Fri 26 Aug 2011
you have too much stuff
Posted by bon under issue stuff, social media meta stuff, stuff to be done
[30] Comments
yeh, you. really. you.
okay, fine, not you. but you. and you. and me.
We Have Too Much Stuff.
all of us. i know this because last night i sucked half a century of dirt and dog hair into my lungs, and as God is my witness, before i expire from some dread disease caused by ancient vacuum mites it is on my heart to shout it from the rooftops.
Too Much! Clutter Kills!
i am thinking of having bumper stickers made, except they would sit in a box in some corner of my house and moulder, and i would trip over them, and that…well, yeh.
***
there is an estate sale at my grandfather’s house tomorrow.
i grew up in apartments, so this house is the last of the places i have known since childhood. my whole life, the very same.
i stand in the living room and i see myself in those grainy Instagram-esque Christmas 1972 snapshots, learning to walk on the moss green carpet. and i see him on the same green carpet in May, with the paramedics around us, and all the 39 years between. all equally vivid. it makes my eyes hurt.
yet as we dismantle and sort and clean, the bones of the house grow unfamiliar and strange. i see things i’ve never laid eyes on, things de-coupled from their stories and their contexts. and i am sad, sniffing about unmoored, a dog searching for its master. i look for my grandfather in the vacuum tubes and the tools and the dust and his 1931 First-Prize-winning hand-drawn map of Australia, marked Clifton, age eleven years, that we found in the back of the basement last night.
i look, but i find him again and again on the green carpet, until my brain clamps down and says no more. he is not here. he is gone. now you go, too. vacuum. wipe. sort.
my grandfather was neither packrat nor hoarder, and he was frugal for the most part and loathe to buy new what could yet be fixed or made serviceable. still, forty-five years in the same house yields Stuff, in copious amounts. stuff not touched or cleaned or seen for years. stuff with its stories forever untold, that none of us understand or can make sense of. stuff that my uncle and my father will take today to the dump, and pay to leave.
last night my uncle pried open the enormous canister of the 1967 Central Vac and i managed somehow to dump half of its contents on the basement floor. i inhaled things no human body has any business inhaling, including what i swear was the fur of a dog who’s been dead since i was in high school. you are welcome, eventual buyer of the family home: this is my body, broken for you. i think i have a hairball.
this is part of the circle of life, in our late 20th-century/21st century existences in this privileged part of the world. our elders grow old and die or move to nursing homes, and we cart away decades of precious things that have devolved somehow into crap, and make landfill, and squirrel a few items aside for another generation to deal with when we go.
there are a few billion of us living this way. the rest, we are taught to assume, aspire to it. we get pimped new stuff everywhere we turn.
the math is suspect.
***
before Dave & i die, we should probably clean the shed, for the sake of our children and the grandchildren who do not exist yet. but here’s the ugly truth: we don’t know what to do with the stuff in the shed.
it’s probably useful, if we could actually identify what’s in there or lay hands to most of it. same goes for the upstairs closet. we might need it. we don’t know. life is uncertain. there’s a hurricane on the way.
here’s the problem. stuff is stories. stuff is both aspirational and grounding, a tether to who we think we are.
even this so-called virtual, where we can trade in actual stories, is no antidote.
sure, i like the internet because my clutter stays mostly hidden, ephemeral. admittedly, my semi-defunct delicious account is a poorly annotated mess, and my laptop’s colonized with programs i ended up not using, but the absolute stunning beauty of the world of bits and bites is its immateriality. poof! now you see it, now it floats like a cyberjunk satellite in an orbit you need never encounter again. (this quality became a lot more appealing after auto-save was invented, admittedly).
and yeh, digital clutter is a marginal improvement, at least for safety purposes. paper burns, after all. i own more books than i will ever read in this life, even if you locked me in the attic for decades with nothing but books and a bucket of fishheads to sustain me. i have paperwork stuffed away in files that i vaguely suspect no one will ever look at again. every surface of my kitchen is plastered with folksy child-made art collages leaking glue and wasting trees left, right, and centre.
but. all of it, digital and trip-over-able, mostly gets in the way of living. it demands. it wants cleaning, curating, sorting, attending to. it wants time. it wants you to buy matching oven mitts.
someday, my children or their children or some poor sot will have to dig their way through what i leave behind on this planet when i leave it. you too. what the hell do i want them to find?
my grandmother’s Art Deco wedding china? my grandfather’s WWII documents? maybe, if i can remember to tell them the stories beforehand. maybe photos – whether albums or holographs, it doesn’t matter. maybe a couple of beautiful things that have some monetary value: art or antiques, perhaps, that they can sell or keep. that’d be thoughtful of me, if only i owned stuff like that.
maybe the blog. Thomas King said, “The truth about stories is that’s all we are.” but really. are they going to read it?
at least it doesn’t require vacuuming.
…what about you? what are you keeping? what do you want to be keeping?
(and while i’m cleaning the shed: anybody need a free Supercycle ten-speed, circa 1984? it’s on the street outside my house: finders-keepers. huzzah).




August 26th, 2011 at 1:40 pm
My grandmother is a recently widowed 82-year-old woman with more than enough spunk left to make me think she’ll be around for another 30 years. Since my grandfather died, though, she has been sifting and sorting and organizing things and memories into albums to give to people. (She also gave me the watch off her wrist when I complimented her on it. There was no talking her out of it.) It makes me uncomfortable because it seems like she’s getting ready to die, but it’s also a practical and lovely thing for her to do. Sigh.
August 26th, 2011 at 1:58 pm
Oh, somehow, I have avoided this. I wasn’t around or responsible for my grandparents’ things. When my father died, we had been estranged for so long, others took care of HIS stuff. I didn’t know his stories at all. My mom? She practically erased her life. I have a few boxes of pictures she gave me years before her death. At her house? Nary a memento. She was unhappy with her choices. The past depressed her so she scrubbed it away.
Okay. Now that is depressing.
I don’t know how to transmit stories from one generation to another these days. I just know how much I wish I KNEW my family’s stories.
August 26th, 2011 at 2:32 pm
We’re renting, a big house, owned by a former UC Berkeley entomologist. (He’s 97 and still kicking.) His stuff is still cluttering up the garage. The kids found a rifle case in the basement; in the garage there’s all kinds of cool stuff including
butterfly nets
a mold, material, & heating element for making your own bullets
guides to beekeeping
sailmaking tools
umpteen jars of assorted screws and nails of all gauges
branding irons for cattle, with the family brand
etc. All worthless and priceless at the same time. And that’s AFTER his son (70) cleared out the place. What a character the guy must be.
August 26th, 2011 at 3:08 pm
You better get that bike up on ebay. All you have to do is say something is from 1984 to a hipster and they will buy it for 10x the value.
August 26th, 2011 at 3:09 pm
We deal with this issue almost constantly. When you live in a house (ok, technically a basement, but there’s no “rest of the house”, so we just call it The Bunker) that literally has no closets (because we built it ourselves and really,the last thing I wanted to do was spend time and money building something to store our crap), you learn about Stuff. With a capital S. I’ve become every pack rat’s nightmare: I beg my friends with cluttered houses to let me come over and “declutter” (translation: throw away whatever you don’t have room for).
The problem with most of the issue we seem to have around clutter is we keep EVERYthing. Thus, the things that really do have true value to us become buried under the stuff we just can’t bring ourselves to get rid of because we might need it. My solution to that has been, put it (whatever you think you might need) away for a year. Somewhere you can’t see it. If you don’t need it, get rid of it.
Ya gotta draw a line somewhere, after all. Otherwise you wind up on a reality show on TLC.
August 26th, 2011 at 3:24 pm
My youngest daughter is cleaning out HER stuff this week – on her way to your fair island to go to school…. it got me thinking – the amount of STUFF that my 18 year old was buried under in that room of hers! Did *I* teach her that?
I don’t even want to think about MY stuff.
When I go to visit my folks, they make me write my name on masking tape and put it on the stuff I want once they’re gone. It’s a bit creepy, and I wonder about shipping it, and where I’m going to put it once it’s here and can I replace something I already own with theirs? I’ll have to buy a bigger house if all my masking-taped stuff is shipped up here someday.
I think I need to be lighter, to start uncluttering. To stop wanting and acquiring. But I have trouble – it’s all imbued with sentiment and I can’t divorce it. I know it’s just, well, stuff… but I hold onto things. There’s worry there too (“what if i get rid of this and then need it?”) – what if I find myself in need?
Fascinating blog, Bonnie. If I lived closer I’d snap up that bike, for sure.
August 26th, 2011 at 3:52 pm
Can I just say your writing is getting better and better all the time? Because it is. You’ve managed to convey that smothering-under-stuff feeling without turning it into an incoherent rant like I did when FIL died and we had to clean up.
I had this discussion with Michael’s uncle this summer when we visited their cottage. They own a three bedroom house with garage – all full of stuff; a trailer home in Florida – likewise full of stuff; and the aforementioned cottage, which has four bedrooms and is fully furnished. Plus has a garage full of – you guessed it – stuff. THREE HOUSES FULL OF STUFF. They are not hoarders exactly; they have just accumulated a ridiculous number of possessions. It’s something I will never understand, really.
August 26th, 2011 at 4:08 pm
There’s always too much of the wrong kind of stuff and never enough of the right kinds of stuff. But it’s only the right kind for a short time, then it starts all over again.
I fight with this everyday. I want simpler. It’s a work in progress.
Will you frame Clifton’s map? Prize winning maps are pretty special. And if you have a line up for that 10 speed, send the overflow to my house, I have one in the shed too.
August 26th, 2011 at 5:12 pm
My in-laws own a house in the country and a condo in town. In spring they decided to sell the country house & made all the kids (4 + 2 kids-in-law + 4 grandkids) help them clean it out. So we got a dumpster and pretty much emptied the house into it. I mean, we picked out a few things we loved but the rest, well, I don’t *need* 6 lampshades, useful as they may be… I have my own house which is already full of crap… My in-laws were so hurt. They were hurt that we didn’t find valuable things they had found valuable, or had an affection for. —- There’s a lesson in there, though I’m still not sure what it is.
August 26th, 2011 at 5:49 pm
I avoid stuff like the plague I believe it is. Meanwhile, my boys and my husband are pack rats. It can make for fractious cohabiting, sometimes. And yet. When my mother and grandmother died, it was left to my brother to dismantle their apartments. I was far away and taking care of two young children. And somehow I feel less able to gain closure on their deaths, because I was not there to touch their stuff and make the hard decisions about its destination.
So maybe there’s some use after all to a life’s debris.
August 26th, 2011 at 5:51 pm
That’s cohabitATing. Yep.
August 26th, 2011 at 7:10 pm
Before my grandma died she moved from her apartment to a hospital room, and we had to clean her apartment. Before the apartment she was in a house, and so things HAD been sorted prior to that. Still. The sheer volume of crap was unbelievable. My cousin was quoted as saying “This is a reason NOT to give your grandmother crappy knick-knacks for Christmas and birthdays.” YES.
Her whole life, she had collected salt-and-pepper shakers. She had china cabinets full of salt-and-pepper shakers. When she died, those were all divided among her three children who – as far as I know – still have them boxed up. When my mom dies, will I get these salt-and-pepper shakers? I think they will need someone to love them.
August 26th, 2011 at 7:25 pm
yes, i suppose the cleaning of things does provide a certain form of closure. and yes, i’d be hurt if my loved ones didn’t want the treasures i’ll inevitably hold on to.
best to burn them all myself, except a few oddities to leave behind, perhaps?
i sound flip. i don’t mean to. in truth, i had my father shove an ancient vinyl laZboy of my grandfather’s (replete with duct tape) into our shed today, because i thought it needed someone to love it. sigh.
we anthropomorphize. we try to keep people with us. we buy new stuff anyway. we are a mess, folks. too much change in too few generations, i think…once we kept things and passed them on b/c they represented hard-won effort. in a world of scarcity, passing things on to the next generation is indeed a gift. in a world of excess…what is it?
August 26th, 2011 at 7:39 pm
When m mother died, my sister and brother and I satin her house and took turns claiming the stuff we wanted. It is one of my favorite memories of her death (sounds odd, know, but losing someone you love also brings forth many non-material gifts). The rule was one at a time, and we had to have a reason… a memory that made that object important (mom’s splattered, margin-written cookbook, for example; the candy dish that I dusted every week for chores). That’s when I knew I was a “grown up”, somehow. That’s how we worked through it. Once the stories were finally finished, we had an estate sale for the rest.
So, it wasn’t the stuff (though it still smarts that my brother got that cookbook), it was the memories that each object embodied that were important. The stuff was the memory delivery system.
August 26th, 2011 at 7:40 pm
Forgive above typos. My iPad seems to have a mind of it’s own.
August 26th, 2011 at 9:17 pm
It’s me, Bonnie…. and I’m off this very minute to my father-in-laws house estate sale. My husband is sitting in the car packed with all his own childhood memories and sale items..and …funny facebook chose to highlight this very article from you… life has a path I guess! I’ll talk to you later… K.
August 26th, 2011 at 11:50 pm
I’m very anti-stuff at the moment and I’ve possibly always been that way. Given we’ve just welcomed a new family member, our stuff is multiplying like proverbial rabbits. Thankfully we only live in a very small two bedroom place, so there is only so much stuff we can physically keep hold of, but still I feel like we’re overrun and weighed down. We even asked for charity donations in lieu of new baby gifts, and still the stuff arrives. And keeps arriving.
Anyway, all this to say I could very much relate to this post. And when the time comes our little family to move somewhere slightly bigger (as we are or possibly have already have outgrown this place) I will be thankful we don’t have too much stuff to cart with us. For us, when we get new stuff in, often that means we have to get some old stuff out. So the big clean out that has coincided with the new baby arriving has been cleansing, to say the least!
xo
August 27th, 2011 at 3:19 am
This is a lovely post. It’s so lovely that it kinda makes me feel bad about being incapable of nostalgia. I’ve already told my mother when she dies I’m having a combination wake and garage sale and clearing out her house. She was less amused by this than I expected.
August 27th, 2011 at 1:08 pm
This resonates today but from a different angle. I have been attempting at various times recently to deal with my paper jungle. Trouble is I start reading this bits and pieces and time flies by. I have no discipline. Then we were handed down a bag full of bionicles. I am pleased it was so much fun for us to build them together while watching the Bionicles movie given to us from someone else. Yet, this morning when younger boy dumped the parts all over the floor again and I stepped on one piece coffee-in-hand, I was less pleased.
I clicked back to last post and was even more moved this time. Thank you for sharing this part of your journey with us.
August 27th, 2011 at 5:02 pm
I have such a love/hate relationship with my stuff. We’ve moved internationally about 6 times in the last 10 years, so what I still have, I find that I care about. Passionately. But really, why? It’s as if stuff gains virtue through age and the fact that it’s still here, rather through any intrinsic or even sentimental value. I go to my neighbour’s garage sales and I don’t want their old junk. But I do still want. want want want. And I’m sick of it, really.
August 27th, 2011 at 10:00 pm
Superior Sanitation just had a great deal on… $110 for a dumpster for a week…fill it up ( as long as it’s not construction materials ) …and they’ll take it away…
we got one 6x6x12 and filed it 2/3′s full…our house still looks like a bomb went off but we got rid of a lot of “stuff” that we really really didn’t need…
getting there..
and yes….we have too much stuff…all of us..
August 27th, 2011 at 11:01 pm
I am a pack rat. I have gotten better in some respects… as you get older, you realize it is simply impossible to hang onto everything. But I do realize I have a ways to go still. ; ) Especially if we decide to move into a condo in the next few years, as I know my dh would like to do. My parents are starting to make noises about downsiziing, & my mother tells me I have to bring (& fill) an empty suitcase each time I come home now, or else someday I’m going to come home & my old stuff will be gone. :p
Two? summers ago, we hauled a bunch of boxes up from the basement & went through them. I blogged about it. My sister rolled her eyes & said, “I don’t know why I need to be here, this is all Lori’s stuff.” The first three boxes we opened were all hers. ; )
August 28th, 2011 at 9:30 pm
It hits me sometimes, the stories attached to things and how they all just evaporate once people leave us. It’s sad, and almost wonderful, all those secrets. The old oil can in my BF’s father’s workshop was just a can to me-to him, it’s the place his Dad stored tidbits since he was a child. It was weighed with meaning, impossible to replace or quantify.
I am attached to little. My mother’s teacups, and mine. My mother’s rosary. The picture of the girls when I first brought Rosalyn home. That’s about it. I lost all the stories so long ago that most things have no meaning that way. Memory sits in my head safely stored.
And I hate crap. I’m forever tossing stuff but with children, I feel like I can’t win.
August 29th, 2011 at 12:13 am
I feel like I’m tossing out stuff with one hand and buying new stuff with the other. They obviously don’t talk to each other like they should. I keep trying to remind myself of the same thing you mentioned: someday a person I love will have to sort through my junk. At this point they would have to love me a lot to go through the garage, so I’d better clean it out. But then there is always ice cream to be had or movies to be watched, and so the cycle continues.
August 29th, 2011 at 12:04 pm
I have a suitcase of my children’s ‘firsts’ -first sleeper, first blanket. I am a terrible clutter-bug but that is due to a busy lifestyle and I don’t mind tossing when inspired. My husband, on the other hand, would keep a gum wrapper if the right person owned it first. He’s terribly nostalgic. (Maybe he’s to blame for my quick ability to toss my kid’s masterpieces -it’d be some sorry situation if we were equally sentimental)
August 30th, 2011 at 9:36 am
We moved 10 times in our first nine years, always culling and therefore never accumulating too much stuff. In a few months we will be leaving here after six years and two children and I am afraid, very afraid. Not of moving, but of the sheer volume of stuffage. Plus, as this next move is meant to be temporary there will be no clear direction about what we will need for where we end up.
Growing up, whenever we would have company we would run around beforehand gathering up ‘stuff’ and dumping it in my parent’s room. I hated the disorder of it. The hurried shoving of unsightly piles, the need to move things that would only need to be moved again (and often again and again) before finding a resting place or the rubbish bin. I’ve always liked expanses of empty spaces and a few well-organised closets.
But then you live and you just gradually accumulate. It’s even intentional at times. However, I suspect that when we’re in the throes of packing I will be vowing to have less stuff when it comes to the next move!
August 30th, 2011 at 5:48 pm
sigh.
there is SO MUCH STUFF at my mother’s house.
it is ephemeral and it is not. i will cry if anything ends up in a dumpster – i want it all to go to a GOOD HOME.
also? instagram-esque is a fabulous back-formation.
August 31st, 2011 at 9:19 pm
My mom was good about de-crapping her stuff. Now that she has passed, the same task awaits us in Florida.
We don’t know what to do with damned ceramic clowns.
August 31st, 2011 at 10:33 pm
…y’know, ceramic clowns can be surprisingly hot on Ebay. do not ask how i know this. but if any of them are also cookie jars, you’re in the money.
so sorry about your mum, Alan, and the task ahead.
September 5th, 2011 at 4:39 am
The Stuff … it wants you to buy oven mitts. Perfect. Yes it does. Even more pernicious, it wants you to buy stuff for IT. Organizing stuff, shelves, plastic sorting bins. More stuff for stuffing the stuff into.
Loved this post for your writing & for all I recognize here. Oh my the stuff torments me, because, god help me, like you I anthropomorphize; I am sentimental and when I look at the stuffed lobster I see it in the corner of my grandparent’s kitchen, lording over the wall-mounted telephone from his regal place on top of the corner cabinet. I do not know where the lobster ended up but I kept the corner cabinet. In it, stuck to the door where my grandmother placed it years & years ago, I have saved the taxi phone number card to & the fire dept number for a small town in Ontario.
*sigh*