Mon 6 Jun 2011
these pictures of you
Posted by bon under mama-baby stuff, the home project
[21] Comments
long before my grandfather died, i stole my childhood photo album from his house.
‘stole’ is perhaps too strong a word. i laid my claim to the psychedelic satin-covered relic, waved it in front of my grandfather, asked if i could take it home. he was gracious. or rather, he laughed and said, “well, i’m not looking at it!”
honesty. it rids your house of clutter.
i was the eldest grandchild. seven of the eight of us were born before my grandmother died in 1988, but it was me and my cousin Angela, born in 1972 and ’73, on whom my grandmother lavished the largesse of her documentary attentions. two matching albums, each with a garish cover, captioned in her handwriting. in each shot, i am labelled the full and complete “Bonnie Elaine.”
in most of the photo albums of my childhood, there are only a couple of pictures of my mother and i together.
the majority are scratchy snapshots, square and white-rimmed, with a seventies patina Instagram would die for. they follow a pattern. child – generally trussed up in finery – stands perched in front of adult – equally awkwardly trussed up in finery, frequently with a Christmas colour scheme. both smile. my mother’s smile is determined, mine distracted. in one, her hand gently but firmly grips the square jut of my chin and points my face to the camera.
i think of myself as having always been a ham, a camera hog. but that came later. only in the photos that my mother snapped when i wasn’t looking do i recognize myself and the shape of our lives then.
that small child alone, bent over her drawing, tongue sticking out? i was in the kitchen with my mother, drawing while the dishes got washed. i filled pastel pages of newsprint with characters, worlds, stories. i was not alone. we were there together. there are simply no pictures to testify.
it is hard to capture a twosome without a third around.
but in this album retrieved from my grandfather’s cupboard, i found another version of my earliest days. the pictures are mostly black & white, my father’s experimental eye evident behind the lens. me in my mother’s arms, shot after shot, a sticky-out-eared infant and a young woman i barely recognize. my mother is twenty-three. her hair hangs long and black. within the year, i know, she will have cut it short forever, and the gray will start, taking over by the time she reaches thirty. within the year my father will be gone, and there will be no more random shots of mother and child.
it was his mother who kept them, and i wonder at the heartache and family politics behind that innocent orange- and pink-covered photo album.
***
i tell stories and take pictures because i need them, somehow. the blog, #thehomeproject, the flickr account with its 3000+ photos of the mundanities of our children’s passing days…they are the tools by which i reflect my world back to myself. the art makes it real. the reflection allows me to see.
Dave teases me that i cannot pass a mirror without looking at myself. it’s true, almost. but i am looking for myself more than at. not vanity, but confirmation. i am here. i am in this skin. this is what they see when they look at me. and i nod and step off again into the strange sea of living, in which i flounder blind.
whether my children will ever want or need these glorified digital photo albums, i do not know. a part of me hopes they will somehow be solid enough in themselves to weather their days without needing them reflected back, diffracted out. maybe they will.
a part of me wants that for them.
but just in case, i store away for all of us these random shots. here we are, me & Posey, watching Oscar in his first gymnastics show. this is my daughter on my knee. this is my face in my fortieth year. these are the lines and the spots and the tired eyes of my adulthood. this is my tongue sticking out as i concentrate, just like when i was a kid.
we were here together.
just in case they need to know. just in case i do.
what do you document? keep? look to?





June 6th, 2011 at 11:42 am
I don’t take many pictures, at least not of the girls if I can help it. My parents barely took any, and what I have totals perhaps 25 if that. I have one just my mother and I, and it’s a polaroid that’s slowly falling apart, but I love it. She’s young, and happy and I’m curled and cute and hating my outfit but sitting on her knee as she has a casual conversation at a friends, a mom date I guess. It’s a world I don’t know, or really even remember.
I try to give the girls, the future daughters, a document of the quiet moments, just in case. In case I’m not there to tell them.
June 6th, 2011 at 12:45 pm
I try to capture the little bits of the every day much more than the ‘big moments’. I keep the camera handy and bust it out to grab a snapshot of them wrestling in our messy house, I record them reading a book out loud — I want for myself to have these little artifacts. Their voices at age 4, the way their little bodies moved when they were 2. That’s the stuff I write, too. I try to capture the little moments that make up our normal because I know I’ll remember the big stuff. But it’s the little stuff that creates the essence of our life.
June 6th, 2011 at 1:01 pm
Sometimes the camera is an extension of me – seeing and recording better than my sleep-deprived mind can muster these days. Other times I just want to be in the moment and I don’t care if there’s no documentation of it. I remind myself that life does not need to be stored in a digital image to have existed and impacted.
As the family photographer the photos of me are ridiculously scarce. I recently realised I need to be a bit more proactive about changing this because I think it’s important to have images that capture the ever day, and my every day is about my family.
June 6th, 2011 at 2:12 pm
Martin tells me not everything has to be a perfect picture. It can be of nothing. And he’s right. You reminded me of that. How when looking back at pictures from childhood, it’s the random ones I like most. Where I can see toys lying around (my favorite doll! I remember her!), the old ugly curtains in the kitchen or the old car in the background, etc. Those are the ones that bring you back.
June 6th, 2011 at 2:19 pm
…that’s one of the things i wonder about too, Misty…so many of the shots from my childhood are actually crappy pictures, fading and out of focus or poorly framed. and yet, they are windows that bring me back to things i think i’ve forgotten, to the real of that time.
today, we live in a world where we seem to expect our lives and houses and visual presentation to be staged at almost all times: best face to the world. we can take umpteen photos and cull for free until we have the perfect shot. i have far more fabulous photos of my kids than EVER existed of our generation, or that of our parents. i am grateful.
but i also need to remember when i’m shooting the fugly pajamas on a Sunday morning that i don’t care if somebody sees them and thinks, ew. i care that maybe twenty years from now one of my kids will look at the shot and remember those cozy pajamas and what that day smelled like. maybe.
June 6th, 2011 at 3:08 pm
I am the oldest – oldest child, oldest grandchild. There are volumes and volumes of pictures of me. Fewer of my brother, born seven years later. And I double-dog dare you to try and find pictures of the youngest..poor youngest brother.
I have always loved to take pictures and remembering the print days makes me occasionally delirious about the non-guilt factor of digital. Just keep pressing the button and a good photo will appear!!! Magic!
I try for the big and small moments, but mostly I try for the people who’s instinct is to take themselves out of the picture. “no no just the kids” or “oh, I look terrible”. My mother is attempting to follow the path of HER mother by editing herself from these opportunities and I won’t let her. Like you bon, I think of my boys looking back, perhaps wondering why they can’t find a picture of Nana…
June 6th, 2011 at 9:50 pm
Yes, i get that, the looking in the mirror bit. Maybe we are always looking for ourselves, confirming that we are in fact here and visible?
I document their words, jotting down little phrases that make me laugh, turning a conversation into a story, and maybe a post. The bones are all shorthand notes, meant to remind me of those moments… They are my dearest treasures of the kids. With four now, it is harder to remember each so well – so I look at their little words, and it brings them back to me.
(thank you for visiting my blog… you made my day. ;-))
June 7th, 2011 at 7:39 am
I document to excess, for my kids. It’s a reaction to my not having been documented enough. My children will probably call me crazy when they see all the albums someday — but they’ll be secretly delighted, as we all are.
June 7th, 2011 at 9:10 am
Hammy, i’m delirious about digital, too. my SLR shots from the late film days were too often seconds late for what i wanted to capture.
Bethany…i wonder, does everyone need that confirmation? what is it?
Slouchy…i hope mine are delighted. maybe. there’s so often so much furor in the blogosphere about what the kids will approve of in terms of documentation. and i know that tone matters, absolutely, that not turning kids into objects of entertainment is important: hell, that’s not documentation anyway. but where is this privacy/documentation line we expect our children to draw? do we understand it?
June 7th, 2011 at 9:20 am
…still thinking about the last question above, about the line btwn privacy & documentation. also thinking about Thor’s comment: what if we aren’t here? does that change things?
i suppose personal histories cause some of us to see or focus on or need legacies more than others. have any of you ever been or known someone who resented a legacy? is it easier to accept when the parents aren’t still fully present and there, all embedded in it?
June 7th, 2011 at 11:14 am
There are two things I wonder about on this topic. One, will I be able to access the files in the distant digital future? I think of my mother-in-law with home movies of my husband and his sister as children on VHS that are basically unwatchable now (who has a VCR anymore?). For this reason I was very diligent about printing hard copies of pictures of L at the beginning but I must admit that I have recently fallen out of practice. Will the file type become obsolete and the thousands of pictures of my sweet baby be lost in the digital ether?
The second thing that strikes me is our ability to experience the present, while busily documenting it. Like Quadelle, I think that there are times that you need to put that camera down, experience the moment with your child, and capture it that way, rather than try to capture it with your camera.
June 7th, 2011 at 3:09 pm
It was too late, my kids almost grown, when my mother died and I realized while looking through old photo albums that it wasn’t the quantity of photos of my children that would matter to them, but the number of photos of us, together, that they would cherish.
June 7th, 2011 at 5:52 pm
There are almost no photos of myself with my kids. This bothers me. There are a few more of my husband with the kids, and there are 1 million of the kids on their own. I think, even if my kids, or your kids, aren’t particularly sentimental, they will still be happy to have the digital record that does exist (big or small). It’s possible they may not cherish is, but then an overabundance of photographic memories is a lot better than a complete lack of them.
June 7th, 2011 at 6:38 pm
Hard question… I’ve been rather circumspect about the types of photos of my kids that I’ve taken. (No nude bath shots, or at least none that show anything remotely private.)
It’s the words I’ve written about them that are harder to judge…
June 7th, 2011 at 8:28 pm
Martha…i wonder about access too. the blog, not so much, because it is stored “in the cloud” and Dave controls the server and WordPress code is open and so…it would be hard to make that disappear.
but flickr is a paid service, a proprietary platform. and this is where my research blog and my writing/parenting blog intersect… ;)
June 8th, 2011 at 2:59 am
everything you write sucks the air right out of me. You are magic.
June 8th, 2011 at 9:15 am
Flutter, you are sweet and kind. and also, you made me laugh, because i first read that line as “everything you write sucks” full stop. and i thought, well, they’ve finally decided to tell it to me like it is. ;)
June 8th, 2011 at 9:09 pm
These are subjects & questions that are near & dear to me. I am a scrapbooker, but long before that, I was known as “the family photographer.” My grandmother gave me a Kodak Instamatic (with flipflash!) for Christmas when I was 15 & I have loved taking photos ever since then. Since I don’t have my own kids, I have always taken photos of our nephews. I made them both scrapbooks of their first year (& intend to continue, someday). I wasn’t sure what they’d think, being teenaged boys, but they both loved them.
Photos are precious to me. I shudder when I hear of people throwing out photos &/or negatives. Even today with digital, I only delete the really really crappy photos. I upload from my camera to my hard drive as soon as I can after taking the photos… I take in my memory card when it’s full and have a full set of prints made AND a backup disk, & I regularly back up my hard drive. And I have several memory cards & rotate them. I only clear the photos off when I’m putting it into the camera again. Call me paranoid. ; )
June 8th, 2011 at 9:18 pm
I keep everything. I border on keepsake hoarding. I have old cards, hundreds of pictures, drawings, crafts from the kids, and the hand made clay creations posing as bowls and cups. They are there to remind me to remember the small things and smile. Someday I hope that it will for the kids too.
June 8th, 2011 at 10:03 pm
T, i think maybe the idea that you have kept them will mean something to the kids, someday.
i can really only speak for me, of course. but i would’ve wanted to know that…that i left a trail on my parent’s life, even if i didn’t have a regular window into it.
June 17th, 2011 at 3:16 am
I’m just dropping in to let you know that this weblog is being featured on Five Star Friday:
http://www.schmutzie.com/fivestarfriday/2011/6/17/five-star-fridays-153rd-edition-is-brought-to-you-by-anne-ca.html