Tue 2 Nov 2010
landing
Posted by bon under pregnancy stuff, social media meta stuff
[36] Comments
the plane guts and dips, sailing in through the headwinds like a drunk girl in unfamiliar heels.
i am in the twelfth row, the hind end of a glorified sardine can. out the rounded rectangle of my window, the earth lurches toward us at strange angles. my stomach tries to grab hold of something solid. my seat vibrates. i note the world carved into patchwork squares below and remember the flight path is over my house.
it is only the gunning roar of the engines that frightens me.
three feet over the runway, we coast like a glider, suspended. an engine sounds its barbaric yawp and i believe for a moment that we will rise again, a phoenix tracing loop-dee-loops against the gray sky. then a wobble, and my eyes wait for the spark and explosion of wing against asphalt.
the perfect metaphor for coming home.
after flying, landing is hard.
***
i spoke at Blissdom Canada: our panel was a big, glorious Kleenex ad. we told stories, and then so did the audience, and they took over in a groundswell. there’s good going on out here in real, individual lives. there was weeping and rejoicing and really, it was better than Christmas. less cleanup.
i watched half my Twitter stream come to life: words made flesh. i sat with people. i touched my hands to your faces, some of you. i heard you laugh. i watched you walk and take up space. i watched your eyes dart about for somewhere to hide.
and i realize now, the story i should have told: everyone is made of secrets.
i heard more secrets in two days in person than i’ve been privy to in years online.
i keep reading that we bloggers spill our guts for breakfast, that we are narcissists, attention whores. the cruellest volley ever fired in the war between objective truth and pluralism was not that stories don’t count, but that those who tell them must be pathological.
they’re wrong.
we are all soft in the middle, somewhere. yeh, even you with the abs. but you know that. we all have broken places, hurts. we’ve all done terrible or wonderful things in the dark, at least once. we’re too old now to deny it. most of us have had things happen that we didn’t deserve. there’s no point in shame, but it’s damn hard to unlearn.
we hold our closest stories to our vests until we see the whites of your eyes. we only tell in the flesh.
maybe we’re making a mistake.
we give our secrets too much power. especially when we live our lives in the glare of the internet: we release 98% of ourselves into the wild and hold back the lumpy bumpy 2% as if it were the Real Thing and we risk making it the Real Thing by treating it like a royal flush to be played when the stakes are highest.
i landed back in my own living room like Dorothy catapulted from a sleepless tornado of polyester and blond wigs, and the grind of housework and deadlines and two children who can’t seem to share the same space without talking at once landed on me like landfill. and i stared at Dave across the expanse of our couch wondering if there was anything about me he didn’t already know and if my real secret is that i’m dull and mundane and a stress monkey who’s actually 98% lumpy bumpy bits. and then i ranted for awhile.
a little bit of freedom is a dangerous weapon.
the truth about secrets, of course, is there are only so many. we live in bodies. they are vulnerable and beautiful. and we are petty and kind, clannish and magnanimous. we are not our secrets, nor just the sum of the parts we share. i knew this when i sat with you. i need to remember, when i sit with myself.
me. not me. mileage may vary.
Kate took more pictures of me in Toronto than i’ve been in since i had kids. to the self sitting here on my couch in dirty jeans, they are the secret, the hidden life. they are also only a story, a thin veneer. they are a promise of next time, and a nod that says, i see you, in your jeans and crumbs and deadlines and pretend secrets.
i wobble like the plane, landing, then coast back into my life.





November 2nd, 2010 at 12:03 pm
I stopped blogging because I felt like I was sharing too many secrets. But I think you’re right: I held back the most important stuff.
Wish I could have sat with you and shared in your Bliss. I am so close to Toronto, but I felt too far to attend.
PS You are radiant as a blonde! Kate’s pictures are fantastic.
November 2nd, 2010 at 12:18 pm
I remember my first conference, last year at BlogHer. Nothing in my online “life” was ever the same for me again. Suddenly, there were real people behind these words that I read every day, actual living beings reading my own work. Which was exhilarating, but also very scary.
November 2nd, 2010 at 1:32 pm
*catches breath* Yes, exactly. That.
November 2nd, 2010 at 1:32 pm
i think the scary part for me is confronting the fact that both worlds are totally real. i am here on my couch littered with candy bar wrappers. and so are you, somewhere. or you’re in a glamourous dress. (maybe even you, Neil). and under that is a body, like any other body, flawed and sheltered.
i mean, i knew that. i knew all the beautiful words come from bodies. i knew we are more and less than our words. but having everybody reduced back to words, suddenly? feels like bedspins.
November 2nd, 2010 at 1:37 pm
I felt exactly this way after my first conference, too. But also.. that people I’d always thought of as friends were actually, truly friends. I remember being so thoroughly shocked that, more or less, everyone was exactly who I thought they’d be. Didn’t that shock you, even on the relatively small-ish scale of Blissdom (versus the mammoth BlogHer)? It shocked me. It was such a delight.
There’s nothing else I can say here, other than you are divine and I adore you, and that you were damn straight to wear that dress. xo
November 2nd, 2010 at 1:45 pm
I know exactly what you’re saying here. And once you meet everyone that you already know and love and get to hug them it’s hard to go home and not be able to call them up and go for coffee whenever you want.
It was great to meet you, Bonnie, and I fully expect you to come to BlogHer next year so that I can hug you and sit up until 3 a.m. chatting with you.
xo
November 2nd, 2010 at 1:46 pm
A little bit of freedom is a dangerous weapon.
I’m still thinking about that one. Your words, as always, too nourishing.
And did I hear something about Cuba next year? (What must I do to become an honorary Canadian?)
November 2nd, 2010 at 1:48 pm
I so identify with this. Sometimes I feel like I have a bit of a double life – and I wasn’t even away by myself! Yikes if that ever happens – and each of those lives is very, very real.
November 2nd, 2010 at 2:11 pm
it is possible that i will leave you an entire blog post.
my fingers are curved, hovering.
it is possible i will say nothing at all.
i may be wearing sweatpants & disheveled hair. i may be wearing sequins. i may or may not have eaten a KitKat bar at 8 a.m.
Whitman says we contain multitudes. Certainly this space does.
What took my breath away was the magic of chemistry: those with whom (or with whose words) I have resonated here in this multitudinous place were, are, in all their messy fleshy truth, the ones with whom i chimed. how do we leap the ether that way?
It is, I think, a bit of this (from the same poem, Whitman again):
“For every atom belonging to me as good belongs to you.”
November 2nd, 2010 at 3:10 pm
you are so beautiful, bonnie.
and that includes your words.
November 2nd, 2010 at 5:21 pm
Gorgeous words, and whoa – look at that blond! This is it, in such a nutshell as to make us all seem accessible, somehow. Just bodies, just secrets… it seems simple, now. Nice, Bon.
November 2nd, 2010 at 6:52 pm
“the cruellest volley ever fired in the war between objective truth and pluralism was not that stories don’t count, but that those who tell them must be pathological.”
I read this sentence three times – the second, to think about it further; the third, just to enjoy it again.
November 2nd, 2010 at 8:30 pm
Do you know what I like about you Bon? You seem to me to be a very generous person.
Also this is brilliant:
‘we’ve all done terrible or wonderful things in the dark, at least once’
November 2nd, 2010 at 8:47 pm
generous. well, uh…afteriris, may i say you look right nice in them pants?
and god, i hope we’ve all done terrible or wonderful things in the dark, at least once. or in the light. or sometime. if you haven’t, you might want to consider it. :)
November 2nd, 2010 at 9:21 pm
I think we all must have, really. And will do so again given the opportunity. Ahem. At least, y’know, some people would. Maybe.
And generous in the best, most complimentary sense of the word in that you look at the world with kind eyes, even the lumpy-bumpy 2% (she says eagerly awaiting further comments on her sartorial choices.)
November 2nd, 2010 at 9:23 pm
“we hold our closest stories to our vests until we see the whites of your eyes. we only tell in the flesh.
maybe we’re making a mistake.”
I wonder this every day. I wonder this every day, as I hold the heaviest stories to my vest, as I keep in the things that are most shadowed, that are most hard to tell. Which is why when anyone tells me that I am brave for telling my stories I always laugh a little and babble something about *oh, no, I am so not so brave as you think.*
Yeah. I think about this a lot.
(Aside, but relevant: it was SUCH a pleasure finally meeting you in person. I am so, so happy that you came and shared your awesome. I only wish that I’d had the time to share in more.)
November 2nd, 2010 at 10:01 pm
Although I only attended Blissdom Canada in the extracurricular portion of the activities, my experience after having attending two BlogHer conferences is that I come home thinking “this time, I’ll find a way to tell what’s REALLY going on around here”. And, I don’t. My story is not on my blog. I’m not sure when I’m going to get it out. Or if.
Stories are complicated and can hurt many people involved in their telling but obviously can also help many others. One day I’ll figure out what I am going to do with mine. Even if it means keeping it trapped.
It was lovely to meet you, briefly. I love putting real faces and arms and legs to names.
November 2nd, 2010 at 10:59 pm
“Stories are complicated and can hurt many people involved in their telling but obviously can also help many others. One day I’ll figure out what I am going to do with mine. Even if it means keeping it trapped.”
Yes, Emma. Exactly that.
The thing about writing stories down is that they can then be found. While it can be a release, it can also create many more problems than it solves. It is a delicate balance. But I appreciate the whites of peoples’ eyes for the release that they provide. Sometimes the stories do need to escape into someone else’s eyes, without making their way onto the Internet. Sometimes we need real hugs and not just virtual ones.
November 2nd, 2010 at 11:31 pm
This is beautiful. And also true.
I had someone leave a comment once saying that they felt I held back when I blog. The whole time I had been feeling like I say too much. Maybe I don’t always give the reader all the words, but I feel like if you look between the lines, the story is there.
November 2nd, 2010 at 11:32 pm
Emma, i felt like i met you for three whole seconds and then wham! you were gone and i couldn’t find you again.
Catherine, likewise. except i meant to pin you down and make you agree to be part of my narrative inquiry into branded cyborg selves (and i mean that in the nicest possible way, as i’m reviving Haraway for the social media era). but then, well, wham! you were gone too.
people apparently vanish a great deal at these functions.
anyhoo, thank you, much, for having me.
and on stories…the last three comments in a sense all have a theme. i suppose i make it seem, in the post, as if i’m saying telling solves all. i don’t believe any such thing. stories have power but they do not cure on their own and they are not always ours to tell. and we do need real hugs, absolutely.
but my cautionary tale is that in holding stories back – especially holding them back not for our daily lives but for these rare, heady occasions when the virtual world becomes embodied – we risk reducing our own embodiment TO those stories. we make ourselves shells carrying around those secrets, looking for absolution and escape and something a hug in whatever form will never suffice to provide. secrets, told or not, are part of who we are. i’m wary of a confessional role structured to make us ONLY our secrets, and one that gives cultural capital to having terrible secrets. we are all more and less than the worst things that have ever happened to us. and if we forget that, i think we lose a chance to heal.
November 3rd, 2010 at 8:28 am
Bon, I so love your writing and thinking.
Maybe another “cruel volley” is the notion that each individual story can only be told one way, that our stories are linear and follow a neat narrative arc. So much of life is irrational. Perhaps that’s why we work so hard to make sense out of it by begging off all the possible choices, by insisting or hoping or dreaming of ONE choice ONE meaning, ONE path. Franzen addresses the problems of limitless freedom in his new book, doesn’t he? And he seems to conclude that the most compelling freedom is freedom *from* choice.
Hmmmm.
Re: secrets: the ones that most fascinate me in the way they inform “who” we imagine ourselves to be–and how others perceive us–are the ones we keep from ourselves.
November 3rd, 2010 at 8:40 am
What I am loving, being so new to the blog world, is that *you* are here, in your words and stories. It’s like reading letters. That’s what blogs like yours impart to me, letters from life, from the heart, truths and sorrows and laughs and insights gained from the crumbs on the couch, the moment when the plane is landing when you have that spectacular perspective on all life and time and meaning and history, and how it vanishes when the wheels hit and we have to stand up and deplane and then it’s a memory of knowing, in that moment, we knew the secret. And moving forward with this knowing, into daily life, which defines us.
Blogs don’t have gatekeepers like I’m used to, editors and publishers who take out whole swatches, who decide what is worthy of being published, what suits the climate, the agenda of the publication, what will make sponsors and readerships happy.
Blogs like yours have an authenticity that is often absent in pitched and heavily edited feature writing these days. it wasn’t always so but there are fewer and fewer markets for personal essays in mainstream publishing, certainly in Canada. And then it is making your ideas match up with an agenda or vision statement and it’s a tricky omlette to flip.
But here it seems the trick is to speak your truth and it’s so profoundly moving, this frontier you dance and write and live upon.
Thanks so much for these wise words, Bon, which resonate with any parent, writer, person who is engaging with life and at times, wondering at it’s very curious combination of deep joy and sorrow. love from ns, ca
November 3rd, 2010 at 10:43 am
I understand what you are saying about holding stories back. I think I need more people who I trust completely to listen without judgment or consequence in my daily life. The people I have met online and that I see only at these blogging conferences are truly special and I wish I could clone them and bring them home with me.
November 3rd, 2010 at 12:42 pm
Going to BlogHer and BlissDomCanada this year has been amazing for me. In so many ways. Meeting the people that for years I’ve been talking to online, making strong friendships, the hugs, the connections. And yes, the incredible feeling of knowing that I can tell her and her and him and her my darkest secrets and knowing that I won’t be judged. The love is amazing. I don’t see the negative, I see only the positive. It is damn depressing to come back from a conference like this. As happy as I am to see my darling children, and snuggle them and inhale them and be happy with them, it’s still sad in a way.
I’m also very censored on my blog, because of how my audience is. There is much I wish I could say and write. But there would be too many questions so for now I keep on writing as I do, which is always honest and from my heart, but with stories missing. The gaps are sometimes filled in the comment section of other blogs, though, so that least there is that.
I LOVED meeting you. You made me cry. I think you’re gorgeous. Thanks for coming outside with me. xoxo
November 3rd, 2010 at 12:51 pm
That should have said because of WHO my audience is.
November 3rd, 2010 at 1:42 pm
That’s what I love about BlogHer, words made flesh. The validation that people you think of as friends in the virtual space really are friends in the physical world.
November 4th, 2010 at 12:28 pm
i hold back many secrets, though sometimes i wish to spill. and you’re right – in person, or even off blog, more secrets get told.
love kate’s pictures of you.
November 5th, 2010 at 12:46 pm
I’m glad I shared my secrets with the whites of your eyes Bonnie.
I’m glad I sat beside you and watched you laugh as you sipped red wine and regaled me with tales of far away places.
I’m glad you were the you I had painted in my head for all these years.
I’m glad my heart loves you so much.
November 5th, 2010 at 1:00 pm
If you think it’s strange to re-enter life after a blog conference, try doing it with your partner. There’s a dual recalibration for the change in pressure, and it’s all bread heels and forgotten leftovers and work schedules. We visited family before coming home, and then they visited us when we came home, and I think it helped ease our descent a bit.
November 5th, 2010 at 2:10 pm
Tanis, i’m glad you did too.
i’m glad for all of it.
and Palinode, yeh. Dave & i have done that even here: joint presentations, and it’s great and we high-five and walk off stage and rush to go pick up the kids and there’s no decompression time, and ouch. mixed with the meeting everybody stuff? that’d be crazy.
November 5th, 2010 at 8:25 pm
You blow me away with your words every time.
Secrets and stories and friendship and decompression.
And you look like Natalie Portman in Closer in that wig.
Only better.
November 6th, 2010 at 2:34 am
Perfectly written. Your sentences are gorgeous. So are you.
November 7th, 2010 at 3:22 pm
I wish it was easier to share secrets in the real world and I don’t necessarily include in that those heady blogging conferences which seem to me as one who hasn’t attended any as hyperreal. The real world is too full of washing, the school run and keeping up with family and work and humdrum things for people to have time to share those things. At least I haven’t found anyone recentl? with whom I can do it or at least who I think can stand to listen.
November 7th, 2010 at 7:42 pm
I left a comment yesterday, but for some reason it didn’t go through… Just wanted to say that I completely understand what you mean.
It was such a pleasure to hear you on the panel at Blissdom Canada. You moved the room with your words and story. Wish we could have met in person, but our paths seemed to cross every time.
November 8th, 2010 at 10:52 pm
My word for you would be ‘open’, both in what you write and how you encounter the world. But ‘witness’ is even better.
My word for myself changes as I change. For me, not to change, not to learn, would be a little death. Off now to look at blissdom. And to hope that you will let us share in your learning – what I have is a diploma in what they called ‘creative advertising’ and branding was a big part of what I learned about at that level.
November 22nd, 2010 at 12:02 am
I’ve become so obsessed with what I’m not saying on my blog that I set up a secret twitter account and blog to say what I wasn’t saying on my public blog. But now I find that I worry about my secret blog being found – kind of like the diary of yore.