Tue 24 Aug 2010
through a glass darkly
Posted by bon under mama-baby stuff
[22] Comments
when you meet my kids, you will note – without fail – that they resemble their father. if you are like most people, you will offer a slightly sympathetic laugh, a nod that acknowledges the long months i spent carrying them only to have them pop out entirely HIS. i will nod back, smiling, helpless in the face of the truth.
the likeness is blatant, uncanny: in all the lines of their faces, the bones, the spacing of their eyes. it makes me prone to cracking snide remarks that i don’t have genes at all. or better, that i’m too stingy to share what god gave me, that i’ve hoarded my genetics all to myself. it is okay, my laugh will respond to yours. only my heart is in these children. that is all.
it’s a lie, though.
my children do look like little carbon copies of Dave and his extended family. Posey is a pint-sized Dave in a dress. Oscar and his father in open-mouthed laughter, heads together, remind me of mirrors reflecting into infinity. yes, in certain light, with my eyes squeezed nearly shut, i can project glimpses of my own ancestral clans over their laughing faces…a tilt of a nose that reminds me of my mother, a chin that seems squarely familiar. but overall, they’re Cormiers, Doucets, Guitards; Acadians through and through.
still. the older they get, the more i see myself reflected in them. not in their appearance, but their actions, inclinations, personalities and strengths and…oh especially…weaknesses.
children are a mirror for the flawed soul. and when you watch them struggle with the same self-defeating tendencies that have plagued you as far back as you can remember, you will sigh, and wish that it was true; that you really had hoarded your genes all to yourself.
***
personality isn’t inborn, i remember her saying, my first year psychology prof in the Child Development course, in some kind of disjointed prelude to Piaget. i was slouched in my seat, seventeen years old and away from home for the first time. something in the words perked up my bad-ass ears and i flew away for a moment, across the strait to my proper, earnest mother and i snorted.
a head turned and i blushed and ducked my own.
for years i had discarded, unassessed, most of the things my mother had told me. we were like magnets, the two of us in my adolescence, poles mostly turned apart and pushing. i felt caged and contemptuous: i denied her authority, rejected her range of knowledge and experience out of hand. too small, too fearful, too parochial.
even things neither of us understood, new things, processes, systems – i picked up faster and so shut her out. if the learning went awry and she dared try to step in, i was a study in impossibility. once, when my electric typewriter refused to load its correction ribbon properly the night before a high school essay was due, my mother had reached over the kitchen table to help and i’d shouted I’m doing it RIGHT! It’s just WRONG! until her hand snapped the dislocated piece into place and i seethed in humiliation.
all this, except in relation to one thing: the absent presence she unquestionably knew – or had once known – better than i. my father.
she didn’t say it often: she was careful not to label with negativity. but in moments of exasperation it slipped from her tongue, half-accusation, half-wonderment. You’re just like your father. and i’d peer into those words like they were tea leaves, scrying for belonging, for some meaningful reflection of the elusive inner self i longed to have identified for me, the one i wasn’t sure anybody could see.
my father had been gone since i was six months old. i had his chin, his smile, his nose, his temper, and apparently most of his undesirable qualities, the kind that make poor, beleaguered mamas want to rend their garments and gnash their teeth.
personality isn’t inborn, my ass, i muttered to that psych prof, slouched over my doodles and notes. you talk to my mother.
***
he is four, my son, my second-born and eldest all at once. and he reminds me daily he is his own self.
the old white laptop from 2005 has been handed down to him in the past year, windfall privilege of growing up in an over-technologized family. he is learning to use a paint program, doing his “work” onscreen like mommy and daddy. ouch, i say, to the chorus of silent condemnation in my head, the one that wonders if he shouldn’t be outside learning to catch. but he is fascinated. the beauty he creates fascinates me.
(his father built him a blog for these paintings; a small gallery, a room of his own. the artist happily fields comments.)
but the artist does not happily field the notion of being wrong.
i could pretend i do not know where he gets this. i could pretend i believe only in nurture, not nature; that my chipper soliloquies of mommy’s learning French and it’s SO FUN; mommy’s practicing her (wobbly-arsed) bike-riding and WOW! i like learning new things and mommy made a mistake and has to start all over and (grit teeth) GEE! i sure am learning a lot doing this a third time! make some ripple on the cosmic pool of his small self. maybe they will. maybe he will learn to recognize frustration far younger than i ever did, and name it and own it and master it with patience and self-regard.
in the meantime, on a Saturday afternoon while his sister naps he explores the new paint program. there is glee, mommy, hey! look at this! and the satisfying splat-splat-splat of squares of yellow landing on a red background. then growling. growling i’d never heard before, except maybe in the recesses of my own mind. growling like a furious, feral animal enraged beyond containment.
my son. four years old.
he must have inadvertently clicked on something he didn’t intend to. the program had shifted modes, so that backtracking was impossible. i said, looks like you have a little problem, huh? and then my hand – my stupid, stupid hand – reached out for the mouse. while my mouth – my stupid, stupid mouth – said maybe you clicked the wrong thing?
i rendered him, in one fell swoop, not just wrong but beyond capacity to solve his own problem.
his own hand swatted at mine like i was a mortal danger and he began to scream – SCREAM – that he had done it RIGHT and it was WRONG but he had done it RIGHT and ouch on the old ears, little man.
perfectionist much? need control much? need the world to make sense and make you feel you know everything much?
ouch, mirror mirror.
i picked up the laptop and shut it. we do not shout in our house, i said quietly. we do not hit. the computer is a privilege, and you will not be allowed to use it if you cannot learn to make mistakes and learn from your mistakes without screaming. what i wanted to do was to pull his small body into my arms and somehow scrub him free of all those heartbreaking tendencies to be his own worst enemy, to be so achingly, willfully blind to his own mistakes that all learning that doesn’t come easy is a torture better skipped.
i cannot.
but i can scrub myself. i am trying, in the late years before i turn forty and bloom into my middle years, to become someone better than nature and nurture happened to cobble together through happenstance and genes, someone who doesn’t make her mama want to rend her garments and gnash her teeth.
***
whether genes or learned behaviour, how do you see your own challenges reflected in your children?
22 Responses to “ through a glass darkly ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Trackback from BonStewart (Bonnie Stewart)
August 24th, 2010 at 9:48 pm
my boy, he’s just like me. ouch. [link to post]




August 24th, 2010 at 10:00 pm
Wow. You’re probably going to see them make the exact same mistakes that you did, and you will mostly be powerless to do anything to stop it, except hopefully be more wiser to the modern world than the last generation. Just remember that you ended up relatively normal, so they should, too.
August 24th, 2010 at 10:02 pm
Oh. I see myself in my children all the time. Sometimes it’s gratifying, sometimes not. It’s uncomfortable when I see them being JUST LIKE ME and becoming unhinged if something isn’t going quite right.
Of course, when I see my husband in my children, it’s alternately hilarious and maddening.
August 24th, 2010 at 10:11 pm
Yes. I have this so much with Zach. I wish he did not have the traits that have broken my heart for years.
August 24th, 2010 at 10:11 pm
I keep grilling 4 year old Lei for not listening to adults and respecting authority.
Mitch says, “Mo, you can’t get mad at her because SHE’S YOU.”
August 24th, 2010 at 10:15 pm
“Children are a mirror for the flawed soul.” Truer words were never blogged. Kids are RAW, so raw, in every sense.
How do I see my own challenges reflected back at me? How do I NOT see them? Silent fuming, nasty looks, passive-aggressive (or not so passive) retaliation, exasperation, stiff upper lips – did I fall into some time machine and end up as the parent of my younger self? It is truly eerie some days. And them my mother-in-law says, “That one? EXACTLY like her father!” and I look at my mother-in-law like she has two heads and shake mine.
Then there’s the other one – like the me I *wanted* to be inside at that age, but never was. All social butterfly, oozing charisma from every pore, could sell snow to Eskimos, EVERYONE knows her name – but with an adolescent insecurity beyond her 9 years of age and street smarts that scare the crap out of me. And yet: quick temper, perfectionist, won’t do it at all if she can’t do it right? Yep – that one’s mine, too.
I’d like to think they possess SOME of my good qualities – they are strong willed, champions of underdogs and animals, artistic (probably more than I ever was), kind-hearted, and achingly perceptive. Life is moving way too fast for me now – I’m ready to drag my feet a bit to slow the circles down.
Thursday they will go off to school and I will sit down for my yearly exercise of remembrance and contemplation, write them letters they don’t know I write and as yet have never seen, as I do every year on the first day of school. And I will try to impart some wisdom to their future selves. I hope someday they can decipher the words I write to them, coming as they do from the former young me and the old wise me at the same time.
Yesterday, a child came out to wander…
August 24th, 2010 at 10:24 pm
Yup. Isaac is me again – he sets so much store by things and when he isn’t perfect the first time, his frustration is epic. Legendary. It breaks my heart because I know the struggles he will have in years to come with his temper and his self-flagellation… I wish I could save him those struggles… I know that I can’t.
Watching him go through it has erased some hurts from my childhood, though – I always thought that if only my parents would say “X” perhaps I wouldn’t have melted down so often. Trying out “X” on my stubborn and wonderful firstborn has taught me that really it doesn’t matter what I or anyone else says; he needs to work it out on his own.
Still though, it’s tough. I hear you.
August 25th, 2010 at 10:40 am
hmm. i wonder if the reflection our kids offer of how our weak spots look from the outside and are experienced by others helps us (if we’re paying attention and WANT to be better) to mediate some of those behaviours in ourselves that we’ve tended to think of us as “just us”?
i know i may try to respond slightly differently the next time my computer craps out and Dave’s trying to help. :)
August 25th, 2010 at 12:21 pm
Everybody says that my son looks exactly like his father, and he does. But I see myself and my sister in his coloring, and in his eyes.
In character and personality he is exactly like me, only more so. And he seems to have gotten double doses of traits that my husband and I share. Like stubbornness, and a certain shyness, and the need to lecture people.
Other people tell me that he is very, very imaginative, and good with languages, art, and music too. It’s good that they remind me because those are things I take too much for granted.
It’s hard to see one’s child struggle with the same things that one still struggles with. I always hope that we’re giving them a head-start, that they can learn from our experience.
Also, he is like me but I’m not like my mother.
August 25th, 2010 at 1:30 pm
Oh.
Because I still (at three years past forty) find it hard to highlight my own positives, I see my negatives so clearly in my six year old. The impatience, the rolling of eyes, the frustration at not getting it right.
All her positives are her own. Her negatives are mine. I’m still a work in progress.
August 25th, 2010 at 3:41 pm
Well, my older kid (just turned four) get mad VERY easily. And then I get mad at him. And I realize how very close to the surface both of our mads are. Eek. When I was little, I got quickly trained to never ever express anger. Hmmmmm……
August 26th, 2010 at 8:40 am
Mosey, i think we’re all a work in progress. :) which is my way of saying i definitely am.
i do think attitudes towards life circumstances end up being learned, so…i may have a lot of perfectionist and control tendencies, but combined with my learned habit towards negative speech and an attitude that is just beginning to emerge from a learned lifetime of passivity…particularly delightful combo.
i’m trying. i hope Oscar and Josephine somehow register the trying, learn from the effort as much as the default.
August 26th, 2010 at 4:53 pm
Ah, Bon. Charlie is every bit my husband’s mini-me. They smile the same, they slouch the same, they have the same eyes. It’s almost eerie.
But in the quiet way he does things, I know he’s mine. He’s incredibly impatient and wants things done his own way. He likes order around him and always wants to please. He’s inquisitive beyond measure and can never learn enough.
…I know. Even when everyone points out how much he looks like his dad, he’s mine, too.
As for Oliver, people keep saying he looks like his dad, but I don’t see it. I think he’s a little more mine. We’ll wait to see who he becomes.
August 27th, 2010 at 2:54 am
Heh. He certainly does not like being wrong, and he’s very, very good at talking his way around it :) He’s a smart kid, he’ll pick it up.
As for my own flaws, there are far too many to list here (what’s the word count limit on these comment boxes?) But the important thing is that I know they’re there. Some of them I work on (my irritating tendency to convince myself that I can’t do something, for example), and some of them I’m okay with (my complete inability to put a dirty dish where it belongs).
Like the old t-shirt says, “Pobody’s Nerfect”.
The important thing is that I am aware of them, for the most part, and am trying to change the really harmful ones (my temper . . . oh, my temper . . . successfully held in for 12 years) while simultaneously lessening the impact of the purely irritating ones. The others, the ones that are just too much, or don’t bother me, I call them quirks, and consider them part of my massive charm :)
I am abrasive, sarcastic, and more than a little rude, by default. Nimue is picking up on the sarcasm, and she can be more condescending than a queen when she wants to be. I’m okay with this, though I do recognise it as a bad thing. If that’s the only bad personality trait she gets from me, I’ll consider it a success. And pray for the rest of the world. A sharp tongue on a face that pretty? Helen has nothing on what she could be.
The real problem is, she’s starting to pick up on my fears, as well. I try not to show them to her, but she sees them anyway. Kids always do. Not the big ones. The little ones. The irrational ones. The ones that sane people shouldn’t have. Clowns. Touching mirrors. Long hallways. That sort of thing. I have so many, I’m surprised I get out of bed most days (under the bed is a terror for me, that’s where Tsurumah lives, coiling into infinity. . . ).
So, some of them I’m alright with, others I’m not. But that’s what being a parent is about. We delude ourselves into thinking that we have full control over the child, but we don’t. They are their own person, and we just impress them more deeply than most other people do. We just have to be careful what side of us they get impressed with.
August 27th, 2010 at 3:19 pm
The one thing you could say to the teen-aged me that would make me hate you more than anything was that I was “so like my mother.” I am, in lots of ways. We look a lot alike. This used to make me want to scream.
Dot, so far, is a mix of both N and I. She smiles a smile much like my smile. Her sleeping face mimics her daddy’s. She can raise one eyebrow, though, which she gets from neither of us, and somehow I find that a hopeful and beautiful thing. She may have to bear some of my burdens, but she’ll bring something uniquely hers to the struggle, and maybe that will be the thing that tips the balance in her favor.
August 28th, 2010 at 1:12 am
Here’s what I wonder. If all of us – humans – are all quite similar to each other, some more than others, and we see our kids through the lens of our own self-perception? I do this all the time – he’s like me, he’s like husband in this way, Grandpa in that way…but I could just as easily say he’s like my friend Joe from college, right? I don’t know…I just wonder, that’s all.
Regardless, it’s fascinating to see the traits and tendencies that our children have in common with us and with other relatives. I’ve been finding I have a lot of understanding for my son’s need to be heard – even when I know what he’s going to say and that it’s not going to change my mind, because if there was ANYTHING that drove me mad as a child, it was not being given the opportunity to be heard when I felt passionately that I had something to say (or a case to make).
Great topic…I love thinking about these things.
August 28th, 2010 at 7:23 pm
I see a lot of me in BubTar, I think that’s why he can push my buttons so easily.
August 29th, 2010 at 10:48 pm
I don’t have children, but, I’m a lot different than my parents. It’s not just genes.
August 30th, 2010 at 7:01 pm
Our daughter is the image of me, both in personality (gawd help her and me)and appearance; our son is like his father both in appearance and in personality-though the boy is a bit more easy-going and impish than his father. Our daughter informed me that I need to go in ‘time out’ because I “boss” her too much. I probably do–I’ve met my match.
I think it’s a generous combo of the old nature/nurture thing which comes in to play.
September 1st, 2010 at 1:03 pm
Ouch. mirror mirror indeed. My daughter is very much like me sometimes. Stubborn, shy, perfectionist, bad at losing and with a terrible temper. But she is also popular, funny, bright and the bad sides are almost exclusively present in my presence. Make the mother feel guilty why don’t you.
September 2nd, 2010 at 10:36 pm
My eldest is equal parts me and her father, but recently she is more me. My youngest is all me. She is me, my sister, my mother, my grandmother, and I believe generations of women before me. Lately, my older girl started chuckling instead of laughing, exactly the same sound my great grandmother, my Meme, used to make.
The Acadian genes, they run deep and strong.
September 14th, 2010 at 9:12 am
Our kids are a mix, but in their looks my genes have a tendency to dominate. So far it’s been harder to ascertain what’s most influenced their personalities. AJ has a sense of self I wholly hope she keeps, although the battle of wills gets a tad exhausting at times. TG’s eagerness to engage with the world, and seeming like he’s never met a stranger is something I both love and worry about. When I tried to find out from my family about what I was like as a kid everyone was so vague and non-descript I suspect neither of my children take after me as their personalities are far more obvious.