Mon 30 Apr 2012
what i wanted to write on Facebook
Posted by bon under coping stuff, mama-baby stuff, milestone stuff, social media meta stuff
[55] Comments
it was 3:20 when we all raced in from the park and scattered.
four people, six different directions. the calculus of families. physics probably says it’s impossible but i have always said pshaw! to physics.
physics wins, of course, in the end: thirty seconds after scattering the two smaller ones were back, pulling me in entirely opposite directions. physics will not allow me to split myself in two.
physics is a damn honey badger.
but i have my own secret calculus: three, not two. sometimes the invisible has its own demands. i said, i am going to the basement now. and then i disappeared. sha-zam. magic.
they followed me, both of them.
but when i pulled out my laptop, they pulled out Lego and Plasticine docile as lambs and there we sat the three of us companionable and so perhaps it was magic after all.
and i made it in time.
i saw the numbers on the clock. i blinked and there he was, small and splayed as they swept him away from me to the bright lights and the yellow gowns flooding the room. dark hair and a trail of blood and one perfect ear and then i could see nothing else, then or now. the window closed. gone again.
i typed into the Facebook status update: “3:24 pm. seven years. happy birthday, Finn.”
***
there really isn’t anything else to say, anymore.
we planted two new baby trees, at the new house, but that was mostly by happenstance. we went over to the old house to see the trees planted that first Mother’s Day, seven springs ago. they are thriving, strong. we bought some cupcakes on the way.
a regular day – life for the living. a cacophony. physics.
until i sat down late last night and opened Facebook again and saw the comments, the likes, the acknowledgements. the love.
for us, i suppose. but for him, too. for a child almost nobody ever met.
each time i write about Finn, i feel a bit skinless, even now.
not because he makes me sad. he never made me sad. his absence made me sad for a long time, but it does not, not anymore.
still. too effusive in my words and you might think me maudlin, unkempt and troubled by grief even after all this time.
too casual in my “liking” of your comments and you might think me crass and cheap and ridiculous.
i do not want to be maudlin, or crass.
i simply want him to be part of my story.
***
seven years ago today, i woke like a bruised thing.
he had been there. i had held him. and i looked ahead and i thought i might choke to death on the silence.
i knew i could not sit, seven years hence, in polite sane company and tell strangers on a park bench: i had a son. he would have been seven today. he’s dead.
in person, in our culture, you cannot do that.
but in the networks of social media, you can. thank Jeebus. some say Facebook acknowledgements take all the human connection out of sorrow and remembrance: perhaps they do, by some people’s definition. but i would say they add back in a whole other dimension of possibility. i do not need you to wail and gnash your teeth on my behalf, especially not anymore. i do not need you to hold me.
i just need a space to speak him, now and then.
Josephine is reaching an age where she is beginning to understand “dead.” Her great-grandfather died last spring, and she has come around to understanding that he isn’t coming back. She knows, vaguely, that she had another brother. Oscar has told her Finn is a star in the sky. I smile, and say maybe he is.
but the other night they were going to bed and Oscar mentioned the stars, and Finn, and suddenly, from her side of the room, a sob.
i don’t want to die, Mummy! she burst out, her voice small and cracked. even when i’m an old lady, Mummy! i don’t want to be lost!
my heart. i went to her and stroked her hair said, of course not, pet. you will never be lost, my love. you are tied to me, to Daddy, to a thousand stories. you will always be my girl.
magical thinking, perhaps. physics might object.
but i write of Finn to tie him to me, to weave him into the fabric of my life. to say, you will always be my boy.
you have given me that space. you have received him, and nodded back, and layered love and kindness where once there was only absence.
he is dead. that is what it is. it is surprisingly okay.
but he is not lost: he exists here. he has a record, like the rest of us.
and more than that, i cannot ask.
so what i wanted to write last night on Facebook was, thank you. just thank you. and yet so much more.
55 Responses to “ what i wanted to write on Facebook ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from The blog is dead. Long live the blog. | Box761
May 5th, 2012 at 1:53 pm[...] like this and this and this and this are out there. This one’s even about letter writing, how can you [...]
-
Pingback from What’s New at University of Venus? Week Ending 12 May 2012 « University of Venus
May 18th, 2012 at 8:00 pm[...] Stewart wrote about how social media can keep us from being lost, about the six key selves of digital identities, and her concerns about EdX, the Harvard + MITx = [...]
-
Pingback from out, out brief candle | cribchronicles.com
June 15th, 2012 at 1:04 pm[...] the end of April, i marked Finn’s birth and death here, as i have every year but the first. i didn’t write of him that first year. the blog [...]





April 30th, 2012 at 2:53 pm
Love you, lady. xo
April 30th, 2012 at 3:02 pm
This . . .
“i just need a space to speak him, now and then.”
Yes.
And? Stunning . . .
April 30th, 2012 at 3:07 pm
Im sitting here tired and sick, waiting for a bus home with Ros when I realized she’s Finn’s age. And suddenly her questions about fire and moving, they stop annoying me. For a moment. Your boy moves through all of us.
April 30th, 2012 at 3:11 pm
you are tied to me and daddy and a thousand stories.
yes.
April 30th, 2012 at 3:21 pm
One of my SAHM geeky things I do is genealogy. I think about the children that didn’t survive. The family didn’t know/remember until I did some digging.
My great-great grandmother had not seven children, but nine. There were two little boys between her first two daughters. Charles died at about 1 1/2 and Carl died at about 2. She was in so much pain that, according to her eldest daughter years later, she demanded that she and her husband go back to Germany so she could “go home and die”. Of course she did not, she lived to have six more children. No one else really remembered those babies. I suspect that in stereotypical Teutonic fashion, she didn’t talk about them after the first pain faded.
But, thanks to the internet, I found their birth records, and have recorded them in the family tree. Because they were little people, who lived and died and should be remembered, even 130 years later.
Memory is good. I am glad you have a place to memorialize.
April 30th, 2012 at 3:27 pm
Yes to this. I was saying to my sister that though my girls are never mentioned by name to me by anyone save herself, they have a footprint of my work life that is big enough to satisfy my need for them to have a story on this earth. But sometimes I too need a space to know that Jordan and Lily were here at one time, that there story has not been so sublimated into my work life as someone who can support families through loss, in loss, after loss. And, this was my sister’s concern about her children who are not here to keeping making new stories. How will it ever be enough?
April 30th, 2012 at 3:32 pm
Maybe it’s not for strangers on park benches, but there sure are alot of us who would sidle up to you without any hesitation to hear every story. We have our own stories now as well – because you and Dave have shared Finn with us – so he’s got a legacy in my life and lots of others’ too. Love and comfort, and happy birthday.
April 30th, 2012 at 3:34 pm
Oh, Bon. God. This is…it. Exactly. It is this village we have where people come and like and nod and hand on back with a pot of soup in the form of a comment that says I get it. Remembering Finn with you seven years later, with seven years of stars woven into the story of you. It is a beautiful rich piece of fabric. xo
April 30th, 2012 at 3:42 pm
Kimberly & Karen…the names leapt out at me.
Charles & Carl: the same name, different versions. to lose both…
Jordan & Lily, Angel Mae & Owen…so many in one family.
i used to be afraid that i would never get to use Finn’s name. writing has been extraordinarily healing in that regard.
thank you, all. i need “like” functionality in order to properly show my appreciation. ;)
April 30th, 2012 at 3:50 pm
I worried a bit when I hit Like, that it was too superficial or casual or something. And of course, I don’t Like Finn’s death. I’m glad you know what I meant.
April 30th, 2012 at 3:52 pm
He is not lost. Thank you for sharing him with us.
April 30th, 2012 at 3:58 pm
Seven years.
I like saying his name.
Happy Birthday Finn. Physics be damned, I like you just the same.
April 30th, 2012 at 4:13 pm
Yes! You’ve articulated it perfectly – be heard, receive bearable and welcome response…keep living. Thank you for speaking ‘aloud’.
April 30th, 2012 at 4:18 pm
My son was also silent when he was born – but somehow he made his way back to us. When you write about Finn, I am transported back to that time. Thank you for sharing these stories of your eternal child. I’m so glad you have found this space to speak him and weave him into the fabric of your life – and ours. Happy Birthday, Finn. x
April 30th, 2012 at 4:19 pm
i hurt, yesterday, for my mom, more because of who she wasn’t than who she was — but the hurt is the same.
and in the midst of hurting, there was finn. you and i share april 29th. it is not a day i would wish anyone to have to share with me. but if it must be shared, you, and especially finn, are wonderful, loving, lovely companions.
April 30th, 2012 at 4:26 pm
Happy birthday sweet Finn. I know how it feels to be one of two who knew a lost baby, it somehow compounds the loss and makes speaking about your child that much harder. But through your sharing of him I feel connected to both you and Finn, Bon, and I am so grateful for that.
April 30th, 2012 at 5:04 pm
So lovely. Thank you for this freshness (for me), this new way of looking at old things. Sometimes I’m too hard on social media and blogging and all of it. This, I get. This I love.
With you here.
xo
April 30th, 2012 at 5:05 pm
The physics of memory and loss and distant twinklings in the sky. Goddamn.
(he said, quietly hoping that no one saw him getting all misty-eyed at work)
April 30th, 2012 at 5:33 pm
Charles and Carl. Yes, same names. Which makes me think she buried one while pregnant with the other. GAH. And she had yet ANOTHER Carl. Her youngest. Whom she had when she was 41. He was developmentally delayed in some way (family legend says he was a dwarf) and lived with his parents until he died, and then with his only sibling that remained in Germany. Gut wrenching, all of it.
April 30th, 2012 at 5:51 pm
Squish. xo
April 30th, 2012 at 7:07 pm
Seven? I had to count on my fingers. Seven. No, there isn’t anything to say anymore…except when there is. I hope you know I’ll always be here in those moments. And I won’t think it crass or maudlin or anything other than what it is. No need to thank. We will always be connected by that number…moving both of us away from that spring seven years ago. {{{hugs}}}
April 30th, 2012 at 7:58 pm
Hi. HI. Yikes, you’re somethin’ else. I don’t presume to know what it would feel like to have Finn swing by these parts but I hope you know that I think of him and that I acknowledge him often.
One of my favourite poems ever is ‘Continuities’ by Walt Whitman. Nothing is ever really lost…
It is perhaps one of the bigger reasons that I didn’t drown when my grandfather died last March (we were very very close and it was my first brush with death). I’ve questioned it since then, but underneath the doubt is the promise, for sure.
I should note that of all the people who endeavor to say something (anything!) to people who are grappling with brand new grief and shock, in my experience, baby-lost mamas are the absolute BEST. I’d almost expect (and allow) them (you) to have this use-anytime trump card, but by-and-large, you’ve all said the best things in the hardest times. I’m not surprised at all, just incredibly grateful.
xo
April 30th, 2012 at 8:49 pm
I like your physics
xo
April 30th, 2012 at 8:58 pm
Oh, Bon. How perfect. How lovely.
Happy birthday, dear Finn. I know I said it on FB as well, but you are loved and missed, dear one. Truly.
xo
April 30th, 2012 at 10:05 pm
This is the first post of yours that has ever made me cry. This is why the internet exists. Always connected. All of us. Even those no longer here. A nod, to you, Dave, Posey, Oscar, and most of all, Finn.
April 30th, 2012 at 10:19 pm
I don’t have any words really. But my thoughts are filled with thankfulness for every word you have ever written about Finn. For making me feel less alone every time.
This.
xo
May 1st, 2012 at 2:10 am
Finn is part of what drew me to you and so he will always be part of you to me. Just like the rest of your family.
May 1st, 2012 at 2:40 am
Finn will always be your boy and Posey and Oscar’s brother. I think it’s wonderful they are learning they once had an older brother. I write this with a tear or two running down my face. I never ever used to be like this until I had kids myself.
Happy birthday, Finn.
May 1st, 2012 at 4:02 am
Thank you for this. It’s beautiful.
Remembering your sweet Finn with you. x
May 1st, 2012 at 10:08 am
Much love.
(Happy birthday, Finn)
May 1st, 2012 at 10:39 am
Wow. Your words, Bon. You arrange them in such a powerful way. Like a symphony.
Happy birthday, Finn.
xxx
May 1st, 2012 at 12:52 pm
Its hard to believe that number. Seven. Wow.
My heart stretches to you.
This is a beautiful, uplifting post. It gives me hope for what is waiting in the wings.
And this, “Physics is a damn honey badger.” Is my favorite thing I’ve read in a long, long while.
Lots of love to you, Bon.
May 1st, 2012 at 2:19 pm
So beautifully written. My son turned one last month which was a wonderful yet emotional celebration…in the background his sister’s tree (Ella would now be 3.5 years old) stood tall in the sunshine enveloping us with her gentle presence. We felt the magic. And as for honey badger’s….one set up camp under my car on safari – I was terrified of him!!
May 1st, 2012 at 3:07 pm
to each of you, thank you.
Alison, i just went back and re-read Continuities, by Whitman. thank you for that.
i bask in the love you all give my child, my children, but especially this child. that you know his name, that he is not lost…it makes my heart quiet. :)
May 1st, 2012 at 4:23 pm
Gorgeous post.
Happy birthday, Finn.
May 1st, 2012 at 4:29 pm
Yes. To this whole, amazing, gorgeous post. I am so glad you (and many more of us) have this space. So much love to you and to your Finn.
May 1st, 2012 at 5:13 pm
Beautiful, just like you. *sniff*
May 1st, 2012 at 5:33 pm
I didn’t realize we are both mothers of Fin(n)s. They are special boys. Ones that should be shared.
May 1st, 2012 at 9:12 pm
Happy birthday, Finn. : ) And (((hugs))) to you, Bon.
Last year, I posted a photo of Katie’s niche at the cemetery on FB. I very rarely talk or write publicly about her outside the “safe” circle of my IRL & online loss mom friends, so I was shocked & delighted at how many people “liked” the photo, & even left comments. It means so much to have them acknowledged, doesn’t it?
May 2nd, 2012 at 11:22 am
When you said that about Charles and Carl, it occurred to me that Posey and Finn have almost the same name too.
Or, if not the same, at least the one echoes the other.
May 2nd, 2012 at 11:48 am
Loribeth…yes. for me, it does. am glad you got – and felt – the same response.
Niobe…it’s true. in French, at least. i’d actually considered Fiona but for me it was too close, too affiliated. Josephine never struck me as connected until she started French daycare…her life as “zho-say-finn” lasted all of three days, until she told ‘em firmly: “i Posey.”
ha. still. :)
May 2nd, 2012 at 6:34 pm
Sometimes you just want to be heard. There is no need for more than knowing your words were seen and your love for Finn felt through each and everyone who was there to listen.
May 3rd, 2012 at 10:48 am
Bonnie, I confess I had to wait to read this, as I had a feeling it would make me cry. (I wasn’t wrong.)
I am so glad for you that you have these spaces where you can share this part of you, and have so many here and there to support you. It is beautiful the way you continue to include Finn in the tally of your family.
May 3rd, 2012 at 5:40 pm
love to you, bon. and finn, always.
May 3rd, 2012 at 6:38 pm
Thank you for still writing about Finn. It is a comfort to me all these miles away in London to read snatches of my observations of the rolling loss of my own son in your words. Thank you for writing about your living two. I have one living and hope for another. That grief sits alongside joy and they do not cross each other out as death and life coexist. This is so hard to explain to others. That is the comfort of reading your blog.
May 4th, 2012 at 3:37 am
It is the numbers vex me. The way the years stop making arrangable sense. The way they run together, especially in the early morning, when my guard is down and eyelashes lie softly on cheeks. The way our hearts & our heads count never manages to add up.
The physics of here-not-here seem to make more sense. Measurable only by leaps of imagination. Of faith.
I read both posts to your boys tonight. Beautiful. Both the counting and the physics accomplished with words set carefully in place. Your blog is an abacus for your heart: grief & growth, specific days & glimpses of memory, snatches of song & particular phrases all moving back and forth under your fingers. Love made manifest.
May 8th, 2012 at 11:01 am
A sweep of the fingers across the heartstrings. Belated birthday remembrance to Finn. Have you read LM Montgomery’s take on this loss of a child – in ‘Ann’s House of Dreams’ and, I think, also in ‘Rilla’?
May 8th, 2012 at 11:18 am
“love made manifest.” thank you, C. that made me satisfied.
Sharon, “they do not cross each other out as life and death co-exist.” yes. yes.
Mary…the Anne connection. yes. it occurred to me somewhere in the early days after Finn died that the only model i knew for the death of an infant was “wee, white Joyce” from Montgomery’s Anne series. which as a good Islander i had read numerous times in my younger years. strange identification moment. and it had some strange, small comfort in it.
May 9th, 2012 at 10:32 am
I’m always so glad you share him with us.
KayTar’s school nurse (who we have become close with beyond the normal school nurse relationship) has a son who died 7 years ago, too. KayTar has been able to overcome those in-person barriers in her magical way and talks to her about him often…she even asked for photos of him, which she keeps beside her bed. KayTar never met him, but she loves him. There is a scribbled note on my fridge that says so. Even though he isn’t physically here anymore, even though we never met him, he is still leaving his mark on the world…just as Finn is. All of us who hold you in our hearts, hold him also. Always.
May 10th, 2012 at 9:13 pm
Bon, your dynamic presentation on identitites yesterday led me to this beautiful tapestry of yours today, for the first time and not the last. Thank you for your heartful ability to shed light on the darkest of experiences.
Over the years, I have known several friends, colleagues and family members who have lost their beautiful babies. Each has been blessed with other children, and as Sharon so eloquently said, I have no doubt their “grief sits alongside joy”.
This still remains such a taboo subject, as many of you noted, a topic too prickly for most of us who are one step removed from it to know how to address. Our fear of hurting you more, of tearing open old wounds, of saying the wrong thing or the clichéd thing gets in the way of being able to say anything at all.
And yet, you don’t really need our words. You have your own, and they are mighty and masterful at telling your own story. Bless you for sharing this so openly, for making a safe space for many others to do the same. I hope the folks with whom I’ve shared your post tonight will find their own sense of comfort here.
More than six decades years later, both of my parents still speak of the brother that each of their mothers lost. My mom says her older brother was a ‘blue baby’. I’m not sure what that means and I didn’t have the courage to ask. My father has never forgotten that there were five boys in his family, not four.
Two friends have told me in the last year that recent miscarriages have opened the door for their sisters, girlfriends and mothers to speak of their own lost children for the first time. It would seem this particular form grief is more frequent than anyone lets on but generations of silence have kept it it from being brought to the surface.
I hope the tides are turning and that the courage expressed by you and your fellow bloggers will help others to make sense of this experience.
Happy Birthday, Finn.
Peace be with each of you.
May 24th, 2012 at 1:08 am
I think of Finn often, your words have woven his name into my being too and I’m so glad. Happy birthday, Finn.
October 27th, 2012 at 9:15 am
bon, reading your lovely elegy to a lost child reminded me of the younger brother I never met. as a child, I used to talk to him all the time, but the social pressures of being who I was caused me to lose that connection. thank you for putting me back in touch with my dear lost Neil, who would have been forty this year, and with the mother who lost him, who has been gone these last fourteen years.
the marvelous thing about those lost too soon, if that is the correct adjective, is that they exist in so many planes at once, both as the memory of who or what they were, and all the infinite possibilities of whom they might have become, given different circumstances. in that way, they are rainbows, possibly even multiple rainbows, a way of tying us to the magical even in the most muggley moments.