Wed 24 Nov 2010
Pandora’s box
Posted by bon under mama-baby stuff, milestone stuff, social media meta stuff
[30] Comments
last night i was at yoga with my mom.
(the above sentence entertains the ever-lovin’ crap out of me. part of me wants to wrap it up in shiny paper and turn it this way and that, like a spaceship that fell from the sky, because yoga with my mom sounds so pleasantly suburban and banal and normal and first-world problem-y, and i feel like i should follow it with charming antics about our trip to Starbucks after and our little shopping escapades and pedicures. which i can’t. my mother drinks tea. she sometimes buys us diapers. we have a storied history, my mama and i, but it has never involved exercise or girlfriend hobbies or shopping as therapy. and so we are rather imposters in this story. and yet, there we were, at yoga.)
we show up a little late because yoga starts at the awkward hour of 7pm and getting outta my house at 6:50pm is akin to extricating oneself from the grasp of a slightly hysterical octopus. we grab mats from the bin. my mother has not yet committed to purchasing one: after waiting 62 years to try an exercise class, she is not prepared to marry the first novelty that happens along. i just haven’t gotten to a store this crazy fall.
every week at yoga, my mother and i have set our mats down beside each other along the wall of the little pine-panelled room. at first, she was nervous, careful and defensive and controlled, uncertain whether she was doing it right. i watched her out of the corner of my eye, whispered little encouragements or explanations. mostly i just watched. i listened to her breathe beside me, took in the shape of her back as we lay on our sides. i am like her, i thought. tiny wrists, short waist, legs that prefer to be curled under.
it is a strange thing, to watch someone and marvel that body was where i began. it has never occurred to me before. we have never spent much time, my mother and i, just being, taking each other in. or if we did, i have forgotten. children betray their mothers’ care, oblivious.
but i catch sight of her hands beside me as we stretch. her winter hands, rough and cracking with the drop in temperature. for a moment, the 38 year old grunting through downward dog disappears. i am a child in bed, those hands on my hair.
forgotten is not the same as gone.
last night, though, when we walked in the room, there was no space for two mats beside each other. and so we ended up at opposite corners of the classroom.
and i missed her.
i was LESS CALM without her. that sentence is almost as funny as the first. when i was in labour with Oscar, and panicking, my poor mother hid behind Dave’s shoulder, hands raised to God, hyperventilating. i did not find this calming. i have found little about my mother calming in at least twenty-five years, in spite of her earnest efforts.
yet there it is. perhaps if we breathed more, talked less.
***
i know that my children will forget most of these days, this brutal frog-march into winter where i feel like i am failing everyone and everything around me. i feel powerless and inept and uncertain. too many essays churned out, sourced and tidied, sentences cropped into submission. now the words stutter from me, hesitant, timid.
in class later today, i will stand up and talk about blogging, and identity, and how digital technologies have made it possible for whole worlds of conversation about mothering and motherhood and being mothered to exist and to be shared.
i thought it would be the easiest thing in the world to research. what do i know better than blogging and mothering? what am i doing here if not trying to write myself into some kind of coherent existence?
today in class i will them that i started to write two weeks before Oscar was born. almost a year after Finn died. i will tell them i was afraid to speak the open wound of my once and future motherhood, and so i wrote it down, that in-between place of uncertainty and hope and fear that was all that i knew.
i kept writing because that place of uncertainty and hope and fear has never gone away, only changed.
i keep writing because i have no other place to tell my mother that i missed her last night.
but i am afraid.
my life as a student this fall has been a drop down a rabbit hole of half-remembered existence. blogging has spoiled me. i have built a place here where i have grown steadily less afraid to speak. i have unlearned a lifetime of being careful and defensive and controlled, uncertain whether i was doing it right…whatever “it” was. i have grown accustomed to being in a shared conversation.
what i say and write as a student, on the other hand, is graded, judged.
and to stand up and talk about writing my motherhood to a room of mostly childless people, while i swallow the guilt of yet again missing supper with my kids, is to get naked. to expose myself. to judgement that does not come from being inside the conversation of the messiness of motherhood and identity.
i hope they understand. i hope they judge with the same generosity i’ve found out here.
i hope these stories matter, these stories of writing ourselves into some kind of coherence. i hope i can find that coherence again, by opening this life to that other one.
***
do you open the Pandora’s Box of your online life with people who know you in the flesh?




November 24th, 2010 at 12:32 pm
I avoided telling my family or anyone I really knew well about my blog. I just found it embarassing to lay myself out like that. There are a few hundred blog posts wrapped up in that statement but I’m not willing to go there.
I became confortable opening up for strangers (AKA online “friends”).
I find you area of study fascinating especially given your own involvement.
November 24th, 2010 at 12:34 pm
THANK-YOU! That was one of the most BEAUTIFUL…HONEST…HEART/WARMING blogs i have EVER READ. GOOD WORK DEAR ;)
November 24th, 2010 at 12:41 pm
I did, yes. And in some ways it made me feel a little timid, like they could crack open my head and see things they might not have otherwise had access to.
Perhaps it also made me edit more, I don’t know.
Sometimes those people who know me in the flesh would read something that I wrote and, when we were together, they would touch my arm and look me in the eye and tell me that they loved it and that would make my day. Every time.
November 24th, 2010 at 12:53 pm
In my blog, my life is an open book. In real life, I am not so quick to share. I imagine all the people I sit in class with every day reading what I write on my blog, and I die a little. So no, I am very careful about who I share it with. A few friends who live far away, who I’ve known for years. The number one person I would never ever tell is my mother. We all need our security blankets, and my blog is mine.
November 24th, 2010 at 12:54 pm
These stories matter. Perhaps not to everyone, but they matter to some.
And that is important and makes doing it worth it.
Good luck kid. You won’t need it but I’m wishing it to you anyways.
November 24th, 2010 at 1:16 pm
The way I look at it — why should anyone be that different than you? You enjoy hearing stories about other people, right? It matters to you? So, why wouldn’t it work the other way?
November 24th, 2010 at 1:17 pm
This post made me cry and I had to stop reading half-way and then come back to comment. And read through the entire post again. You’re a beautiful writer, and yes, it does matter. I am sure, despite the fact that your students are mostly without children, they will be moved and touched and applaud you. Wish I could be there to hear your speak. You do inspire. xoxo
November 24th, 2010 at 1:20 pm
You’re so brave. You’re so brave to put it out there, what you’re feeling, the guilt of motherhood, exposing it to students who – let’s face it, we were youthful students once – really cannot understand the overwhelming world of motherhood. They can’t really understand feeling guilty for missing dinner or leaving at 6:50. I admire you, for putting it all out there and making people feel less alone.
November 24th, 2010 at 1:22 pm
Beautiful post. I wish I could get my mother to go to a yoga class when we’re together, which is rare. She prefers to be sitting, always. Inanimate.
I don’t open my blog up to people I know in real life except for very good friends who I know will not share it. I don’t want my family, or work associates, reading my blog. I don’t link Twitter and Facebook, I have separate email accounts for blog and “real life” because I found that my Yahoo account was broadcasting when I’d blog. So I moved my blog, linked it to a new email account that my family doesn’t have access to.
Yes, your stories matter. Keep writing. I’m adding you to my blogroll, got here through Schmutzie’s tweet.
November 24th, 2010 at 1:27 pm
thank you for telling me it matters.
and Neil, good point. i think it’s more about them not being in this conversation but in a relationship that has judgement and competition foregrounded that makes me feel exposed, like i’m unveiling a one-way mirror.
in truth, one of my very best friends in the world is in that class. she, like you, has no kids. but she’s been in this conversation with me from the beginning, and has been one of the very few people in my real life with whom i talked about Finn easily. she stepped in to take over the brand new keys to the house the day he was born, when Dave had to go running from the real estate agent to the car, to try to get to Halifax in time.
so she will be there beaming at me. and she’s going to be talking about her own research, which involves coming out as gay, so my face will be beaming back at her for courage.
still, the after makes me feel vulnerable. it’s a strange straddling of worlds, this life in the open stuff. and i don’t want opening up this space to research to make it even harder to write. i don’t want to start internalizing my Rules of Academic Writing here. gawd. that’s why i dropped the capital letters in the first place. :)
November 24th, 2010 at 1:36 pm
I too feel naked sometimes. It’s mostly ok, but when I meet someone in person who already knows my insides from the blog (but has never commented), my stomach still lurches.
And then it’s ok. But I wonder still what they think I’ll be like, and if my outsides match.
November 24th, 2010 at 1:49 pm
My mother called me at work one day to tell me she spent her morning reading my entire blog. At hearing this I wanted to hide under my desk. Turns out she liked it, but that really didn’t matter. I felt naked.
It reminds me of Pink Floyd’s Final Cut:
“And if I show you my dark side
Will you still hold me tonight?
And if I open my heart to you
And show you my weak side
What would you do?
Would you sell your story to Rolling Stone?
Would you take the children away
And leave me alone?
And smile in reassurance
As you whisper down the phone?
Would you send me packing?
Or would you take me home?”
Regardless of parenthood or anything else, I think everyone can relate to wanting a place they can bare thier soul.
November 24th, 2010 at 1:55 pm
My site started out as a place for me to share stories and photos of my kids with family and friends far away so, yes, everyone reads. I live in a small town and so many people I hardly know read me. It can be a little (or a lot) awkward and weird but, eh. If they have issues then they can stop reading.
Rooting for you, lovely lady.
November 24th, 2010 at 1:58 pm
just sitting here quietly, witnessing, listening, reading.
streaming tears. not bothering much to wipe them, they keep spilling, tipped out of me by your words.
how can this conversation not matter?
We are in relationship with our mothers all our lives. Even when they are gone (I see mine in my hands now, through the tears as I type) we come from them, and consciously (as you are, so articulately & beautifully here) or unconsciously, through them we define our own motherhood.
You will rock your presentation Bon. Because the saying is true: she who rocks the cradle rocks the world.
November 24th, 2010 at 2:38 pm
I showed my current boyfriend (I hate this word at my age. ugh) the first week we were talking. Mostly, it felt easy-if you read this, you’ll know if you can’t deal with shit.
He read a bit, and then stopped. He didn’t know the girl in most of those pages. It was important to me to start anew with someone like that. Open doors.
Family tho…no. They wouldn’t get it, and very few friends who don’t blog know about it. Thordora is a very different person than Jada, and I’m not in love with the idea of everyone in my life knowing all that’s there.
I think it’s also a question of how a person has been writing online, and about what.
That part with your mother at yoga? Made me ache for mine, even if I’m not of her body. I’m glad you’ve found that space with her.
November 24th, 2010 at 2:57 pm
You must be on your way by now. Thinking of you. You speak your messy heart better than any other messy heart I know. You are a magnet, and you will be fine. xo
November 24th, 2010 at 7:21 pm
I don’t leave little sentences often enough at the places I love to spend time. {You are amazing.} xo
November 24th, 2010 at 8:01 pm
I wished for teachers like you. Thanks for writing.
November 24th, 2010 at 8:04 pm
most IRL people i know either outright hate that i blog or are made uncomfortable by it. i’m glad that you have such supportive friends, both IRL and here (as evidenced by these comments!).
xo
November 24th, 2010 at 8:53 pm
The fragility of our mother-daughter relationships is common, but what you’ve done is put the feeling of that “uneasy love” into words. I LOVED how you wrote that body is where I came from and it brings it all full circle for me as a new mom… my son will look at me someday and think those same thoughts and I hope (and cross my fingers) that he thinks forgotten, but not gone. Love your blog! Keep it coming!
November 24th, 2010 at 10:19 pm
My relationship with my mother is far more complex than my relationship with my father. Already, with my children not even old enough for school, it feels like things are far more complex when relating to my daughter than my son. I wonder how this will play out in the years to come, and if being conscious of it gives me some chance to shape things to be different.
I would’ve loved to have been there to hear you speak, to be another encouraging face in the room. However, it is good that you get to touch the minds and hearts of those who do not know of the kind of experiences you have had, as their lives will be richer for it.
November 24th, 2010 at 11:00 pm
I lurk because I’m a shy person, but what you write is beautiful. I’m going to school part time, learning to blog, and a mom to one daughter. Thanks for writing what you do.
November 25th, 2010 at 1:42 pm
How did it go?
Love that phrase, “the Pandora’s box of your online life.” I have tried very hard to keep my online & “real life” worlds separate, my blog in particular. One person I know IRL (a blogger herself & very Net-savvy) has found it & when I asked her to keep my secret, she said, “No problem (((hugs))).” I’ve also had one or two anonymous comments, the content of which made me think that the writer knows me. Supportive comments, but slightly unnerving nevertheless.
I’m finding my worlds are becoming slightly more blurred since I joined Facebook last year, & I wrote about this recently on my blog. On FB, I am “friends” with my cousins, dh’s cousins, our two nephews & my SIL, high school friends (close friends & mere classmates), university friends, online scrapbooking friends, friends from our IRL pregnancy loss support group & online ALI community friends. It’s kind of weird having all these different & previously mostly separate aspects of my life rubbing shoulders in one place.
It’s hard putting yourself out there, I know, especially when you’re not quite sure your audience is going to “get it.” Just remember, though — some of those clueless young childless students will be parents themselves someday. (Sadly, odds being what they are, some of them will also experience pregnancy & infant loss.) And someday, they’ll remember your words & your example, & take comfort in it, & maybe become part of the blogging commmunity themselves. (((hugs)))
November 25th, 2010 at 2:49 pm
…thank you, everyone, for all the love and kindness. i was a little shaky still when i got home from class last night, and i wrapped myself in that blanket of kindess and warmth and felt…good.
class went well…it’s hard to connect infant death and discourse theory and i was uncomfortable making people uncomfortable…but after my trusty friend T broke through the entertaining silence that followed my discussion of silencing…some interesting conversations ensued. some sharing, some ideas, all good.
to be fair to my classmates too, they’re none of them kids. ten in the group, all between maybe 35 and 50 or 55? three with grown children, one other with school-age/preschool kids. so i guess, when you add me in, half and half. but only 2 of us really in the “kids” phase of our lives.
everyone was gracious, and kind. as they usually are. still strange to be graded on a talk like this. because no matter how i started with discourse and tried to come around to narrative theory and Foucault and Judith Butler and blah blah blah, my guess is that what people heard was “dead baby dead baby dead baby.” which is not bad. i appreciate them receiving that. but it IS fascinating. comes full circle to my original feeling that some subjects really are just too heavy for everyday conversation…and thus what drove me to start writing.
November 25th, 2010 at 3:59 pm
I keep the lid of my box tighly closed most of the time. I have crakced it open and let a little spill out onto my blog, but it is so rare.
This was a beautiful post.
November 25th, 2010 at 4:16 pm
“…akin to extricating oneself from the grasp of a slightly hysterical octupus.”
That’s gold, Bonnie, GOLD!!
November 26th, 2010 at 9:58 am
Lovely. I almost resented the words that you were writing, because I have a… complicated relationship with my mother and we have made strides, but we have not gone to yoga together yet.
And, as is her pattern, she fumed, couldn’t support and shamed me when she found my first blog, but now that I am in a place where I don’t care what she thinks,she brags about any success it brings me, as though she had a hand in it.
November 27th, 2010 at 12:07 am
I went snowshoeing with my mother once. All this new snow had just fallen and I was in heaven, absolutely overjoyed, while it was so much work for my poor mother that she nearly had to be carried back home. Now I hike with my dad.
I love what you said about some topics being too tough for everyday conversation. That’s so true… Yet the blog, it’s always there, empty screen ready to be filled.
November 29th, 2010 at 1:58 am
Oh you just are so…I just love you Bon
November 29th, 2010 at 8:18 pm
I really, really liked this post.
It seems counter-intuitive that some people can be so open out here in cyberspace while still asserting that they are shy, self-conscious, and private. Can you really be a private person if you tell your secrets on the Internet? The truth is, sometimes secrets need to be told and it is much easier to tell those secrets if you are never going to have to meet the eyes of those who know the depths of you. For me, anyway.
My mom recently found my blog. I’m curious to discover if this will cause me to censor myself more in these spaces.