Tue 7 Feb 2012
all the best things she said
Posted by bon under coping stuff, relationship stuff
[40] Comments
the day after. Susan’s gone.
i dreamed about her yesterday morning. we were some kind of Thelma and Louise, secret agents laughing, doing vague, crazy dream-things until little feet woke me at 5:45 am and i rose blurry from the fog and i wondered.
and then i waited – edgy and wrong – all day, and then i heard.
i like to imagine the dream was her saying goodbye. i like to imagine i will see her in the stars. i don’t know if i really believe either of these things, but i leave the door cracked to the possibility.
i do know that i will look at the sky with wonder for the rest of my life, because she taught me.
she will always be a teacher, in my mind. she was my friend, as she was a thousand people’s friend. she was Marty‘s friend, particularly: the real Thelma to her Louise. thank you, Marty, for sharing her. you two were damn lucky in each other.
Susan was one of my very first blogging friends. one of the first people who opened this space up and grabbed me with words by the bones of my wrists, building for me a world of the real that has nothing to do with in the flesh.
except when the flesh has ceased and you know there will be no more words. and you say to no one in particular, hey, there seems to be a Volkswagen parked on my chest. it’s made of cement. and then your heart swells up and leaks out your eyes.
this is my first real experience of what it means to lose one of our own. i see us all out here as parts of a web, knots in an enormous 3D crocheted blanket snarled together like one of Dave’s rhizomes, all marvellously, intricately interconnected.
for me, Susan was one of the key knots, a touchstone by which I knew and understood the whole. the empty space that was hers, then, is distributed and strange, the grief ephemeral and yet amplified.
she was not mine, or yours, i know. yet she gave herself to us.
last night, after the kids and i lay in their little beds in their new room under a ceiling speckled with projected stars, i came downstairs and i looked up the comments she’d left here, over the years.
seventy-odd little messages over nearly five years, plus a couple of dozen emails. one afternoon together, running in the rain. gifts, each one.
Susan was adamant that what matters in life – what survives – is what we put into the world: publications and people.
i sat here last night re-reading these comments like old love letters, smiling through the tears that stung and dropped. and i thought, this is what we blog for.
i celebrate her tonight through a few of her words. private words, scattered across my own…augmenting them, making them more. they were a gift to me, these, and the other hundred messages or so. maybe i’m just giddy with the gravity of sorrow and all, but i keep thinking, don’t bogart that Susan. share.
inhale deep, while you’re here. breathe her in.
***
March, 2007. it has always been her perspective on the term “mommyblogger” that gave it dignity, for me:
Personally, I love the term mommyblogger when applied correctly to those
of us who write about our kids and delight in it (and who aren’t currently professional
writers or claim other labels and reject the term).
It implies and acknowledges the community inherent in child-raising, and it gives
voice to the nameless thousands out there who have for centuries carried babies, held
little hands, wiped noses, and helped children learn.
The thousands — millions — tens of millions — who give their all to helping these little children
learn to talk, read, cook, laugh, love, and find themselves in a big, scary world.
The tens of millions who,
in a world of “Dr” this and “Mr” that, are known primarily by one name — Mommy.
I am proud to be a Mommy, and proud to be a mommyblogger. That’s my choice,
but right now it feels pretty wonderful.
- whymommy
May, 2008. her capacity for presence, even from far away, floored me. the one time i met her, she made me feel like i was the only person in the world. when her gaze was trained on you, literally or figuratively, you had her whole heart for a minute.
Thinking of you today.
My neighbor over the fence and I chatted about you today. We explained to her mother just
how far away PEI is, and how your writing resonates with our souls. She and I have never
talked much, but as we shared our favorites and wished you well, it was amazing to see.
- whymommy
June, 2008. i wrote about pipers at a funeral, just a musing. and she shot straight back, from the hip. i had forgotten this one, until last night. it took my breath. please read. i don’t think Susan will ever be forgotten, but i hear her. can we find a way to honour this, in our big old crocheted blanket way?
Bon,
I don’t want tears and mournful songs at my funeral. I want parents and children to
gather, to take my children in their arms, and to hug them closely when I can’t anymore.
They can sing if they like, but I really just hope that friends and family will focus on life, and a
future that will encompass my children even when
I am no longer here to set up playdates and parties. I don’t mind if everyone
forgets me, but I could not bear it if they forgot my children.
- whymommy
April, 2010. she was a rocket scientist, which makes me smile. i can barely add six digits. but we were both researchers at heart, for all the disciplinary differences, lovers of ideas and knowledge. what i realized last night is that we were bound, too, by journeys that both confronted the spectre of separating parent from child, in death. my writing began there, and has ended in healing. would that Susan’s trajectory could have been so clean.
Your voice is a dear one to me, and I am forever grateful that you did reach out on that day.
You have taught me so much about loss, and about daring to move on, while
never, ever forgetting.
Last week I heard the name “Finn,” and I snapped to attention, head swiveling so fast
to see the little boy being called in the park. I thought for sure it must have been a mistake,
and, indeed, he had already disappeared behind the
climbing tree. I only caught a glimpse of his sneakers.
I thought of you, then, and Finn and Oscar and Posey and Dave, and wanted to tell you.
I know because of you that telling you that I remember him doesn’t hurt.
I hope, at least, that that is still true.
I remember Finn, and I am able to talk now to babylost mamas with an open heart,
not running away from the topic, all because of you.
-whymommy
November, 2011. the last comment she left me. it makes me nod. yep: recognizing luck, counselling belief in beauty, in hope. stretching beyond me to the wisdom of perspective. yeh, that was Susan.
My map? Gone, pressed neatly into the family Bible, history upon history,
not mattering in the end. In the end, all I have is this hand I hold, and I cling tightly,
for he is all that I have.
There is beauty in relationships yet, bon … wait for it, the beauty will surprise you
again even while you mourn the losses of ten.
You are lucky in yours, as I am in mine.
- Susan @Whymommy
this was my friend, her generosity, her warmth, her incredible capacity to give of herself. the comment is remarkably like her final post: in the end, she was not ours, but Curt’s. it lifts the Volkswagen off my chest a little to know that she had that kind of love to hold her and carry her.
i am glad there is no more pain, for her. but it hurts me to think there will be no more words. she put so much of herself – so much beauty and thoughtfulness – into her words.
what words of hers do you have? in your comments stream, or from FB, or just from her own blog? what are your favourites? what can you share?
please don’t bogart that Susan. i am not quite ready to stop hearing from her.
40 Responses to “ all the best things she said ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from - Planting Dandelions Planting Dandelions
February 10th, 2012 at 12:24 pm[...] All the Best Things She Said by Bon Stewart [...]
-
Pingback from out, out brief candle | cribchronicles.com
June 15th, 2012 at 1:19 pm[...] there would be no thousands of comments and conversations and networks formed here over years, no traces of friends found and since gone and i would be the lesser. and i know [...]
-
Pingback from what produsage is and why it matters | theory.cribchronicles.com
July 3rd, 2012 at 9:05 am[...] friendships became fleshed out by face-to-face meetings. Shared histories evolved, preserved in the amber of our blog archives. I became a consumer of the medium, as well as a [...]




February 7th, 2012 at 10:23 pm
oh, bon. this made me a little weepy, all over again. wow.
February 7th, 2012 at 10:32 pm
what breaks my heart, here, is that i REMEMBER some of these comments — that we are bound up, all of us, so tightly in one another.
i grieve with you.
February 7th, 2012 at 10:34 pm
oh oh oh- i am a distant witness to her. but in your remembrance there’s the reminder that the witnesses are eventually all there is. i type and cry. and witness.
February 7th, 2012 at 10:34 pm
Breathtaking.
I did not know Susan, but I followed her blog and her speech at BlogHer ’10 was the very first voice I heard at my one and only blogging conference. To me, she represented what was best about blogging, and I will miss her voice terribly.
February 7th, 2012 at 10:36 pm
last night I imagined her in the sky, able to see the whole planet at a glance and each of us a tiny red speck. She could see a colourful representation of all the hearts she touched and she could swoop down and visit us and turn our speck to purple.
February 7th, 2012 at 10:43 pm
Beautiful. Thanks for sharing.
February 7th, 2012 at 11:02 pm
Crying again. Beautiful: this, you, her.
February 7th, 2012 at 11:02 pm
i didn’t know susan.
but when i read that she believed all that we leave behind is our words and our people, i recognized a kindred soul.
i’m sorry for your grief and grateful for your words.
February 7th, 2012 at 11:08 pm
thank you for sharing this with us, bon. xoxo
February 7th, 2012 at 11:10 pm
In her blog page titled, “Princess Army” (http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com/princess-army/) Susan wrote:
“Once upon a time, I thought that admitting my weaknesses and fears on the internet would make people think less of me, both here and in the professional world. I never foresaw the real effect of sharing this journey with you and encouraging you in your own struggles via your blogs and Facebook – together, we have all become stronger.”
I still struggle to put the raw me out there in my blog sometimes – and I marvel at how you and Susan and countless others do it. But I am learning and getting stronger for the struggle.
Even though her struggle is over, her words will resonate and continue to make stronger you, we who knew her (even tangentially), and maybe even people yet to meet her. Thanks, Bon, for introducing me to Susan and for allowing me to share her journey and yours.
February 7th, 2012 at 11:10 pm
Wow. This post took my breath away. Bon, she loved you very much. This is such a beautiful tribute to her. I’m not ready to stop hearing her words either.
February 7th, 2012 at 11:13 pm
Beautiful, Bon. I tried to read it all, but had to stop. My best friend, the Thelma to my Louise, was diagnosed with cancer and given about 18 months to live around Christmas holidays. She has also left comments on my blog, and we tweet/email often. Your post reminded me to compile all the great conversations together to keep for this kind of moment. Which, if I were to be honest, I hope never comes. I know it will, and that makes the now so bittersweet.
So sorry for your loss.
February 7th, 2012 at 11:18 pm
This is so beautiful. Thank you for saying what I haven’t even begun to untangle… and that’s me without the proximity that you had (and have) to her. xo
February 7th, 2012 at 11:19 pm
thank you…thank you for this
February 7th, 2012 at 11:39 pm
This honors her so perfectly. Thank you for this, Bon.
February 8th, 2012 at 12:13 am
I chatted with her a few times about science. In a blogging world where most of my friends were English majors, it was super-exciting for me to know a real live rocket scientist, especially one involved with NASA!
From Susan on 2010 post titled Team WhyMommy’s Virtual Science Fair –
“Neil, you had me at “geeky attraction to science.”
It’s too bad your professors let you get away with faking the data in high school — and even more so that they didn’t teach you something even more important. A good experiment has a hypothesis. A GREAT experiment has a null hypothesis — so that even if the answer isn’t what you expected, you learn something. That way, even if your wheat doesn’t grow, you’ve learned something — for instance that that kind of wheat can’t be relied upon to feed the world.
Funny thing, science. We teach children the rules so well and so often that sometimes we forget to teach how to channel every child’s natural curiosity into something productive. Even if it’s a null result.
Or a lunchables sandwich.
This was fun, Neil — thank you! I’ve enjoyed getting to know you on Twitter too!”
February 8th, 2012 at 8:55 am
Bon, this was so beautiful. I hope that one day I get to meet you too. The day you two met was so special to you both.
February 8th, 2012 at 9:37 am
Such a lovely post. Mine doesn’t feel like a volkswagon on my chest, more like my heart is in a vise.
I’m going to go back and look for her comments and e-mails. What a tremendous comfort they will be.
February 8th, 2012 at 9:39 am
Sarah, exactly. we are all bound up here, histories overlapping like threads, sometimes parallel, sometimes tangled. in looking over those old comments, whole choral conversations emerged.
i’d like to build a small record of part of those: if you have old comments of Susan’s that are “her,” that reflect her thoughtfulness and generosity, please share them here. like a collage of who she was to all of us.
February 8th, 2012 at 9:54 am
An elegy to your friend… beautifully and openly shared. Our knobby interwebz blanket bears witness to that love and meaning. XO.
February 8th, 2012 at 10:17 am
I wrote once, upon hearing of the death of someone from my hometown, about talking to my oldest daughter about dying. I wrote the post for myself, not really thinking about its impact one anyone, really just wanting to work through grieving and mortality.
Susan came, and as she did from time to time, she left a comment.
Yes. This.
How lucky was I to find this tonight?
Beautiful. (thankyou)
I was so grateful to have brought her some measure of confort, even unwittingly. Later she and I emailed about an idea she had. She had a way of breathing life into her words, like a scenic designer making the willows seem to dance and the stars to flirt with the indigo ofthe sky.
http://amandamagee.com/2010/03/our-time/
February 8th, 2012 at 11:22 am
this is a great honor + tribute to a wonderful woman. Let’s keep her wise words living online. xo thank you.
February 8th, 2012 at 11:49 am
this was a charity that she loved. I am trying to work with them on a little project in 2012. That would be.incredible. Thanks, Amy! YES! My charity of choice.right now is Metavivors, which supports research on metastatic cancer like nobody’s business! As they run it out of their cancer support group turned 501(c)3, they take no overhead other than paypal fees (so don’t send via paypal) and fund incredible grants, while helping.g metastatic women set up heir own support groups. The site is educational and hopeful, and the women are inspiring.
This would be very, very cool.
Happy Thanksgiving, Amy! I am so grateful to know beautifilly-minded, generous women like you!
February 8th, 2012 at 1:06 pm
Thank you for sharing this Bon. I tried (not nearly as elequantly as you) to blog about my memories of Susan, you can find it here: http://www.educatingjackie.com/2012/02/twinkle-twinkle-little-star.html
February 8th, 2012 at 1:49 pm
Bon,
I knew of Susan through you and I too have been more than touched by her. She was a gift to many. As are you. Thank you for sharing both her and yourself with us. I so appreciate it.
Jane
February 8th, 2012 at 4:16 pm
What an elegant idea, to honor a beloved blogger through the words she shared with you. I’m sad again to lose her, but stunned by the unbelievable power of this simple tribute. xoxo.
February 8th, 2012 at 5:08 pm
Thank you for this.
February 8th, 2012 at 6:47 pm
I took my kids out on Monday night to admire the almost full moon and I thought of Susan. I had not heard the news yet. But because of her, I made that little extra time to show my boy and girl the full moon and explain some of the stars and they stared up at the sky in awe and delight. She has made hundreds of thousands of ripples of difference to us in the blogosphere. I wish I could hug her children for her.
February 8th, 2012 at 9:20 pm
Dear Bon,
I read your post this morning before leaving to take my mother to Susan’s funeral. I had to catch my breath when I realized that I was the over the fence neighbor(more accurately the daughter of the neighbor)that Susan mentioned in her email to you. I remember talking with her that day about all the amazing bloggers I had discovered through her blog. Susan’s was my first, my “gateway” blog, introducing me to an entire world of eloquent writers, artists, teachers, mothers and other wonderful, and in my opinion, brave souls willing to share of themselves so publically so that those of us who read their words feel just a little less alone as we try to make sense of a world that often doesn’t make sense. For that I am forever grateful to Susan and my life is forever changed.
We lost my father to cancer just a few short months before Susan’s own diagnosis. The day he died Susan and her boys came to the house with homemade cookies. Such a simple gesture but it meant so much. I don’t think I would have eaten at all those first few days if it weren’t for those cookies. Much later, she and my mother were talking cancer treatments and the basic unfairness of it all when my mother asked her “Aren’t you just so angry?” I will never forget her response. She said, “I don’t have time to be angry.” How you respond to what life throws at you is a choice. She chose to be happy and make the very most of the time afforded to her. I did not know her well but I learned so much from her example. There were smiles and hugs and laughing, playing children at the reception following the service today. I think Susan would be pleased.
February 8th, 2012 at 9:41 pm
Cheryl, gasp.
sitting here with tears running down my face again. thank you, for speaking up, for saying it was you. feels like Susan is still giving gifts, making connections, with her generous spirit.
i am glad there were playing children at the reception today. i am still stunned – because out here, in the ether, it is harder to mark the rituality and physicality of death – that you were at her funeral. that she is truly that gone. so it is, i guess. so it must be.
“i don’t have time to be angry.” just sitting with that for a second. the first thing Susan ever wrote that really drew me into her blog hit me very much like that statement just did: a window into a worldview never imagined.
it suddenly occurs to me that none of us have time to be angry. thank you, Cheryl, more than i can say.
February 9th, 2012 at 12:37 am
Oh my that took my breath away. I’m working on a book of stories of Susan for her boys and reading what she wanted at her funeral hours after I’ve attended her funeral has shaken me.
I stood in the hall this afternoon and watched her sweet boys munching on cookies, teasing each other and wrestling. Smiling.
And I thought how beautiful they are.
February 9th, 2012 at 4:38 am
Weeping at this beautiful post, and again at Cheryl’s exquisite comment.
I heard Susan speak at BlogHer in New York. She had such grace.
x
February 9th, 2012 at 7:04 am
What a beautiful tribute. Thank you for sharing so deeply.
BTW, Susan’s friend Minky / Stephanie is collecting posts about Susan on her blog – you should link this up http://dialmforminky.com/2012/02/stop-all-the-clocks/
February 9th, 2012 at 9:32 am
Dear Bon,
I let a day go by before resolving to come back here and comment. It was one of those “well no one cares to read what I have to say out here in one of those most distant and thready parts of the web. But…in honor of Tilla…and Susan I will share. I’ll try to be brief.
I lost my best friend to inflammatory breast cancer in 1992. She was my soulmate. She was that sort of friend you are lucky to have only once in life. She was 37. She had 2 small children. She was nursing the youngest when she was diagnosed (‘You have mastitis from nursing’ they told her at first). Tilla was an exquisitely expert nurse and educator (how we met, I was a nurse educator then too). She knew better.
Tilla’s way of coping was to deny…to the end. She lived in continual hope of a cure and brushed off her recurrence symptoms as strained muscles, and colds from her boys, and such. We never said good bye. The last time I saw her she drug herself to my home to greet my newborn son. We shared stuff like that…the big life events. And…the small stuff. And all the things that best friends do.
So…what does Tilla have to do with Susan?
I ‘found’ your blog (and my way to Susan) this way: I heard George Siemens speak at a conference in 2008. George online led me to Dave (Cormier) online…led me to your lovely space (I have been lurking here for a while. I aspire to write as beautifully and as often. I am not confident in my online self so much as others. I don’t share much). Then…I followed you to Susan.
Susan’s IBC experience immediately struck that Tilla nerve. I could not stay away. Reading and occasionally speaking to Susan via comments to let her know that one of those web connections was lifting her up became a way to honor Tilla and to openly recall those first hand IBC experiences she was never that comfortable discussing….our one communication disconnect. I never spoke of Tilla to Susan. Tilla’s time from diagnosis to the end of her battle lost was cruelly swift. It seemed not the sort of thing to share.
So, forgive my intrusion here. But I comment in honor of Tilla, and Susan …both taken far too early but who both touched lives beyond measure.
Thank you for sharing her.
And now fading back to the threads at the margin and still lurking.
February 9th, 2012 at 10:13 pm
I can’t bear to look right now.
But I look out my window – it is summer here in Australia – and see my sons play house and the big shady tree that Susan and I promised each other that we would sit under sipping cool summer drinks while our kids played, someday…
She was my first online friend. She introduced me to twitter, I only joined so I could keep up with her updates while she was in hospital the first time.
Here is the post I wrote when I found out she had gone to hospice… it has a link to the guest post she wrote for me talking about our friendship that I still can’t bear to read.
I will miss her dearly.
February 10th, 2012 at 5:08 pm
Funny, one of the first things I did was go back and search my comments for words of wisdom from her. It’s such a beautiful reminder that our words live on here, after we cease to ourselves. I wonder if we all thought that way how much that would change the internet.
Thanks for this Bon. Sighing, but in an okay way.
February 13th, 2012 at 8:15 am
Am so sorry to hear about your friend, it’s heartbreaking.