about the physicality of boys. I have one of each and that’s what strikes me as the major difference between them — that, and their need to interact with others. (My daughter is always creating relationships between her stuffed dinosaurs, or between the dinosaurs in her drawings, or noticing the relationships between kids at school; whereas my son is all, Is there another person in the room?)
I’m a loner myself so I tend to relate better to boys. Before having children I was afraid I’d discriminate against my daughter — and sadly, I think I do. I am trying very hard to be more girl-like as regards relationships.
February 8th, 2010 at 4:51 pm
I had no brothers and never learned to talk to boys until I was twenty, so having Bub has been a huge revelation to me. What I’ve discovered is the innocence of boys, and it’s something I never expected, even as I watched them warily at the mall after the ultrasound that warned me of Bub’s gender. I saw rowdiness and bad behaviour of boys but it’s only now that I see their innocence.
February 8th, 2010 at 5:49 pm
Bonnie-I love how you described in your post about how you’d send (in your sketches) the boys to the basements. The whole boy-thing was foreign to me. Had one sister and never really dated until university, so males seemed foreign and weird to me. They still do, save for my husband, who really doesn’t fit into the stereotypical male mould. Though, he would have enjoyed watching the Superbowl, if there hadn’t have been child-related activities to trump the show…oops, I mean game.
I’ve a boy and a girl. The boy’s only 11 months old, so he’s still pretty young. I still do see differences b/n the two. The boy’s quite physical, and destructive, compared to what my daughter was like at the same age. He’s also a big flirt with women. My daughter could’ve cared less. Not sure if it’s a gender thing or birth-order thing, which makes them different. I was concerned when I found out # 2 was a boy during the 20 week ultrasound, that I wouldn’t know how to relate to him or know how to manage. I’ve learned, over the past 11 months that even though he’s of a gender I wasn’t totally familiar with (i.e.) no brothers nor lots of male friends at an early age, I do appreciate the differences my son and daughter have. I’m glad I have one of each!
February 8th, 2010 at 8:50 pm
It’s a parenting landmine sometimes… there are definitely different parenting skills at hand for each gender. Having 2 of each is showing me that there are so many differences, sometimes not even applicable to gender. Just to humanity, and personality. Tomboy daughters & sensitive, affectionate sons buck the system. But it is a good thing to experience both. To learn to parent better as you figure out what they *need.* Thoughtful read, Bon.
February 8th, 2010 at 11:42 pm
Hmmm. I have a Super Bowl gone wrong story I should share some day. It ends with a young, hormonal, still immature Mary telling a handful of people to F-off and then running to my boyfriend’s room to cry hysterically. (I’m still simultaneously embarrassed at my lack of self-control that day and pissed off at the insensitive jerks that provoked it.)
Anyway, for some reason, I wanted a boy. I could not even articulate at the time why. I had one brother who I was not close to and who was something of a bully. I had one sister with whom I shared an intense sibling rivalry. I cried with relief when my son was born.
And then I was a boy-mom for 8 years before crossing over to the other side. My friends laughed at me because I was so reluctant about to have a daughter. Pink and purple explosions and Barbies and all that jazz. Blech. It has turned out okay. She’s an atypical girlie-girl. We do pink, purple, Barbies, and Hannah Montana. But we also do farts and gutteral noises and horrible messes.
All of this is apparently just my excuse to talk about my own experience!
I do think it is good for us to experience the unexpected through our children. Our tendency to label people is challenged when our boys and girls either act within those stereotypes or refuse to.
It keeps us on our toes.
February 9th, 2010 at 4:43 pm
as the mother of a solo girl, i often look on at boys in amazement and wonder how i would deal.
as far as the superbowl goes, this year was the first that i ever really watched. And that was because of our beloved NOLA Saints. normally i avoid it like the plague
February 10th, 2010 at 11:54 pm
i find myself in a totally opposite place. i have 5 brothers (and only 2 sisters. only, haha). i know boy really really well. i always loved boys. i loved being their friend, i loved screaming alongside them at games (though i am not a sports fan) while drinking beer and sometimes i forget that i absolutely should not belch in public (did it at a coffee house much to tim’s chagrin).
i was terrified at the prospect of having twin daughters…felt like my stomach fell out from the bottom when the thought hit me that there could be two of them in there. and my utter relief when i heard it was boys, well, it makes me feel a little ashamed. because now i wonder what i will not be learning as i do not plan to mother again.
boys i know, always have. i am completely daunted by the idea of raising a girl. half the time i still feel like i am trying to figure out what it means to be one myself.
February 11th, 2010 at 10:35 pm
My sister has become the mother of boys (14 and
and her world and mine (with a 3 y/o) never gelled as much as I thought they would once I too became a parent: I’m horrified by her boys’ violences and smelliness, and my daughter’s hairdo requirements baffle her. It’s weird.
February 17th, 2010 at 10:50 pm
Bon! I lost you – it’s been months, I think, since I’ve read here. Just updating my Reader and added your blog. Good to read you
. I love my two boys. At least in this house, their drama is far less weighty than the 2.5 year old girl’s. Don’t get me wrong, she’s my third arm. But boy oh my I seem to jive with the boys’ way of handling emotions. Perhaps Moira is like looking in a mirror. I’m a huge talker and a pretty emotional person; raising that is hard. The boys fight it out and move right on, no grudges. I love that. Moira still brings up times she was ‘mad wif me’ two weeks ago, LOL.
As for a 4th child, we walked that road for almost two years after she was born. Hardest letting go I’ve ever done. But one day, the summer after she was two, I held another baby and promptly wished to return it to its mom. Very little maternal nurturing going on there, where five years ago I wished to hold any crying baby. I realized I had my plate happily full, and I just felt, finally, that I wanted to move forward with our life as a family of five rather than add on. Very glad we made that choice, as I tried to get PG again for two months and my heart wasn’t 100% into it – which also spoke volumes to me…good to be here again..